Skip to contentSkip to conversation

2.6.21-ck1

DISCUSSION Con Kolivas 4 participants 4 messages May 4, 2007 – May 6, 2007

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

This patchset is designed to improve system responsiveness and interactivity. It is configurable to any workload but the default -ck patch is aimed at the desktop and -cks is available with more emphasis on serverspace.

Apply to 2.6.21
http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/ck/patches/2.6/2.6.21/2.6.21-ck1/patch-2.6.21-ck1.bz2

or server version
http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/ck/patches/2.6/2.6.21/2.6.21-ck1/patch-2.6.21-cks1.bz2

web:
http://kernel.kolivas.org

wiki:
http://ck.wikia.com

all patches:
http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/ck/patches/

Changes since 2.6.20-ck1:

The staircase-deadline cpu scheduler has replaced the old staircase design in this version. The extra scheduling policies in 2.6.20-ck1 of SCHED_IDLEPRIO (idle cpu scheduling) and SCHED_ISO (unprivileged soft real time) have been rewritten and work in the same manner on this new scheduler. In almost all ways this should be a drop in replacement for the older -ck and no userspace changes should be required apart from deprecating the "compute" tunable (see below).

More HZ options were added to this kernel. I have had repeated requests for this as people have found woefully coded binary only availability software that is dependant on the HZ value for performance (specifically the game servers). Since it's trivial to add extra values I offer (mostly unsupported) values up to 10000 HZ. People have found game servers benefitting from up to 4000 if I recall correctly. Note this patch will, unfortunately, cause a reject with 2.6.21.1 so if you wish to apply -ck to that kernel, please apply 2.6.21.1 first and then -ck and ignore the reject, or back out the hz-raise_max-2.patch

The "interactive" tunable in
/proc/sys/kernel/interactive
still exists but its effects are now subtle, and fairness is still quite strongly maintained with it enabled, and starvation is still impossible. The -cks patch has this disabled by default. From the sysctl documentation included in Documentation/sysctl/kernel here is a summary:

The staircase-deadline cpu scheduler can be set in either purely forward-looking mode for absolutely rigid fairness and cpu distribution according to nice level, or it can allow a small per-process history to smooth out cpu usage perturbations common in interactive tasks by enabling this sysctl. While small fairness issues can arise with this enabled, overall fairness is usually still strongly maintained and starvation is never possible. Enabling this can significantly smooth out 3d graphics and games.

The "compute" tunable has been deprecated. The new tunable which is more flexible is the use of "rr_interval"
/proc/sys/kernel/rr_interval
and this describes the millisecond duration tasks at the same priority round robin between each other. The default value chosen is 6ms on UP on -ck and 10ms on UP on -cks. With more cpus it is scaled upwards. It can be changed on the fly up to 5000. Setting it to this has a similar and even more profound effect on throughput for pure cpu bound tasks but causes large increases in scheduling latency. This would be highly desirable for a render or compile farm machine though.

Split patches available:
http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/ck/patches/2.6/2.6.21/2.6.21-ck1/patches/

Full patchlist:

ck1-version.patch
2.6.21-sd-0.48.patch
sched-sd-0.48-interactive_tunable.patch
sched-range.patch
sched-iso-5.4.patch
track_mutexes-1.patch
sched-idleprio-2.3.patch
sched-limit_policy_changes.patch
sched-add-above-background-load-function.patch
cfq-ioprio_inherit_rt_class.patch
cfq-iso_idleprio_ionice.patch
mm-swap_prefetch-35.patch
mm-convert_swappiness_to_mapped.patch
mm-lots_watermark.diff
mm-kswapd_inherit_prio-1.patch
mm-prio_dependant_scan-2.patch
mm-background_scan-2.patch
mm-filesize_dependant_lru_cache_add.patch
mm-idleprio_prio.patch
kconfig-expose_vmsplit_option.patch
hz-default_1000.patch
hz-no_default_250.patch
hz-raise_max-2.patch
ck-desktop-tune.patch
+/- 2.6.21-ck1-cks1.patch

乾杯

Signature · 1 line
-ck
#1 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Con Kolivas

This patchset is designed to improve system responsiveness and interactivity. It is configurable to any workload but the default -ck patch is aimed at the desktop and -cks is available with more emphasis on serverspace.

Hi Con,

I have 2.6.21-ck1 running happily on a variety of machines. Everything seems fine on both uniprocessor and SMP machines.

I've been running SD for a couple of weeks now, including alternating between a SD patched kernel and an "old" staircase based kernel for a week of that. SD seems perfectly smooth. In fact on going back to the old kernel for a day I'm sure it felt more "choppy". I don't really do benchmarks, "feel" is more relevant to me. Right now I'd say my R4 "feels" better with SD than it has for a long time. Nice Job. Thanks for persisiting.

As an aside I realized whilst trying non ck kernels the last few weeks just how much of a difference swap prefetch actually makes on a lowish memory machine such as this.

Arigatou gozaimashita

David

#2 lore raw
In reply to Con Kolivas
Quoted 5 lines · Con Kolivas

This patchset is designed to improve system responsiveness and interactivity. It is configurable to any workload but the default -ck patch is aimed at the desktop and -cks is available with more emphasis on serverspace.

Apply to 2.6.21
http://www.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/ck/patches/2.6/2.6.21/2.6.21-ck1/patch-2.6.21-ck1.bz2

Hi all,

i am using this patch for the first time and i am reporting my experience.

Before this patch with all the programs i usually keep running
(opera/iceweasel with lots of tabs, icedove mail client, konversation irc client, akregator feed reader, and the super-hog second life client, vim, among others) the reponse was a bit slugish (waiting for program focus, wait for redrawing specially when i change from one virtual desktop to another).

After I started using this patch the response/interactivity seems
improved and faster, i never used Linux so responsive as now. I can switch between virtual desktops with immediate response. Even with a load of 2.0 (now, while i am writing this) thse system it's very responsive and the audio and video still work without glitches.

Just for the record, and if it matters i am using it on a laptop with a T2500 CPU, 1 GB RAM.

If there's any way i can help, providing data, running any kind of benchmark to quantify the beahaviour, etc... please ask.

Thanks all who made/tested this patch. Good work. Thanks.

[...]

Quoted 3 lines

乾杯

Signature · 4 lines
Com os melhores cumprimentos/Best regards,

Miguel Figueiredo
http://www.DebianPT.org
#3 lore raw
In reply to Con Kolivas

Hello Con,

Quoted 1 line · Con Kolivas

This patchset is designed to improve system responsiveness and interactivity. It is configurable to any workload but the default -ck patch is aimed at the desktop and -cks is available with more emphasis on serverspace.

I have used SD for the first time with this patchset, and I have to say, my experience has been very positive over the past four days. My desktop has been extraordinarily smooth during interactive tasks with no audio drop-outs. Best of all, the desktop has been completely responsive despite CPU hogging tasks. I do not need to nice X either. This looks like a perfect scheduler.

Swap prefetch continues to work its miracles as I've been doing a lot of work lately with a 33"x44" poster that contains many high-resolutions images, while using gimp at the same time!

Thanks so much for all your incredible work!

Quoted 4 lines

乾杯

best,
Ryan