Dual-Licensing Linux Kernel with GPL V2 and GPL V3
Quoted 3 lines · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
It was probably a strategic mistake for GNU to lock into Linux, instead of developing a system that would allow GNU to plug-and-play the Kernel. A mistake that could easily be rectified, given enough desire.
Second, GPLv2 was/is probably instrumental to the success of GNU/Linux. That's because GPLv2 seems to be fair, which allows the largest possible community to form. Changing this fairness, driven by paranoia arguments, to hamper commercial entities to enter this community may possibly reduce the growth of this community.
Interestingly, it's this same paranoia that drives kernel developer to renounce a "Stable Kernel API" for fear of exploitation by certain commercial entities. Which makes you kind of wonder, why they wouldn't move to GPLv3.
Or does paranoia and paradox go hand in hand?
Thanks!
--
Al
Quoted 11 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 3 lines · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
---
Actually, for use in devices (like TiVos or cell phones), it is very definitely the kernel that is of interest. Many such devices use little or no GNU software (some manufacturers have consciously avoided it because of the possibility of shifts like the GPLv3 changes).
scott
Quoted 12 lines · Scott Preece
Quoted 10 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 1 line · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
Quoted 6 lines
---
Actually, for use in devices (like TiVos or cell phones), it is very definitely the kernel that is of interest. Many such devices use little or no GNU software (some manufacturers have consciously avoided it because of the possibility of shifts like the GPLv3 changes).
Sure, but was it Linux in embedded devices that made Linux what it is today, or was it GNU/Linux?
Thanks!
--
Al
Quoted 15 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 14 lines · Scott Preece
Quoted 10 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 1 line · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
---
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Actually, for use in devices (like TiVos or cell phones), it is very definitely the kernel that is of interest. Many such devices use little or no GNU software (some manufacturers have consciously avoided it because of the possibility of shifts like the GPLv3 changes).
Sure, but was it Linux in embedded devices that made Linux what it is today, or was it GNU/Linux?
if it was the GNU that made linux what it is today and the linux kernel mearly an oppurtunist then the GNU/Hurd, GNU/Solaris, GNU/BSD and for that matter GNU/Microsoft distributions should be steadily and quickly gaining marketshare
oh, sorry, people barely know that they exist (including people convinced that the linux kernel is junk compared to Solaris) and they are little more than proof-that-it-can-be-done showpieces.
it was the ability of the linux kernel to adapt to vastly different hardware (including embeded hardware) that made Linux what it is today.
and I do mean 'Linux" not 'GNU/Linux' in the statement above.
David Lang
Quoted 3 lines · On 6/19/07, [email protected] <[email protected]> wrote:
it was the ability of the linux kernel to adapt to vastly different hardware (including embeded hardware) that made Linux what it is today.
Which is why NetBSD is currently poised to take over the world...
Dave
Quoted 6 lines · On Wed, 20 Jun 2007 00:11:24 -0400 "Dave Neuer" <[email protected]>…
Quoted 3 lines · On 6/19/07, [email protected] <[email protected]> wrote:
it was the ability of the linux kernel to adapt to vastly different hardware (including embeded hardware) that made Linux what it is today.
Which is why NetBSD is currently poised to take over the world...
To be honest I wish some of the people continually stealing our work would just go off and use BSD instead since the BSD people welcome that kind of binary only one way usage.
The license is/was a problem however because of the advertising clause parts. It was one reason BSD was not used on a large companies choice of routers - the 'credit required' bit at the time gave the lawyers heartburn.
Alan
Quoted 22 lines · [email protected] wrote:
Quoted 21 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 19 lines · Scott Preece
Quoted 11 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 2 lines · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
---
Actually, for use in devices (like TiVos or cell phones), it is very definitely the kernel that is of interest. Many such devices use little or no GNU software (some manufacturers have consciously avoided it because of the possibility of shifts like the GPLv3 changes).
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Sure, but was it Linux in embedded devices that made Linux what it is today, or was it GNU/Linux?
if it was the GNU that made linux what it is today and the linux kernel mearly an oppurtunist then the GNU/Hurd, GNU/Solaris, GNU/BSD and for that matter GNU/Microsoft distributions should be steadily and quickly gaining marketshare
They may never reach critical mass, as GNU/Linux already crossed that border. Their only hope may possibly be a drop-in kernel replacement to leverage the vast availability of GNU/Linux distributions.
So what's this got to do with the GPLv2/v3 debate? It's the seemingly fair GPLv2 that was possibly instrumental in growing this large GNU/Linux community, and changing this fairness by hampering parties to enter this community may well be counterproductive.
Thanks!
--
Al
Quoted 15 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 14 lines · Scott Preece
Quoted 10 lines · Al Boldi
Quoted 1 line · Nicolas Mailhot
Tivo didn't make the Linux success. More Tivos can definitely undo it.
I don't think so.
First, it's not Linux that made success, but rather GNU that uses Linux as its kernel. And, believe it or not, when people say Linux, they really mean GNU. People could care less what kernel they were running, as long as the system is up and runs the procs that offer their services.
---
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Actually, for use in devices (like TiVos or cell phones), it is very definitely the kernel that is of interest. Many such devices use little or no GNU software (some manufacturers have consciously avoided it because of the possibility of shifts like the GPLv3 changes).
Sure, but was it Linux in embedded devices that made Linux what it is today, or was it GNU/Linux?
It was Apache. Apache showed corporate users and small businesses desperate to cash in on the Interweb c. 1995-1998 that they could do it w/out paying some proprietary vendor and get better performance, security and support to boot (I reported a bug in Apache JServ in 1998 and a fix was released by the time I came back from lunch 1/2 hour later). Linux was a tool for UNIX sysadmins and admin wannabes to practice their UNIX chops at home - or a conveniently inexpensive platform on which to run Apache. Companies -- other than Linux distributors -- didn't bet their business on it.
Apache's success greatly contributed to the corporate acceptance of Linux, IMHO.
Dave
Quoted 2 lines · Dave Neuer
It was Apache. Apache showed corporate users and small businesses desperate to cash in on the Interweb c. 1995-1998 ...
Right time period ...
Quoted 4 lines
Linux was a tool for UNIX sysadmins and admin wannabes to practice their UNIX chops at home - or a conveniently inexpensive platform on which to run Apache. Companies -- other than Linux distributors -- didn't bet their business on it.
Wrong conclusion. Been there, done that, helped bet the company on networks based on Linux servers.
Quoted 1 line
Apache's success greatly contributed to the corporate acceptance of Linux, IMHO.
Wrong again. Apache was not allowed to distribute strong encryption for e-commerce servers over that time frame. The solution we bought was O/S agnostic.
And to quote your next message, you have given all the reasons why NetBSD has already taken over the world.
By the time of Linux 2.0.x, it could stay up for years at a time even if it was running on garbage. There was no alternative even *close*.
-sb
Quoted 9 lines · SL Baur
Quoted 4 lines · Dave Neuer
Linux was a tool for UNIX sysadmins and admin wannabes to practice their UNIX chops at home - or a conveniently inexpensive platform on which to run Apache. Companies -- other than Linux distributors -- didn't bet their business on it.
Wrong conclusion. Been there, done that, helped bet the company on networks based on Linux servers.
One of thousands, no doubt.
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Apache's success greatly contributed to the corporate acceptance of Linux, IMHO.
Wrong again. Apache was not allowed to distribute strong encryption for e-commerce servers over that time frame.
In the US only, and it was easily available for free if people didn't care about violating patents or you could buy Stronghold from Covalent. And plenty of folks didn't need encryption or did without it even if they did.
Quoted 2 lines
By the time of Linux 2.0.x,
1996, right? When Linux had just got SMP support, and Apache was running on a majority of webservers, according to Netcraft?
Quoted 3 lines
it could stay up for years at a
time even if it was running on garbage. There was no alternative even *close*.
You're preaching to the choir about Linux quality. I started using it in 1997 (to run Apache, on a cast-off i486sx w/ 8 MB ram IIRC), and it was years before I ever had it crash on me.
My point was about perceptions, not quality -- not that Linux wasn't good, but that it was not widely considered to be "enterprise class." For certain uses, Apache was, in a way that was fairly novel for Free Software.
Anyway, it was also meant to be somewhat tongue-in-cheek (what's the emoticon for a tongue in a cheek?) -- anyone who thinks they know the _one_ reason Linux was successful is on crack (well, it might have been Linus' accent).
Dave
Quoted 2 lines
Sure, but was it Linux in embedded devices that made Linux what it is today, or was it GNU/Linux?
No, it was the fact that Linux has always been able to run on garbage.
My introduction to Linux was in 1995 when I was given a network of computers made out of back-laboratory garbage and US$0 software budget and told to make it work. None of the BSDs could cut it, but Linux could.
User space Unix tool rewrites all of which I could have gotten from *BSD had absolutely nothing to do with it. I doubt that I am typical.
-sb