What's the state of sdev->tagged_queue
Hi Doug,
scsi_ioctl.c has the following comment from you:
* The next two ioctls either need to go or need to be changed to
* pass tagged queueing changes through the low level drivers.
* Simply enabling or disabling tagged queueing without the knowledge
* of the low level driver is a *BAD* thing.
and scsi.h has this:
unsigned tagged_queue:1;/* This is going away!!!! Look at simple_tags
instead!!! Please fix your driver now!! */
but several drivers still look at it although it's never touched outside scsi_ioctl.c and the individual drivers. Most drivers uses also look pretty bogus. Can we just the ioctls and the field?
53c700.c: if(SCp->device->tagged_supported && !SCp->device->tagged_queueAM53C974.c: if (!hostdata->connected->device->tagged_queue)AM53C974.c: cmd->device->tagged_queue = 0;AM53C974.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue && (tag != TAG_NONE)) {NCR5380.c: cmd->device->tagged_queue = 0;arm/acornscsi.c: if (SCpnt->device->tagged_queue) {arm/acornscsi.c: host->SCpnt->device->tagged_queue = 0;arm/acornscsi.c: scd->tagged_queue ? "en" : "dis",arm/fas216.c: if (SCpnt->device->tagged_queue && SCpnt->cmnd[0] != REQUEST_SENSE &&arm/fas216.c: scd->tagged_queue ? "en" : "dis",ncr53c8xx.c: if (lp && !lp->numtags && cmd->device && cmd->device->tagged_queue) {qla1280.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue)qla1280.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue)scsi.h: unsigned tagged_queue:1;/* This is going away!!!! Look at simple_tagsscsi_ioctl.c: sdev->tagged_queue = 1;scsi_ioctl.c: sdev->tagged_queue = 0;sym53c8xx.c: if (lp && !lp->numtags && cmd->device && cmd->device->tagged_queue) {
Quoted 1 line · Christoph Hellwig
Hi Doug,
Hi Christoph.
Quoted 7 lines
scsi_ioctl.chas the following comment from you:* The next two ioctls either need to go or need to be changed to
* pass tagged queueing changes through the low level drivers.
* Simply enabling or disabling tagged queueing without the knowledge
* of the low level driver is a *BAD* thing.
Quoted 8 lines
and
scsi.hhas this:unsigned tagged_queue:1;/* This is going away!!!! Look at
simple_tags
instead!!! Please fix your driver now!! */but several drivers still look at it although it's never touched outside
scsi_ioctl.cand the individual drivers. Most drivers uses also look pretty bogus. Can we just the ioctls and the field?
I assume that should read "Can we just kill the ioctls and the field?" :-)
The answer to that is yes I think. The ioctls for certain, the field I'm pretty sure of. Originally, the field was used as a boolean that was when we enabled tagged queueing on a device. Now, a value of simple_tags > 1 should do the same thing. However, due to usage of cmd_per_lun on both tagged and untagged devices (I would have to check this, I'm a bit out of touch since my accident) may cause confusion. If we set queue depth to cmd_per_lun the device may look tagged when it is in fact not tagged. The replacement test may need to be if simple_tags > cmd_per_lun to indicate true tagged queueing.
Quoted 1 line
53c700.c: if(SCp->device->tagged_supported && !SCp->device->tagged_queue
This is checking that tagged queueing is supported and not already enabled (a holdover from the fact that select_queue_depths would get called more than once on a single device if we ever had a scsi add-single-device command after the initial device scan).
Quoted 1 line
AM53C974.c: if (!hostdata->connected->device->tagged_queue)
Tests tagged queueing not active on a device.
Quoted 1 line
AM53C974.c:cmd->device->tagged_queue= 0;
Disabling tagged queueing on a device.
Quoted 1 line
AM53C974.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue&& (tag !=TAG_NONE)) {
Checking for a tagged device with an untagged command. Others are all similar.
Quoted 5 lines
NCR5380.c:cmd->device->tagged_queue= 0;arm/acornscsi.c: if (SCpnt->device->tagged_queue) {arm/acornscsi.c:host->SCpnt->device->tagged_queue= 0;arm/acornscsi.c:scd->tagged_queue? "en" : "dis",arm/fas216.c: if (SCpnt->device->tagged_queue&& SCpnt->cmnd[0] !=REQUEST_SENSE&&
Quoted 8 lines
arm/fas216.c:scd->tagged_queue? "en" : "dis",ncr53c8xx.c: if (lp && !lp->numtags &&cmd->device&&cmd->device->tagged_queue) {qla1280.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue)qla1280.c: if (cmd->device->tagged_queue)scsi.h: unsigned tagged_queue:1;/* This is going away!!!! Look atsimple_tagsscsi_ioctl.c:sdev->tagged_queue= 1;scsi_ioctl.c:sdev->tagged_queue= 0;sym53c8xx.c: if (lp && !lp->numtags &&cmd->device&&cmd->device->tagged_queue) {
This does bring up another issue I've been thinking about though so I'll suggest it now.
Currently, we use the value of host->this_id to skip the scsi device of the host controller in our device scan. What I would like to do is create an sg device entry for this_id that is type processor, is a fake device, that implements whatever ioctls at the mid layer level that are appropriate, but that also allow the low level driver to register a fall through host ioctl routine that can be attached to this device. This would give us a uniform method of accessing host controllers via the scsi subsystem. Generic ioctls that can be handled in the mid layer can be done so. Host adapter specific ioctls can then be handled by the driver. At least this way we wouldn't have to have a different /proc method of doing these things in every single driver and we would be able to use a normal ioctl interface for things like controlling the various smart raid controllers, etc. Thoughts?
Signature · 4 lines
Doug Ledford <[email protected]> 919-754-3700 x44233 Red Hat, Inc. 1801 Varsity Dr. Raleigh, NC 27606
Quoted 5 lines · Doug Ledford
Quoted 3 lines
but several drivers still look at it although it's never touched outside
scsi_ioctl.cand the individual drivers. Most drivers uses also look pretty bogus. Can we just the ioctls and the field?I assume that should read "Can we just kill the ioctls and the field?" :-)
Umm, yes..
Quoted 4 lines
The answer to that is yes I think. The ioctls for certain, the field I'm pretty sure of. Originally, the field was used as a boolean that was when we enabled tagged queueing on a device. Now, a value of
simple_tags> 1 should do the same thing.
simple_tags == 1? in my source it's a bitfield.
Quoted 3 lines
However, due to usage of
cmd_per_lunon both tagged and untagged devices (I would have to check this, I'm a bit out of touch since my accident)
Sorry, didn't know of that. I hope you're well already and if not I wish you to get well soon.
Quoted 3 lines
may cause confusion. If
we set queue depth tocmd_per_lunthe device may look tagged when it is in fact not tagged. The replacement test may need to be ifsimple_tags
<snip>
Quoted 3 lines
Currently, we use the value of
host->this_idto skip the scsi device of the host controller in our device scan. What I would like to do is create an sg device entry forthis_idthat is type processor,
We already have scsi_get_host_dev to get such a device if the LLDD wants it. Generalizing it sounds like a good idea. But before that we need a 64bit dev_t so we can have sg devices for the ever-growing number of scsi_devices :)
Quoted 4 lines
is a fake
device, that implements whatever ioctls at the mid layer level that are appropriate, but that also allow the low level driver to register a fall through host ioctl routine that can be attached to this device.
I don't think we should another ioctl routine. Just use the normal ioctl routine in the host template and let the LLDD check for host->this_id.
Quoted 1 line · Christoph Hellwig
simple_tags== 1? in my source it's a bitfield.
Duh, told you I was out of touch. I wrote that and I forgot what it was :-)
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 1 line
Currently, we use the value of
host->this_idto skip the scsi device of the host controller in our device scan. What I would like to do is create an sg device entry forthis_idthat is type processor,We already have
scsi_get_host_devto get such a device if the LLDD wants it. Generalizing it sounds like a good idea. But before that we need a 64bitdev_tso we can have sg devices for the ever-growing number ofscsi_devices:)
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
is a fake device, that implements whatever ioctls at the mid layer level that are appropriate, but that also allow the low level driver to register a fall through host ioctl routine that can be attached to this device.
I don't think we should another ioctl routine. Just use the normal ioctl routine in the host template and let the LLDD check for
host->this_id.
More out-of-touchness...
Signature · 4 lines
Doug Ledford <[email protected]> 919-754-3700 x44233 Red Hat, Inc. 1801 Varsity Dr. Raleigh, NC 27606