A few questions
I have a few questions about iptables, and about some of the traffic I've seen on this list.
1) I've successfully set up DNAT so that I can, say, request port 81 on the firewall/gateway box and hit the webserver on port 80 on a box behind the gateway. No problem. But it doesn't work on the LAN. I understand why, after reading some docs, but I've been trying to find a way around it. Problem is, I don't know what all iptables will auto-reverse for me and what I need to specify. For example, I suppose I could SNAT local connections through the gateway --to-source $GATEWAYIP, but would returning packets be taken care of, or must I come up with a rule for that? I've tried both without success.
2) Quite a few people are using my iptables script, and the most common complaint I get is dcc failure. ip_conntrack_irc (and everything else) is compiled into my (monolithic) kernel. Most people don't have this setup. Dcc of course works for me. I have the user modprobe ip_conntrack_irc, and typically it still doesn't work for them. Logs show it failing at a catch-all rule, which tells me conntrack isn't working. However if we add ip_conntrack_irc to /etc/modules and reboot, all is well. So, 2a) why is this? and 2b) surely there's something less drastic than a reboot that will put ip_conntrack_irc to work?
3) I see quite a few messages on the list about people going to a great deal of trouble to get a VPN connection to NAT through an iptables firewall. I have an always-on PPTP connection to the M$ VPN server at work, and I have never had to do anything special to get it to work. I have to assume, then, that I have some liberal rule or policy that is likely insecure, and I wonder what it could be. I'm afraid I don't have a pasteable rule set, as it's spread out across config files and such. If anyone cares to pore over it, it's at http://www.linuxkungfu.org/ipkungfu-0.2.0.tgz
Thanks!
Rocco
Quoted 12 lines · Rocco Stanzione
I have a few questions about iptables, and about some of the traffic I've seen on this list.
1) I've successfully set up DNAT so that I can, say, request port 81 on the firewall/gateway box and hit the webserver on port 80 on a box behind the gateway. No problem. But it doesn't work on the LAN. I understand why, after reading some docs, but I've been trying to find a way around it. Problem is, I don't know what all iptables will auto-reverse for me and what I need to specify. For example, I suppose I could SNAT local connections through the gateway --to-source $GATEWAYIP, but would returning packets be taken care of, or must I come up with a rule for that? I've tried both without success.
AFAIK, DNAT and SNAT take care of entire connections, not just individual packets. For example:
iptables -t nat --destination ${OUTSIDE_IP} --dport ${OUTSIDE_PORT} -j DNAT --to-destination ${INSIDE_IP}:${INSIDE_PORT}
takes care of both packets of the form
src:${OUTSIDE_IP}:${OUTSIDE_PORT}
dst:${INSIDE_IP}:${INSIDE_PORT}
as well as the return packets
src:${INSIDE_IP}:${INSIDE_PORT}
dst:${OUTSIDE_IP}:${OUTSIDE_PORT}
Quoted 10 lines
2) Quite a few people are using my iptables script, and the most common complaint I get is dcc failure.
ip_conntrack_irc(and everything else) is compiled into my (monolithic) kernel. Most people don't have this setup. Dcc of course works for me. I have the user modprobeip_conntrack_irc, and typically it still doesn't work for them. Logs show it failing at a catch-all rule, which tells me conntrack isn't working. However if we addip_conntrack_ircto/etc/modulesand reboot, all is well. So, 2a) why is this? and 2b) surely there's something less drastic than a reboot that will putip_conntrack_ircto work?
I think you need both ip_conntrack_irc.o and ip_nat_irc.o to get DCC working. I run a DCC fserve behind my firewall.
Quoted 13 lines
3) I see quite a few messages on the list about people going to a great deal of trouble to get a VPN connection to NAT through an iptables firewall. I have an always-on PPTP connection to the M$ VPN server at work, and I have never had to do anything special to get it to work. I have to assume, then, that I have some liberal rule or policy that is likely insecure, and I wonder what it could be. I'm afraid I don't have a pasteable rule set, as it's spread out across config files and such. If anyone cares to pore over it, it's at http://www.linuxkungfu.org/ipkungfu-0.2.0.tgz
Thanks!
Rocco
ia not getting list mails
hi
any problem with list
iam not getting regular mails
thanks
hare