possible GPL violation by Free
Hello,
I got information about a possible GPL violation in France. A network service company called "Free" provides a kind of ADSL modem named "Freebox". This "Freebox" is not only an ADSL modem but also has functions of a router, an IP phone and a TV, using video streaming via ATM. Although the "Freebox" does not contain any information about GPL, a rumor says that this runs Linux as the kernel and VideoLAN for the video streaming. And, this company does not provide the source code even to those who have Freeboxes. I don't know any other software used in Freebox, but at least Linux and VideoLAN are under the term of GPL. This information seems to be given by anonymous people working for the company.
The company Free reasons that they don't need to make the source code available, because they don't sell Freebox but merely _rents_ Freebox to customers. So the company thinks that customers do not own Freebox legally, and so they have no right to claim that they can ask the source code.
But, if this is a good reason, I think many other people can refuse to publish source code. For example, a distributor who "rents" CDROMs can say, "I am not forced to give you the source code, because you do not own your CDROM."
Unfortunately I have little knowledge on French copyright laws, so I cannot judge if this is wrong.
Regards,
Okuji
Quoted 5 lines · Yoshinori K. Okuji
The company Free reasons that they don't need to make the source code available, because they don't sell Freebox but merely _rents_ Freebox to customers. So the company thinks that customers do not own Freebox legally, and so they have no right to claim that they can ask the source code.
Hi there,
Someone should then perhaps call them and find out whether it's possible to purchase one of these boxes - thereby trapping them in to not having this argument.
Je le ferais, mais mon francais n'est pas tres bon, et je n'habite pas en France.
Jon.
Quoted 7 lines · Yoshinori K. Okuji
I got information about a possible GPL violation in France. A network service company called "Free" provides a kind of ADSL modem named "Freebox". This "Freebox" is not only an ADSL modem but also has functions of a router, an IP phone and a TV, using video streaming via ATM. Although the "Freebox" does not contain any information about GPL, a rumor says that this runs Linux as the kernel and VideoLAN for the video streaming.
The Freebox does not run VideoLAN software but has a built-in
hardware MPEG-2 decoder. Free uses VideoLAN software to stream video, but this is internal use and perfectly complies with the GPL. I may add that a VideoLAN developer works for Free and still commits code into the SVN repository, which he is not required to do.
If there is a problem here, it looks like a problem with Linux (and
probably GNU) only.
Quoted 11 lines
And, this company does not provide the source code
even to those who have Freeboxes. I don't know any other software used in Freebox, but at least Linux and VideoLAN are under the term of GPL. This information seems to be given by anonymous people working for the company.The company Free reasons that they don't need to make the source code available, because they don't sell Freebox but merely _rents_ Freebox to customers. So the company thinks that customers do not own Freebox legally, and so they have no right to claim that they can ask the source code.
Do you have a reference to an official statement for this? A lot of
companies are rumoured to say a lot of things, and you should really cautiously check your facts. If this is indeed they reasoning, it impugns the general GPL interpretation that renting a piece of hardware is distribution of the software therein.
To carefully verify this, you need to have a Freebox user ask
Free for the Linux source code. No one else is entitled to do it. Maybe you could even find a Linux developer who has a Freebox and did contributions to the kernel significant enough that they must be in the Freebox.
If Free is using an unmodified kernel, they are already providing
the sources for it (ftp://ftp.free.fr/pub/linux/kernel/). If they are using a modified version of the kernel, then they should be asked for the source. If anyone is going to do this, please be diplomatic, and try to rely on facts rather than Internet rumours. I would hate to see Free exasperated by Slashdot morons and deciding not to contribute to VideoLAN any longer.
Regards,
Signature · 1 line
Sam. <http://sam.zoy.org/>
Hi,
Quoted 7 lines · Yoshinori K. Okuji
I got information about a possible GPL violation in France. A network service company called "Free" provides a kind of ADSL modem named "Freebox". This "Freebox" is not only an ADSL modem but also has functions of a router, an IP phone and a TV, using video streaming via ATM. Although the "Freebox" does not contain any information about GPL, a rumor says that this runs Linux as the kernel and VideoLAN for the video streaming.
When they built the first freebox, I found an inside photo on the net. I don't remember which chip it was (several years ago), but it was clear from the maker that it only supported vxworks. And at this time, people were already saying it was running linux. There are so many rumors about many devices running linux that people should check (at least provide the result of an nmap -O). For most end-users, "linux" is the word for "a reliable embedded OS with IP support".
However, I also found a photo of the new one on the net, which shows a big broadcom BCM6348. This one supports both linux and vxworks, but judging by the number of responses on google, there is a great chance that broadcom pushes linux on it since they also provide many other solutions involving linux.
Regards,
Willy
Quoted 2 lines · Sam Hocevar
To carefully verify this, you need to have a Freebox user ask
Free for the Linux source code. No one else is entitled to do it.
This is some serious misinformation, that needs to be corrected.
Please take a look at your copy of the GPL, in particular section 3. It states that the distributor of the software has 3 options, the third one only for non-profit distribution, so not applicable here. This leaves Free with 2 options:
1) distribute the source together with the binaries, which they do not appear to be doing
2) distribute the source with an offer, for ANY 3rd party, to get the source code on request (they don't appear to be doing this either)
In addition to this, I find the reasoning that "people rent the box, so we don't sell the software" to be very suspicious. Even if the boxes are only rented, the software on them is still being distributed!
IANAL, of course, so YMMV ...
Signature · 3 lines
"Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it." - Brian W. Kernighan
Quoted 10 lines · Rik van Riel
Quoted 2 lines
To carefully verify this, you need to have a Freebox user ask
Free for the Linux source code. No one else is entitled to do it.This is some serious misinformation, that needs to be corrected.
Please take a look at your copy of the GPL, in particular section 3. It states that the distributor of the software has 3 options, the third one only for non-profit distribution, so not applicable here. This leaves Free with 2 options:
Quoted 6 lines
1) distribute the source together with the binaries, which they do not appear to be doing
2) distribute the source with an offer, for ANY 3rd party, to get the source code on request (they don't appear to be doing this either)
I know the GPL and I know they don't appear to be doing any of these
two things. However it might be hidden in some obscure agreement between Free and the user, renounced upon in such an agreement (which would violate the GPL, like QuakeLives did) or indeed not be there at all. And the only people who can verify this are the Freebox users.
Quoted 4 lines
In addition to this, I find the reasoning that "people rent the box, so we don't sell the software" to be very suspicious. Even if the boxes are only rented, the software on them is still being distributed!
As stated in my previous email, I agree with you on this. Renting is
distributing.
Signature · 1 line
Sam.
Quoted 7 lines · Sam Hocevar
Quoted 1 line
This leaves Free with 2 options:
I know the GPL and I know they don't appear to be doing any of these
two things. However it might be hidden in some obscure agreement between Free and the user, renounced upon in such an agreement (which would violate the GPL, like QuakeLives did) or indeed not be there at all. And the only people who can verify this are the Freebox users.
Even if the Freebox users were to renounce their own rights under the GPL, I do not see how they could renounce OUR rights for us ...
Signature · 3 lines
"Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it." - Brian W. Kernighan
Quoted 1 line · Yoshinori K. Okuji
Hello,
[...]
Quoted 6 lines
The company Free reasons that they don't need to make the source code available, because they don't sell Freebox but merely _rents_ Freebox to customers. So the company thinks that customers do not own Freebox legally, and so they have no right to claim that they can ask the source code.
Perhaps customers can demand to _rent_ the source code too then? ;-)
Helge Hafting
Quoted 11 lines · Sam Hocevar
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
This leaves Free with 2 options:
I know the GPL and I know they don't appear to be doing any of these
two things. However it might be hidden in some obscure agreement between Free and the user, renounced upon in such an agreement (which would violate the GPL, like QuakeLives did) or indeed not be there at all. And the only people who can verify this are the Freebox users.
Quoted 3 lines
Even if the Freebox users were to renounce their own rights under the GPL, I do not see how they could renounce OUR rights for us ...
The GPL doesn't give any rights to anyone but the people the software is
distributed to. Though the agreement must be enforceable by any third party, that third party must actually be a recipient of the agreement, either directly or indirectly.
So in other words, if you make a custom binary of the Linux kernel and
distribute it to me, then you have to give me an agreement that any third party can enforce to get the source code. But I don't have to give that agreement to any third parties if I don't want to.
The rationale behind this requirement in the GPL is that without it,
redistribution would be difficult. Since the GPL allows the recipients of the code to further distribute it, they must be also able to distribute the right to the source code.
The GPL does not permit you to impose any other restrictions. So you can't
use this as a loophole to escape the requirement of distributing the source code. A simple way to understand it is this -- wherever the executable can go, so too must the source go. Wherever the executable can go, so too must the right to redistribute the executable (and therefore, so to must go the ability to get the source).
If you lawfully obtained the executable to anything derived from GPL'd
code, you should be able to obtain the source code. If not, you might or might not be able to. If you have the executable, and didn't steal it or something, you should also have either the source code or the right to easily obtain the source code.
DS
Quoted 3 lines · you
Although the "Freebox" does not contain any information about GPL, a rumor says that this runs Linux as the kernel and VideoLAN for the video streaming.
Please research such issues further before making public accusations.
I don't know the internals of Freebox, but Free surely has profound knowledge of free software and it's licensing issues (they funded libavcodec development and provide the bandwidth for the savannah/ sourceforge alike gna.org in cooperation with FSF France.)
Cheers,
Morit
Hello,
Quoted 3 lines · Willy Tarreau
(at least provide the
result of an nmap -O). For most end-users, "linux" is the word for "a reliable embedded OS with IP support".
Here it is, on a Freebox v1 (the Freebox distributed now is version 3, but version 1 was still distributed less than one year ago (i.e. under the 3 years limit in the GPL)).
Disclaimer: this scan output should be taken carefully. Please do not jump to conclusions.
(IP and MAC hidden)
--------------------------------
Starting nmap 3.70 ( http://www.insecure.org/nmap/ ) at 2004-10-10 20:23 CEST
Initiating SYN Stealth Scan against XX.XX.XX.254 [1660 ports] at 20:23 Discovered open port 22/tcp on XX.XX.XX.254
Discovered open port 199/tcp on XX.XX.XX.254
The SYN Stealth Scan took 5.12s to scan 1660 total ports. For OSScan assuming that port 22 is open and port 1 is closed and neither are firewalled
Host XX.XX.XX.254 appears to be up ... good.
Interesting ports on XX.XX.XX.254:
(The 1658 ports scanned but not shown below are in state: closed)
PORT STATE SERVICE
22/tcp open ssh
199/tcp open smux
MAC Address: 00:07:XX:XX:XX:XX (Freebox SA)
Device type: general purpose
Running: Linux 2.4.X|2.5.X
OS details: Linux 2.4.0 - 2.5.20
OS Fingerprint:
TSeq(Class=RI%gcd=1%SI=40A886%IPID=Z%TS=100HZ) T1(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=16A0%ACK=S++%Flags=AS%Ops=MNNTNW) T2(Resp=N) T3(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=16A0%ACK=S++%Flags=AS%Ops=MNNTNW) T4(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=0%ACK=O%Flags=R%Ops=) T5(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=0%ACK=S++%Flags=AR%Ops=) T6(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=0%ACK=O%Flags=R%Ops=) T7(Resp=Y%DF=Y%W=0%ACK=S++%Flags=AR%Ops=) PU(Resp=Y%DF=N%TOS=C0%IPLEN=164%RIPTL=148%RID=E%RIPCK=E%UCK=E%ULEN=134% DAT=E)
Uptime 41.944 days (since Sun Aug 29 21:XX:XX 2004) TCP Sequence Prediction: Class=random positive increments
Difficulty=4237446 (Good luck!)
TCP ISN Seq. Numbers: 99D03998 9A7D22DF 9A644725 9A6FDD72 9A0BEAA0 IPID Sequence Generation: All zeros
Nmap run completed -- 1 IP address (1 host up) scanned in 8.556 seconds
-------------------------------
If I remember correctly my contract, after 36 months, I become the owner of the freebox. The argument about renting does not seem to hold, anyway.
I will contact Free to ask for more information.
Best,
/er.
Signature · 2 lines
Eric Rannaud <[email protected]> http://www.eleves.ens.fr/home/rannaud/
Quoted 4 lines
If I remember correctly my contract, after 36 months, I become the owner of the freebox. The argument about renting does not seem to hold, anyway.
In the United States, it is illegal to rent computer software without the
copyright holder's permission. Arguments such as, "I'm selling/renting the computer/hard drive, the software just happens to be on it" don't generally impress the courts.
In any event, it seems pretty obvious to me that renting a physical medium
that contains an encoded copyrighted work is a form of distribution of that work. The operation of that physical device is as much a derived work of the copyrighted work as the visual/audio experience of seeing a play is a derived work of the script for the play.
In other words, I don't think any court or lawyer would find the "we're
renting the computer, not distributing the software that comes with it and is required for its operation" to be persuasive. IANL, YMMV.
DS
Quoted 6 lines · David Schwartz
In any event, it seems pretty obvious to me that renting a
physical medium that contains an encoded copyrighted work is a form of distribution of that work. The operation of that physical device is as much a derived work of the copyrighted work as the visual/audio experience of seeing a play is a derived work of the script for the play.
Are you sure it's not a performance?
Signature · 2 lines
Måns Rullgård [email protected]
Hi,
Quoted 8 lines
Initiating SYN Stealth Scan against XX.XX.XX.254 [1660 ports] at 20:23
PORT STATE SERVICE
22/tcp open ssh
199/tcp open smux
MAC Address: 00:07:XX:XX:XX:XX (Freebox SA)
Device type: general purpose
Running: Linux 2.4.X|2.5.X
OS details: Linux 2.4.0 - 2.5.20
I think you just scanned the router, or whatever network appliance it is, behind the freebox :-)
The freebox is quite transparent when it's plugged to the network. Try to just plug in to your computer and assign it an IP using arp -s...
(not sure, however)
Signature · 1 line
Colin
Quoted 9 lines · Colin Leroy
Hi,
I think you just scanned the router, or whatever network appliance it is, behind the freebox :-)
The freebox is quite transparent when it's plugged to the network. Try to just plug in to your computer and assign it an IP using arp -s...
(not sure, however)
Ermmm, indeed, that's quite possible :-{ I've been lured by the MAC address, which was correct. But that didn't mean anything. The problem is that once the freebox is disconnected from the xDSL line, it becomes completely silent on the network. nmap -O -P0 is meaningless.
It does seem to act like a bridge, indeed.
Quoted 2 lines · Mathieu
Are you sure you don't scan your computer : the freebox v1 don't have router mode and act like a bridge.
No, my computer doesn't look like that.
I have asked Free for more information about the OS running on the freebox. I don't know what kind of tests could be performed on such a device. If you have any suggestion.
/er.
Signature · 2 lines
Eric Rannaud <[email protected]> http://www.eleves.ens.fr/home/rannaud/