MMC: Add 8-bit bus width support
Quoted 1 line
I am not aware of mmc cards having 8 pins yet.
Transcend seems to have one that's reasonably available; NewEgg has the 4GB card for $US 9.50, and Transcend sells it direct too (at least in the US). I'm a bit curious what read rates they achieve ... likely not 50 MB/sec!
The relevant search keyword seems to be "MMCplus".
A third use for 8-bit bus widths is the CE-ATA.org stuff (ATA over MMC) ... I'm not sure how real that is, but the Seagate website has two "Lyrion" products of 30MB and 60MB using 8-bit MMC for small disks. I had thought bigger drives had been announced (e.g. from Samsung, 200+ MB); maybe they're visible only through OEM channels.
- Dave
Quoted 8 lines · David Brownell
Quoted 1 line
I am not aware of mmc cards having 8 pins yet.
Transcend seems to have one that's reasonably available; NewEgg has the 4GB card for $US 9.50, and Transcend sells it direct too (at least in the US). I'm a bit curious what read rates they achieve ... likely not 50 MB/sec!
The relevant search keyword seems to be "MMCplus".
Right. MMCplus and MMCmobile cards are all required to have 8 bit support, and they've been around for years. The catch is that there have been essentially no controllers out in the wild which can take advantage of them. Even when the controller chip supports 8 bit operation, the ODM usually only connects 4 pins up - and when they actually do, it's for a controller which we don't know how to control :-)
This OMAP controller is a first.
Quoted 6 lines
A third use for 8-bit bus widths is the CE-ATA.org stuff (ATA over MMC) ... I'm not sure how real that is, but the Seagate website has two "Lyrion" products of 30MB and 60MB using 8-bit MMC for small disks. I had thought bigger drives had been announced (e.g. from Samsung, 200+ MB); maybe they're visible only through OEM channels.
True - except that CE-ATA wants to signal ATA command completion on the CMD line which I'm fairly certain requires explicit hardware level support. In the absence of that, you'd have to poll.
--phil
Quoted 8 lines · Philip Langdale
Quoted 7 lines · David Brownell
Quoted 1 line
I am not aware of mmc cards having 8 pins yet.
Transcend seems to have one that's reasonably available; NewEgg has the 4GB card for $US 9.50, and Transcend sells it direct too (at least in the US). I'm a bit curious what read rates they achieve ... likely not 50 MB/sec!
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
The relevant search keyword seems to be "MMCplus".
Right. MMCplus and MMCmobile cards are all required to have 8 bit support, and they've been around for years.
Specs have been around. Products have been harder to find, at least at retail, in part because of the catch you mention:
Quoted 5 lines
The catch
is that there have been essentially no controllers out in the wild which can take advantage of them. Even when the controller chip supports 8 bit operation, the ODM usually only connects 4 pins up
SD cards only need 4 pins, of course. And until the 8-bit MMC cards get more common, there's not much point in using those more expensive sockets.
Quoted 4 lines
- and when they actually do, it's
for a controller which we don't know how to control :-)This OMAP controller is a first.
OMAP SOCs have a way of doing that for more than one technology at a time, in my observation. ;)
Right now OMAP3 boards with 8-bit MMC support are widely available via beagleboard.org ... for $US 150, you get quite a lot. But end-user boards, vs developer ones, still don't use those sockets a lot.
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 6 lines
A third use for 8-bit bus widths is the CE-ATA.org stuff (ATA over MMC) ... I'm not sure how real that is, but the Seagate website has two "Lyrion" products of 30MB and 60MB using 8-bit MMC for small disks. I had thought bigger drives had been announced (e.g. from Samsung, 200+ MB); maybe they're visible only through OEM channels.
True - except that CE-ATA wants to signal ATA command completion on the CMD line which I'm fairly certain requires explicit hardware level support. In the absence of that, you'd have to poll.
ISTR seeing a slide showing four options for that.
Software polling is always possible ... but it's usually easy to get an IRQ from a spare GPIO line, the controller need not support that explicitly.
I've seen *one* Linux board with a CE-ATA connector, and that was the 4-bit version. Presumably when Linux grows a CE-ATA driver, this issue will get dealt with.
- Dave
Quoted 4 lines
--phil