Skip to contentSkip to conversation

WRT54G

DISCUSSION Aiko Barz 3 participants 3 messages Sep 19, 2004 – Sep 21, 2004

lore
Share & tools
lore

Aiko Barz

author
#0 lore raw

Hi there!

It's the wrt54g subject again...
I'm mirroring the Sveasoft-firmware, which was published under the terms of "GPL". At least Sveasoft said that. Of course, many drivers are closed. And others look like this:
* This is UNPUBLISHED PROPRIETARY SOURCE CODE of Broadcom Corporation;
Since those drivers are kept outside the kernel-tree it might be allright with the GPL.

Now, wind changed quite a bit: Sveasoft wants money for their firmware. (It's ok with me.) Sveasoft actually sells the code. You only get a copy if you are a registered, paying Sveasoft-user. This also covers the GPL-part.

This site http://www.linksys.com/support/gpl.asp also implies, that i can redistribute those drivers and firmwares. But it is the same problem with them. Those wrt54g-firmwares also contain non-GPL sourcecodes and binaries.

Sveasoft is hunting down mirrorsites right now. Of course, they want to earn some money. So i'm not sure what I should do next?! Going down or asking for the rest of the code?

Bis denne,
Aiko

Signature · 5 lines
  .~.	 Aiko Barz
  /v\ 	 
 // \\	 Mail: [email protected]
/( _ )\  Web:  http://www.chroot.de
 ^^ ^^   PGP:  http://www.chroot.de/index.php?navi=GnuPG
#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Aiko Barz

Hi there!

It's the wrt54g subject again...
I'm mirroring the Sveasoft-firmware, which was published under the terms of "GPL". At least Sveasoft said that.

Can you prove they said that ?

Quoted 4 lines

This site http://www.linksys.com/support/gpl.asp also implies, that i can redistribute those drivers and firmwares. But it is the same problem with them. Those wrt54g-firmwares also contain non-GPL sourcecodes and binaries.

It's up to Linksys what license they grant you for their non-free stuff. If its linked with GPL stuff then it might be GPL because its a derivative work. Sveasoft's only business is code they own the copyright to themselves and didn't give other people rights to redistribute (or gave them specifically revokable rights to distribute)

Quoted 3 lines

Sveasoft is hunting down mirrorsites right now. Of course, they want to earn some money. So i'm not sure what I should do next?! Going down or asking for the rest of the code?

That depends what they said about the code and what you can prove about it. Sveasoft's evil claws extend only to code they themselves own copyright to and have not already granted things like GPL rights too (or any other irrevocable right).

It highlights the dangers of relying on a partially proprietary software stack, as well as why Richard Stallman always asks vendors of Linux and other free software products that if they also bundle non-free software it is easy to tell which is which. Hence Debian has a seperate non-free archive, Fedora is open source only but there are third party yum repositories for non-free products and so on.

Alan

#2 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 4 lines

This site http://www.linksys.com/support/gpl.asp also implies, that i can redistribute those drivers and firmwares. But it is the same problem with them. Those wrt54g-firmwares also contain non-GPL sourcecodes and binaries.

It's up to Linksys what license they grant you for their non-free stuff. If its linked with GPL stuff then it might be GPL because its a derivative work. Sveasoft's only business is code they own the copyright to themselves and didn't give other people rights to redistribute (or gave them specifically revokable rights to distribute)

IANAL but I'd very calm about this specific threat. Linksys published the complete source code to this router product including Makefiles to build your own firmware. The only parts which were only delivered as binaries are the tools to assemble a firmware, the bootloader and the helper code for the OpenSource module controlling the WLAN chipset.

Most of the software they bundle is GPL (including the kernel, uclibc (LGPL), busybox, iptables, dnsmasq...) so Linksys is doing pretty well in releasing the source. The also include applications which are marked "propietary" but AFAIS they're not linked against any GPLed source so I'd consider them still as belonging to Linksys.

IOW if Sveasoft is distributing any *part* of the original firmware (and they have to at least for the WLAN interface) they're in violation of the GPL *and* (probably illegally) distributing propietary applications written or licensed by Linksys. And I really doubt they changed the OS to something non-GPLed and use a completely different environment.

If I were them I'd rather hide behind rock and hope that noone notices that they're violating licenses instead of threatening people.

Servus,
Daniel