Where to put new sensor drivers?
Hi,
I wrote a driver for an I2C connected ambient light sensor and submitted it to the linux-i2c list[1]. In the first place, I wasn't aware of drivers/i2c/chips being deprecated and hencei, I subsequently moved it to what seemed to match best in the current tree, drivers/hwmon. But as Jean Delvare pointed out, this is not the place for it either because it doesn't really monitor the hardware, which is true.
So I posted a proposal[2] patch series that adds drivers/sensors for such cases (some of the drivers in the legacy folder drivers/i2c/chips have the same problem than my new one has) but haven't got reply on it yet, probably because linux-i2c is the wrong place to ask.
Maybe someone here has an oppinon about that?
Thanks,
Daniel
[1] http://article.gmane.org/gmane.linux.drivers.i2c/3148
[2] http://article.gmane.org/gmane.linux.drivers.i2c/3159
Quoted 11 lines · Daniel Mack
I wrote a driver for an I2C connected ambient light sensor and submitted it to the linux-i2c list[1]. In the first place, I wasn't aware of
drivers/i2c/chipsbeing deprecated and hencei, I subsequently moved it to what seemed to match best in the current tree,drivers/hwmon. But as Jean Delvare pointed out, this is not the place for it either because it doesn't really monitor the hardware, which is true.So I posted a proposal[2] patch series that adds
drivers/sensorsfor such cases (some of the drivers in the legacy folderdrivers/i2c/chipshave the same problem than my new one has) but haven't got reply on it yet, probably because linux-i2c is the wrong place to ask.
Hmm, no feedback here either? I was pointed to the 'industrial I/O' thread[1], but that one didn't go mainline yet, and I didn't find any reference of someone picking up this idea.
Are such drivers not wanted in the kernel? I could also move my code to userspace, but I though if it's supported by the kernel, more people can acutally use it easily.
Daniel
Quoted 8 lines · Daniel Mack
Quoted 7 lines · Daniel Mack
I wrote a driver for an I2C connected ambient light sensor and submitted it to the linux-i2c list[1]. In the first place, I wasn't aware of
drivers/i2c/chipsbeing deprecated and hencei, I subsequently moved it to what seemed to match best in the current tree,drivers/hwmon. But as Jean Delvare pointed out, this is not the place for it either because it doesn't really monitor the hardware, which is true.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
So I posted a proposal[2] patch series that adds
drivers/sensorsfor such cases (some of the drivers in the legacy folderdrivers/i2c/chipshave the same problem than my new one has) but haven't got reply on it yet, probably because linux-i2c is the wrong place to ask.Hmm, no feedback here either? I was pointed to the 'industrial I/O' thread[1], but that one didn't go mainline yet, and I didn't find any reference of someone picking up this idea.
Well drivers/sensors sounds sane. Or maybe drivers/senses :-).
Pavel
Signature · 2 lines
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek (cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html