Skip to contentSkip to conversation

static LSM objection

DISCUSSION Kees Cook 1 participant 2 messages Oct 12, 2007

lore
Share & tools
lore

Kees Cook

author
#0 lore raw

Hi,

I just wanted to voice my opinion about the static LSM changes. (I apologize about being late[1] to the discussion[2] -- I'd only recently become aware of it.) I'm personally really against this. For example, I want to give people choice about their security protections in Ubuntu, and I'd like to let them pick the MAC that suits their needs.

Some people want SELinux, some people want AppArmor. (Yes, I know AppArmor isn't in mainline yet, but it does seem they're getting closer -- three distros are shipping AppArmor. The static changes feel motivated by political rather than technical reason -- though it of course have technical merit.) Considering things like SMACK and TOMOYO, it is going to be very troublesome for distros to have to start building multiple kernels to support each given MAC that their users want to use.

So, unless this is just re-hashing and you can point me to discussion points I missed, can someone help me understand the technical issues around this change? It sounds like the primary reason for making it non-modular is performance loss due to call overhead. Aren't there other ways to solve this without removing the boot-time module choice? (Make it unloadable?)

I'm not convinced that the advantages of making it static out-weigh the benefit of having it as a choice at boot-time. (I don't really mind needing a reboot to switch MAC implementations, as long as there is some benefit from making them unloadable, though it sounds like there are people would are against making LSMs unloadable too.)

Thanks,

-Kees

/me pops the safety off his fire extinguisher

[1] http://lkml.org/lkml/2007/7/19/228
[2] http://lkml.org/lkml/2007/7/14/91

Signature · 1 line
Kees Cook
author
#1 lore raw
Quoted 1 line · Kees Cook

I just wanted to voice my opinion about the static LSM changes.

Through the magic of greylisting (thanks vger) and IRC, I've just had a chat with Arjan and GregKH about this stuff. So, just to follow up for people interested in watching me talk to myself:

- while an LSM must be compiled in, they are not mutually exclusive, and the desired module can be selected at boot-time.

As such, I don't have any strong objections. It'd be nice for folks doing LSM development to allow for a way for it to be modular, but I'll let them fight for that. :)

Sorry for the noise,

-Kees

Signature · 1 line
Kees Cook