Plans for better performance metrics in upcoming kernels?
Hi,
I'm wondering what the plans are for more accurate and more useful performance metrics in upcoming kernels.
CPU Utilization by process is apparently a known-inaccuracy.
There are no disk I/O metrics per process.
CPU Queue Length doesn't appear to be available?
Etc.
Linux clearly falls behind the competition in this area. It makes it rather tough to do system performance analysis on a Linux box! :-)
Is there a plan to deal with these issues? ETA's?
Cordially,
Scott
Quoted 5 lines · Scott Chapman
Hi,
I'm wondering what the plans are for more accurate and more useful performance metrics in upcoming kernels.CPU Utilization by process is apparently a known-inaccuracy.
This could be improved using Ingo's nanosecond scheduler patch.
Quoted 3 lines
There are no disk I/O metrics per process.
This is now quite easy with per process IO contexts.
Quoted 3 lines
CPU Queue Length doesn't appear to be available?
It wouldn't be difficult.
Quoted 8 lines
Etc.
Linux clearly falls behind the competition in this area. It makes it rather tough to do system performance analysis on a Linux box! :-)
Is there a plan to deal with these issues? ETA's?
Thinks are worked on depending on demand, and interest. I think a lot of people are put of doing good kernel metrics due to lack of good extensible userspace tools, and maybe a lack of standard ways to do the exporting.
Hi all,
I received one reply to this email. I take it there is nobody really heading up the implementation of improved/missing performance metrics in the kernel?
Is this on anyone's radar?
What is Linus' take on more/better metrics? Is he likely to roll them in if they are implemented?
Is there any plan to implement any existing patches?
If I can get developer time applied to this project, I don't want to re-invent the existing pieces. Who do I coordinate with?
Cordially,
Scott
Quoted 19 lines · Scott Chapman
Hi,
I'm wondering what the plans are for more accurate and more useful performance metrics in upcoming kernels.CPU Utilization by process is apparently a known-inaccuracy.
There are no disk I/O metrics per process.
CPU Queue Length doesn't appear to be available?
Etc.
Linux clearly falls behind the competition in this area. It makes it rather tough to do system performance analysis on a Linux box! :-)
Is there a plan to deal with these issues? ETA's?
Cordially,
Scott
We have a project to maintain and improve systat here at OSDL. We're looking for others to help in this area, if your're interested.
Quoted 44 lines · Scott Chapman
Hi all,
I received one reply to this email. I take it there is nobody really heading up the implementation of improved/missing performance metrics in the kernel?
Is this on anyone's radar?
What is Linus' take on more/better metrics? Is he likely to roll them in if they are implemented?
Is there any plan to implement any existing patches?
If I can get developer time applied to this project, I don't want to re-invent the existing pieces. Who do I coordinate with?
Cordially,
ScottQuoted 12 lines · Scott Chapman
Hi,
I'm wondering what the plans are for more accurate and more useful performance metrics in upcoming kernels.CPU Utilization by process is apparently a known-inaccuracy.
There are no disk I/O metrics per process.
CPU Queue Length doesn't appear to be available?
Etc.
Quoted 7 lines
Linux clearly falls behind the competition in this area. It makes it rather tough to do system performance analysis on a Linux box! :-)
Is there a plan to deal with these issues? ETA's?
Cordially,
Scott-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/
Signature · 2 lines
Craig Thomas [email protected]
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Scott" == Scott Chapman <[email protected]> writes:
Scott> Hi all, I received one reply to this email. I take it there is Scott> nobody really heading up the implementation of improved/missing Scott> performance metrics in the kernel?
I've been working on microstate acounting, and am interested in better metrics overall, for capacity planning and for accounting.
I think that SGI also have been doing some work -- see
http://oss.sgi.com/projects/csa/
Peter C