Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Binary Drivers

DISCUSSION Martin Knoblauch 2 participants 3 messages Dec 26, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Oh, if only for Christmas - stop this stupid car comparisons. They are
just that - utter nonsense.

Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line

I have no idea why you assume that "having the right to do X"

implies

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

"must be told how to do X". The have the right (except as laws prohibit it) to modify the car's systems, but (except for some specific legal requirements) the manufacturer is not required to explain anything, even basic operation.

It's really common sense. Imagine if you buy the right to use my car, but I don't give you the key.

I would sue you for fraud, because the key is "key" in using the car.

Quoted 3 lines

Can I say, "yes, you have the right to use my car, you bought that, but that doesn't mean I have to tell you how to use my car."

You don't need to tell me how to use your car. I know that. All you
have to do is hand over the car, all the papers and of course the key.

You do not have to tell me how the motor-control is programmed. That
knowledge is not needed to operate the car.

Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

If I buy a device that has a safety of some kind, the manufacturer cannot prohibit me from removing or disabling the safety unless some law gives them that authority. ...

They might be obliged to make it as hard as possible to tamper with
the safety to prevent their (in the sense they made and sold it) devices being used in illegal ways. Otherwise they could end up in court themselves.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Yes, I agree. However, they are completely allowed to make it arbitrarily hard for you to remove (by, for instance, welding the safety in place).

I do not think they can. You cannot at the same time argue that they sold me the right to remove the safety and that they can take active steps to stop me from using the safety.

The are not stopping you from using the safety. They are stopping you
from misusing it. And common sense does not show why they would be required to help you in breaking the law. So, any of this is OK in my opinion:

* voiding the warranty (and stating so) if you tamper with the safety
* block the function of the device if the safety has been tampered with
* not telling you how the thing works at all (unless you are a certified car maintainer under NDA).

Quoted 2 lines

Again, the same example -- you buy the right to use my car, but I shoot at you every time you step on my property.

Oh, come on. This is such utter nonsense. What has it to do with the
topic?

Quoted 3 lines

Or I sell you my car, but right before I do, I put on a lock that only I can unlock and make it deliberately hard for you to remove it.

If it blocks me from using the car, I sue you for fraud. Because you
prevent the common sense use of my property.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Again, (IANAL), I think this is simply a misconception. Buyng a physical object gives you the right to do anything with it that the law allows,

Exactly.

Quoted 3 lines

but imposes no obligation on the seller to explain it (other than specific restrictions hte law may apply to specific classes of objects for safety or other reasons).

Absolutely correct.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 3 lines

It's up to you, in deciding whether to buy it, to decide whether it comes with sufficient documentation to satisfy your needs.

I think that simply defies common sense. If I sold you a house and then refused to provide you the keys, and made you break down the doors to get in, you'd have every right to sue me. A house *has* *to* come with keys. If not, the seller should bear the cost of your inability to use the house in a reasonable way without damaging it.

Another completely nonsensical example. Of course, if I sell you a
house and keep the keys after you have paid the agreed upon price, you can sue me for fraud. But I do not have to explain how the lock works? Do I?

Quoted 6 lines

You cannot sell something and then claim that you retained certain rights over the thing you sold unless you either negotiated for those rights or some law allows you to keep those rights. If you sell a computer, and it is password-protected, the password has to come with it. You cannot keep it a secret. You cannot negligently "happen to" lose it.

Sure, I need to give you the password or a means to legally reset it.
But I do not have to explain the password algorithm to you. I don't even have to tell you which algorithm is used, or which language it is implemented in.

Quoted 5 lines

When you buy a video car, you are *not* buying the right to use that video card with Windows. You are buying all the rights to the video card, to use it any way you please. The manufacturer has no right (because it sold that right when it sold the video card) to interfere or obstruct your right to use it as you please.

It depends what is written on the box, or what is in the contract. If
it says "works with XXX" (and it does), you have no right to demand that it works with YYY, or that the manufacturer has to help you make it work with YYY.

The manufacturer may not be allowed to *actively* prevent you from
making it work with YYY, but I see no legal problem (IANAL, in any jurisdiction of the wolrd) if they make it hard for you by being *passive*.

If they promised that it works with YYY, it is another story. They are
obliged to make it work or compensate you. How they make it work is up to them, as long as they keep the promise. Whether you are satisfied is up to you.

Quoted 4 lines

If you retain some rights over something, then you are not selling it in the normal sense. You are selling a subset of the rights to it, and the buy must be told what rights he is getting and what rights he is not getting.

They are not keeping any right from you. They are just not being
helpful.

And now lets stop the car nonsense !!!! :-)

Martin

------------------------------------------------------
Martin Knoblauch

email: k n o b i AT knobisoft DOT de
www:   http://www.knobisoft.de
#1 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Martin Knoblauch

Oh, if only for Christmas - stop this stupid car comparisons. They are
just that - utter nonsense.

And now lets stop the car nonsense !!!! :-)

I agree, if you really want to talk about cars, I can relate the woes I've heard from mechanics about how impossible it is to service new model Fords these days. Without the engine management systems diagnostics devices they can't do anything. Ford controls who gets these devices and demands a cut of every service, essentially setting the price. Service centers that don't play ball don't get the devices or get the devices taken away from them if they question Ford's pricing policies. Of course, this should be illegal, and our governments should be enforcing antitrust laws, but Ford is a big company and has lots of lawyers..

Repco and other after market manufacturers can't easily make a clone of these devices like they do every other part, because reverse engineering software is not really as advanced as reverse engineering spare parts.. or maybe software reverse engineering is just so much more expensive than automotive reverse engineering that it is not cost effective to clone these devices.. or maybe they're just afraid of the lawyers too.

Trent

#2 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · --- Trent Waddington
Quoted 2 lines · Martin Knoblauch

Oh, if only for Christmas - stop this stupid car comparisons. They

are

Quoted 3 lines

just that - utter nonsense.

And now lets stop the car nonsense !!!! :-)

I agree, if you really want to talk about cars, I can relate the woes I've heard from mechanics about how impossible it is to service new model Fords these days.

A behaviour that is not very different from gthe GMs, BMWs,
daimler-Chryslers, Toyota, "you name them" of this world.

I never said I liked the attitude.

Quoted 9 lines

Without the engine management systems
diagnostics devices they can't do anything. Ford controls who gets these devices and demands a cut of every service, essentially setting the price. Service centers that don't play ball don't get the devices or get the devices taken away from them if they question Ford's pricing policies. Of course, this should be illegal, and our governments should be enforcing antitrust laws, but Ford is a big company and has lots of lawyers..

Actually we have/had a similar situation here in Germany. We are used
to having "licensed dealerships" which are only allowed to sell one car brand. This might be illegal by EU laws now.

Quoted 8 lines

Repco and other after market manufacturers can't easily make a clone of these devices like they do every other part, because reverse engineering software is not really as advanced as reverse engineering spare parts.. or maybe software reverse engineering is just so much more expensive than automotive reverse engineering that it is not cost effective to clone these devices.. or maybe they're just afraid of the lawyers too.

Understanding software is more difficult, because you also have to
understand the working prinziple of the underlying hardware, which you often have no specs for either. So you have to reverse engineer both layers.

Cheers
Martin

------------------------------------------------------
Martin Knoblauch

email: k n o b i AT knobisoft DOT de
www:   http://www.knobisoft.de