How movable is zone movable?
Hi,
How dependable should zone movable be? After a boot kvm is able to get enough hugepages to
back the session. After a day or two it becomes a lot less predictable. Sometimes it will swap out for 30 seconds and then succeed other times it will fail. Interestingly, it sometimes works if I cancel the kvm session after it tells me it cannot allocate the hugepages and immediatly restart. It there some way to determine what is not respecting zone moveable? Or is zone moveable just a suggestion and not expected to really be moveable?
I have the following set in sysctl.conf
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3G kernel.shmmax = 8589934592 vm.nr_hugepages = 128 vm.nr_overcommit_hugepages = 1408 vm.hugepages_treat_as_movable = 1 vm.hugetlb_shm_group = 1005
This is with any recient kernel release (2.6.28 and later)
Thanks,
Ed Tomlinson
Quoted 11 lines · On Sun, 12 Apr 2009 11:29:09 -0400 Ed Tomlinson <[email protected]> wrote:
Hi,
How dependable should zone movable be? After a boot kvm is able to get enough hugepages to
back the session. After a day or two it becomes a lot less predictable. Sometimes it will swap out for 30 seconds and then succeed other times it will fail. Interestingly, it sometimes works if I cancel the kvm session after it tells me it cannot allocate the hugepages and immediatly restart. It there some way to determine what is not respecting zone moveable? Or is zone moveable just a suggestion and not expected to really be moveable?I have the following set in sysctl.conf
Quoted 9 lines
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3G kernel.shmmax = 8589934592 vm.nr_hugepages = 128 vm.nr_overcommit_hugepages = 1408 vm.hugepages_treat_as_movable = 1 vm.hugetlb_shm_group = 1005This is with any recient kernel release (2.6.28 and later)
At first, "Movable" means that it's only includes anon/file-cache, they are migratable by page migration (memory hotremove) and considered to be easy to be freed. Unfortunately, "move/migrate memory" for memory recalim is not implemented yet. So, at allocating hugepages, all necessary memory should be freed (swapped out).
Plz see /proc/meminfo before trying to allocate hugepages.
%cat /proc/meminfo
Then, ACTIVE+INACTIVE is current usage of "Movable" pages. (AnonPages means pages needs swap to be freed.) (or plz see /proc/zoneinfo)
If ACTIVE+INACTIVE is near to 3G in your system, some amount of memory will be swapped out at huge page allocation.
One tricky way to gain big unused chunk of memory is memory offline->online. This will use page migration. (But I don't think it's tested widely.)
Thanks,
-Kame
Quoted 3 lines · Ed Tomlinson
Hi,
How dependable should zone movable be?
It should be quite dependable for resizing the static hugepage pool, particularly if you are willing to wait. However, with latest libhugetlbfs, the hugeadm utility still has a --hard option incase you need to wait a long time for the resize to occur.
Quoted 3 lines
After a boot kvm is able to get enough hugepages to
back the session. After a day or two it becomes a lot less predictable. Sometimes it will swap out for 30 seconds and then succeed other times it will fail.
Unfortunately, that sounds about right. If there is significant fragmentation, it takes time to find out a contiguous area that can be reclaimed. mlock() if it's a factor will complicate things further.
Quoted 3 lines
Interestingly, it sometimes works if I cancel the kvm session after
it tells me it cannot allocate the hugepages and immediatly restart. It there some way to determine what is not respecting zone moveable?
Ok, that is odd. Are base pages being mlocked()? If they are, they could be the problem as the patches to move those pages around were never merged.
Quoted 3 lines
Or is zone moveable just a suggestion and not expected to really be moveable?
They are expected to be movable, but pages that get locked do not get moved at the moment.
Quoted 8 lines
I have the following set in sysctl.conf
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3G kernel.shmmax = 8589934592 vm.nr_hugepages = 128 vm.nr_overcommit_hugepages = 1408 vm.hugepages_treat_as_movable = 1 vm.hugetlb_shm_group = 1005
How big did you make the movable zone and what is the hugepage size? I'm guessing the hugepage size is 2MB but no harm in being sure. If that's the case, the movable zone should be at least 2816MB to maximise success rates when resizing.
Quoted 3 lines
This is with any recient kernel release (2.6.28 and later)
That's pretty recent. /proc/vmstat will also tell you how many allocations are actually failing.
Signature · 3 lines
Mel Gorman Part-time Phd Student Linux Technology Center University of Limerick IBM Dublin Software Lab
Quoted 3 lines · Mel Gorman
Quoted 1 line
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3GHow big did you make the movable zone and what is the hugepage size?
Scratch that question, I missed you said it was 3G. Are pages being mlocked()?
Signature · 3 lines
Mel Gorman Part-time Phd Student Linux Technology Center University of Limerick IBM Dublin Software Lab
Quoted 7 lines · On Monday 13 April 2009 06:04:40 you wrote:
Quoted 3 lines · Mel Gorman
Quoted 1 line
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3GHow big did you make the movable zone and what is the hugepage size?
Scratch that question, I missed you said it was 3G. Are pages being
mlocked()?
Looks like there are mlocked pages. What stopped the patches to allow these pages to be migrated?
TIA
Ed
(from /proc/zoneinfo)
Node 0, zone Movable
pages free 35321
min 858
low 1072
high 1287
scanned 0 (aa: 2 ia: 0 af: 0 if: 0)
spanned 786432
present 775680
nr_free_pages 35321
nr_inactive_anon 29383
nr_active_anon 82452
nr_inactive_file 376826
nr_active_file 219586
nr_unevictable 816
nr_mlock 816
nr_anon_pages 110648
nr_mapped 28364
nr_file_pages 598492
nr_dirty 131
nr_writeback 0
nr_slab_reclaimable 0
nr_slab_unreclaimable 0
nr_page_table_pages 0
nr_unstable 0
nr_bounce 0
nr_vmscan_write 95
nr_writeback_temp 0
protection: (0, 0, 0, 0)
pagesets
cpu: 0
count: 7
high: 186
batch: 31
vm stats threshold: 24
cpu: 1
count: 7
high: 186
batch: 31
vm stats threshold: 24
cpu: 2
count: 14
high: 186
batch: 31
vm stats threshold: 24
all_unreclaimable: 0
prev_priority: 12
start_pfn: 1441792
inactive_ratio: 4Quoted 4 lines · Ed Tomlinson
Quoted 3 lines · On Monday 13 April 2009 06:04:40 you wrote:
Quoted 2 lines · Mel Gorman
Quoted 1 line
# huge_pages with movablecore set to 3G
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
How big did you make the movable zone and what is the hugepage size?
Scratch that question, I missed you said it was 3G. Are pages being
mlocked()?Looks like there are mlocked pages. What stopped the patches to allow these pages to be migrated?
My recollection is fuzzy but it was mainly down to three points.
1. I could occasionally lock up the system if under enough load using page migration. I didn't have a reliable reproduction case to pin down whether it was something in page migration or something wrong with the way I was using it. There have been fixes in page migration since though so it's possible that got fixed along the way.
2. At the time, memory partitioning and anti-fragmentation were not long in mainline and dynamic hugepage pool resizing was very new. It was not clear there were going to be users of dynamic hugepage pool resizing that would need memory compaction as well. I was reasonasbly confident but that's not users.
3. There were significant problems in hugetlbfs that needed fixing up such as the reliability of MAP_PRIVATE. It was more important to chase down the stuff people certainly needed than complete features that they might need.
The patches weren't downright rejected as such but I didn't push hard as there were almost zero users of dynamic hugepage pool resizing to be complaining about mlock(). Improving hugetlbfs was more important and of obvious benefit and I reckoned I'd wait and see who complained about mlock.
This has changed now. hugetlbfs is in way better state than it was and it sounds like KVM is a user that is both interested in using dynamic pool resizing and has mlocked pages. How much demand is there do you think?
There is someone currently working on helping the pool resizing from userspace by temporarily adding a swap device during pool resize that will take a while to complete. The plan was that they would revisit memory compaction based on the prototype patches I did ages ago later in the year but maybe that can be pushed along a bit harder if there was enough interest.
Signature · 3 lines
Mel Gorman Part-time Phd Student Linux Technology Center University of Limerick IBM Dublin Software Lab