USB speedtouch: better proc info
PATCH 1/1 USB speedtouch: better proc info
Output the correct device name, show the state of the device (for debugging) and of the ADSL line (anyone want to write a graphical utility to show this, like under windows?). We no longer consult the usb_device struct in udsl_atm_proc_read, so don't take a reference to it. Against Greg's current 2.5 USB tree.
speedtouch.c | 68 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--------- 1 files changed, 58 insertions(+), 10 deletions(-)
drivers/usb/misc/speedtouch.c +58 -10
@@ -156,6 +156,7 @@/* usb device part */ struct usb_device *usb_dev; +char description [64 ];int firmware_loaded;/* atm device part */
@@ -698,8 +699,6 @@dbg ("udsl_atm_dev_close: killing tasklet" );tasklet_kill (&instance->send_tasklet); -dbg ("udsl_atm_dev_close: freeing USB device" ); -usb_put_dev (instance->usb_dev);dbg ("udsl_atm_dev_close: freeing instance" );kfree (instance); }
@@ -722,8 +721,10 @@ }if (!left--) -return sprintf (page,"SpeedTouch USB %s-%s (%02x:%02x:%02x:%02x:%02x:%02x)\n" , - instance->usb_dev->bus->bus_name, instance->usb_dev->devpath, +return sprintf (page,"%s\n" , instance->description); + +if (!left--) +return sprintf (page,"MAC: %02x:%02x:%02x:%02x:%02x:%02x\n" , atm_dev->esi[0 ], atm_dev->esi[1 ], atm_dev->esi[2 ], atm_dev->esi[3 ], atm_dev->esi[4 ], atm_dev->esi[5 ]);
@@ -735,6 +736,30 @@atomic_read (&atm_dev->stats.aal5.rx_err), atomic_read (&atm_dev->stats.aal5.rx_drop)); +if (!left--) { +switch (atm_dev->signal) { +case ATM_PHY_SIG_FOUND : +sprintf (page,"Line up" ); +break ; +case ATM_PHY_SIG_LOST : +sprintf (page,"Line down" ); +break ; +default : +sprintf (page,"Line state unknown" ); +break ; + } + +if (instance->usb_dev) { +if (!instance->firmware_loaded) +strcat (page,", no firmware\n" ); +else +strcat (page,", firmware loaded\n" ); + }else +strcat (page,", disconnected\n" ); + +return strlen (page); + } +return 0 ; }
@@ -867,7 +892,8 @@struct udsl_instance_data *instance;unsigned char mac_str [13 ];unsigned char mac [6 ]; -int i; +int i, length; +char *buf;dbg ("Trying device with Vendor=0x%x, Product=0x%x, ifnum %d" , dev->descriptor.idVendor, dev->descriptor.idProduct, ifnum);
@@ -962,7 +988,7 @@ instance->atm_dev->ci_range.vpi_bits =ATM_CI_MAX ; instance->atm_dev->ci_range.vci_bits =ATM_CI_MAX ; - instance->atm_dev->signal =ATM_PHY_SIG_LOST ; + instance->atm_dev->signal =ATM_PHY_SIG_UNKNOWN ;/* tmp init atm device, set to 128kbit */ instance->atm_dev->link_rate =128 *1000 /424 ;
@@ -976,14 +1002,34 @@memcpy (instance->atm_dev->esi, mac,6 ); -wmb (); +/* device description */ + buf = instance->description; + length =sizeof (instance->description); + +if ((i =usb_string (dev, dev->descriptor.iProduct, buf, length)) <0 ) + goto finish; + + buf += i; + length -= i; + + i =snprintf (buf, length," (" ); + buf += i; + length -= i; + +if (length <=0 || (i =usb_make_path (dev, buf, length)) <0 ) + goto finish; + buf += i; + length -= i; + +snprintf (buf, length,")" ); + +finish: +/* ready for ATM callbacks */ instance->atm_dev->dev_data = instance;usb_set_intfdata (intf, instance); -usb_get_dev (dev); -return 0 ; fail:
@@ -1116,8 +1162,10 @@for (i =0 ; i <UDSL_NUMBER_SND_BUFS ; i++)kfree (instance->all_buffers[i].base); + instance->usb_dev =NULL ; +/* atm finalize */ -shutdown_atm_dev (instance->atm_dev); +shutdown_atm_dev (instance->atm_dev);/* frees instance */ }
Am Montag, 24. Februar 2003 10:58 schrieb Duncan Sands:
Quoted 5 lines
Output the correct device name, show the state of the device (for debugging) and of the ADSL line (anyone want to write a graphical utility to show this, like under windows?). We no longer consult the
usb_devicestruct inudsl_atm_proc_read, so don't take a reference to it. Against Greg's current 2.5 USB tree.
First of all, let me say that you're doing wonders with this driver. But this particular patch I don't like. It improves stuff that should be removed. More specifically:
1. Does anything prevent you from using the medium detection hooks the network layer provides?
2. What need is there to export manufacturer id and mac address again?
3. Doesn't the rest belong into sysfs rather than procfs?
Regards
Oliver
Quoted 11 lines · Oliver Neukum
Am Montag, 24. Februar 2003 10:58 schrieb Duncan Sands:
Quoted 5 lines
Output the correct device name, show the state of the device (for debugging) and of the ADSL line (anyone want to write a graphical utility to show this, like under windows?). We no longer consult the
usb_devicestruct inudsl_atm_proc_read, so don't take a reference to it. Against Greg's current 2.5 USB tree.First of all, let me say that you're doing wonders with this driver. But this particular patch I don't like. It improves stuff that should be removed. More specifically:
Quoted 5 lines
1. Does anything prevent you from using the medium detection hooks the network layer provides?
2. What need is there to export manufacturer id and mac address again?
3. Doesn't the rest belong into sysfs rather than procfs?
[Note to Chas: the speedtouch is a USB/ATM modem. The driver lurks in drivers/usb/misc/speedtouch.c]
Hi Oliver, thanks for your comments. While I agree with you in principle, I disagree in practice. The driver exports the following information in /proc/net/atm/speedtch:
(1) name and location of the USB device
(2) MAC address (serial number)
(3) AAL5 transmission statistics
(4) Line status
(5) Modem status
(1) is needed in order to work out which modem corresponds to which ATM device. This should be dealt with using sysfs, however the ATM layer has not yet been ported to sysfs. Until it is, this seems like the best way to export this information.
(2) and (3) are redundant - they are published by the ATM layer in other proc files. I thought about removing them, but decided against it because (a) it can be convenient having everything in one proc file, and (b) it is backwards compatible with the 2.4 out-of-kernel driver. They could go.
You suggested (in a private mail) using netif_carrier_on/off to export (4). The ATM layer already has a method for reporting this, and I use it: set the ATM_PHY_SIG_FOUND/LOST bits in atm_dev->signal. The problem is that the ATM layer doesn't do anything with this info (like export it to user space). So I think it is fair enough to export it in the proc file while waiting for the ATM layer to be fixed.
As for (5), this could be exported using sysfs. Since it is a USB matter, I guess I could do this now. So this could also go.
All the best,
Duncan.
Quoted 11 lines
Hi Oliver, thanks for your comments. While I agree with you in principle, I disagree in practice. The driver exports the following information in
/proc/net/atm/speedtch:(1) name and location of the USB device
(2) MAC address (serial number)
(3) AAL5 transmission statistics
(4) Line status
(5) Modem status
Quoted 4 lines
(1) is needed in order to work out which modem corresponds to which ATM device. This should be dealt with using sysfs, however the ATM layer has not yet been ported to sysfs. Until it is, this seems like the best way to export this information.
For the time being I agree.
Quoted 5 lines
(2) and (3) are redundant - they are published by the ATM layer in other proc files. I thought about removing them, but decided against it because (a) it can be convenient having everything in one proc file, and (b) it is backwards compatible with the 2.4 out-of-kernel driver. They could go.
As long as you have a proc file at all, you may as well print them, IMHO.
Quoted 7 lines
You suggested (in a private mail) using netif_carrier_on/off to export (4). The ATM layer already has a method for reporting this, and I use it: set the ATM_PHY_SIG_FOUND/LOST bits in
atm_dev->signal. The problem is that the ATM layer doesn't do anything with this info (like export it to user space). So I think it is fair enough to export it in the proc file while waiting for the ATM layer to be fixed.
Yes, but I think that you should notify the network layer too. I see no reason any network driver shouldn't report this directly. There's nothing specific to ATM in losing signal.
It's purely physical thing low level drivers should deal with.
Quoted 2 lines
As for (5), this could be exported using sysfs. Since it is a USB matter, I guess I could do this now. So this could also go.
Yes.
Regards
Oliver
Hi Oliver,
Quoted 33 lines · Oliver Neukum
Quoted 10 lines
Hi Oliver, thanks for your comments. While I agree with you in principle, I disagree in practice. The driver exports the following information in
/proc/net/atm/speedtch:(1) name and location of the USB device
(2) MAC address (serial number)
(3) AAL5 transmission statistics
(4) Line status
(5) Modem statusQuoted 4 lines
(1) is needed in order to work out which modem corresponds to which ATM device. This should be dealt with using sysfs, however the ATM layer has not yet been ported to sysfs. Until it is, this seems like the best way to export this information.
For the time being I agree.
Quoted 5 lines
(2) and (3) are redundant - they are published by the ATM layer in other proc files. I thought about removing them, but decided against it because (a) it can be convenient having everything in one proc file, and (b) it is backwards compatible with the 2.4 out-of-kernel driver. They could go.
As long as you have a proc file at all, you may as well print them, IMHO.
Quoted 7 lines
You suggested (in a private mail) using netif_carrier_on/off to export (4). The ATM layer already has a method for reporting this, and I use it: set the ATM_PHY_SIG_FOUND/LOST bits in
atm_dev->signal. The problem is that the ATM layer doesn't do anything with this info (like export it to user space). So I think it is fair enough to export it in the proc file while waiting for the ATM layer to be fixed.
Quoted 4 lines
Yes, but I think that you should notify the network layer too. I see no reason any network driver shouldn't report this directly. There's nothing specific to ATM in losing signal.
It's purely physical thing low level drivers should deal with.
I can't notify the network layer because there is no net_device I can get hold of.
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines
As for (5), this could be exported using sysfs. Since it is a USB matter, I guess I could do this now. So this could also go.
Yes.
Shall I ask Greg to apply the patch?
All the best,
Duncan.