RAID-0 read perf. decrease after 2.4.20
Quoted 13 lines
Hello All!
Has anyone else experienced a drastic drop in read performance on software
RAID-0 with post 2.4.20 kernels? We have a few Athlon XP's here at our lab with double IDE disks on different channels set up as RAID-0. Some bonnie++ benchmark results with various kernels, on the same machine (Athlon XP 2400+, 2 GHz, 1.5 GB RAM, VIA chipset, 2*Maxtor 120 GB 6Y060L0):
write read
2.4.20-ac1: 88,000 135,000 K/sec
2.4.21-pre7: 93,000 75,000
2.4.22-ac4: 94,000 82,000
Hi,
I can attest a similar drop in read performance on a IA64 box going
from a 2.4.19ish kernel to 2.4.22. In our setup the RAID0 is LVM, not MD.The RAID is used a a scratch device for a out-of-core finite element program (NASTRAN).
The setup is some 20 disks on 4 controllers. "iozone" read/reread
Performance went from about 400MB/sec to 260 MB/sec, while write went up a notch. Unfortunatelly the read performance is more important for the application in question.
Due to the fact that I have no controll over the use of the system I
cannot make any experiments to find out what killed performance. Sorry :-(
Martin
=====
------------------------------------------------------
Martin Knoblauch
email: [email protected] or [email protected] www: http://www.knobisoft.de
Quoted 30 lines · Martin Knoblauch
Quoted 13 lines
Hello All!
Has anyone else experienced a drastic drop in read performance on software
RAID-0 with post 2.4.20 kernels? We have a few Athlon XP's here at our lab with double IDE disks on different channels set up as RAID-0. Some bonnie++ benchmark results with various kernels, on the same machine (Athlon XP 2400+, 2 GHz, 1.5 GB RAM, VIA chipset, 2*Maxtor 120 GB 6Y060L0):
write read
2.4.20-ac1: 88,000 135,000 K/sec
2.4.21-pre7: 93,000 75,000
2.4.22-ac4: 94,000 82,000Hi,
I can attest a similar drop in read performance on a IA64 box going
from a 2.4.19ish kernel to 2.4.22. In our setup the RAID0 is LVM, not MD.The RAID is used a a scratch device for a out-of-core finite element program (NASTRAN).The setup is some 20 disks on 4 controllers. "iozone" read/reread
Performance went from about 400MB/sec to 260 MB/sec, while write went up a notch. Unfortunatelly the read performance is more important for the application in question.Due to the fact that I have no controll over the use of the system I
cannot make any experiments to find out what killed performance. Sorry :-(
Quoted 9 lines
Martin
=====
------------------------------------------------------
Martin Knoblauchemail: [email protected] or [email protected] www: http://www.knobisoft.de
And this isn't the read-ahead size change thing?
Superior disk perf. of 2.4.20-ac (Was: RAID-0 read perf. decrease after 2.4.20)
Hell Joshua and All!
Quoted 5 lines · Joshua Schmidlkofer
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Has anyone else experienced a drastic drop in read performance on software
RAID-0 with post 2.4.20 kernels? We have a few Athlon XP's here at ourAnd this isn't the read-ahead size change thing?
When did this change take place? It would be easy to test then. I did some more tests on the weekend and found that this isn't RAID related; also normal single disk access is much faster on the 2.4.20-ac's than on other recent kernels. Just to summarise, the disk speed on one of the Athlon XP's (2GHz, 1.5 GB RAM, 2*160 GB Maxtor 6Y080L0) according to bonnie++:
RAID-0 VIA write read
2.4.19 none 10,000 9,000
2.4.20 3.35 73,000 88,000
2.4.20-ac1 3.35-ac 70,000 135,000
2.4.20-ac2 3.35-ac 71,000 140,000
2.4.21-pre1 3.35-ac 71,000 79,000
2.4.21-pre3 3.35-ac 71,000 79,000
2.4.23-rc3 3.37 65,000 82,000
single disk
2.4.20-ac2 3.35-ac 55,000 74,000
2.4.23-rc3 3.37 54,000 48,000
So the single disk read performance of 2.4.20-ac2 is as fast as a double RAID-0 array of other kernels.
Have a nice day,
Mikael J.
http://www.helsinki.fi/~mpjohans/