strange keyboard lag after suspend testing
Hi!
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected. /proc/interrupts seem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html
Hi,
Quoted 7 lines · Pavel Machek
Hi!
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?
Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?
Andreas Mohr
Hi!
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html
Quoted 8 lines · Pavel Machek
Hi!
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
Hi!
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said
Mouse _seems_ okay, but I'm not sure if I'd notice lag there.
Quoted 2 lines
that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Hmm, seems that it only happens in X... so maybe it is some strange scheduling artefact?
Hmm, something is wrong here:
On console, I get expected 4-5 ticks a second. In x in gnome-terminal, I get this:
root@amd:~# while true ; do echo -n . ; sleep .2; date; done .Tue Mar 20 17:28:34 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:35 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:35 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:35 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:36 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:36 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:36 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:36 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:37 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:37 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:37 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:37 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:38 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:38 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:38 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:39 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:39 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:39 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:39 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:39 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:40 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:40 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:40 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:40 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:41 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:41 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:41 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:42 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:28:42 CET 2007
So sorry for false alarm, it is not keyboard related, it is just very very strange.
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html
Hi!
Quoted 23 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said
Mouse _seems_ okay, but I'm not sure if I'd notice lag there.
Quoted 2 lines
that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Quoted 7 lines
Hmm, seems that it only happens in X... so maybe it is some strange scheduling artefact?
Hmm, something is wrong here:
On console, I get expected 4-5 ticks a second. In x in gnome-terminal, I get this:
It gets weirder: I killed some tasks and now: (on unloaded system running X, notice that top latency was ~1sec at 33:09).
root@amd:~# while true ; do echo -n . ; sleep .2; date; done .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:09 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007
As soon as I load the cpu up with while1, machine starts to behave.
When I turn on bluetooth (USB), ACPI can no longer use C3, and machine starts to behave. Hmm?
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html
Quoted 55 lines · Pavel Machek
Hi!
Quoted 23 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said
Mouse _seems_ okay, but I'm not sure if I'd notice lag there.
Quoted 2 lines
that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Quoted 7 lines
Hmm, seems that it only happens in X... so maybe it is some strange scheduling artefact?
Hmm, something is wrong here:
On console, I get expected 4-5 ticks a second. In x in gnome-terminal, I get this:
It gets weirder: I killed some tasks and now: (on unloaded system running X, notice that top latency was ~1sec at 33:09).
root@amd:~# while true ; do echo -n . ; sleep .2; date; done .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:09 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007
Quoted 4 lines
As soon as I load the cpu up with while1, machine starts to behave.
When I turn on bluetooth (USB), ACPI can no longer use C3, and machine starts to behave. Hmm?
Smells like a cpufreq problem or something related.
Greetings,
Rafael
Adding Thomas Gleixner to CC
Pavel Machek <[email protected]> ha scritto:
Quoted 55 lines
Hi!
Quoted 23 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I was testing suspend in 2.6.21-rc4 a lot, and now... machine feels like someone added 50..100msec delay somewhere in keyboard handling. Mouse does not seem affected.
/proc/interruptsseem to increase as they should, for both keyboard and mouse. Can someone reproduce it? Any ideas how to debug it?Probably just asking the obvious:
it's not a trivial "failed to re-configure repeat rate upon resume" (which one could rule out by running "kbdrate" again)
but a lag in some interrupt handler or somewhere else deeper, right?Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said
Mouse _seems_ okay, but I'm not sure if I'd notice lag there.
Quoted 2 lines
that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Quoted 7 lines
Hmm, seems that it only happens in X... so maybe it is some strange scheduling artefact?
Hmm, something is wrong here:
On console, I get expected 4-5 ticks a second. In x in gnome-terminal, I get this:
It gets weirder: I killed some tasks and now: (on unloaded system running X, notice that top latency was ~1sec at 33:09).
root@amd:~# while true ; do echo -n . ; sleep .2; date; done .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:09 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007
Quoted 4 lines
As soon as I load the cpu up with while1, machine starts to behave.
When I turn on bluetooth (USB), ACPI can no longer use C3, and machine starts to behave. Hmm?
When the CPU is in C3 the TSC and LAPIC (IIRC) are stopped, sounds like the problem is here. Maybe after resume kernel fails to fall back to a "safe" clocksource.
Luca
Signature · 3 lines
Inquietudine sintetica Solo, davanti all'ignoto Tienimi stretto a te
Hi!
Quoted 42 lines
Quoted 42 lines
Quoted 12 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
No, it is not keyboard rate. Keyboard lags during normal typing, sometimes letters come in groups of two or so...
I might start looking at embedded controller changes and switches. If ACPI misbehaves that could starve keyboard controller... But you said
Mouse _seems_ okay, but I'm not sure if I'd notice lag there.
Quoted 2 lines
that mouse is OK... Hmm, what happens if you load evbug and type while watching syslog. Do you observe the same delays?
Quoted 7 lines
Hmm, seems that it only happens in X... so maybe it is some strange scheduling artefact?
Hmm, something is wrong here:
On console, I get expected 4-5 ticks a second. In x in gnome-terminal, I get this:
It gets weirder: I killed some tasks and now: (on unloaded system running X, notice that top latency was ~1sec at 33:09).
root@amd:~# while true ; do echo -n . ; sleep .2; date; done .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:07 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:08 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:09 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:10 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:11 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007 .Tue Mar 20 17:33:12 CET 2007
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
As soon as I load the cpu up with while1, machine starts to behave.
When I turn on bluetooth (USB), ACPI can no longer use C3, and machine starts to behave. Hmm?
When the CPU is in C3 the TSC and LAPIC (IIRC) are stopped, sounds like the problem is here. Maybe after resume kernel fails to fall back to a "safe" clocksource.
Notice that problem is _not_ easily reproducible :-(. One suspend is not enough to trigger it.
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html