Skip to contentSkip to conversation

non-fakeraid controllers

DISCUSSION [email protected] 7 participants 9 messages Feb 7, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

This is not an attempt to start a religious flamewar about what is
RAID vs. what is softraid vs. what is fakeraid.

Does anyone has a list/refence/etc on reasonably modern SCSI
controllers (at least u160) in a non-fakeraid way i.e. the way that would allow linux to boot from a RAID protected disk array when one of the drives in the array failed even if the root filesystem is located on the same array?

Thanks,
Alex

#1 lore raw
Quoted 12 lines · [email protected] wrote:

Hi,

This is not an attempt to start a religious flamewar about what is
RAID vs. what is softraid vs. what is fakeraid.

Does anyone has a list/refence/etc on reasonably modern SCSI
controllers (at least u160) in a non-fakeraid way i.e. the way that would allow linux to boot from a RAID protected disk array when one of the drives in the array failed even if the root filesystem is located on the same array?

Ability to boot requires bios/bootloader support. Depending on the bios in question, this may work for real RAID, fakeraid or even linux sw raid.

You can boot directly from the software raid-1 in linux. And you can set it up so it will boot with one drive failed too - although you may have to disconnect the bad drive so the biosdoesn't mistakenly try to load the kernel bootloader from the damaged disk.

Having the root filesytem on a damaged array is not a problem - as soon as the kernel is running it can activate the raid in degraded mode and use the filesystem just fine. This is no more secure than a single-disk setup though, so don't wait too long before you replace the failed drive.

Fakeraid controllers may have bios support for booting, but often you'll find that linux have no support for the fake raid. So you have to turn that off and use software raid instead. An expensive "real raid" controller that have linux support, will usually have a bios that support booting from the raid too. Writing to manufacturers should get you the details on booting in degraded conditions.

Helge Hafting

#6 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 10 lines · On Mon, Feb 06, 2006 at 08:51:26PM -0500, [email protected]…

Hi,

This is not an attempt to start a religious flamewar about what is
RAID vs. what is softraid vs. what is fakeraid.

Does anyone has a list/refence/etc on reasonably modern SCSI
controllers (at least u160) in a non-fakeraid way i.e. the way that would allow linux to boot from a RAID protected disk array when one of the drives in the array failed even if the root filesystem is located on the same array?

LSI 1030/1035 U320 (fusion) controllers have simple raid0/raid1 support

Adaptec and LSI still have some u160 or even u320 controllers in the aacraid/ megaraid series afaik, the present the same interface to the OS for parallel scsi/sata/sas so it's a bit hard to say for me which is the most recent parallel scsi one.

The old Mylex controllers supported by drivers/block/DAC960.c support up to u160, and u320 with an IBM-branded controller which probably isn't sold separately from IBM Equipment and probably not at all anymore.

The IBM i/pSeries integrated RAID supports up to U320 (drivers/scsi/ipr.c), but you don't get it without an i/pSeries system.

There's Intel Branded, Adaptec manufactured RAID cards that support U160 SCSI, they're supported by drivers/scsi/gdth.c

#7 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 5 lines · On Llu, 2006-02-06 at 20:51 -0500, [email protected] wrote:

Does anyone has a list/refence/etc on reasonably modern SCSI
controllers (at least u160) in a non-fakeraid way i.e. the way that would allow linux to boot from a RAID protected disk array when one of the drives in the array failed even if the root filesystem is located on the same array?

Most raid (soft or otherwise) will usually do it. I don't know any SCSI hardware which will do it reliably unless you go fibrechannel or SATA simply because a dead scsi drive can and sometimes does hang the entire shared bus.

The majority of the time the aacraid based cards will do what you need (most of the time anyway) and can also do a lot of on the fly recovery and management. The fusions can do some raid stuff of this nature. Most of the newer hardware is going SATA however.

Alan

#2 lore raw
In reply to Helge Hafting
Quoted 13 lines · Helge Hafting

Ability to boot requires bios/bootloader support. Depending on the bios in question, this may work for real RAID, fakeraid or even linux sw raid.

You can boot directly from the software raid-1 in linux. And you can set it up so it will boot with one drive failed too - although you may have to disconnect the bad drive so the biosdoesn't mistakenly try to load the kernel bootloader from the damaged disk.

Having the root filesytem on a damaged array is not a problem - as soon as the kernel is running it can activate the raid in degraded mode and use the filesystem just fine. This is no more secure than a single-disk setup though, so don't wait too long before you replace the failed drive.

Quoted 7 lines

Fakeraid controllers may have bios support for booting, but often you'll find that linux have no support for the fake raid. So you have to turn that off and use software raid instead. An expensive "real raid" controller that have linux support, will usually have a bios that support booting from the raid too. Writing to manufacturers should get you the details on booting in degraded conditions.

Heinz wrote a utility called 'dmraid' which detects and activates various hardware fakeraid volumes using the kernel device mapper. I'm using it at home to dual boot ubuntu and winxp ( just in case ) from a stripe of two WD 10,000 rpm raptors and it works great. I'm still pushing to get it integrated into dapper. At this time however, neither my hardware, nor dmraid support raid-5. Hopefully this will change in the future.

#3 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · Phillip Susi

Heinz wrote a utility called 'dmraid' which detects and activates various hardware fakeraid volumes using the kernel device mapper. I'm using it at home to dual boot ubuntu and winxp ( just in case ) from a stripe of two WD 10,000 rpm raptors and it works great. I'm still pushing to get it integrated into dapper. At this time however, neither my hardware, nor dmraid support raid-5. Hopefully this will change in the future.

I've been wondering about dmraid. I considered buying an adaptec sata raid (hardware). One of the drawbacks on hardware raid is the format isn't compatible with any other card (or rather manufacturer). So the question is, has anyone written anything that can detect and activate disks from a hardware raid controller when they are placed on a controller w/o any raid?

basically what I mean is, 3 disks, raid5 was in a system with hardware raid. the raid card blows up and cannot get another one so to get the data back, place disks in another machine or on a standard controller and use software raid or whatever to recover the data.

Signature · 2 lines
 Lab tests show that use of micro$oft causes cancer in lab animals
 Got Gas???
#4 lore raw
Quoted 9 lines · Wakko Warner

I've been wondering about dmraid. I considered buying an adaptec sata raid (hardware). One of the drawbacks on hardware raid is the format isn't compatible with any other card (or rather manufacturer). So the question is, has anyone written anything that can detect and activate disks from a hardware raid controller when they are placed on a controller w/o any raid?

basically what I mean is, 3 disks, raid5 was in a system with hardware raid. the raid card blows up and cannot get another one so to get the data back, place disks in another machine or on a standard controller and use software
raid or whatever to recover the data.

Yes, that is one of the problems with hardware raid controllers. If you can figure out the controller's metadata format, possibly by asking adaptec, or reverse engineering, then patching dmraid to understand that format ( it already understands several used by fakeraid controllers ) should be rather easy.

#5 lore raw
Quoted 13 lines · Phillip Susi
Quoted 11 lines · Wakko Warner

I've been wondering about dmraid. I considered buying an adaptec sata raid (hardware). One of the drawbacks on hardware raid is the format isn't compatible with any other card (or rather manufacturer). So the question is, has anyone written anything that can detect and activate disks from a hardware raid controller when they are placed on a controller w/o any raid?

basically what I mean is, 3 disks, raid5 was in a system with hardware raid. the raid card blows up and cannot get another one so to get the data back,
place disks in another machine or on a standard controller and use software raid or whatever to recover the data.

Quoted 5 lines

Yes, that is one of the problems with hardware raid controllers. If you can figure out the controller's metadata format, possibly by asking adaptec, or reverse engineering, then patching dmraid to understand that format ( it already understands several used by fakeraid controllers ) should be rather easy.

One of the things that I noticed with adaptec's and ami's raid (and an old mylex dac960 IIRC) is that you can create containers or partitions (which every they call them) on a disk set. I guess you can take 3 disks, create a raid5 using half the capcity of the 3 disks and a raid0 on the rest. I'm not sure about fakeraid controllers as I've never configured one.

Signature · 2 lines
 Lab tests show that use of micro$oft causes cancer in lab animals
 Got Gas???
#8 lore raw
In reply to [email protected]
Quoted 11 lines · On 2/7/06, [email protected]…

Hi,

This is not an attempt to start a religious flamewar about what is
RAID vs. what is softraid vs. what is fakeraid.

Does anyone has a list/refence/etc on reasonably modern SCSI
controllers (at least u160) in a non-fakeraid way i.e. the way that would allow linux to boot from a RAID protected disk array when one of the drives in the array failed even if the root filesystem is located on the same array?

Personally I have very good exeriences with Linux & IBM ServeRAID controllers (especially the ServeRAID-5i, ServeRAID-5M & ServeRAID-6M) as well as HP's Integrated Smart Array 6i controller in their ProLiant DL380 G4 servers.

--
Jesper Juhl <[email protected]>
Don't top-post http://www.catb.org/~esr/jargon/html/T/top-post.html
Plain text mails only, please http://www.expita.com/nomime.html