is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
http://www.konicaminolta.us
http://www.efi.com/
product: option for konica-minolta bizhub c351
IC-402 Embedded Fiery Print Controller
operating system:
Linux
product: EFI - Fiery System 6e system 6e X3e CONTROLLER SOLUTIONS
operating system:
Linux
product: EFI - PrintMe
operating system:
Linux
<< NO SOURCE CODE FOR LINUX >> on media/web
xboom
Quoted 6 lines · art
is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
Quoted 6 lines
product: option for konica-minolta bizhub c351
IC-402 Embedded Fiery Print Controllerproduct: EFI - Fiery System 6e system 6e X3e CONTROLLER SOLUTIONS
product: EFI - PrintMe
Probably not, but it's hard to tell.
When they sell you the system, they have to tell you how to get sources if those things run Linux, but they don't actually have to make the sources available otherwise.
(I didn't look the things up, but it's also pretty unlikely that they'd have a custom kernel on them. I don't see why they should - at least the IC-402 thing seems to be basically just an embedded PC. So I suspect they have little incentive to keep anything secret).
Linus
Quoted 3 lines · art
is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
<< NO SOURCE CODE FOR LINUX >> on media/web
Did you:
a). Buy the product.
b). Ask them for the source?
Jon.
Quoted 10 lines · Jon Masters
Quoted 3 lines · art
is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
<< NO SOURCE CODE FOR LINUX >> on media/web
Did you:
a). Buy the product.
b). Ask them for the source?
it's not quite as simple. You can't know if it's a gpl violation, because they could have shipped the source to the people who bought it. (for embedded stuff with a disk on it, like most printer controllers, it's easy to just put the source on that disk with the binary and satisfy the gpl)
If they did not ship the source they need to ship a written offer that is valid for *everyone* not just the people they gave the binary to.
Quoted 5 lines · Arjan van de Ven
Quoted 4 lines · Jon Masters
Quoted 1 line · art
is this GPL v2 violation - konica-minolta or EFI ?
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line
<< NO SOURCE CODE FOR LINUX >> on media/web
Did you:
a). Buy the product.
b). Ask them for the source?it's not quite as simple.
Who's your response for? me or the original poster? I know the issues, I'm just trying to get him to say whether he bought it and to determine some of the necessary background :-)
Jon.