How to implement multithreaded event loop ?
Hi!
I am trying to implement a multithreaded event loop using epoll. So, I have 2 kind of events. First, there are conditions on fds I have (listener sockets, client connections, my connections to other clients). Second, I need to have some kind of priority queue into which I can push forthcoming timed events.
In case of single-threaded server, this is fairly trivial. I just need to make heap queue and add its 1st (i.e. minimal) element as timeout to each next epoll_wait call. When some condition breaks the wait, I can always do find_min and wait again with new timeout.
Things become complicated when I need to scale. So, without this timeout cruft, I can just add proper locking around my data structures but main epoll_wait loop is multithread-aware, e.g. it will retrieve different events for different waiting threads (to be absolutely fair with you, I did not implemented this part yet, but I assume that some combination of edge triggered + one shot epoll will do the trick). But, if using heap priority queue to manage timed events, I need to wake up each waiting thread when any event was added to the heap before one that was minimal.
Quoted 1 line
From all I've read about it, waking up all waiting thread isn't
trivial.
Another solution proposed by my poor brain is - to have alive thread which will handle this priority queue, and have one fifo fd in my epoll set dedicated to this purpose. Priority queue management thread will write single char to that fd when some timed event needs to be processed.
Doing some google search, I've found this message:
http://www.uwsg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0210.3/2416.html
Things can be much easier if there was timer kernel object (or its equivalent). Can anyone give me some advice - how I should solve this problem?
Thanks in advance.
Signature · 2 lines
Paul P 'Stingray' Komkoff Jr // http://stingr.net/key <- my pgp key This message represents the official view of the voices in my head
Quoted 11 lines · Paul P Komkoff Jr
I am trying to implement a multithreaded event loop using epoll. So, I have 2 kind of events. First, there are conditions on fds I have (listener sockets, client connections, my connections to other clients). Second, I need to have some kind of priority queue into which I can push forthcoming timed events.
In case of single-threaded server, this is fairly trivial. I just need to make heap queue and add its 1st (i.e. minimal) element as timeout to each next
epoll_waitcall. When some condition breaks the wait, I can always dofind_minand wait again with new timeout.
Quoted 9 lines
Things become complicated when I need to scale. So, without this timeout cruft, I can just add proper locking around my data structures but main
epoll_waitloop is multithread-aware, e.g. it will retrieve different events for different waiting threads (to be absolutely fair with you, I did not implemented this part yet, but I assume that some combination of edge triggered + one shot epoll will do the trick). But, if using heap priority queue to manage timed events, I need to wake up each waiting thread when any event was added to the heap before one that was minimal.
One solution (if you really cannot scale using multiple processes) is the one that you're describing, where you have many threads doing epoll_wait. You have to be careful to not fetch too many event on a single wait (preferably one), otherwise you can end up with period of time with pending events on a single thread, while others are free to spin. If the timers that you are using are simply to timeout pending operations, the timer resolution does not need to be that high, so you could use a maximum timeout of a second or so for epoll_wait (and handle timers like you planned). Another solution would be to have a single epoll_wait loop thread that feeds your threads that are waiting on a mutex, protecting an event queue from which threads pull events. This will make timeout handling somehow easier, but delivering an event would mean a ctx switch to wake the epoll_wait thread, plus another one waking a processing thread.
Quoted 11 lines
Another solution proposed by my poor brain is - to have alive thread which will handle this priority queue, and have one fifo fd in my epoll set dedicated to this purpose. Priority queue management thread will write single char to that fd when some timed event needs to be processed.
Doing some google search, I've found this message:
http://www.uwsg.iu.edu/hypermail/linux/kernel/0210.3/2416.html
Things can be much easier if there was timer kernel object (or its equivalent). Can anyone give me some advice - how I should solve this problem?
Like lingering IRQs, nobody cared :-) Linus also proposed a "signal fd", that could have been used for timers, but nobody showed interest either.
- Davide