Online ext4 defragmention
On Sun, 11 Jan 2009 15:28:38 -0500, I waved a wand and this message magically appears in front of Theodore Tso:
Quoted 11 lines · Alex Buell
Quoted 4 lines
Can someone confirm if the online ext4 defragmentation ioctls will be going into 2.6.29? Thanks, I'm planning a migration from a disparate collection of filesystems to ext4 over the next few months.
Unfortunately, the defragmentation patches need to a lot of work (to be honest, largely refactored and almost rewritten) before they are ready to for mainline yes. I am also concerned that the current defrag patches also try too hard to keep blocks in the same block group, even as a higher priority keeping them non-fragmented.
So maybe 2.6.30? :-D
Quoted 7 lines
Also, note that some of the benefits of ext4 only show up if you do a backup, mkfs, and restore; that's because there are layout changes that can only take place if you reformat the filesystem. Finally, there are some allocation algorithm changes which didn't make the 2.6.29 merge window which I think will make a long-term difference. So you'll probably want to use 2.6.29 with the ext4 patch set.
Quoted 7 lines
So if you want the best performance and fastest fsck times (which I infer given your query about the defragmentation ioctls), you may want to consider doing a reformat and restore operation as part of your ext4 migration, at least for filesystem that you plan to use for active use. If the filesystem is just going to be an mp3 archive, for example, it might not be worth it to do the backup/reformat/restore path.
Having done 1) remounting ext3 volumes as ext4 and 2) backing up data before reformatting as an ext4 volume, and restoring afterwards, and noticed that with option 2 I got noticeable improvements in performance.
Thank you for your advice, it seems reformatting is the best thing to do.
Signature · 9 lines
http://www.munted.org.uk Fearsome grindings. -- http://www.munted.org.uk Fearsome grindings.