multiple servers per automount
This is probably a faq but I havn't seen it asked in recent months...
I have a situation where two network appliance filers with identical file systems are used to serve read only mounts for CAD software tools. Both Solaris and HP-UX support an automount like:
cadtool -ro tools1,tools2:/vol/vol1/tools/&
and will automatically switch to the other server if the initial mount becomes unavailable.
Last time I was able to check Linux autofs did not support the failover and complained about the syntax. Has this changed or are there plans to support the syntax above with failover for read only mounts?
Thanks,
Rich Sahlender
Quoted 6 lines · Rich Sahlender
This is probably a faq but I havn't seen it asked in recent months...
I have a situation where two network appliance filers with identical file systems are used to serve read only mounts for CAD software tools. Both Solaris and HP-UX support an automount like:
Quoted 9 lines
cadtool -ro tools1,tools2:/vol/vol1/tools/&
and will automatically switch to the other server if the initial mount becomes unavailable.
Last time I was able to check Linux autofs did not support the failover and complained about the syntax. Has this changed or are there plans to support the syntax above with failover for read only mounts?
This should not be an autofs feature but an NFS feature, for obvious
reasons: it's equally applicable for static mounts.
Furhtermore, failover HAS to be done at the NFS layer.
The fact that Slowlaris does it in autofs is not a good motivation -- it's idiotic design.
-hpa
Quoted 20 lines · H. Peter Anvin
Quoted 6 lines · Rich Sahlender
This is probably a faq but I havn't seen it asked in recent months...
I have a situation where two network appliance filers with identical file systems are used to serve read only mounts for CAD software tools. Both Solaris and HP-UX support an automount like:
Quoted 9 lines
cadtool -ro tools1,tools2:/vol/vol1/tools/&
and will automatically switch to the other server if the initial mount becomes unavailable.
Last time I was able to check Linux autofs did not support the failover and complained about the syntax. Has this changed or are there plans to support the syntax above with failover for read only mounts?
This should not be an autofs feature but an NFS feature, for obvious
reasons: it's equally applicable for static mounts.
Quoted 6 lines
Furhtermore, failover HAS to be done at the NFS layer.
The fact that Slowlaris does it in autofs is not a good motivation -- it's idiotic design.
-hpa
I disagree. These are read only mounts. How is it an idiotic design to provide a little extra availability by switching to another server in the list if the mounted server becomes unavailable?
Furthermore, the fact that it is equally applicable for static mounts does not make it an obvious NFS issue. I submit it's both an NFS and an autofs issue...
Quoted 9 lines · H. Peter Anvin
This should not be an autofs feature but an NFS feature, for obvious
reasons: it's equally applicable for static mounts.Furhtermore, failover HAS to be done at the NFS layer.
The fact that Slowlaris does it in autofs is not a good motivation -- it's idiotic design.
*Ahem*. Solaris has had NFS client failover since 2.6. Linux is still playing catch up in this arena.
Failover is not handled in the automount layer, but rather passed on to nfs layer itself. man mount_nfs.
Mike Waychison
Ian Kent
maintainerQuoted 9 lines · Mike Waychison
Quoted 7 lines · H. Peter Anvin
This should not be an autofs feature but an NFS feature, for obvious
reasons: it's equally applicable for static mounts.Furhtermore, failover HAS to be done at the NFS layer.
The fact that Slowlaris does it in autofs is not a good motivation -- it's idiotic design.
Ohh .. Nasty .... mmmmaaahhh.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
*Ahem*. Solaris has had NFS client failover since 2.6. Linux is still
playing catch up in this arena.
Failover is not handled in the automount layer, but rather passed on to nfs layer itself. manmount_nfs.
On a related not Mike.
Is the number of NFS mounts on Solaris unlimited or is it table driven? I can't find a reference to it anywhere.
Signature · 4 lines
,-._|\ Ian Kent / \ Perth, Western Australia *_.--._/ E-mail: [email protected] v Web: http://themaw.net/
Quoted 7 lines · Ian Kent
On a related not Mike.
Is the number of NFS mounts on Solaris unlimited or is it table driven? I can't find a reference to it anywhere.
I've asked around, and I'm told that there is no set limit (besides having enough memory). I'm told that more recent Solaris releases have been tested up to around 260,000 concurrent NFS mounts.
Mike Waychison