Skip to contentSkip to conversation

linux infrared remote control drivers

PATCH In review Jarod Wilson 23 participants 196 messages Oct 20, 2009 – Dec 12, 2009

Subsystems (3)
lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

v2 cover linux infrared remote control drivers

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Never meant for it to be more than a year before the second attempt at submitting lirc drivers, but day jobs and life tend to get in the way. Development work has been ongoing despite all that, just took a bit longer than anticipated to address as much of the review comments as possible and get up the guts for another submission. ;)

For those not in the know, lirc has existed out-of-tree at lirc.org for years and years, and is currently patched into the kernels or provided as add-on kernel module packages in a number of distributions (its been patched into Fedora kernels going on 2.5 years now), so the code is in fairly wide use and is reasonably well tested, despite not being in the upstream kernel itself.

The drivers included in this submission are for the Windows MCE USB IR transceivers and the SoundGraph iMON USB receivers/displays. I have multiple devices driven by each of these drivers, and have done fairly extensive testing on them, currently primarily on 2.6.31 and 2.6.32.

The MCE transceiver can handle just about any IR protocol you can throw at it on the RX side, thus it passes raw IR through to the userspace lircd daemon for processing. An lircd.conf file maps IR codes to key codes, and they can be consumed by the system either via applications with lirc client support, or they can be fed back into the input subsys via uinput. The transmit side has no input subsys interaction. Note that this driver now handles both generations of MCE transceivers.

The iMON receivers come in two flavors, an early version that passes raw IR, and all more recent versions that do onboard decoding of IR signals. The iMON driver now supports running as a pure input device on devices with onboard decoding, as well as "classic" lirc mode for the ones that don't decode onboard and includes a modparam option to let the onboard decode devices continue to operate in "classic" mode, for those who prefer it.

There's been talk about a raw IR input device type/ioctls/whatever. But it doesn't yet exist, and I know *I* don't have time to write it up... lircd and lirc drivers could be adapted to use such a thing if/when it sees the light of day, but for now, the lirc_dev ("classic" lirc mode) interface is quite well battle-tested, and very capable for both raw IR receive and transmit. There's also been a patchset proposed to do raw IR decoding in the kernel. I'm fine with that idea too, but only if there is *also* a way to get the raw IR out to userspace (lircd), as there are some esoteric IR protocols out there and we can be a lot more nimble about adding support for decoding new and different protocols in userspace than we can in the kernel -- and lircd can now feed all the resulting key codes back into the input subsystem via uinput too.

The hope is that we can get lirc_dev (upon which all other lirc drivers depend) merged, along with these initial two drivers, then we can start reviewing the additional 15 or so lirc drivers for inclusion as well.

Combined diffstat:

 MAINTAINERS                      |    9 +
 drivers/input/Kconfig            |    2 +
 drivers/input/Makefile           |    1 +
 drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig       |   26 +
 drivers/input/lirc/Makefile      |    8 +
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h        |  100 ++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.c    |  837 +++++++++++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.h    |  194 +++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c   | 2471 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.h   |  209 ++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c | 1235 +++++++++++++++++++
 11 files changed, 5092 insertions(+), 0 deletions(-)

Git tree:
* git://git.wilsonet.com/linux-2.6-lirc.git/
Git web:
* http://git.wilsonet.com/linux-2.6-lirc.git/
Upstream lirc project:
* http://www.lirc.org/

(If you're going to clone, I'd highly suggest adding it as a remote to a linus' tree checkout rather than clone'ing directly, as I don't have nearly as much bandwidth at home as kernel.org... ;)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#188 lore raw

PATCH v2 3/3 lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

Successfully tested with multiple devices with and without displays.

Changes from prior submission:
- dual-endpoint devices now appear as a single lirc device
- proper support for devices with touchscreens
- full input device support for mouse mode
- full input device support for onboard decoding devices, with modparam fallback option for classic lirc mode
- auto-detection of lcd/vfd/vga display in most cases
- support for several new devices
- uses dev_foo printk macros
- able to decode both imon and mce protocol

---
 drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig     |    6 
 drivers/input/lirc/Makefile    |    1 
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c | 2471 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.h |  209 +++
 4 files changed, 2687 insertions(+)
drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +6 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================
@@ -11,6 +11,12 @@ menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
 
 if INPUT_LIRC
 
+config LIRC_IMON
+	tristate "SoundGraph iMON Receiver and Display"
+	depends on LIRC_DEV
+	help
+	  Driver for the SoundGraph iMON IR Receiver and Display
+
 config LIRC_MCEUSB
 	tristate "Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceiver"
 	depends on LIRC_DEV && USB
drivers/input/lirc/Makefile +1 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Makefile
===================================================================
@@ -4,4 +4,5 @@
 # Each configuration option enables a list of files.
 
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_LIRC)	+= lirc_dev.o
+obj-$(CONFIG_LIRC_IMON)		+= lirc_imon.o
 obj-$(CONFIG_LIRC_MCEUSB)	+= lirc_mceusb.o
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +2471 -0

2,471 lines not on this page · raw message

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.h new file +209 -0

209 lines not on this page · raw message

#1 lore raw

PATCH v2 1/3 lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Core Linux Infrared Remote Control driver and infrastructure

-Add Kconfig and Makefile bits
-Add device driver interface and headers

The initial Kconfig and Makefile bits were done by Mario Limonciello for the Ubuntu kernel, but have been tweaked a bit since then. Any errors are probably my doing.

Changes from prior submission:
- Now uses dev_dbg instead of its own dprintk
- Dynamic device numbers used
- sleep_on() ripped out in favor of wake bits
- Kconfig text improved and simplified
- All inline keywords removed where possible
- Obfuscating #defines and wrapper functions removed
- We call 'em lirc drivers now instead of lirc plugins

CC Christoph Bartelmus <[email protected]>
CC Mario Limonciello <[email protected]>
---
 MAINTAINERS                   |    9 
 drivers/input/Kconfig         |    2 
 drivers/input/Makefile        |    1 
 drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig    |   16 
 drivers/input/lirc/Makefile   |    6 
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h     |  100 +++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.c |  837 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.h |  194 +++++++++
 8 files changed, 1165 insertions(+)
MAINTAINERS +9 -0
Index: b/MAINTAINERS
===================================================================
@@ -3219,6 +3219,15 @@ W:	http://www.pasemi.com/
 L:	[email protected]
 S:	Supported
 
+LINUX INFRARED REMOTE CONTROL DRIVERS (LIRC)
+P:	Jarod Wilson
+M:	[email protected]
+P:	Christoph Bartelmus
+M:	[email protected]
+W:	http://www.lirc.org/
+L:	[email protected]
+S:	Maintained
+
 LINUX SECURITY MODULE (LSM) FRAMEWORK
 M:	Chris Wright <[email protected]>
 L:	[email protected]
drivers/input/Kconfig +2 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/Kconfig
===================================================================
@@ -170,6 +170,8 @@ source "drivers/input/tablet/Kconfig"
 
 source "drivers/input/touchscreen/Kconfig"
 
+source "drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig"
+
 source "drivers/input/misc/Kconfig"
 
 endif
drivers/input/Makefile +1 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/Makefile
===================================================================
@@ -20,6 +20,7 @@ obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_MOUSE)	+= mouse/
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_JOYSTICK)	+= joystick/
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_TABLET)	+= tablet/
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_TOUCHSCREEN)	+= touchscreen/
+obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_LIRC)	+= lirc/
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_MISC)	+= misc/
 
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_APMPOWER)	+= apm-power.o
drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig new file +16 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+#
+# LIRC driver(s) configuration
+#
+menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
+	bool "Linux Infrared Remote Control IR receiver/transmitter drivers"
+	help
+	  Say Y here, and all supported Linux Infrared Remote Control IR and
+	  RF receiver and transmitter drivers will be displayed. When paired
+	  with a remote control and the lirc daemon, the receiver drivers
+	  allow control of your Linux system via remote control.
+
+if INPUT_LIRC
+
+# Device-specific drivers go here
+
+endif
drivers/input/lirc/Makefile new file +6 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Makefile
===================================================================
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
+# Makefile for the lirc drivers.
+#
+
+# Each configuration option enables a list of files.
+
+obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_LIRC)	+= lirc_dev.o
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +100 -0

100 lines not on this page · raw message

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.c new file +837 -0

837 lines not on this page · raw message

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.h new file +194 -0

194 lines not on this page · raw message

#184 lore raw

PATCH v2 2/3 lirc driver for Windows MCE IR transceivers

In reply to Jarod Wilson

lirc driver for Windows Media Center Ed. IR transceivers

Successfully tested with the mce v2 transceiver and remote that shipped with a Hauppauge HVR-1500 expresscard tuner and an mce v1 transceiver from an old HP Media Center system.

Changes from prior submission:
- both v1 and v2 transceivers supported by one driver now
- transmit works on the v1 devices
- support for several new devices
- now uses dev_dbg (and friends) instead of its own dprintk

---
 drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig       |    6 
 drivers/input/lirc/Makefile      |    1 
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c | 1235 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 3 files changed, 1241 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)
drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +5 -1
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================
@@ -11,6 +11,10 @@ menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
 
 if INPUT_LIRC
 
-# Device-specific drivers go here
+config LIRC_MCEUSB
+	tristate "Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceiver"
+	depends on LIRC_DEV && USB
+	help
+	  Driver for Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceivers
 
 endif
drivers/input/lirc/Makefile +1 -0
Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Makefile
===================================================================
@@ -4,3 +4,4 @@
 # Each configuration option enables a list of files.
 
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_LIRC)	+= lirc_dev.o
+obj-$(CONFIG_LIRC_MCEUSB)	+= lirc_mceusb.o
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +1235 -0

1,235 lines not on this page · raw message

#191 lore raw
In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 5 lines · Jarod Wilson

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Hm. Submitting this while the vast majority of people who might review it were at the Japan Linux Symposium seems like it might have been a bad idea. Or does no feedback mean its all good and ready to be merged? ;)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#192 lore raw
Quoted 10 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that
includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of
which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Quoted 4 lines

Hm. Submitting this while the vast majority of people who might review it were at the Japan Linux Symposium seems like it might have been a bad idea. Or does no feedback mean its all good and ready to be merged? ;)

Silence is concurrence. :)

Actually I will note, that lirc_dev.h uses kfifo:

http://git.wilsonet.com/linux-2.6-lirc.git/?a=blob_plain;f=drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.h;hb=f47f5e852d08f174c303d0ed53649733190014f7

but it least it appear to be nicely wrappered in that file. Moving to a new kfifo implementation should be fairly easy, if the kfifo change makes it in first.

Regards,
Andy

#194 lore raw
In reply to Jarod Wilson

Em Wed, 4 Nov 2009 17:56:31 -0500
Jarod Wilson <[email protected]> escreveu:

Quoted 10 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 8 lines

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that
includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of
which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Quoted 3 lines

Hm. Submitting this while the vast majority of people who might review it were at the Japan Linux Symposium seems like it might have been a bad idea.

True :) Such long trips generally affects the week before (to finish some pending stuff before traveling) and the week after, where we have a big backlog to handle.

Quoted 2 lines

Or does no feedback mean its all good and ready to be merged? ;)

They are on my queue. I was handling a long pile of patches for the existing drivers during last week. I intend to send the fixes upstream during this week, and then going to analyze the lirc patches.

It would be wonderful to get also some feedback from the event/input people.

Cheers,
Mauro

#193 lore raw
In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 18 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 10 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that
includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of
which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Quoted 4 lines

Hm. Submitting this while the vast majority of people who might review it were at the Japan Linux Symposium seems like it might have been a bad idea. Or does no feedback mean its all good and ready to be merged? ;)

Silence is concurrence. :)

Quoted 7 lines

Actually I will note, that lirc_dev.h uses kfifo:

http://git.wilsonet.com/linux-2.6-lirc.git/?a=blob_plain;f=drivers/input/lirc/lirc_dev.h;hb=f47f5e852d08f174c303d0ed53649733190014f7

but it least it appear to be nicely wrappered in that file. Moving to a new kfifo implementation should be fairly easy, if the kfifo change makes it in first.

Yeah, been keeping an eye on your own kfifo usage discussion w/lirc's usage in mind... Thank you for blazing that trail. ;)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#195 lore raw
In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 21 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Em Wed, 4 Nov 2009 17:56:31 -0500
Jarod Wilson <[email protected]> escreveu:

Quoted 10 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 8 lines

This here is a second go at submitting linux infrared remote control (lirc) drivers for kernel inclusion, with a much smaller patch set that
includes only the core lirc driver and two device drivers, all three of
which have been heavily updated since the last submission, based on feedback received.

Quoted 3 lines

Hm. Submitting this while the vast majority of people who might review it were at the Japan Linux Symposium seems like it might have been a bad idea.

True :) Such long trips generally affects the week before (to finish some pending stuff before traveling) and the week after, where we have a big backlog to handle.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Or does no feedback mean its all good and ready to be merged? ;)

They are on my queue. I was handling a long pile of patches for the existing drivers during last week. I intend to send the fixes upstream during this week, and then going to analyze the lirc patches.

I'd heard as much, but figured I should go ahead with the fishing expedition just the same to see if we couldn't hook anyone else too...

Quoted 1 line

It would be wonderful to get also some feedback from the event/input people.

Yeah, I think that's probably the folks who really have the final say on this, as we're ultimately (mostly) input devices.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#185 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 2/3 v2] lirc driver for Windows MCE IR transceivers

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Hi

Thank you for trying to get lirc mainline. Hoping that no real complaints against it arise, what about submitting the tree to linux-next, so it gets more testing exposure before the merge window opens for 2.6.33?

Quoted 1 line · Jarod Wilson

lirc driver for Windows Media Center Ed. IR transceivers

[...]

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig menuconfig INPUT_LIRC · line 16

Quoted 12 lines

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +3 -1
@@ -11,6 +11,10 @@ menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
 
 if INPUT_LIRC
 
-# Device-specific drivers go here
+config LIRC_MCEUSB
+	tristate "Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceiver"
+	depends on LIRC_DEV && USB

You have obviously renamed LIRC_DEV to INPUT_LIRC just before the submission, but missed to do so for the individual drivers which still depend on LIRC_DEV and are therefore not selectable; the same applies to [PATCH 3/3 v2] lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays.

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig menuconfig INPUT_LIRC · line 20

Quoted 4 lines
drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +2 -0
+	help
+	  Driver for Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceivers
 
 endif

Regards
Stefan Lippers-Hollmann

#186 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 2/3 v2] lirc driver for Windows MCE IR transceivers

Quoted 5 lines · Stefan Lippers-Hollmann

Hi

Thank you for trying to get lirc mainline. Hoping that no real complaints against it arise, what about submitting the tree to linux-next, so it gets more testing exposure before the merge window opens for 2.6.33?

At the point, I'd be happy with getting into linux-next or even the staging tree.

Quoted 11 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line

lirc driver for Windows Media Center Ed. IR transceivers

[...]

Quoted 8 lines

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +0 -0
@@ -11,6 +11,10 @@ menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
 

if INPUT_LIRC

Quoted 9 lines

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig menuconfig INPUT_LIRC · line 16

Quoted 4 lines
drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +3 -1
-# Device-specific drivers go here
+config LIRC_MCEUSB
+	tristate "Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceiver"
+	depends on LIRC_DEV && USB

You have obviously renamed LIRC_DEV to INPUT_LIRC just before the submission, but missed to do so for the individual drivers which still depend on LIRC_DEV and are therefore not selectable; the same applies to [PATCH 3/3 v2] lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays.

D'oh. Yeah, I sure did. Didn't notice the fubar, because I was building and testing the stuff on an existing kernel that already had LIRC_DEV defined. Earlier versions actually had both INPUT_LIRC and LIRC_DEV, which are essentially one in the same. I'll fix that shortly.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#2 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Hi Jarod,

Quoted 9 lines · Jarod Wilson

Core Linux Infrared Remote Control driver and infrastructure

(quoted diff) +0 -2
-Add Kconfig and Makefile bits
-Add device driver interface and headers

The initial Kconfig and Makefile bits were done by Mario Limonciello for the Ubuntu kernel, but have been tweaked a bit since then. Any errors are probably my doing.

Quoted 8 lines

Changes from prior submission:
- Now uses dev_dbg instead of its own dprintk
- Dynamic device numbers used
- sleep_on() ripped out in favor of wake bits
- Kconfig text improved and simplified
- All inline keywords removed where possible
- Obfuscating #defines and wrapper functions removed
- We call 'em lirc drivers now instead of lirc plugins

Sorry to not analyze the code before. -ETOOBUSY here...

Some generic comments first:

1) As I said before, this code adds a new input API. So, you should get input people's ack about it. It seems fine for me;

2) It would be really cool if you could submit a patch for DocBook as well, in order to describe the API. IMO, the better is to put it together with media infrastructure docbook, since, although it is possible to use lirc code with other hardware (and were originally designed for it), the current wider usage is together with V4L/DVB devices. The Docbooks are at kernel Documentation/DocBook/ directory. Also, we have a copy of it at our development tree (http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb) at media-specs/ directory.

3) In general, the code looks sane for me. I have just a few small sugestions for improvements:

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h

Quoted 4 lines

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +0 -0

Hmm... as you're defining the kernel userspace interface, it would be better to put the header under include/linux.

Quoted 12 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +12 -0
+#define LIRC_GET_FEATURES              _IOR('i', 0x00000000, unsigned long)
+
+#define LIRC_GET_SEND_MODE             _IOR('i', 0x00000001, unsigned long)
+#define LIRC_GET_REC_MODE              _IOR('i', 0x00000002, unsigned long)
+#define LIRC_GET_SEND_CARRIER          _IOR('i', 0x00000003, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_GET_REC_CARRIER           _IOR('i', 0x00000004, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_GET_SEND_DUTY_CYCLE       _IOR('i', 0x00000005, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_GET_REC_DUTY_CYCLE        _IOR('i', 0x00000006, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_GET_REC_RESOLUTION        _IOR('i', 0x00000007, unsigned int)
+
+/* code length in bits, currently only for LIRC_MODE_LIRCCODE */
+#define LIRC_GET_LENGTH                _IOR('i', 0x0000000f, unsigned long)

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h line 87

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +10 -0
+
+#define LIRC_SET_SEND_MODE             _IOW('i', 0x00000011, unsigned long)
+#define LIRC_SET_REC_MODE              _IOW('i', 0x00000012, unsigned long)
+/* Note: these can reset the according pulse_width */
+#define LIRC_SET_SEND_CARRIER          _IOW('i', 0x00000013, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_SET_REC_CARRIER           _IOW('i', 0x00000014, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_SET_SEND_DUTY_CYCLE       _IOW('i', 0x00000015, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_SET_REC_DUTY_CYCLE        _IOW('i', 0x00000016, unsigned int)
+#define LIRC_SET_TRANSMITTER_MASK      _IOW('i', 0x00000017, unsigned int)
+

Hmm... unsigned int/unsigned long are not portable between different architectures. It would be better to use instead __u16/__u32/__u64. This way, you won't need a 32 bits compat layer.

Quoted 105 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +105 -0
+
+int lirc_register_driver(struct lirc_driver *d)
+{
+	struct irctl *ir;
+	int minor;
+	int bytes_in_key;
+	unsigned int chunk_size;
+	unsigned int buffer_size;
+	int err;
+
+	if (!d) {
+		printk(KERN_ERR "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+		       "driver pointer must be not NULL!\n");
+		err = -EBADRQC;
+		goto out;
+	}
+
+	if (MAX_IRCTL_DEVICES <= d->minor) {
+		dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+			"\"minor\" must be between 0 and %d (%d)!\n",
+			MAX_IRCTL_DEVICES-1, d->minor);
+		err = -EBADRQC;
+		goto out;
+	}
+
+	if (1 > d->code_length || (BUFLEN * 8) < d->code_length) {
+		dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+			"code length in bits for minor (%d) "
+			"must be less than %d!\n",
+			d->minor, BUFLEN * 8);
+		err = -EBADRQC;
+		goto out;
+	}
+
+	dev_dbg(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: sample_rate: %d\n",
+		d->sample_rate);
+	if (d->sample_rate) {
+		if (2 > d->sample_rate || HZ < d->sample_rate) {
+			dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+				"sample_rate must be between 2 and %d!\n", HZ);
+			err = -EBADRQC;
+			goto out;
+		}
+		if (!d->add_to_buf) {
+			dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+				"add_to_buf cannot be NULL when "
+				"sample_rate is set\n");
+			err = -EBADRQC;
+			goto out;
+		}
+	} else if (!(d->fops && d->fops->read) && !d->rbuf) {
+		dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+			"fops->read and rbuf cannot all be NULL!\n");
+		err = -EBADRQC;
+		goto out;
+	} else if (!d->rbuf) {
+		if (!(d->fops && d->fops->read && d->fops->poll &&
+		      d->fops->ioctl)) {
+			dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+				"neither read, poll nor ioctl can be NULL!\n");
+			err = -EBADRQC;
+			goto out;
+		}
+	}
+
+	mutex_lock(&lirc_dev_lock);
+
+	minor = d->minor;
+
+	if (minor < 0) {
+		/* find first free slot for driver */
+		for (minor = 0; minor < MAX_IRCTL_DEVICES; minor++)
+			if (!irctls[minor])
+				break;
+		if (MAX_IRCTL_DEVICES == minor) {
+			dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+				"no free slots for drivers!\n");
+			err = -ENOMEM;
+			goto out_lock;
+		}
+	} else if (irctls[minor]) {
+		dev_err(d->dev, "lirc_dev: lirc_register_driver: "
+			"minor (%d) just registered!\n", minor);
+		err = -EBUSY;
+		goto out_lock;
+	}
+
+	ir = kzalloc(sizeof(struct irctl), GFP_KERNEL);
+	if (!ir) {
+		err = -ENOMEM;
+		goto out_lock;
+	}
+	init_irctl(ir);
+	irctls[minor] = ir;
+	d->minor = minor;
+
+	if (d->sample_rate) {
+		ir->jiffies_to_wait = HZ / d->sample_rate;
+	} else {
+		/* it means - wait for external event in task queue */
+		ir->jiffies_to_wait = 0;
+	}
+
+	/* some safety check 8-) */
+	d->name[sizeof(d->name)-1] = '\0';

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +10 -0
+
+	bytes_in_key = BITS_TO_LONGS(d->code_length) +
+			(d->code_length % 8 ? 1 : 0);
+	buffer_size = d->buffer_size ? d->buffer_size : BUFLEN / bytes_in_key;
+	chunk_size  = d->chunk_size  ? d->chunk_size  : bytes_in_key;
+
+	if (d->rbuf) {
+		ir->buf = d->rbuf;
+	} else {
+		ir->buf = kmalloc(sizeof(struct lirc_buffer), GFP_KERNEL);

For security reasons, wouldn't be better to use kzalloc here?

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +10 -0
+#ifdef CONFIG_COMPAT
+#define LIRC_GET_FEATURES_COMPAT32     _IOR('i', 0x00000000, __u32)
+
+#define LIRC_GET_SEND_MODE_COMPAT32    _IOR('i', 0x00000001, __u32)
+#define LIRC_GET_REC_MODE_COMPAT32     _IOR('i', 0x00000002, __u32)
+
+#define LIRC_GET_LENGTH_COMPAT32       _IOR('i', 0x0000000f, __u32)
+
+#define LIRC_SET_SEND_MODE_COMPAT32    _IOW('i', 0x00000011, __u32)
+#define LIRC_SET_REC_MODE_COMPAT32     _IOW('i', 0x00000012, __u32)

You wouldn't need those code, if you declare the ioctl's as __u32 at the first place.

Also, the compat layer is needed not only for x86_64, but some other architectures like sparc64 needs it, since userspace is 32 bits and kernelspace is 64 bits.

With V4L ioctls, we needed to do some adjustments for sparc, since the sizes there are different for other types as well. Unfortunately, I can't remember what were the difference (maybe int size?).

So, IMO, it would be a way better if you just declare everything using __u16/__u32/__u64 at the original ioctl definition and just remove all compat code.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h

Quoted 9 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +9 -0
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_register_driver);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_unregister_driver);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_close);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_poll);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_ioctl);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_compat_ioctl);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_read);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_get_pdata);
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(lirc_dev_fop_write);

I would declare everything as EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL instead.

#3 lore raw

[RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 11 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Jarod Wilson wrote:
1) As I said before, this code adds a new input API. So, you should get input people's ack about it. It seems fine for me;

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h

Quoted 4 lines

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/lirc.h new file +0 -0

Hmm... as you're defining the kernel userspace interface, it would be better to put the header under include/linux.

It seems that I ran away from one important discussion here...

In fact, it seemed better to start a thread to discuss the API issues in separate, an then adequate the code to do whatever decided.

-

The way the out-of-tree lirc driver works is by outputing (and inputing) a raw sequence of pulses and spaces that have several different IR protocols, like NEC, RC4, RC5, RC6 and pulse-distance protocols. On the other hand, the current Input event interface (and the IR drivers at V4L/DVB code) does is to have in-kernel code that converts those sequences or pulse/space into a keystroke representation, outputing it to userspace.

To make things a little more complicated, it is also possible for some devices to output IR codes. Let's first discuss the IR input case. IMO, whatever we define for input, we should do also for output.

There's some advantages and disadvantages of both strategies, being the most notable ones:

Raw pulse/space allows reception of IR's from all different variations of the IR protocols. However:
it means a more complex setup at userspace, since the user must
use a daemon to decode IR code;
user must inform the IR type and the kernel driver that will receive
those keystrokes.

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device. Considering the common case where the lirc driver will be associated with a media input device, the IR type can be detected automatically on kernel. However, advanced users may opt to use other IR types than what's provided with the device they bought.

It should also be noticed that not all the already-existing IR drivers on kernel can provide a lirc interface, since several devices have their own IR decoding chips inside the hardware. On some cases, the hardware can be programmed to receive more than one IR protocol type, where on others, the manufacturer provides IR decoding capabilities only for the protocol they decided to provide together with their hardware.

IMO, there are two different approaches that can be taken:

1) Just add lirc API as-is and let's have two different ways to get IR events on kernel, and have two different API's for IR;

2) create a lirc kernel API, and have a layer there to decode IR protocols and output them via the already existing input layer. In this case, all we need to do, in terms of API, is to add a way to set the IR protocol that will be decoded, and to enumberate the capabilities. The lirc API, will be an in-kernel API to communicate with the devices that don't have IR protocols decoding capabilities inside the hardware.

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space or it would be better to standardize it to always use the existing input layer?

Comments?

Cheers,
Mauro

#187 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 2/3 v2] lirc driver for Windows MCE IR transceivers

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 164 lines · Jarod Wilson

lirc driver for Windows Media Center Ed. IR transceivers

Successfully tested with the mce v2 transceiver and remote that shipped with a Hauppauge HVR-1500 expresscard tuner and an mce v1 transceiver from an old HP Media Center system.

Changes from prior submission:
- both v1 and v2 transceivers supported by one driver now
- transmit works on the v1 devices
- support for several new devices
- now uses dev_dbg (and friends) instead of its own dprintk

---
 drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig       |    6 
 drivers/input/lirc/Makefile      |    1 
 drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c | 1235 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 3 files changed, 1241 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-)

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/Kconfig +5 -1
@@ -11,6 +11,10 @@ menuconfig INPUT_LIRC
 
 if INPUT_LIRC
 
-# Device-specific drivers go here
+config LIRC_MCEUSB
+	tristate "Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceiver"
+	depends on LIRC_DEV && USB
+	help
+	  Driver for Windows Media Center Ed. USB IR Transceivers
 
 endif

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/Makefile
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/Makefile +1 -0
@@ -4,3 +4,4 @@
 # Each configuration option enables a list of files.
 
 obj-$(CONFIG_INPUT_LIRC)	+= lirc_dev.o
+obj-$(CONFIG_LIRC_MCEUSB)	+= lirc_mceusb.o

Index: b/drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c
===================================================================

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +111 -0
@@ -0,0 +1,1235 @@
+/*
+ * LIRC driver for Windows Media Center Edition USB Infrared Transceivers
+ *
+ * (C) by Martin A. Blatter <[email protected]>
+ *
+ * Transmitter support and reception code cleanup.
+ * (C) by Daniel Melander <[email protected]>
+ *
+ * Original lirc_mceusb driver for 1st-gen device:
+ * Copyright (c) 2003-2004 Dan Conti <[email protected]>
+ *
+ * Original lirc_mceusb driver deprecated in favor of this driver, which
+ * supports the 1st-gen device now too. Transmitting on the 1st-gen device
+ * only functions on port #2 at the moment.
+ *
+ * Support for 1st-gen device added June 2009,
+ * by Jarod Wilson <[email protected]>
+ *
+ * Initial transmission support for 1st-gen device added August 2009,
+ * by Patrick Calhoun <[email protected]>
+ *
+ * Derived from ATI USB driver by Paul Miller and the original
+ * MCE USB driver by Dan Conti (and now including chunks of the latter
+ * relevant to the 1st-gen device initialization)
+ *
+ *
+ * This program is free software; you can redistribute it and/or modify
+ * it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
+ * the Free Software Foundation; either version 2 of the License, or
+ * (at your option) any later version.
+ *
+ * This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+ * but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+ * MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
+ * GNU General Public License for more details.
+ *
+ * You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
+ * along with this program; if not, write to the Free Software
+ * Foundation, Inc., 59 Temple Place, Suite 330, Boston, MA 02111-1307 USA
+ *
+ */
+
+#include <linux/kernel.h>
+#include <linux/errno.h>
+#include <linux/init.h>
+#include <linux/slab.h>
+#include <linux/module.h>
+#include <linux/kmod.h>
+#include <linux/smp_lock.h>
+#include <linux/completion.h>
+#include <linux/uaccess.h>
+#include <linux/usb.h>
+#include <linux/wait.h>
+#include <linux/time.h>
+
+#include "lirc.h"
+#include "lirc_dev.h"
+
+#define DRIVER_VERSION	"1.90"
+#define DRIVER_AUTHOR	"Daniel Melander <[email protected]>, " \
+			"Martin Blatter <[email protected]>, " \
+			"Dan Conti <[email protected]>"
+#define DRIVER_DESC	"Windows Media Center Edition USB IR Transceiver " \
+			"driver for LIRC"
+#define DRIVER_NAME	"lirc_mceusb"
+
+#define USB_BUFLEN	32	/* USB reception buffer length */
+#define LIRCBUF_SIZE	256	/* LIRC work buffer length */
+
+/* MCE constants */
+#define MCE_CMDBUF_SIZE	384 /* MCE Command buffer length */
+#define MCE_TIME_UNIT	50 /* Approx 50us resolution */
+#define MCE_CODE_LENGTH	5 /* Normal length of packet (with header) */
+#define MCE_PACKET_SIZE	4 /* Normal length of packet (without header) */
+#define MCE_PACKET_HEADER 0x84 /* Actual header format is 0x80 + num_bytes */
+#define MCE_CONTROL_HEADER 0x9F /* MCE status header */
+#define MCE_TX_HEADER_LENGTH 3 /* # of bytes in the initializing tx header */
+#define MCE_MAX_CHANNELS 2 /* Two transmitters, hardware dependent? */
+#define MCE_DEFAULT_TX_MASK 0x03 /* Val opts: TX1=0x01, TX2=0x02, ALL=0x03 */
+#define MCE_PULSE_BIT	0x80 /* Pulse bit, MSB set == PULSE else SPACE */
+#define MCE_PULSE_MASK	0x7F /* Pulse mask */
+#define MCE_MAX_PULSE_LENGTH 0x7F /* Longest transmittable pulse symbol */
+#define MCE_PACKET_LENGTH_MASK  0x7F /* Pulse mask */
+
+
+/* module parameters */
+#ifdef CONFIG_USB_DEBUG
+static int debug = 1;
+#else
+static int debug;
+#endif
+
+/* general constants */
+#define SEND_FLAG_IN_PROGRESS	1
+#define SEND_FLAG_COMPLETE	2
+#define RECV_FLAG_IN_PROGRESS	3
+#define RECV_FLAG_COMPLETE	4
+
+#define MCEUSB_INBOUND		1
+#define MCEUSB_OUTBOUND		2
+
+#define VENDOR_PHILIPS		0x0471
+#define VENDOR_SMK		0x0609
+#define VENDOR_TATUNG		0x1460
+#define VENDOR_GATEWAY		0x107b
+#define VENDOR_SHUTTLE		0x1308
+#define VENDOR_SHUTTLE2		0x051c
+#define VENDOR_MITSUMI		0x03ee
+#define VENDOR_TOPSEED		0x1784
+#define VENDOR_RICAVISION	0x179d
+#define VENDOR_ITRON		0x195d

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 121

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +10 -0
+#define VENDOR_FIC		0x1509
+#define VENDOR_LG		0x043e
+#define VENDOR_MICROSOFT	0x045e
+#define VENDOR_FORMOSA		0x147a
+#define VENDOR_FINTEK		0x1934
+#define VENDOR_PINNACLE		0x2304
+#define VENDOR_ECS		0x1019
+#define VENDOR_WISTRON		0x0fb8
+#define VENDOR_COMPRO		0x185b
+#define VENDOR_NORTHSTAR	0x04eb

Hmm... we should consider moving the USB ID's to a global kernel header, just like what we have with PCI IDs...We have some of those ID's on some common headers:

drivers/hid/hid-ids.h
drivers/media/dvb/dvb-usb/dvb-usb-ids.h

Unfortunately, it seems that each subsystem have their own place to store it, and several drivers have the ID's at their own code.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 533

Quoted 9 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +9 -0
+#if 0
+	Uncomment this if the last 100ms "infinity"-space should be transmitted
+	to lirc directly instead of at the beginning of the next transmission.
+	Changes pulse/space order.
+
+			if (++i < buf_len && ir->buf_in[i] == 0x01)
+				send_packet_to_lirc(ir);
+
+#endif

Hmm... Generating a different code if uncommenting it doesn't seem nice. It should be checked what code will produce the right RC5 protocol and uncomment the #if or remove it completely to avoid temptation of latter change the behavior by uncommenting it.

Quoted 92 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +92 -0
+
+
+static int mceusb_lirc_ioctl(struct inode *node, struct file *filep,
+			     unsigned int cmd, unsigned long arg)
+{
+	int result;
+	unsigned int ivalue;
+	unsigned long lvalue;
+	struct mceusb_dev *ir = NULL;
+
+	/* Retrieve lirc_driver data for the device */
+	ir = lirc_get_pdata(filep);
+	if (!ir || !ir->usb_ep_out)
+		return -EFAULT;
+
+
+	switch (cmd) {
+	case LIRC_SET_TRANSMITTER_MASK:
+
+		result = get_user(ivalue, (unsigned int *) arg);
+		if (result)
+			return result;
+		switch (ivalue) {
+		case 0x01: /* Transmitter 1     => 0x04 */
+		case 0x02: /* Transmitter 2     => 0x02 */
+		case 0x03: /* Transmitter 1 & 2 => 0x06 */
+			set_transmitter_mask(ir, ivalue);
+			break;
+
+		default: /* Unsupported transmitter mask */
+			return MCE_MAX_CHANNELS;
+		}
+
+		dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, ": SET_TRANSMITTERS mask=%d\n", ivalue);
+		break;
+
+	case LIRC_GET_SEND_MODE:
+
+		result = put_user(LIRC_SEND2MODE(LIRC_CAN_SEND_PULSE &
+						 LIRC_CAN_SEND_MASK),
+				  (unsigned long *) arg);
+
+		if (result)
+			return result;
+		break;
+
+	case LIRC_SET_SEND_MODE:
+
+		result = get_user(lvalue, (unsigned long *) arg);
+
+		if (result)
+			return result;
+		if (lvalue != (LIRC_MODE_PULSE&LIRC_CAN_SEND_MASK))
+			return -EINVAL;
+		break;
+
+	case LIRC_SET_SEND_CARRIER:
+
+		result = get_user(ivalue, (unsigned int *) arg);
+		if (result)
+			return result;
+
+		set_send_carrier(ir, ivalue);
+		break;
+
+	default:
+		return lirc_dev_fop_ioctl(node, filep, cmd, arg);
+	}
+
+	return 0;
+}
+
+static struct file_operations lirc_fops = {
+	.owner		= THIS_MODULE,
+	.write		= mceusb_transmit_ir,
+	.ioctl		= mceusb_lirc_ioctl,
+	.read		= lirc_dev_fop_read,
+	.poll		= lirc_dev_fop_poll,
+	.open		= lirc_dev_fop_open,
+	.release	= lirc_dev_fop_close,
+};
+
+static int mceusb_gen1_init(struct mceusb_dev *ir)
+{
+	int i, ret;
+	char junk[64], data[8];
+	int partial = 0;
+
+	/*
+	 * Clear off the first few messages. These look like calibration
+	 * or test data, I can't really tell. This also flushes in case
+	 * we have random ir data queued up.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 837

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +10 -0
+	 */
+	for (i = 0; i < 40; i++)
+		usb_bulk_msg(ir->usbdev,
+			usb_rcvbulkpipe(ir->usbdev,
+				ir->usb_ep_in->bEndpointAddress),
+			junk, 64, &partial, HZ * 10);
+
+	ir->is_pulse = 1;
+
+	memset(data, 0, 8);

Please use, instead:

	memset(data, 0, sizeof(data));
Quoted 5 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +5 -0
+
+	/* Get Status */
+	ret = usb_control_msg(ir->usbdev, usb_rcvctrlpipe(ir->usbdev, 0),
+			      USB_REQ_GET_STATUS, USB_DIR_IN,
+			      0, 0, data, 2, HZ * 3);

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 852

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +10 -0
+
+	/*    ret = usb_get_status( ir->usbdev, 0, 0, data ); */
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - ret = %d status = 0x%x 0x%x\n", __func__,
+		ret, data[0], data[1]);
+
+	/*
+	 * This is a strange one. They issue a set address to the device
+	 * on the receive control pipe and expect a certain value pair back
+	 */
+	memset(data, 0, 8);

Please use, instead:

	memset(data, 0, sizeof(data));
Quoted 125 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +125 -0
+
+	ret = usb_control_msg(ir->usbdev, usb_rcvctrlpipe(ir->usbdev, 0),
+			      USB_REQ_SET_ADDRESS, USB_TYPE_VENDOR, 0, 0,
+			      data, 2, HZ * 3);
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - ret = %d, devnum = %d\n",
+		__func__, ret, ir->usbdev->devnum);
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - data[0] = %d, data[1] = %d\n",
+		__func__, data[0], data[1]);
+
+	/* set feature: bit rate 38400 bps */
+	ret = usb_control_msg(ir->usbdev, usb_sndctrlpipe(ir->usbdev, 0),
+			      USB_REQ_SET_FEATURE, USB_TYPE_VENDOR,
+			      0xc04e, 0x0000, NULL, 0, HZ * 3);
+
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - ret = %d\n", __func__, ret);
+
+	/* bRequest 4: set char length to 8 bits */
+	ret = usb_control_msg(ir->usbdev, usb_sndctrlpipe(ir->usbdev, 0),
+			      4, USB_TYPE_VENDOR,
+			      0x0808, 0x0000, NULL, 0, HZ * 3);
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - retB = %d\n", __func__, ret);
+
+	/* bRequest 2: set handshaking to use DTR/DSR */
+	ret = usb_control_msg(ir->usbdev, usb_sndctrlpipe(ir->usbdev, 0),
+			      2, USB_TYPE_VENDOR,
+			      0x0000, 0x0100, NULL, 0, HZ * 3);
+	dev_dbg(ir->d->dev, "%s - retC = %d\n", __func__, ret);
+
+	return ret;
+
+};
+
+static int mceusb_dev_probe(struct usb_interface *intf,
+				const struct usb_device_id *id)
+{
+	struct usb_device *dev = interface_to_usbdev(intf);
+	struct usb_host_interface *idesc;
+	struct usb_endpoint_descriptor *ep = NULL;
+	struct usb_endpoint_descriptor *ep_in = NULL;
+	struct usb_endpoint_descriptor *ep_out = NULL;
+	struct usb_host_config *config;
+	struct mceusb_dev *ir = NULL;
+	struct lirc_driver *driver = NULL;
+	struct lirc_buffer *rbuf = NULL;
+	int devnum, pipe, maxp;
+	int minor = 0;
+	int i;
+	char buf[63], name[128] = "";
+	int mem_failure = 0;
+	int is_pinnacle;
+	int is_microsoft_gen1;
+
+	dev_dbg(&intf->dev, ": %s called\n", __func__);
+
+	usb_reset_device(dev);
+
+	config = dev->actconfig;
+
+	idesc = intf->cur_altsetting;
+
+	is_pinnacle = usb_match_id(intf, pinnacle_list) ? 1 : 0;
+
+	is_microsoft_gen1 = usb_match_id(intf, microsoft_gen1_list) ? 1 : 0;
+
+	/* step through the endpoints to find first bulk in and out endpoint */
+	for (i = 0; i < idesc->desc.bNumEndpoints; ++i) {
+		ep = &idesc->endpoint[i].desc;
+
+		if ((ep_in == NULL)
+			&& ((ep->bEndpointAddress & USB_ENDPOINT_DIR_MASK)
+			    == USB_DIR_IN)
+			&& (((ep->bmAttributes & USB_ENDPOINT_XFERTYPE_MASK)
+			    == USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_BULK)
+			|| ((ep->bmAttributes & USB_ENDPOINT_XFERTYPE_MASK)
+			    == USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_INT))) {
+
+			dev_dbg(&intf->dev, ": acceptable inbound endpoint "
+				"found\n");
+			ep_in = ep;
+			ep_in->bmAttributes = USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_INT;
+			if (is_pinnacle)
+				/*
+				 * setting seems to 1 seem to cause issues with
+				 * Pinnacle timing out on transfer.
+				 */
+				ep_in->bInterval = ep->bInterval;
+			else
+				ep_in->bInterval = 1;
+		}
+
+		if ((ep_out == NULL)
+			&& ((ep->bEndpointAddress & USB_ENDPOINT_DIR_MASK)
+			    == USB_DIR_OUT)
+			&& (((ep->bmAttributes & USB_ENDPOINT_XFERTYPE_MASK)
+			    == USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_BULK)
+			|| ((ep->bmAttributes & USB_ENDPOINT_XFERTYPE_MASK)
+			    == USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_INT))) {
+
+			dev_dbg(&intf->dev, ": acceptable outbound endpoint "
+				"found\n");
+			ep_out = ep;
+			ep_out->bmAttributes = USB_ENDPOINT_XFER_INT;
+			if (is_pinnacle)
+				/*
+				 * setting seems to 1 seem to cause issues with
+				 * Pinnacle timing out on transfer.
+				 */
+				ep_out->bInterval = ep->bInterval;
+			else
+				ep_out->bInterval = 1;
+		}
+	}
+	if (ep_in == NULL) {
+		dev_dbg(&intf->dev, ": inbound and/or endpoint not found\n");
+		return -ENODEV;
+	}
+
+	devnum = dev->devnum;
+	pipe = usb_rcvintpipe(dev, ep_in->bEndpointAddress);
+	maxp = usb_maxpacket(dev, pipe, usb_pipeout(pipe));
+
+	mem_failure = 0;
+	ir = kzalloc(sizeof(struct mceusb_dev), GFP_KERNEL);
+	if (!ir) {
+		mem_failure = 1;

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 987

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +10 -0
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	driver = kzalloc(sizeof(struct lirc_driver), GFP_KERNEL);
+	if (!driver) {
+		mem_failure = 2;
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	rbuf = kmalloc(sizeof(struct lirc_buffer), GFP_KERNEL);

kzalloc?

Quoted 53 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +53 -0
+	if (!rbuf) {
+		mem_failure = 3;
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	if (lirc_buffer_init(rbuf, sizeof(int), LIRCBUF_SIZE)) {
+		mem_failure = 4;
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	ir->buf_in = usb_buffer_alloc(dev, maxp, GFP_ATOMIC, &ir->dma_in);
+	if (!ir->buf_in) {
+		mem_failure = 5;
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	ir->urb_in = usb_alloc_urb(0, GFP_KERNEL);
+	if (!ir->urb_in) {
+		mem_failure = 7;
+		goto mem_failure_switch;
+	}
+
+	strcpy(driver->name, DRIVER_NAME);
+	driver->minor = -1;
+	driver->features = LIRC_CAN_SEND_PULSE |
+		LIRC_CAN_SET_TRANSMITTER_MASK |
+		LIRC_CAN_REC_MODE2 |
+		LIRC_CAN_SET_SEND_CARRIER;
+	driver->data = ir;
+	driver->rbuf = rbuf;
+	driver->set_use_inc = &mceusb_ir_open;
+	driver->set_use_dec = &mceusb_ir_close;
+	driver->code_length = sizeof(int) * 8;
+	driver->fops  = &lirc_fops;
+	driver->dev   = &intf->dev;
+	driver->owner = THIS_MODULE;
+
+	mutex_init(&ir->lock);
+	init_waitqueue_head(&ir->wait_out);
+
+	minor = lirc_register_driver(driver);
+	if (minor < 0)
+		mem_failure = 9;
+
+mem_failure_switch:
+
+	switch (mem_failure) {
+	case 9:
+		usb_free_urb(ir->urb_in);
+	case 7:
+		usb_buffer_free(dev, maxp, ir->buf_in, ir->dma_in);
+	case 5:
+		lirc_buffer_free(rbuf);

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 1050

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +10 -0
+	case 4:
+		kfree(rbuf);
+	case 3:
+		kfree(driver);
+	case 2:
+		kfree(ir);
+	case 1:
+		dev_info(&intf->dev, "out of memory (code=%d)\n", mem_failure);
+		return -ENOMEM;
+	}

That seems ugly, IMHO ;) Better to use the standard way for it. Also, as kfree(NULL) is valid, you could simply remove cases 3, 2 and 1.

The better is to use the standard way for errors, like:

error_free_urb:

	usb_free_urb(ir->urb_in);
error_free_usb_buf:
	usb_buffer_free(dev, maxp, ir->buf_in, ir->dma_in);
error_free_lirc_buf:
	lirc_buffer_free(rbuf);
error:
	kfree(rbuf);
	kfree(driver);
	kfree(ir);
	dev_info(&intf->dev, "out of memory (code=%d)\n", mem_failure);

	return -ENOMEM;

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 1058

Quoted 9 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +8 -0
+
+	driver->minor = minor;
+	ir->d = driver;
+	ir->devnum = devnum;
+	ir->usbdev = dev;
+	ir->len_in = maxp;
 
+	ir->overflow_len = 0;
+	ir->flags.connected = 0;

There's no need to initialize with 0, since kzalloc were used.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c line 1065

Quoted 8 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_mceusb.c new file +7 -0
+	ir->flags.pinnacle = is_pinnacle;
+	ir->flags.microsoft_gen1 = is_microsoft_gen1;
+	ir->flags.transmitter_mask_inverted =
+		usb_match_id(intf, transmitter_mask_list) ? 0 : 1;
+
+	ir->lircdata = PULSE_MASK;
 
+	ir->is_pulse = 0;

There's no need to initialize with 0, since kzalloc were used.

Cheers,
Mauro

#189 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 3/3 v2] lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

In reply to Jarod Wilson

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c line 183

Quoted 9 lines · Jarod Wilson

lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

Successfully tested with multiple devices with and without displays.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +3 -0
+static struct usb_device_id imon_usb_id_table[] = {
+	/* TriGem iMON (IR only) -- TG_iMON.inf */
+	{ USB_DEVICE(0x0aa8, 0x8001) },

...

Another set of USB vendor ID's... this time, vendors weren't described. The same comment I did on patch 2/3 applies here... IMO, we should really try to create a global list of vendors/devices on kernel. Of course this is not a non-go issue, as it is already present on several other USB drivers.

Quoted 5 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +5 -0
+
+	/*
+	 * Translate received data to pulse and space lengths.
+	 * Received data is active low, i.e. pulses are 0 and
+	 * spaces are 1.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c line 1737

Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +10 -0
+	 *
+	 * My original algorithm was essentially similar to
+	 * Changwoo Ryu's with the exception that he switched
+	 * the incoming bits to active high and also fed an
+	 * initial space to LIRC at the start of a new sequence
+	 * if the previous bit was a pulse.
+	 *
+	 * I've decided to adopt his algorithm.
+	 */
+

Before digging into all code details, am I wrong or this device has the pulse/space decoding inside the chip?

In this case, we shouldn't really be converting their IR keystroke events into a pseudo set of pulse/space marks, but use the standard events interface.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#4 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Quoted 5 lines

Considering the common case
where the lirc driver will be associated with a media input device, the IR type can be detected automatically on kernel. However, advanced users may opt to use other IR types than what's provided with the device they bought.

I think most users would want to do that, though I don't have hard numbers of course. Why use a number of RCs simultaneously while one will do?

Quoted 3 lines

It should also be noticed that not all the already-existing IR drivers on kernel can provide a lirc interface, since several devices have their own IR decoding chips inside the hardware.

Right. I think they shouldn't use lirc interface, so it doesn't matter.

Quoted 7 lines

2) create a lirc kernel API, and have a layer there to decode IR protocols and output them via the already existing input layer. In this case, all we need to do, in terms of API, is to add a way to set the IR protocol that will be decoded, and to enumberate the capabilities. The lirc API, will be an in-kernel API to communicate with the devices that don't have IR protocols decoding capabilities inside the hardware.

I think this makes a lot of sense.
But: we don't need a database of RC codes in the kernel (that's a lot of data, the user has to select the RC in use anyway so he/she can simply provide mapping e.g. RC5<>keycode).

We do need RCx etc. protocols implementation in the kernel for the input layer.

"lirc" interface: should we be sending time+on/off data to userspace, or the RC5 etc. should be implemented in the kernel? There is (?) only a handful of RC protocols, implementing them in the kernel and passing only information such as proto+group+code+press/release etc. should be more efficient.

Perhaps the raw RCx data could be sent over the input layer as well? Something like the raw keyboard codes maybe?

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code <> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

Quoted 2 lines

or it would be better to standardize it
to always use the existing input layer?

I'd optionally provide a keyboard-alike input layer interface, with mappings (proto + raw code <> key) provided by userspace program. This should also work with multiple remotes.

Then the existing drivers (such as saa713x with GPIO+IRQ-driven IR receiver (IR signal on/off generating IRQ)) should be converted.

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#5 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 4 lines · Krzysztof Halasa

I think this makes a lot of sense.
But: we don't need a database of RC codes in the kernel (that's a lot of data, the user has to select the RC in use anyway so he/she can simply provide mapping e.g. RC5<>keycode).

Just bear in mind that with the current in-kernel code, users do *not
* have to manually select the RC code to use if they are using the default remote that shipped with the product. This helps alot for those unfamiliar with LIRC, since their product "works out of the box" with the remote the product came with. I agree though, that the user should be able to easily change the RC to be used if he/she decides to use a remote other than the default.

Devin

Signature · 2 lines
Devin J. Heitmueller - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
#12 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Modern input drivers in the mainline kernel have a scancode-to-keycode translation table (or equivalent) which can be overwritten by userspace. The mechanism to do that is the EVIOCSKEYCODE ioctl.

(This is no recommendation for lirc. I have no idea whether a pulse/space -> scancode -> keycode translation would be practical there.)

Signature · 3 lines
Stefan Richter
-=====-==--= =-== =-===
http://arcgraph.de/sr/
#6 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller

2009/11/23 Devin Heitmueller <[email protected]>:

Quoted 3 lines

Just bear in mind that with the current in-kernel code, users do *not
* have to manually select the RC code to use if they are using the default remote that shipped with the product.

This could still happen, if LIRC checks the identifiers of the reciving device, and has a database that tells it mappings between those devices and the remote controls that shipped with them. However, it occours to me that the IR circumstances map pretty well to what happens with ps/2 and serial devices now:

1: There are a variety of drivers for serio computer-side hardware, each of which speaks the serio interface to the next-higher level. These corrospond to the drivers for IR recievers.
2: There's a raw serio interface, for those wishing to do strange things. 3: There's also a variety of things that take data, using the kernel serio API, and decode it into input events -- the ps2 keyboard driver, the basic mouse driver, the advanced mice drivers. This is where the interface falls down a little bit -- the ps2 keyboard driver is the closest analogue to what I'm suggesting. The ps2 keyboard driver creates scancode events, which map nicely to what the keyboard is sending -- these are, for ex, rc5 codes. It will also produce key-up/key-down events, if it has a keymap loaded. (This is the difference with a ps2 keyboard -- a ps2 keyboard gets a map assigned to it at boottime, so it works out-of-box. This isn't really possible with an IR remote -- though perhaps rc5 is standarized enough, I don't think other protocols neccessarly are.)

Userspace would have to load a keymap; those don't really belong in kernel code. Of course, userspace could look at the device identifiers to pick a reasonable default keymap if it's not configured to load another, solving the out-of-box experince.

Why is this such a contentious point? I can understand wanting to keep uncommon decoding algos out of the kernel, and keymaps, but at the same time, they are currently there, in multiple drivers, and while colesing them into a single place each makes sense, I'm not convinced that moving them out completely makes all that much sense. Having an explicit layer between the raw pulse/space layer and the decoders means that usespace can hook in there, and create scancode events, if it wishes to, but for the majority of remotes that use just a couple of encoding schemes, the code can stay in the kernel. Of course, devices that do the decoding in hardware would not implement the raw interface, but simply create the scancode/keycode events.

-=- James Mastros

#8 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller

2009/11/23 Devin Heitmueller <[email protected]>:

Quoted 3 lines

Just bear in mind that with the current in-kernel code, users do *not
* have to manually select the RC code to use if they are using the default remote that shipped with the product.

This could still happen, if LIRC checks the identifiers of the reciving device, and has a database that tells it mappings between those devices and the remote controls that shipped with them. However, it occours to me that the IR circumstances map pretty well to what happens with ps/2 and serial devices now:

1: There are a variety of drivers for serio computer-side hardware, each of which speaks the serio interface to the next-higher level. These corrospond to the drivers for IR recievers.
2: There's a raw serio interface, for those wishing to do strange things. 3: There's also a variety of things that take data, using the kernel serio API, and decode it into input events -- the ps2 keyboard driver, the basic mouse driver, the advanced mice drivers. This is where the interface falls down a little bit -- the ps2 keyboard driver is the closest analogue to what I'm suggesting. The ps2 keyboard driver creates scancode events, which map nicely to what the keyboard is sending -- these are, for ex, rc5 codes. It will also produce key-up/key-down events, if it has a keymap loaded. (This is the difference with a ps2 keyboard -- a ps2 keyboard gets a map assigned to it at boottime, so it works out-of-box. This isn't really possible with an IR remote -- though perhaps rc5 is standarized enough, I don't think other protocols neccessarly are.)

Userspace would have to load a keymap; those don't really belong in kernel code. Of course, userspace could look at the device identifiers to pick a reasonable default keymap if it's not configured to load another, solving the out-of-box experince.

-=- James Mastros

#9 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 27 lines · James Mastros

2009/11/23 Devin Heitmueller <[email protected]>:

Quoted 3 lines

Just bear in mind that with the current in-kernel code, users do *not
* have to manually select the RC code to use if they are using the default remote that shipped with the product.

This could still happen, if LIRC checks the identifiers of the reciving device, and has a database that tells it mappings between those devices and the remote controls that shipped with them. However, it occours to me that the IR circumstances map pretty well to what happens with ps/2 and serial devices now:

1: There are a variety of drivers for serio computer-side hardware, each of which speaks the serio interface to the next-higher level. These corrospond to the drivers for IR recievers.
2: There's a raw serio interface, for those wishing to do strange things. 3: There's also a variety of things that take data, using the kernel serio API, and decode it into input events -- the ps2 keyboard driver, the basic mouse driver, the advanced mice drivers.  This is where the interface falls down a little bit -- the ps2 keyboard driver is the closest analogue to what I'm suggesting.  The ps2 keyboard driver creates scancode events, which map nicely to what the keyboard is sending -- these are, for ex, rc5 codes.  It will also produce key-up/key-down events, if it has a keymap loaded.  (This is the difference with a ps2 keyboard -- a ps2 keyboard gets a map assigned to it at boottime, so it works out-of-box.  This isn't really possible with an IR remote -- though perhaps rc5 is standarized enough, I don't think other protocols neccessarly are.)

Quoted 4 lines

Userspace would have to load a keymap; those don't really belong in kernel code.  Of course, userspace could look at the device identifiers to pick a reasonable default keymap if it's not configured to load another, solving the out-of-box experince.

I think perhaps before we go much further into this, we may wish to come up with a set of use cases and expected behavior. I worry that part of the problem here is people are thinking of how their particular cards behave, and few people have a holistic picture of all the possible scenarios. Whatever implementation we come up, we should be confident that it meets the requirements of *all* the various hardware implementations.

I will try to draft up some requirements/use cases if people think this would be worthwhile.

Devin

Signature · 6 lines
Devin J. Heitmueller - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#23 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Key mapping can be easily changed via input interface, as noticed by others.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Considering the common case
where the lirc driver will be associated with a media input device, the IR type can be detected automatically on kernel. However, advanced users may opt to use other IR types than what's provided with the device they bought.

I think most users would want to do that, though I don't have hard numbers of course. Why use a number of RCs simultaneously while one will do?

If you're building a dedicated hardware to act as a MCE, it makes sense to use just one IR to control your TV and your hardware, but the common usage is to add a TV board or stick to your desktop to see TV. For this, the standard IR fits well.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

It should also be noticed that not all the already-existing IR drivers on kernel can provide a lirc interface, since several devices have their own IR decoding chips inside the hardware.

Right. I think they shouldn't use lirc interface, so it doesn't matter.

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

It is very bad to have two interfaces for the same thing, because people may do things like that.

Also, there are some cases where the same V4L driver can receive IR scancodes directly for one board, while for others, it needs to get pulse/space decoding.

So, it makes sense to have an uniform way for doing it.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 7 lines

2) create a lirc kernel API, and have a layer there to decode IR protocols and output them via the already existing input layer. In this case, all we need to do, in terms of API, is to add a way to set the IR protocol that will be decoded, and to enumberate the capabilities. The lirc API, will be an in-kernel API to communicate with the devices that don't have IR protocols decoding capabilities inside the hardware.

Quoted 4 lines

I think this makes a lot of sense.
But: we don't need a database of RC codes in the kernel (that's a lot of data, the user has to select the RC in use anyway so he/she can simply provide mapping e.g. RC5<>keycode).

This is an interesting discussion. We currently have lots of such tables in kernel, but it can be a good idea to have it loaded by udev during boot time.

Quoted 2 lines

We do need RCx etc. protocols implementation in the kernel for the input layer.

Yes. We already have this. See bttv, saa7134 and cx88 for several of such protocol decoding.

Quoted 10 lines

"lirc" interface: should we be sending time+on/off data to userspace, or the RC5 etc. should be implemented in the kernel? There is (?) only a handful of RC protocols, implementing them in the kernel and passing only information such as proto+group+code+press/release etc. should be more efficient.

Perhaps the raw RCx data could be sent over the input layer as well? Something like the raw keyboard codes maybe?

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Are you meaning that we should do more than one RC per input event interface? If so, why do you think we need to handle more than one IR protocol at the same time? I think this will just make the driver more complex without need. Also, I'm not sure if this would work well for all protocols.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code <> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

Since the key mapping table can be changed anytime, I don't see this as an issue. If we are doing protocol handling in kernel, we just need to add some extensions to the existing input event API to properly handle the IR protocol type.

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Agreed. We can postpone this discussion after solving the IR receivers

Cheers,
Mauro.

maintainer
#49 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Quoted 4 lines

Perhaps the raw RCx data could be sent over the input layer as well? Something like the raw keyboard codes maybe?

Curreently the "scan" codes in the input layer serve just to help users to map whatever the device emits into a proper input event code so that the rest of userspace would not have to care and would work with all types of devices (USB, PS/2, etc).

I would not want to get to the point where the raw codes are used as a primary data source.

Quoted 9 lines

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code <> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

I think if the data is used to do the primary protocol decoding then it should be a separate interface that is processed by someone and then fed into input subsystem (either in-kernel or through uinput).

Again, I would prefer to keep EV_KEY/KEY_* as the primary event type for keys and buttons on all devices.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#13 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Stefan Richter
Quoted 11 lines · Stefan Richter
Quoted 6 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Modern input drivers in the mainline kernel have a scancode-to-keycode translation table (or equivalent) which can be overwritten by userspace. The mechanism to do that is the EVIOCSKEYCODE ioctl.

This mechanism is already used by all V4L drivers and several DVB drivers.

Quoted 2 lines

(This is no recommendation for lirc. I have no idea whether a pulse/space -> scancode -> keycode translation would be practical there.)

pulse/space -> scancode translation is already done by several existing drivers.

For example, there are several bttv and saa7134 devices that polls (or receive IRQ interrupts) to detect pulses (and the absense of them) in order to create a pulse/space code. The conversion from pulse/space to scancode is done inside the driver, with the help of some generic routines and based on the protocol specifications.

The conversion from the scancode to a keycode is done based on in-kernel keycode tables that can be changed from userspace with EVIOCSKEYCODE ioctl.

I can't see any technical reason why not doing the same for the lirc drivers, except for one issue:

Those devices where the decoding is done by software can support any IR protocols. So, it is possible to buy a device with a NEC IR, and use a RC5 IR to control it.

However, currently, there's no way to inform the kernel to use a different algorithm to translate the kernel.

This can be solved by adding a few ioctls to enumerate the supported protocols and to select the one(s) that will be handled by the kernel driver.

Cheers,
Mauro

#10 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to James Mastros
Quoted 7 lines · James Mastros

2009/11/23 Devin Heitmueller <[email protected]>:

Quoted 3 lines

Just bear in mind that with the current in-kernel code, users do *not
* have to manually select the RC code to use if they are using the default remote that shipped with the product.

This could still happen, if LIRC checks the identifiers of the reciving device, and has a database that tells it mappings between those devices and the remote controls that shipped with them.

True, but this means that everyone with an IR will need to use lirc.

/me thinks that, whatever decided with those lirc drivers, this should be applied also to the existing V4L/DVB drivers.

IMO, it would be better to load the tables at the boot time (or at the corresponding hotplug event, for USB devices).

Quoted 10 lines

However, it occours to me that the IR circumstances map pretty well to what happens with ps/2 and serial devices now:

1: There are a variety of drivers for serio computer-side hardware, each of which speaks the serio interface to the next-higher level. These corrospond to the drivers for IR recievers.
2: There's a raw serio interface, for those wishing to do strange things. 3: There's also a variety of things that take data, using the kernel serio API, and decode it into input events -- the ps2 keyboard driver, the basic mouse driver, the advanced mice drivers.

Seems an interesting model.

Quoted 10 lines

This is where the
interface falls down a little bit -- the ps2 keyboard driver is the closest analogue to what I'm suggesting. The ps2 keyboard driver creates scancode events, which map nicely to what the keyboard is sending -- these are, for ex, rc5 codes. It will also produce key-up/key-down events, if it has a keymap loaded. (This is the difference with a ps2 keyboard -- a ps2 keyboard gets a map assigned to it at boottime, so it works out-of-box. This isn't really possible with an IR remote -- though perhaps rc5 is standarized enough, I don't think other protocols neccessarly are.)

Even with RC5, there are some vendors that implement it differently on his IR (for example, using VCR and/or TV group for the keys).

Quoted 4 lines

Userspace would have to load a keymap; those don't really belong in kernel code. Of course, userspace could look at the device identifiers to pick a reasonable default keymap if it's not configured to load another, solving the out-of-box experince.

I like this idea. We currently have hundreds of IR keymaps already in kernel. It seems good to remove from kernel and let udev load those.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#24 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

I'm a bit short on time to write up a more complete reply to anything in this thread at the moment, but a few quick notes interspersed below.

Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 1 line · Krzysztof Halasa

Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> writes:

...

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Considering the common case
where the lirc driver will be associated with a media input device, the IR type can be detected automatically on kernel. However, advanced users may opt to use other IR types than what's provided with the device they bought.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I think most users would want to do that, though I don't have hard numbers of course. Why use a number of RCs simultaneously while one will do?

If you're building a dedicated hardware to act as a MCE, it makes sense to use just one IR to control your TV and your hardware, but the common usage is to add a TV board or stick to your desktop to see TV. For this, the standard IR fits well.

The main use case that I have personal experience using IR and capture devices is with MythTV. Its not at all uncommon for a MythTV user to have a setup where the capture devices are attached to a completely different system from the system where the IR part needs to be. MythTV is client-server -- the backend server does the video capture via the capture devices, and the frontend client plays back the video, and its the frontend client that you navigate via an IR remote control. There are quite a few available IR options that are NOT tied to a video capture device at all -- the mceusb and imon drivers submitted in my patch series are actually two such beasts.

And particularly with the mceusb receivers, because they support damn near every IR protocol under the sun at any carrier frequency, using a remote other than the bundled one is quite common. Most people's set top boxes and/or televisions and/or AV receivers come with a remote capable of controlling multiple devices, and many bundled remotes are, quite frankly, utter garbage. I use a Logitech Harmony 880 universal remote myself.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

It should also be noticed that not all the already-existing IR drivers on kernel can provide a lirc interface, since several devices have their own IR decoding chips inside the hardware.

Right. I think they shouldn't use lirc interface, so it doesn't matter.

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

Historically, this is true. But the version I submitted actually defaults to operating as a pure input layer device for all the imon devices that do onboard decoding. There are older imon devices that don't do onboard decoding, and I retained "legacy", if you will, lirc interface support in this pass of the driver for the onboard decode devices for those that want to keep things running as they always have (via a modparam).

More replyification later tonight...

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#7 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to James Mastros
Quoted 5 lines · James Mastros

(This is the
difference with a ps2 keyboard -- a ps2 keyboard gets a map assigned to it at boottime, so it works out-of-box. This isn't really possible with an IR remote -- though perhaps rc5 is standarized enough, I don't think other protocols neccessarly are.)

Even with RC5 this isn't really possible. RC5 specifies several classes of remotes, and with a typical HTPC scenario the sensor will pick up more than one remote codeset - e.g. one for the display, one for TV card, and maybe others (all those codes may be coming from a single remote). We have no way to know in advance which one code set is for the PC.

The only thing which we can "preconfigure" is the remote bundled with the sensor (card etc). And even this can be incorrect. Several sensors don't came with a remote controller.

I think the default sensor->remote assignment may only make sense in userspace, while configuring the mapping.

Of course all the above changes when the sensors can't present the "raw" data (IR on/off) but does all the decoding internally (and for example can't decode all RC5 but only keys used on its remote). In such unfortunate cases it has to go to the input layer directly.

Quoted 4 lines

Userspace would have to load a keymap; those don't really belong in kernel code. Of course, userspace could look at the device identifiers to pick a reasonable default keymap if it's not configured to load another, solving the out-of-box experince.

Precisely.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#11 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

True, but this means that everyone with an IR will need to use lirc.

I think that if the input layer (instead of raw code) is used, a utility which only sets the mapping(s) would suffice. I.e. no daemon.

Quoted 2 lines

/me thinks that, whatever decided with those lirc drivers, this should be applied also to the existing V4L/DVB drivers.

Certainly.

Quoted 2 lines

IMO, it would be better to load the tables at the boot time (or at the corresponding hotplug event, for USB devices).

Sure (unless the "raw code" interface is in use).

Though maybe the raw code interface should be done in a simple library instead of requiring the daemon.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#14 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 3 lines

(This is no recommendation for lirc. I have no idea whether a pulse/space -> scancode -> keycode translation would be practical there.)

It would, but not exactly in the present shape.

Quoted 5 lines

For example, there are several bttv and saa7134 devices that polls (or receive IRQ interrupts) to detect pulses (and the absense of them) in order to create a pulse/space code. The conversion from pulse/space to scancode is done inside the driver, with the help of some generic routines and based on the protocol specifications.

Right. There are currently several problems (I'm quite familiar with saa713x RC5 code): the one that it barely works and is not implemented for most such "GPIO/IRQ-driven" cards (as of 2.6.29 or so). This could be fixed, I even have a working though quick&dirty patch. Another: the RC5 allows for groups and codes within groups. The mapping can only use one group, and there can only be one mapping. These design limitations mean it's unusable in many cases.

Quoted 2 lines

Those devices where the decoding is done by software can support any IR protocols.

Yes, and there can be multiple remote controllers, and multiple code groups within a remote.

Quoted 3 lines

This can be solved by adding a few ioctls to enumerate the supported protocols and to select the one(s) that will be handled by the kernel driver.

The driver may have to handle many protocols simultaneously. This is not a problem from a technical POV.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#28 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

IOW the driver generates artificial pulse code for lircd? I think - pure bloat. lircd can get events from input layer without problems. Perhaps I misunderstood?

Quoted 2 lines

It is very bad to have two interfaces for the same thing, because people may do things like that.

I think having a "raw" scan code interface + the key code "cooked" mode is beneficial. For remotes lacking the raw interface only the latter could be used.

Quoted 3 lines

Also, there are some cases where the same V4L driver can receive IR scancodes directly for one board, while for others, it needs to get pulse/space decoding.

Sure.

Quoted 3 lines

This is an interesting discussion. We currently have lots of such tables in kernel, but it can be a good idea to have it loaded by udev during boot time.

Sure.

Quoted 2 lines

Are you meaning that we should do more than one RC per input event interface?

I think so. Why not?

For example, one of my remotes generates codes from at least two RC5 groups (in only one "mode"). Currently a remote is limited to only one RC5 group.

I think the mapping should be: key = proto + group + raw code, while key2 could be different_proto + different group (if any) + another code.

Quoted 2 lines

If so, why do you think we need to handle more than one IR protocol at the same time?

Why not?
There are X-in-1 remotes on the market for years. They can "speak" many protocols at once. One may want to have a protocol to handle DVD apps while another for DVB etc.
And someone may want to use several different remotes, why not? Personally I use two different remotes (both set to speak RC5 but what if I couldn't set the protocol?). Sure, it requires a bit of hackery (not with pulse code and lircd).

Quoted 1 line

I think this will just make the driver more complex without need.

Not much more, and there is a need.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#25 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

There are quite a few available IR options that are NOT tied to a video capture device at all -- the mceusb and imon drivers submitted in my patch series are actually two such beasts.

Precisely. This also includes the parallel and serial port receivers, I'm under impression that they are, or at least were, the most common, due to their extreme simplicity.

Quoted 6 lines

And particularly with the mceusb receivers, because they support damn near every IR protocol under the sun at any carrier frequency, using a remote other than the bundled one is quite common. Most people's set top boxes and/or televisions and/or AV receivers come with a remote capable of controlling multiple devices, and many bundled remotes are, quite frankly, utter garbage.

This is precisely also my experience.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#50 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 7 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

Curreently the "scan" codes in the input layer serve just to help users to map whatever the device emits into a proper input event code so that the rest of userspace would not have to care and would work with all types of devices (USB, PS/2, etc).

I would not want to get to the point where the raw codes are used as a primary data source.

The "key" interface is not flexible enough at present.

Quoted 2 lines

Again, I would prefer to keep EV_KEY/KEY_* as the primary event type for keys and buttons on all devices.

Primary, I think so.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#26 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Hi Jarod,

Quoted 1 line · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line

Krzysztof Halasa wrote:

[...]

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

Historically, this is true.

No, it's not.
I think you misunderstood the code. The comment may be a bit misleading, too.
Early iMON devices did not decode in hardware and the part of the driver that Krzystof is referring to is translating a bit-stream of the sampled input data into pulse/space durations.

Christoph

#82 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa

Czesc Krzysztof,

on 23 Nov 09 at 15:14, Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
[...]

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

Christoph

#83 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 5 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:
Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I don't say don't use a transmitter.
I say the transmitter is not an input device, they are completely independent functions. I can't see any reason to try and fit both in the same interface - can you?

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#84 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 4 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:
Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I don't say don't use a transmitter.
I say the transmitter is not an input device, they are completely independent functions. I can't see any reason to try and fit both in the same interface - can you?

There is an argument to be made that since it may be desirable for both IR receivers and transmitters to share the same table of remote control definitions, it might make sense to at least *consider* how the IR transmitter interface is going to work, even if it is decided to not implement such a design in the first revision.

Personally, I would hate to see a situation where we find out that we took a bad approach because nobody considered what would be required for IR transmitters to reuse the same remote control definition data.

Devin

Signature · 2 lines
Devin J. Heitmueller - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
#182 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

I though about it a bit - my idea:

1. Receivers that can only decode their own remote controllers. The present code (saa713x etc) can stay mostly unchanged. I'd only verify that 7 bits (or whatever the number is) is enough for all cases. The ioctl() should stay unchanged. That means keyboard-like input layer interface.

2. Receivers that can be programmed to receive different codes, and/or which simply generate IRQ on space/mark changes. They would use a new ioctl() instead:

int set_rc_mapping_ioctl(void *data ...)

data should be:

	u32 protocol1;
	u32 length1;
	u32 protocol2;
        u32 length2;
        ...
        u32 protocol_last;
        u32 length_last;
        (u32) 0.

The protocol data would follow (after all proto/length fields to avoid alignment issues, but that's a detail of course).

For example, RC5. It uses 1 start bit (formerly 2 bits), 1 "toggle" bit, 5 address bits (group code) and 7 command bits (formerly 6 bits). Each key would be represented by u16, or maybe by a couple of u8. A "discard repeated" (perhaps inverted) bit should be included. Of course, the "symbolic" key code should be included for each "scan" code.

Maybe:  u8 address_and_discard_repeated_bit;
        u8 command_value;
        u8 symbolic_key_code;

repeated as required.

Protocol2 would follow protocol1 etc. (alignment issues). The driver could see this info (for example, to program hardware to receive a specific protocol) and then it should pass it to the generic lirc_set_mapping() routine.

I'd also add separate trivial space/mark protocol, for debugging etc.

Maybe:  u8 key_code_for_space;
        u8 key_code_for_mark;

Maybe specifying length = 0 (meaning constant "key" codes) would be enough? I think the "key" code should also specify some time stamp (or pulse length).

Interface to the sensor driver:
The driver should register an IRQ called on both (preferably) edges of the input signal. Basically it should only register IRQ and do:

irqreturn_t xxx_irq()

{
	ack_irq_as_usual_etc();
        if (input_signal->changed_state) /* really for us */
		lirc_signal_state_change(input_signal->current_state);
}

The sensor driver would not know about the protocols etc. unless it needs to e.g. program the hardware.

The middle layer (some sort of a library, and module) would interface to the userspace (ioctl passed by the driver, input interface) and to the hw driver. It would have to enable and call the required protocol decoders (based on the keymap loaded).

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#85 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 9 lines · Devin Heitmueller

There is an argument to be made that since it may be desirable for both IR receivers and transmitters to share the same table of remote control definitions, it might make sense to at least *consider* how the IR transmitter interface is going to work, even if it is decided to not implement such a design in the first revision.

Personally, I would hate to see a situation where we find out that we took a bad approach because nobody considered what would be required for IR transmitters to reuse the same remote control definition data.

I briefly though about such possibility, but dismissed it with assumption that we won't transmit the same codes (including "key" codes) that we receive.

Perhaps I'm wrong.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#86 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 6 lines · Devin Heitmueller

There is an argument to be made that since it may be desirable for both IR receivers and transmitters to share the same table of remote control definitions, it might make sense to at least *consider* how the IR transmitter interface is going to work, even if it is decided to not implement such a design in the first revision.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Personally, I would hate to see a situation where we find out that we took a bad approach because nobody considered what would be required for IR transmitters to reuse the same remote control definition data.

I briefly though about such possibility, but dismissed it with assumption that we won't transmit the same codes (including "key" codes) that we receive.

I'm not specifically suggesting that you would want to transmit the same codes that you receive, but you probably want the database of remote control definitions to be shared.

For example, you might want the IR receiver to be listening for codes using the "Universal Remote Control XYZ" profile and the IR transmitter pretending to be "Cable Company Remote Control ABC" when blasting IR codes to the cable box. Ideally, there would be a single shared database of the definitions of the remote controls, regardless of whether you are IR receiving or transmitting.

Devin

Signature · 2 lines
Devin J. Heitmueller - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
#87 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 6 lines · Devin Heitmueller

For example, you might want the IR receiver to be listening for codes using the "Universal Remote Control XYZ" profile and the IR transmitter pretending to be "Cable Company Remote Control ABC" when blasting IR codes to the cable box. Ideally, there would be a single shared database of the definitions of the remote controls, regardless of whether you are IR receiving or transmitting.

Well, with different receivers, the maps must certainly be different. There can be single database in the userspace but the kernel must be uploaded the relevant info only.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#93 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Czesc Krzysztof,

on 23 Nov 09 at 15:14, Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
[...]

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I agree with Christoph.

Is it that the input subsystem is better developed and seen as a leverage point for development and thus an "easier" place to get results earlier? If so, then one should definitely deal with transmitters early in the design, as that is where the most unknowns lie.

With the end of analog TV, people will have STBs feeding analog only video cards. Being able to change the channel on the STB with an IR transmitter controlled by applications like MythTV is essential.

And on some different notes:

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

I believe Jarod's intent is to have the LIRC components, that need to be in kernel modules, moved into kernel mainline to avoid the headaches of out of kernel driver maintenance. I'm not sure it is time well spent for developers, or end users, to develop yet another IR receive implementation in addition to the ones we suffer with now.

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

http://download.microsoft.com/download/9/8/f/98f3fe47-dfc3-4e74-92a3-088782200fe7/TWEN05007_WinHEC05.ppt

"Microsoft recommends the Microsoft-Philips IR protocol (based on RC6)
* You can become a licensee at no charge to you
[...]
* How to license RC6
* Contact RemoteMC @ microsoft.com for license agreement"

I would much rather that RC-6 be handled as much as possible in user space than in the kernel. LIRC userspace components already handle it, IIRC.

Regards,
Andy "LIRC Fan-Boy" Walls

#89 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:
Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I don't say don't use a transmitter.
I say the transmitter is not an input device, they are completely independent functions. I can't see any reason to try and fit both in the same interface - can you?

The underlying hardware need not be completely independent.

For example, the CX2584[0123], CX2388[578], CX23418, and CX2310[012] chips have IR hardware that shares a common timing source, interrupt line, interrupt status register, etc, between IR Rx and Tx. They can also do things like loopback of Tx to Rx.

That said, an underlying hardware implementation can be split up to user space with separate interfaces Tx and Rx. The underlying driver module would have to manage the dependencies. I would guess that would be easier for driver modules, if the userspace interfaces were designed with such combined IR Tx/Rx hardware in mind.

Regards,
Andy

#27 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi Jarod,

Quoted 1 line · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line

Krzysztof Halasa wrote:

[...]

Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 1 line

Historically, this is true.

No, it's not.
I think you misunderstood the code. The comment may be a bit misleading, too.
Early iMON devices did not decode in hardware and the part of the driver that Krzystof is referring to is translating a bit-stream of the sampled input data into pulse/space durations.

Sorry, no, I know the newer devices don't actually send pulse/data info out to userspace, just hex codes that correspond to key presses. What I meant was "onboard decoding devices can operate as pure input devices or in classic lirc mode", leaving out the details on exactly what they were sending out to userspace. :)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#190 lore raw

Re: [PATCH 3/3 v2] lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 12 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Jarod Wilson

lirc driver for SoundGraph iMON IR receivers and displays

Successfully tested with multiple devices with and without displays.

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +3 -0
+static struct usb_device_id imon_usb_id_table[] = {
+	/* TriGem iMON (IR only) -- TG_iMON.inf */
+	{ USB_DEVICE(0x0aa8, 0x8001) },

...

Quoted 4 lines

Another set of USB vendor ID's... this time, vendors weren't described. The same comment I did on patch 2/3 applies here... IMO, we should really try to create a global list of vendors/devices on kernel. Of course this is not a non-go issue, as it is already present on several other USB drivers.

My first thought is that a global list shared by everyone would be a pain to manage -- which upstream tree would be the entry point for additions? I think a global-within-lirc header would be just fine though. Most usb lirc drivers don't have very long lists, these two (mceusb and imon) are by far the longest ones.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 10 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +10 -0
+
+	/*
+	 * Translate received data to pulse and space lengths.
+	 * Received data is active low, i.e. pulses are 0 and
+	 * spaces are 1.
+	 *
+	 * My original algorithm was essentially similar to
+	 * Changwoo Ryu's with the exception that he switched
+	 * the incoming bits to active high and also fed an
+	 * initial space to LIRC at the start of a new sequence
Quoted 8 lines

drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c line 1737

Quoted 5 lines
drivers/input/lirc/lirc_imon.c new file +5 -0
+	 * if the previous bit was a pulse.
+	 *
+	 * I've decided to adopt his algorithm.
+	 */
+

Before digging into all code details, am I wrong or this device has the pulse/space decoding inside the chip?

The current generation of imon devices do onboard decoding, but the driver supports older imon devices as well, which do NOT do onboard decoding, and follow the code referenced by the above comment block.

Quoted 2 lines

In this case, we shouldn't really be converting their IR keystroke events into a pseudo set of pulse/space marks, but use the standard events interface.

And that's actually the default mode for the devices that do onboard decoding -- the key mappings are all in lirc_imon.h. A modparam can be used to override pure input mode and instead pass the decoded hex values out to userspace for lircd to handle.

Its entirely possible we could split this driver into two, one that is for the older devices, and another for the newer devices that do onboard decoding, which is a pure input mode driver (and still usable with lirc via its devinput userspace driver). It'd be a lot of extra work at the moment though, and I have no older devices to test with, only the newer ones.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#58 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 6 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 5 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

...

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code<> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

Quoted 6 lines

I think if the data is used to do the primary protocol decoding then it should be a separate interface that is processed by someone and then fed into input subsystem (either in-kernel or through uinput).

Again, I would prefer to keep EV_KEY/KEY_* as the primary event type for keys and buttons on all devices.

Current lircd actually inter-operates with the input subsystem quite well for any and all supported remotes if their keys are mapped in their respective lircd.conf file using standard input subsystem key names, and the lirc daemon started with the --uinput param. lircd decodes the raw IR, finds the mapping in its config, and happily passes it along to uinput.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#94 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 1 line · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-11-23 at 22:11 +0100, Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

...

Quoted 6 lines

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

There's one gripe I agree with, and that is that its still not plug-n-play. Something where udev auto-loads a sane default remote config for say, mceusb transceivers, and the stock mce remote Just Works would be nice, but auto-config is mostly out the window the second you involve transmitters and universal remotes anyway. But outside of that, I think objections are largely philosophical -- in a nutshell, the kernel has an input layer, remotes are input devices, and lirc doesn't conform to input layer standards. I do understand that argument, I just don't currently agree that all IR must go through the input layer before the drivers are acceptable for upstream -- especially since lircd can reinject decoded key presses into the input layer via uinput.

Quoted 5 lines

I believe Jarod's intent is to have the LIRC components, that need to be in kernel modules, moved into kernel mainline to avoid the headaches of out of kernel driver maintenance. I'm not sure it is time well spent for developers, or end users, to develop yet another IR receive implementation in addition to the ones we suffer with now.

Yeah, a fairly relevant factor in all this is that, despite not being in the linux kernel source tree proper-like, the lirc drivers and lirc have been in use for many years by lots of users. The likes of Fedora, Debian, Ubuntu, SUSE, Mandriva, etc. have all been shipping lirc drivers for years now. While lirc certainly isn't perfect (its not always the easiest thing for users to set up), it has actually proven itself pretty robust and useful in the field, once set up. The bulk of breakage in lirc I've personally had to deal with has mostly come in the form of kernel interface changes, which would definitely be mitigated by not having to maintain the drivers out-of-tree any longer.

Now, I'm all for "improving" things and integrating better with the input subsystem, but what I don't really want to do is break compatibility with the existing setups on thousands (and thousands?) of MythTV boxes around the globe. The lirc userspace can be pretty nimble. If we can come up with a shiny new way that raw IR can be passed out through an input device, I'm pretty sure lirc userspace can be adapted to handle that. If a new input-layer-based transmit interface is developed, we can take advantage of that too. But there's already a very mature lirc interface for doing all of this. So why not start with adding things more or less as they exist right now and evolve the drivers into an idealized form? Getting *something* into the kernel in the first place is a huge step in that direct
ion.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#59 lore raw

IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Folks, I really want to tell everyone that doing all the mapping from raw codes to keypresses in kernel is wrong.

This idea keeps showing up, because many users think that remotes send some universal codes that you can just 'parse' and feed back to input system.

Its not the case.
There are many protocols, I know that by experimenting with my universal remote. There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy. Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.
Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.
Some don't send anything.

There are some weird remotes that send whole packet of data will all kind of states.

Think about it, video capture device is also an input device, a scanner is an input device too, sound card can work as input device too. But we aren't doing any parsing, even we don't support deflating of many proprietary and standard video/image encoding formats.
We let userspace do it.

Kernel job is to take the information from device and present it to userspace using uniform format, that is kernel does 1:1 translating, but doesn't parse the data.
Uniform format doesn't mean kernel always converts to one format, its not like sound card always recording in 32 bit 96000 Khz format, even if underlying device doesn't support that.

So, device that decode IR code are presented to userspace as pure input devices. I agree that creating fake raw codes from that is bad.

But devices that send raw data pass it to lirc.
lirc is well capable to decode it, and its not hard to add auto-detection based on existing configuration drivers, so IR devices will work with absolutely no configuration.
All you will have to do is ensure that lirc is installed. Then udev can even start it automatically.
Then as soon as you press a key, lirc can scan its config database, and find a config file to use. combine that with a GUI for unknown remotes and you get an awesome usability.

Also don't forget that there are pure userspace drivers. They won't have access to in-kernel decoder so they will still have to parse protocols, so will have code duplication, and will still need lirc thus.

So why to burden the kernel with protocols, etc..

Best regards,
Maxim Levitsky

#60 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

Quoted 9 lines · Maxim Levitsky

Its not the case.
There are many protocols, I know that by experimenting with my universal remote. There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy. Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.
Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.

The signal recevied by the ir receiver contains glitches. Depending on the receiver there can be quite a few. It is also not trivial to turn the raw signal sent by the remote into a digital value, even if you know what to expect. It takes digital signal processing techniques to turn the messy sequence of inaccurate mark and space lengths into a best guess at what digital code the remote sent.

It's like turning raw VBI data into decoded ASCII teletext from a simulated keyboard device, all in the kernel.

Quoted 3 lines

Kernel job is to take the information from device and present it to userspace using uniform format, that is kernel does 1:1 translating, but doesn't parse the data.

One thing that could be done, unless it has changed much since I wrote it 10+ years ago, is to take the mark/space protocol the ir device uses and sent that data to lircd via the input layer. It would be less efficient, but would avoid another kernel interface. Of course the input layer to lircd interface would be somewhat different than other input devices, so it's not entirely correct to say another interface is avoided.

#61 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

Quoted 11 lines · Trent Piepho
Quoted 9 lines · Maxim Levitsky

Its not the case.
There are many protocols, I know that by experimenting with my universal remote. There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy. Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.
Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.

Quoted 6 lines

The signal recevied by the ir receiver contains glitches. Depending on the receiver there can be quite a few. It is also not trivial to turn the raw signal sent by the remote into a digital value, even if you know what to expect. It takes digital signal processing techniques to turn the messy sequence of inaccurate mark and space lengths into a best guess at what digital code the remote sent.

Exactly

Quoted 3 lines

It's like turning raw VBI data into decoded ASCII teletext from a simulated keyboard device, all in the kernel.

You hit a nail on the head with this one.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

Kernel job is to take the information from device and present it to userspace using uniform format, that is kernel does 1:1 translating, but doesn't parse the data.

Quoted 6 lines

One thing that could be done, unless it has changed much since I wrote it 10+ years ago, is to take the mark/space protocol the ir device uses and sent that data to lircd via the input layer. It would be less efficient, but would avoid another kernel interface. Of course the input layer to lircd interface would be somewhat different than other input devices, so it's not entirely correct to say another interface is avoided.

I agree with this one, but it is very optional.

I also want to add that lirc can and does behave just like an input device.
It sends the parsed events using uinput, so your remote appears just like a keyboard.
It can even act like a mouse, and btw I use that feature, and it works just fine.

So lets put lirc into the kernel finally?

Best regards,
Maxim Levitsky

#140 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#95 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 4 lines · Jarod Wilson

The bulk of breakage in lirc I've personally had to deal with has mostly come in the form of kernel interface changes, which would definitely be mitigated by not having to maintain the drivers out-of-tree any longer.

Certainly.

Quoted 7 lines

Now, I'm all for "improving" things and integrating better with the input subsystem, but what I don't really want to do is break compatibility with the existing setups on thousands (and thousands?) of MythTV boxes around the globe. The lirc userspace can be pretty nimble. If we can come up with a shiny new way that raw IR can be passed out through an input device, I'm pretty sure lirc userspace can be adapted to handle that.

Lirc can already handle input layer. Since both ways require userspace changes, why not do it the right way the first time? Most of the code is already written.

Quoted 6 lines

If a new input-layer-based transmit interface is developed, we can take advantage of that too. But there's already a very mature lirc interface for doing all of this. So why not start with adding things more or less as they exist right now and evolve the drivers into an idealized form? Getting *something* into the kernel in the first place is a huge step in that direction.

What I see as potentially problematic is breaking compatibility multiple times.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#68 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Maxim Levitsky
Quoted 1 line · Maxim Levitsky

There are many protocols,

Few of them really popular.

Quoted 1 line

There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy.

Receivers? Accuracy? What do you mean exactly?

Quoted 2 lines

Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.

Of course. You can't change that. Being designed to be used with PC is not relevant.

Quoted 3 lines

Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.

I have never seen a remote that sends "model" number.
But I admit I only used few universal (including programmable) and few simple bundled remotes.

Quoted 1 line

Some don't send anything.

How do they communicate with the receiver?

Quoted 2 lines

There are some weird remotes that send whole packet of data will all kind of states.

Of course. This is called "encoding".

Quoted 2 lines

Think about it, video capture device is also an input device, a scanner is an input device too, sound card can work as input device too.

But their primary function isn't passing keystrokes, is it?

Quoted 3 lines

Kernel job is to take the information from device and present it to userspace using uniform format, that is kernel does 1:1 translating, but doesn't parse the data.

Why do you think so?
This is less efficient, and more complicated. And would require incompatible changes to drivers already in the kernel. Keyword:
"regression".

Quoted 3 lines

lirc is well capable to decode it, and its not hard to add auto-detection based on existing configuration drivers, so IR devices will work with absolutely no configuration.

Really? You don't know what you're talking about. Forget this idea, there is absolutely no way to use this without prior configuration. You can get as far as suggesting default "bundled" model, if there was something bundled with the receiver of course.

Quoted 2 lines

Then as soon as you press a key, lirc can scan its config database, and find a config file to use.

Forget it.

Quoted 3 lines

Also don't forget that there are pure userspace drivers. They won't have access to in-kernel decoder so they will still have to parse protocols, so will have code duplication, and will still need lirc thus.

This is not a problem. BTW I have nothing against lirc. It can get keystrokes from input layer. That's the way I use it in fact.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#66 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Trent Piepho
Quoted 6 lines · Trent Piepho

The signal recevied by the ir receiver contains glitches. Depending on the receiver there can be quite a few. It is also not trivial to turn the raw signal sent by the remote into a digital value, even if you know what to expect. It takes digital signal processing techniques to turn the messy sequence of inaccurate mark and space lengths into a best guess at what digital code the remote sent.

This is of course true. Except that most receivers do that in hardware, the receiver/demodular chip such as TSOP1838 does it.
If you receive with a phototransistor or a photodiode feeding some sort of ADC device (not a very smart design), sure - you have to do this yourself.

I have never heard of such receiver, though.

Quoted 6 lines

One thing that could be done, unless it has changed much since I wrote it 10+ years ago, is to take the mark/space protocol the ir device uses and sent that data to lircd via the input layer. It would be less efficient, but would avoid another kernel interface. Of course the input layer to lircd interface would be somewhat different than other input devices, so it's not entirely correct to say another interface is avoided.

IOW, it would be worse, wouldn't it?

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#96 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa

Hi,

Quoted 1 line · Krzysztof Halasa

Jarod Wilson <[email protected]> writes:

[...]

Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

nimble. If we can come up with a shiny new way that raw IR can be passed out through an input device, I'm pretty sure lirc userspace can be adapted to handle that.

As Trent already pointed out, adding support for raw IR through an input device would require a new interface too. You just put the label "input device" on it. This does not make much sense for me.

Quoted 2 lines

Lirc can already handle input layer. Since both ways require userspace changes,

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

We had exactly the same discussion around one year ago. I've seen no new arguements in the current discussion and nobody came up with this shiny new way of integrating LIRC into the input layer since last year. Maybe it's about time to just accept that the LIRC interface is the way to go.

Can we finally get the patch integrated, please?

Christoph

#97 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#124 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 1 line · Krzysztof Halasa

Jarod Wilson <[email protected]> writes:

...

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 7 lines

Now, I'm all for "improving" things and integrating better with the input subsystem, but what I don't really want to do is break compatibility with the existing setups on thousands (and thousands?) of MythTV boxes around the globe. The lirc userspace can be pretty nimble. If we can come up with a shiny new way that raw IR can be passed out through an input device, I'm pretty sure lirc userspace can be adapted to handle that.

Lirc can already handle input layer. Since both ways require userspace changes, why not do it the right way the first time? Most of the code is already written.

There's obviously still some debate as to what "the right way" is. :)

And the matter of someone having the time to write the rest of the code that would be needed.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 6 lines

If a new input-layer-based transmit interface is developed, we can take advantage of that too. But there's already a very mature lirc interface for doing all of this. So why not start with adding things more or less as they exist right now and evolve the drivers into an idealized form? Getting *something* into the kernel in the first place is a huge step in that direction.

What I see as potentially problematic is breaking compatibility multiple times.

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

1) bring drivers in in their current state
- users keep using lirc as they always have

2) add in-kernel decoding infra that feeds input layer

3) add option to use in-kernel decoding to existing lirc drivers
- users can keep using lirc as they always have
- users can optionally try out in-kernel decoding via a modparam

4) switch the default mode from lirc decode to kernel decode for each lirc driver
- modparam can be used to continue using lirc interface instead

5) assuming users aren't coming at us with pitchforks, because things don't actually work reliably with in-kernel decoding, deprecate the lirc interface in driver

6) remove lirc interface from driver, its now a pure input device

This would all be on a per-lirc-driver basis, and if/when all decoding could be reliably done in-kernel, and/or there was a way other than the lirc interface to pass raw IR signals out to userspace, the lirc interface could be removed entirely.

And we still need to consider IR transmitters as well. Those are handled quite well through the lirc interface, and I've not seen any concrete code (or even fully fleshed out ideas) on how IR transmit could be handled in this in-kernel decoding world.

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight. ;)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#98 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 11 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

Quoted 4 lines

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel? And/or, everything could converge on a new in-kernel decoding infra that wasn't badly broken. Sure, there may be two separate ways of doing essentially the same thing for a while, but meh. The lirc way works NOW for an incredibly wide variety of receivers, transmitters, IR protocols, etc.

I do concur that Just Works decoding for bundled remotes w/o having to configure anything would be nice, and one way to go about doing that certainly is via in-kernel IR decoding. But at the same time, the second you want to use something other than a bundled remote, things fall down, and having to do a bunch of setkeycode ops seems less optimal than simply dropping an appropriate lircd.conf in place.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#99 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed. I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be, to avoid a regression in functionality. We cannot go from a mode where it worked automatically to a mode where now inexperienced users now have to deal with the guts of getting lircd properly configured.

If such an interface were available, I would see to it that at least all the devices I have added RC support for will continue to work (converting the in-kernel RC profiles to lirc RC profiles as needed and doing the associations with the driver).

The other key thing I don't think we have given much thought to is the fact that in many tuners, the hardware does RC decoding and just returns NEC/RC5/RC6 codes. And in many of those cases, the hardware has to be configured to know what format to receive. We probably need some kernel API such that the hardware can tell lirc what formats are supported, and another API call to tell the hardware which mode to operate in.

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

Devin

Signature · 2 lines
Devin J. Heitmueller - Kernel Labs
http://www.kernellabs.com
#100 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

Quoted 5 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

Quoted 9 lines

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed. I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be, to avoid a regression in functionality. We cannot go from a mode where it worked automatically to a mode where now inexperienced users now have to deal with the guts of getting lircd properly configured.

Agreed. Auto-config of lircd for remotes bundled with receivers is definitely on the TODO list. It sorta kinda works using gnome-lirc-properties, but well, that's not an actual lirc project component, and from what I've seen, its fairly incomplete (and reproduces a device ID list within its own code, that has never been fully updated to match the list of stuff the lirc drivers actually support).

Quoted 5 lines

If such an interface were available, I would see to it that at least all the devices I have added RC support for will continue to work (converting the in-kernel RC profiles to lirc RC profiles as needed and doing the associations with the driver).

Quoted 7 lines

The other key thing I don't think we have given much thought to is the fact that in many tuners, the hardware does RC decoding and just returns NEC/RC5/RC6 codes. And in many of those cases, the hardware has to be configured to know what format to receive. We probably need some kernel API such that the hardware can tell lirc what formats are supported, and another API call to tell the hardware which mode to operate in.

Well, we've got a number of IOCTLs already, could extend those. (Although its been suggested elsewhere that we replace the IOCTLs with sysfs knobs). A simple sysfs attr that contains the name of the default config file for the bundled remote of a given receiver would seem simple enough to implement.

Quoted 3 lines

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

D'oh, sorry, I recall reading that email, but neglected to respond. Yes, I think that's useful, and would gladly contribute to the list.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#125 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

1) bring drivers in in their current state
- users keep using lirc as they always have

2) add in-kernel decoding infra that feeds input layer

Well. I think the above is fine enough.

Quoted 10 lines

3) add option to use in-kernel decoding to existing lirc drivers
- users can keep using lirc as they always have
- users can optionally try out in-kernel decoding via a modparam

4) switch the default mode from lirc decode to kernel decode for each lirc driver
- modparam can be used to continue using lirc interface instead

5) assuming users aren't coming at us with pitchforks, because things don't actually work reliably with in-kernel decoding, deprecate the lirc interface in driver

6) remove lirc interface from driver, its now a pure input device

But 3-6 are IMHO not useful. We don't need lirc _or_ input. We need both at the same time: input for the general, simple case and for consistency with receivers decoding in firmware/hardware; input for special cases such as mapping the keys, protocols not supported by the kernel and so on (also for in-tree media drivers where applicable).

Quoted 3 lines

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight. ;)

I think: in-kernel decoding only as the general, primary means. Not the only one.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#119 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Yes.

Quoted 3 lines

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel?

For many of them "lirc mode" can be easily _added_.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#106 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 7 lines · Devin Heitmueller

The other key thing I don't think we have given much thought to is the fact that in many tuners, the hardware does RC decoding and just returns NEC/RC5/RC6 codes. And in many of those cases, the hardware has to be configured to know what format to receive. We probably need some kernel API such that the hardware can tell lirc what formats are supported, and another API call to tell the hardware which mode to operate in.

For such cases, I wouldn't bother with lirc mode. Input layer + key mapping with ioctl (probably improved), and lircd can grab events from input layer if needed.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#101 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Well, we've got a number of IOCTLs already, could extend those. (Although its been suggested elsewhere that we replace the IOCTLs with sysfs knobs).

Not sure if sysfs would be fast enough.

Quoted 3 lines

A simple sysfs attr that contains the name of the default config file for the bundled remote of a given receiver would seem simple enough to implement.

A model name maybe. Though there is this mapping thing which I think need ioctl().

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#62 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Maxim Levitsky
Quoted 17 lines · Maxim Levitsky
Quoted 10 lines · Trent Piepho
Quoted 8 lines · Maxim Levitsky

Its not the case.
There are many protocols, I know that by experimenting with my universal remote. There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy. Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.
Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.

Quoted 6 lines

The signal recevied by the ir receiver contains glitches. Depending on the receiver there can be quite a few. It is also not trivial to turn the raw signal sent by the remote into a digital value, even if you know what to expect. It takes digital signal processing techniques to turn the messy sequence of inaccurate mark and space lengths into a best guess at what digital code the remote sent.

Quoted 6 lines

Exactly

Quoted 3 lines

It's like turning raw VBI data into decoded ASCII teletext from a simulated keyboard device, all in the kernel.

You hit a nail on the head with this one.

Absolutely. There are a number of use cases when you want access to the space-pulse (i.e. IR) information. For debugging purposes; support for non-standard remotes. Being able to do a precise recording of IR activity so you can replay without parsing. One could even imagine IR being used for completely different purposes than "key strokes", so the kernel should not enforce this "policy".

In the past I've spent time dissecting the IR output of a strange remote, I would hate to think this would not be possible due to mad kernel interfaces which cater just for drooling in front of the telly with your *new* remote.

Sean

#107 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 9 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

I think at the end of the day we'll want to have all IR drivers use the same interface. The way the current in-kernel input layer drivers work obviously isn't perfect too, so we *must* consider both worlds to get a good solution for long-term ...

Quoted 3 lines

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed.

I bet this simply isn't going to change.

Quoted 4 lines

I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to
automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be,
to avoid a regression in functionality.

*Requiring* lircd for the current in-kernel drivers doesn't make sense
at all. Allowing lircd being used so it can do some more advanced stuff makes sense though.

Quoted 4 lines

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

Lets have a look at the problems the current input layer bits have compared to lirc:

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

input_event->type = EV_IR
input_event->code = IR_RC5
input_event->value = <rc5 value>

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified

    rc5/rc6/... codes.

* All the ir-code -> keycode mapping magic can be handled by the core input layer then. All the driver needs to do is to pass on the information which keymap should be loaded by default (for the bundled remote if any). The configuration can happen in userspace (sysfs attribute + udev + small utility in tools/ir/).
* lirc drivers which get ir codes from the hardware can be converted to pure input layer drivers without regressions. lircd is not required any more.

(2) input layer doesn't give access to the raw samples.

Not sure how to deal with that best. Passing them through the input layer would certainly be possible to hack up. But what would be the point? The input layer wouldn't do any processing on them. It wouldn't buy us much. So we might want to simply stick with todays lirc interface for the raw samples.

Drivers which support both ir codes (be it by hardware or by in-kernel decoding) and raw samples would register two devices then, one input device and one lirc device. It would probably a good idea to stop sending events to the input layer as soon as someone (most likely lircd) opens the lirc device to avoid keystrokes showing up twice.

By default the in-kernel bits will be at work, but optionally you can have lircd grab the raw samples and do fancy advanced decoding.

(3) input layer doesn't allow transmitting IR codes.

If we keep the lirc interface for raw samples anyway, then we can keep it for sending too, problem solved ;) How does sending hardware work btw? Do they all accept just raw samples? Or does some hardware also accept ir-codes?

cheers,
Gerd

#63 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Sean Young
Quoted 2 lines · Sean Young

Absolutely. There are a number of use cases when you want access to the space-pulse (i.e. IR) information.

I think nobody proposes otherwise (except for devices which can't pass this info).

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#108 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann

Hi Gerd,

on 25 Nov 09 at 22:58, Gerd Hoffmann wrote:
[...]

Quoted 9 lines

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

   input_event->type  = EV_IR
   input_event->code  = IR_RC5
   input_event->value = <rc5 value>
Quoted 6 lines

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified

     rc5/rc6/... codes.

Unfortunately with most hardware decoders the code that you get is only remotely related to the actual code sent. Most RC-5 decoders strip off start bits. Toggle-bits are thrown away. NEC decoders usually don't pass through the address part. Some even generate some pseudo-random code (Irman). There is no common standard which bit is sent first, LSB or MSB. Checksums are thrown away.
To sum it up: I don't think this information will be useful at all for lircd or anyone else. Actually lircd does not even know anything about actual protocols. We only distinguish between certain protocol types, like Manchester encoded, space encoded, pulse encoded etc. Everything else like the actual timing is fully configurable.

[...]

Quoted 4 lines

If we keep the lirc interface for raw samples anyway, then we can keep it for sending too, problem solved ;) How does sending hardware work btw? Do they all accept just raw samples? Or does some hardware also accept ir-codes?

Usually raw samples in some form. I've never seen any device that would accept just ir-codes. UIRT2 devices have some more advanced modes but also accept raw samples.

Christoph

#64 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Sean Young

Absolutely. There are a number of use cases when you want access to the space-pulse (i.e. IR) information.

I think nobody proposes otherwise (except for devices which can't pass this info).

I think we were taking about such devices.

I have no objection that devices that *do* decode the protocol, they should be handled inside kernel.

But devices that send raw pulse/space data should be handled in lirc that will feed the data back to the kernel via uinput.

Best regards,
Maxim Levitsky

#109 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 12 lines
Quoted 12 lines

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

    input_event->type  = EV_IR
    input_event->code  = IR_RC5
    input_event->value =<rc5 value>

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified rc5/rc6/... codes.

Unfortunately with most hardware decoders the code that you get is only remotely related to the actual code sent. Most RC-5 decoders strip off start bits.

I would include only the actual data bits in the payload anyway.

Quoted 2 lines

Toggle-bits are thrown away. NEC decoders usually don't pass through the address part.

Too bad. But information which isn't provided by the hardware can't be passed up anyway, no matter what kernel/userspace interface is used. Gone is gone.

Quoted 1 line

There is no common standard which bit is sent first, LSB or MSB.

Input layer would have to define a bit order. And drivers which get it the other way from the hardware have to convert. Or maybe signal the order and the input core then will convert if needed.

Quoted 1 line

Checksums are thrown away.

Don't include them.

Quoted 2 lines

To sum it up: I don't think this information will be useful at all for lircd or anyone else.

Why not? With RC5 remotes applications can get the device address bits for example, which right now are simply get lost in the ir code -> keycode conversion step.

Quoted 4 lines

Actually lircd does not even know anything about
actual protocols. We only distinguish between certain protocol types, like Manchester encoded, space encoded, pulse encoded etc. Everything else like the actual timing is fully configurable.

I know that lircd does matching instead of decoding, which allows to handle unknown encodings. Thats why I think there will always be cases which only lircd will be able to handle (using raw samples).

That doesn't make attempts to actually decode the IR samples a useless exercise though ;)

cheers,
Gerd

#120 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 9 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

It has been on mine. I have been somewhat against the input subsystem route for unification because it neglects transmitters and appears to trade the userspace complexity we already have (i.e. LIRC configuration) for another new (and hence less documented) configuration complexity for end users.

My strategy for unification goes something like this:

1. Get lirc_dev and the needed supporting headers in the kernel. I will concede LIRC is not perfect or beautiful, but I'll assert it is feature complete for all the end user use cases that matter.

2. Encapsulate all the various IR controller hardware handling in V4L-DVB into v4l_subdevice objects and provide a uniform interface to IR hardware internally via v4l2_subdev_ir_ops. The exact nature of the IR hardware is then mostly abstracted away: I2C bus microcontroller, register block, GPIO line control of discretes devices, etc. can all be accessed in a somewhat unifrom manner.

3. In conjunction with 2, common IR handling routines that exist in various drivers already can be broken out: RC-5 protocol handling, etc.

4. Develop an internal interface so the v4l2_subdev object instance for the IR hardware is exposed through a bridge driver's v4l2_device object.

5. Develop the needed layer between lirc_dev and the v4l2_device object to connect things up.

That unifies all the IR cats and dogs in V4L-DVB at the low levels and glues them in a consistent manner to something up top (i.e. lirc_dev) that already handles Rx, Tx, protocols, keymapping, etc.

My primary desire is to encapsulate or remove the complexity we currently have in kernel with all the ad-hoc IR hardware handling and get it unifrom and layered.

The upper level glue to userspace doesn't have to be lirc_dev, but why not? It's there and the end users are familiair with it. I have set-top boxes, I need IR Tx.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel?

I think all the V4L-DVB IR hardware can be. I have not done sufficient research on the Serial, USB and other devices to say personally.

Quoted 5 lines

And/or, everything could converge on a new in-kernel decoding infra that wasn't badly broken. Sure, there may be two separate ways of doing essentially the same thing for a while, but meh. The lirc way works NOW for an incredibly wide variety of receivers, transmitters, IR protocols, etc.

Also LIRC has had years of requirements collection and refinement of use cases. Anything new implementation will likely end up converging to the feature set LIRC already has implemented.

Quoted 9 lines

I do concur that Just Works decoding for bundled remotes w/o having to configure anything would be nice, and one way to go about doing that certainly is via in-kernel IR decoding. But at the same time, the second you want to use something other than a bundled remote, things fall down, and having to do a bunch of setkeycode ops seems less optimal than simply dropping an appropriate lircd.conf in place.

From a big picture perspective I would never see the OS kenrel as a good

place to address usability issues. It seems more logical to fix usability issues with a decent GUI application and good documentation. (LIRC needs a configuration GUI!). Expecting IR usability problems to be eased by the kernel and command line utilties is - well - optimistic.

I'll add that there are too many factors that can be permuted by the end user and OEM -- protocols, remote layouts, button codes, PC IR Rx/Tx hardware, and Set top boxes feeding PC video capture devices -- that generating defaults that "Just Work" is a generally unsolvable problem.

Regards,
Andy

#118 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 20 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed. I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be, to avoid a regression in functionality. We cannot go from a mode where it worked automatically to a mode where now inexperienced users now have to deal with the guts of getting lircd properly configured.

If such an interface were available, I would see to it that at least all the devices I have added RC support for will continue to work (converting the in-kernel RC profiles to lirc RC profiles as needed and doing the associations with the driver).

Quoted 7 lines

The other key thing I don't think we have given much thought to is the fact that in many tuners, the hardware does RC decoding and just returns NEC/RC5/RC6 codes. And in many of those cases, the hardware has to be configured to know what format to receive. We probably need some kernel API such that the hardware can tell lirc what formats are supported, and another API call to tell the hardware which mode to operate in.

Please think about how we would need to augment the v4l_subdev_ir_ops:

http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/include/media/v4l2-subdev.h#l246
http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/include/media/v4l2-subdev.h#l305
http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/include/media/v4l2-subdev.h#l27

I think encapsulation of the various IR devices under V4L-DVB into v4l_subdevices can facilitate your suggestions.

The CX23888 IR subdevice code configures itself to a single default setup for Tx and Rx:

http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/drivers/media/video/cx23885/cx23888-ir.c#l1192
http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/drivers/media/video/cx23885/cx23888-ir.c#l1211

but there isn't a reason V4L2 IR subdevices couldn't configure to a per "product" defaults based on information about the detected card from the main bridge driver code.

Regards,
Andy

Quoted 5 lines

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

Devin

#121 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls

Am Mittwoch, den 25.11.2009, 22:31 -0500 schrieb Andy Walls:

Quoted 102 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

It has been on mine. I have been somewhat against the input subsystem route for unification because it neglects transmitters and appears to trade the userspace complexity we already have (i.e. LIRC configuration) for another new (and hence less documented) configuration complexity for end users.

My strategy for unification goes something like this:

1. Get lirc_dev and the needed supporting headers in the kernel. I will concede LIRC is not perfect or beautiful, but I'll assert it is feature complete for all the end user use cases that matter.

2. Encapsulate all the various IR controller hardware handling in V4L-DVB into v4l_subdevice objects and provide a uniform interface to IR hardware internally via v4l2_subdev_ir_ops. The exact nature of the IR hardware is then mostly abstracted away: I2C bus microcontroller, register block, GPIO line control of discretes devices, etc. can all be accessed in a somewhat unifrom manner.

3. In conjunction with 2, common IR handling routines that exist in various drivers already can be broken out: RC-5 protocol handling, etc.

4. Develop an internal interface so the v4l2_subdev object instance for the IR hardware is exposed through a bridge driver's v4l2_device object.

5. Develop the needed layer between lirc_dev and the v4l2_device object to connect things up.

That unifies all the IR cats and dogs in V4L-DVB at the low levels and glues them in a consistent manner to something up top (i.e. lirc_dev) that already handles Rx, Tx, protocols, keymapping, etc.

My primary desire is to encapsulate or remove the complexity we currently have in kernel with all the ad-hoc IR hardware handling and get it unifrom and layered.

The upper level glue to userspace doesn't have to be lirc_dev, but why not? It's there and the end users are familiair with it. I have set-top boxes, I need IR Tx.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel?

I think all the V4L-DVB IR hardware can be. I have not done sufficient research on the Serial, USB and other devices to say personally.

Quoted 5 lines

And/or, everything could converge on a new in-kernel decoding infra that wasn't badly broken. Sure, there may be two separate ways of doing essentially the same thing for a while, but meh. The lirc way works NOW for an incredibly wide variety of receivers, transmitters, IR protocols, etc.

Also LIRC has had years of requirements collection and refinement of use cases. Anything new implementation will likely end up converging to the feature set LIRC already has implemented.

Quoted 9 lines

I do concur that Just Works decoding for bundled remotes w/o having to configure anything would be nice, and one way to go about doing that certainly is via in-kernel IR decoding. But at the same time, the second you want to use something other than a bundled remote, things fall down, and having to do a bunch of setkeycode ops seems less optimal than simply dropping an appropriate lircd.conf in place.

From a big picture perspective I would never see the OS kenrel as a good

place to address usability issues. It seems more logical to fix usability issues with a decent GUI application and good documentation. (LIRC needs a configuration GUI!). Expecting IR usability problems to be eased by the kernel and command line utilties is - well - optimistic.

Quoted 9 lines

I'll add that there are too many factors that can be permuted by the end user and OEM -- protocols, remote layouts, button codes, PC IR Rx/Tx hardware, and Set top boxes feeding PC video capture devices -- that generating defaults that "Just Work" is a generally unsolvable problem.

Regards,
Andy

It has something that seemingly can be discussed endlessly.

By all good pros and cons, it takes much too long to see anything forthcoming soon.

To remind, we had eleven 2.6.x test kernels, nothing on lirc came even close to it, and on 2.6.6 some first sign of life again ... IIRC.

Including 2.5.x, how long is that?

By all sympathy, it was a big peace of crap for much too long, simply ignoring the kernel development, and I don't have any tears for it getting dropped that time.

We _need_ to live without it, that is the only reason for the IR input layer in kernel, and not any other way round.

Gerd can of course tell better, but that is how I have it and there was a lot of work because of such lamers not coming by in time then.

Cheers,
Hermann

#113 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 45 lines · Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 9 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

I think at the end of the day we'll want to have all IR drivers use the same interface. The way the current in-kernel input layer drivers work obviously isn't perfect too, so we *must* consider both worlds to get a good solution for long-term ...

Quoted 3 lines

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed.

I bet this simply isn't going to change.

Quoted 4 lines

I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to
automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be,
to avoid a regression in functionality.

*Requiring* lircd for the current in-kernel drivers doesn't make sense at all. Allowing lircd being used so it can do some more advanced stuff makes sense though.

Quoted 4 lines

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

Lets have a look at the problems the current input layer bits have compared to lirc:

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

Quoted 6 lines
   input_event->type  = EV_IR
   input_event->code  = IR_RC5
   input_event->value = <rc5 value>

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

RC-6 Mode 6A can be up to 67 bits:

http://www.picbasic.nl/frameload_uk.htm?http://www.picbasic.nl/rc5-rc6_transceiver_uk.htm

(This page is slightly wrong, there is some data coded in the header such as the RC-6 Mode, but I can't remeber if it's biphase or not.)

Quoted 20 lines

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified

     rc5/rc6/... codes.

* All the ir-code -> keycode mapping magic can be handled by the core input layer then. All the driver needs to do is to pass on the information which keymap should be loaded by default (for the bundled remote if any). The configuration can happen in userspace (sysfs attribute + udev + small utility in tools/ir/).
* lirc drivers which get ir codes from the hardware can be converted to pure input layer drivers without regressions. lircd is not required any more.

(2) input layer doesn't give access to the raw samples.

Not sure how to deal with that best. Passing them through the input layer would certainly be possible to hack up. But what would be the point? The input layer wouldn't do any processing on them. It wouldn't buy us much. So we might want to simply stick with todays lirc interface for the raw samples.

Quoted 8 lines

Drivers which support both ir codes (be it by hardware or by in-kernel decoding) and raw samples would register two devices then, one input device and one lirc device. It would probably a good idea to stop sending events to the input layer as soon as someone (most likely lircd) opens the lirc device to avoid keystrokes showing up twice.

By default the in-kernel bits will be at work, but optionally you can have lircd grab the raw samples and do fancy advanced decoding.

(2a) Input layer doesn't help with raw samples:

So now what about devices that don't produce codes at all, but simply pulse width measurements? Where's the infrastrucutre to perform low pass filtering to get rid of glitches and to perform oversampling to deal with pulse jitter, so that adding a new IR device isn't a pain incurred per driver?

I was quite dismayed at how much I had to reimplement here, just for RC-5 for the sake of the input layer and having a remote "Just Work":

http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/74ad936bcca2/linux/drivers/media/video/cx23885/cx23885-input.c

lirc does all that stuff in spades.

Quoted 6 lines

(3) input layer doesn't allow transmitting IR codes.

If we keep the lirc interface for raw samples anyway, then we can keep it for sending too, problem solved ;) How does sending hardware work btw? Do they all accept just raw samples? Or does some hardware also accept ir-codes?

The Conexant chips' integrated IR Tx hardware expects a series of pulse widths and a flag for mark or space with each width.

I'd have to research other implementations.

Regards,
Andy

Quoted 2 lines

cheers,
Gerd

#126 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 29 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

1) bring drivers in in their current state
- users keep using lirc as they always have

2) add in-kernel decoding infra that feeds input layer

Well. I think the above is fine enough.

Quoted 10 lines

3) add option to use in-kernel decoding to existing lirc drivers
- users can keep using lirc as they always have
- users can optionally try out in-kernel decoding via a modparam

4) switch the default mode from lirc decode to kernel decode for each lirc driver
- modparam can be used to continue using lirc interface instead

5) assuming users aren't coming at us with pitchforks, because things don't actually work reliably with in-kernel decoding, deprecate the lirc interface in driver

6) remove lirc interface from driver, its now a pure input device

But 3-6 are IMHO not useful. We don't need lirc _or_ input. We need both at the same time: input for the general, simple case and for consistency with receivers decoding in firmware/hardware; input for special cases such as mapping the keys, protocols not supported by the kernel and so on (also for in-tree media drivers where applicable).

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight. ;)

I think: in-kernel decoding only as the general, primary means. Not the only one.

Okay, I read ya now. I got my wires crossed, thought you were advocating for dropping the lirc interface entirely. I think we're on the same page then. :)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
maintainer
#51 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

Curreently the "scan" codes in the input layer serve just to help users to map whatever the device emits into a proper input event code so that the rest of userspace would not have to care and would work with all types of devices (USB, PS/2, etc).

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

I would not want to get to the point where the raw codes are used as a primary data source.

The "key" interface is not flexible enough at present.

In what way the key interface is unsufficient for delivering button events?

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#70 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 11 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 10 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

Right, but still the keys usually do have the well-defined meaning, teh issue is in mapping raw code to the appropriate keycode. This can be done either by lirc config file (when lirc is used) or by some other means.

Quoted 18 lines

...

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code<> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

Quoted 6 lines

I think if the data is used to do the primary protocol decoding then it should be a separate interface that is processed by someone and then fed into input subsystem (either in-kernel or through uinput).

Again, I would prefer to keep EV_KEY/KEY_* as the primary event type for keys and buttons on all devices.

Quoted 6 lines

Current lircd actually inter-operates with the input subsystem quite well for any and all supported remotes if their keys are mapped in their respective lircd.conf file using standard input subsystem key names, and the lirc daemon started with the --uinput param. lircd decodes the raw IR, finds the mapping in its config, and happily passes it along to uinput.

Right.

I guess the question is what is the interface we want the regular userspace (i.e. not lircd) to use. Right now programs has to use 2 intercfaces - one lirc for dealing with remotes that are not using the standard event interface and evdev for remotes using it as well as the rest of the input devices.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#69 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Maxim Levitsky
Quoted 2 lines · Maxim Levitsky

Folks, I really want to tell everyone that doing all the mapping from raw codes to keypresses in kernel is wrong.

Why is this wrong? Doing simple translation is easy and it does not require having all the tables for all possible remotes in the kernel. We have appropriate interfaces to load keymaps at runtime (for the devices whose drivers support this feature).

Quoted 4 lines

This idea keeps showing up, because many users think that remotes send some universal codes that you can just 'parse' and feed back to input system.

Well, they send some data that can be parsed and thus fed to whatever we want to feed it.

Quoted 10 lines

Its not the case.
There are many protocols, I know that by experimenting with my universal remote. There are many receivers, and all have different accuracy. Most remotes aren't designed to be used with PC, thus user has to invent mapping between buttons and actions.
Its is not possible to identify remotes accurately, many remotes send just a 8 bit integer that specifies the 'model' thus many remotes can share it.
Some don't send anything.

Quoted 5 lines

There are some weird remotes that send whole packet of data will all kind of states.

Think about it, video capture device is also an input device, a scanner is an input device too, sound card can work as input device too.

You are stretching. There are no button presses involved with sound (not unless you go all the way down to keys on a piano ;) )

Quoted 7 lines

But we aren't doing any parsing, even we don't support deflating of many proprietary and standard video/image encoding formats.
We let userspace do it.

Kernel job is to take the information from device and present it to userspace using uniform format, that is kernel does 1:1 translating, but doesn't parse the data.

Should we return to the times where we had raw PS/2 data streams sent to userspace, separately from HID and other formats? I don't think it is a good idea.

Quoted 8 lines

Uniform format doesn't mean kernel always converts to one format, its not like sound card always recording in 32 bit 96000 Khz format, even if underlying device doesn't support that.

So, device that decode IR code are presented to userspace as pure input devices. I agree that creating fake raw codes from that is bad.

Quoted 10 lines

But devices that send raw data pass it to lirc.
lirc is well capable to decode it, and its not hard to add auto-detection based on existing configuration drivers, so IR devices will work with absolutely no configuration.
All you will have to do is ensure that lirc is installed. Then udev can even start it automatically.
Then as soon as you press a key, lirc can scan its config database, and find a config file to use. combine that with a GUI for unknown remotes and you get an awesome usability.

Why can't the same be done in kernalspace though?

Quoted 6 lines

Also don't forget that there are pure userspace drivers. They won't have access to in-kernel decoder so they will still have to parse protocols, so will have code duplication, and will still need lirc thus.

So why to burden the kernel with protocols, etc..

We do burden it with TCP, shall we take it out?

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#122 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 25 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

It has been on mine. I have been somewhat against the input subsystem route for unification because it neglects transmitters and appears to trade the userspace complexity we already have (i.e. LIRC configuration) for another new (and hence less documented) configuration complexity for end users.

Quoted 5 lines

My strategy for unification goes something like this:

1. Get lirc_dev and the needed supporting headers in the kernel. I will concede LIRC is not perfect or beautiful, but I'll assert it is feature complete for all the end user use cases that matter.

So... What I'd like to propose is that I address Mauro's review comments for my v2 patchset, and resubmit a v3 patchset. If there are no show-stoppers, lets get the thing merged. If people don't want to use it, they don't have to, I won't be offended. But it seems there are quite a few people that would be incredibly happy to see this finally get in. There are definitely worse things that could be merged. :)

And from what I've been able to surmise, the input layer would need so much new functionality to handle both raw IR output and IR transmit, that we'd simply be reinventing a hefty chunk of the lirc device interface under the guise of being an input device, to be used *only* by things that can already simply use the existing feature-complete lirc device interface, which seems... wasteful.

Quoted 9 lines

2. Encapsulate all the various IR controller hardware handling in V4L-DVB into v4l_subdevice objects and provide a uniform interface to IR hardware internally via v4l2_subdev_ir_ops. The exact nature of the IR hardware is then mostly abstracted away: I2C bus microcontroller, register block, GPIO line control of discretes devices, etc. can all be accessed in a somewhat unifrom manner.

3. In conjunction with 2, common IR handling routines that exist in various drivers already can be broken out: RC-5 protocol handling, etc.

Once 1 happens, I'd be happy to work on adding code to currently pure lirc device drivers (like lirc_mceusb) to do in-kernel decoding for their bundled remotes. The vague plan in my head (shamelessly heisted from someone else in this thread, can't remember who atm) involves each lirc device registering two devices, one input device and one lirc device. Out of the box, without lircd, they would operate as a pure input device with their bundled remote -- out-of-the-box bliss. Once lircd opened the device's lirc device, we'd stop sending input data, and feed data out via the lirc interface.

This hybrid approach gives those who want nothing to do with lircd and the lirc device interface what they want (hell, drivers might even be buildable w/o the lirc portion even enabled), and those that want more flexibility can use either/or.

Quoted 11 lines

4. Develop an internal interface so the v4l2_subdev object instance for the IR hardware is exposed through a bridge driver's v4l2_device object.

5. Develop the needed layer between lirc_dev and the v4l2_device object to connect things up.

That unifies all the IR cats and dogs in V4L-DVB at the low levels and glues them in a consistent manner to something up top (i.e. lirc_dev) that already handles Rx, Tx, protocols, keymapping, etc.

Quoted 7 lines

My primary desire is to encapsulate or remove the complexity we currently have in kernel with all the ad-hoc IR hardware handling and get it unifrom and layered.

The upper level glue to userspace doesn't have to be lirc_dev, but why not? It's there and the end users are familiair with it. I have set-top boxes, I need IR Tx.

Yup, me too. :)

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel?

I think all the V4L-DVB IR hardware can be. I have not done sufficient research on the Serial, USB and other devices to say personally.

Which serial and/or usb devices other than those already supported by lirc drivers did you have in mind? Damn near all the serial and usb IR devices I know of are already supported by either another lirc kernel driver I have laying in wait, or by a userspace driver (typically interfacing w/a usb receiver using libusb).

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines

And/or, everything could converge on a new in-kernel decoding infra that wasn't badly broken. Sure, there may be two separate ways of doing essentially the same thing for a while, but meh. The lirc way works NOW for an incredibly wide variety of receivers, transmitters, IR protocols, etc.

Also LIRC has had years of requirements collection and refinement of use cases. Anything new implementation will likely end up converging to the feature set LIRC already has implemented.

Yep, I suspect as much myself. The only major feature I'm aware of that lirc hasn't already implemented is zero-config, works-out-of-the-box, really.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines

I do concur that Just Works decoding for bundled remotes w/o having to configure anything would be nice, and one way to go about doing that certainly is via in-kernel IR decoding. But at the same time, the second you want to use something other than a bundled remote, things fall down, and having to do a bunch of setkeycode ops seems less optimal than simply dropping an appropriate lircd.conf in place.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line

From a big picture perspective I would never see the OS kenrel as a good

place to address usability issues. It seems more logical to fix usability issues with a decent GUI application and good documentation. (LIRC needs a configuration GUI!).

gnome-lirc-properties attempts to be that, but needs a lot more love, and isn't actually part of the lirc userspace source, its maintained by some gnome folks on freedesktop.org, iirc...

Quoted 8 lines

Expecting IR usability problems to
be eased by the kernel and command line utilties is - well - optimistic.

I'll add that there are too many factors that can be permuted by the end user and OEM -- protocols, remote layouts, button codes, PC IR Rx/Tx hardware, and Set top boxes feeding PC video capture devices -- that generating defaults that "Just Work" is a generally unsolvable problem.

Agreed. *Especially* with IR TX in the mix, which a LOT of DVR users rely heavily upon -- we have no way of divining what the hell IR codes a random set top box needs. And the bulk of bundled remotes we can make Just Work are flimsy, crappy, cheap plastic pieces of junk. No self-respecting HTPC user actually uses any of those things. ;)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
maintainer
#67 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Trent Piepho
Quoted 7 lines · Trent Piepho

One thing that could be done, unless it has changed much since I wrote it 10+ years ago, is to take the mark/space protocol the ir device uses and sent that data to lircd via the input layer. It would be less efficient, but would avoid another kernel interface. Of course the input layer to lircd interface would be somewhat different than other input devices, so it's not entirely correct to say another interface is avoided.

No, it would still be completely new interface that just happened to use input layer as transport. An ordinary program that would just want to react to play. pause, forward, etc buttons would have no idea what to do with the data so you'd still need a very specialized library to deal with the data.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#176 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 23 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Czesc Krzysztof,

on 23 Nov 09 at 15:14, Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
[...]

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I agree with Christoph.

Is it that the input subsystem is better developed and seen as a leverage point for development and thus an "easier" place to get results earlier? If so, then one should definitely deal with transmitters early in the design, as that is where the most unknowns lie.

With the end of analog TV, people will have STBs feeding analog only video cards. Being able to change the channel on the STB with an IR transmitter controlled by applications like MythTV is essential.

Quoted 8 lines

And on some different notes:

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Is it that LIRC supports MythTV and mplayer or MythTV and mplayer are forced to support lirc because the remores are not available through other means? I believe it is the latter and applications writers would be happy to reduce number of ways they get button data.

I don't think there is LIRC aversion per se. We are just trying to decide whether multiple interfaces for the same data is needed. And I don't think that we will completely reject userspace components. Just as input subsystem allows for userspace drivers I do not think why we can't have the same for the LIRC. But I do think that the primary interface for regular userspace consumers (read mplayer and MythTV and the likes) should be input event interface (EV_KEY/KEY_*).

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#102 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Jarod Wilson

Well, we've got a number of IOCTLs already, could extend those. (Although its been suggested elsewhere that we replace the IOCTLs with sysfs knobs).

Not sure if sysfs would be fast enough.

Why would sysfs write be slower than ioctl?

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#71 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 12 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 11 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 10 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

Right, but still the keys usually do have the well-defined meaning,

Except when they don't. I have two very similar remotes, one that was bundled with a system from CaptiveWorks, and one that was bundled with an Antec Veris IR/LCD (SoundGraph iMON rebrand). Outside of the Antec remote having a mouse pad instead of up/down/left/right/enter, they have an identical layout, and the keys in the same locations on the remotes send the same IR signal. But the button names vary a LOT between the two. So on the DVD key on the Antec and the MUTE key on the CW send the same signal. Same with Audio vs. Eject, TV vs. History, etc. Moral of the story is that not all IR protocols spell things out particularly well for what a given code should actually mean.

Quoted 4 lines

teh
issue is in mapping raw code to the appropriate keycode. This can be done either by lirc config file (when lirc is used) or by some other means.

The desire to map a button press to multiple keystrokes isn't uncommon either, though I presume that's doable within the input layer context too.

Quoted 27 lines
Quoted 18 lines

...

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines

We need to handle more than one RC at a time, of course.

Quoted 2 lines

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space

I think so, doing the RCx proto handling in the kernel (but without RCx raw code<> key mapping in this case due to multiple controllers etc.). Though it could probably use the input layer as well(?).

Quoted 6 lines

I think if the data is used to do the primary protocol decoding then it should be a separate interface that is processed by someone and then fed into input subsystem (either in-kernel or through uinput).

Again, I would prefer to keep EV_KEY/KEY_* as the primary event type for keys and buttons on all devices.

Quoted 6 lines

Current lircd actually inter-operates with the input subsystem quite well for any and all supported remotes if their keys are mapped in their respective lircd.conf file using standard input subsystem key names, and the lirc daemon started with the --uinput param. lircd decodes the raw IR, finds the mapping in its config, and happily passes it along to uinput.

Right.

Quoted 7 lines

I guess the question is what is the interface we want the regular userspace (i.e. not lircd) to use. Right now programs has to use 2 intercfaces - one lirc for dealing with remotes that are not using the standard event interface and evdev for remotes using it as well as the rest of the input devices.

From the mythtv perspective, using the input layer could yield a better out-of-the-box experience -- users don't have to set up an lircrc mapping that converts key names as specified in lircd.conf into commands (key strokes, actually) that mythtv understands. For example, a button labeled "Play" in lircd.conf has to be mapped to 'p' in ~/.lircrc for mythtv to do the right thing with it. If everything came through the input layer, be that natively or via lircd's uinput reinjection, there would be no need to do that extra mapping step, mythtv would simply handle a KEY_PLAY event. So at worst, one manual mapping to do -- IR signal to standard button name in lircd.conf -- instead of two. But the lircrc approach does also allow more flexibility, in that you can only have a certain app respond t

o a certain key, if so desired, and remap a key to a different function (KEY_RED, KEY_GREEN, KEY_BLUE, KEY_YELLOW -- what should their default functionality be? I know some users map a pair of those to mythtv's "skip to next commflag point" and "skip to prior commflag point").

Unfortunately, mythtv currently doesn't handle KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, etc., etc. at all right now, it operates purely on keys commonly found on a standard keyboard. Remedying that is on my TODO list for the next release, if I can carve out the time.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#177 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 33 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 23 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Czesc Krzysztof,

on 23 Nov 09 at 15:14, Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
[...]

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I agree with Christoph.

Is it that the input subsystem is better developed and seen as a leverage point for development and thus an "easier" place to get results earlier? If so, then one should definitely deal with transmitters early in the design, as that is where the most unknowns lie.

With the end of analog TV, people will have STBs feeding analog only video cards. Being able to change the channel on the STB with an IR transmitter controlled by applications like MythTV is essential.

Quoted 8 lines

And on some different notes:

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Quoted 4 lines

Is it that LIRC supports MythTV and mplayer or MythTV and mplayer are forced to support lirc because the remores are not available through other means? I believe it is the latter and applications writers would be happy to reduce number of ways they get button data.

Well, when mythtv was started, I don't know that there were many input layer remotes around... lirc was definitely around though. serial receivers and transmitters, both supported by lirc_serial, were the most frequently used devices outside of plain old keyboards. The lirc support in mythtv actually relies on mapping remote button names as defined in lircd.conf to keyboard key strokes. As mentioned elsewhere in this beast of a thread, mythtv doesn't currently support things like KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, KEY_CHANNELUP, etc. just yet, but I intend on fixing that...

Quoted 7 lines

I don't think there is LIRC aversion per se. We are just trying to decide whether multiple interfaces for the same data is needed. And I don't think that we will completely reject userspace components. Just as input subsystem allows for userspace drivers I do not think why we can't have the same for the LIRC. But I do think that the primary interface for regular userspace consumers (read mplayer and MythTV and the likes) should be input event interface (EV_KEY/KEY_*).

Works for me.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#110 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann

Hi Gerd,

on 26 Nov 09 at 00:22, Gerd Hoffmann wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

To sum it up: I don't think this information will be useful at all for lircd or anyone else.

[...]

Quoted 6 lines

I know that lircd does matching instead of decoding, which allows to handle unknown encodings. Thats why I think there will always be cases which only lircd will be able to handle (using raw samples).

That doesn't make attempts to actually decode the IR samples a useless exercise though ;)

Well, in my opinion it is kind of useless. I don't see any use case or any demand for passing this kind of information to userspace, at least in the LIRC context.
If there's no demand, why bother?

Christoph

#127 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson

Hi,

on 25 Nov 09 at 12:44, Jarod Wilson wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

[...]

Quoted 2 lines

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight.

I'm happy to see that the discussion is getting along.
But I'm still a bit hesitant about the in-kernel decoding. Maybe it's just because I'm not familiar at all with input layer toolset.

1. For sure in-kernel decoding will require some assistance from userspace to load the mapping from IR codes to keys. So, if there needs to be a tool in userspace that does some kind of autodetection, why not have a tool that does some autodetection and autoconfigures lircd for the current device. Lots of code duplication in kernel saved. What's the actual benefit of in-kernel decoding?

2. What would be the format of the key map? lircd.conf files already exist for a lot of remote controls. Will we have a second incompatible format to map the keys in-kernel? Where are the tools that create the key maps for new remotes?

Maybe someone can shed some light on this.

Christoph

maintainer
#128 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 14 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi,

on 25 Nov 09 at 12:44, Jarod Wilson wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

[...]

Quoted 2 lines

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight.

I'm happy to see that the discussion is getting along.
But I'm still a bit hesitant about the in-kernel decoding. Maybe it's just because I'm not familiar at all with input layer toolset.

Quoted 6 lines

1. For sure in-kernel decoding will require some assistance from userspace to load the mapping from IR codes to keys. So, if there needs to be a tool in userspace that does some kind of autodetection, why not have a tool that does some autodetection and autoconfigures lircd for the current device. Lots of code duplication in kernel saved. What's the actual benefit of in-kernel decoding?

Why are you mixing configuration and decoding? Configuration I expect will be done with the help of userspace. Udev is probably the best place.

Quoted 6 lines

2. What would be the format of the key map? lircd.conf files already exist for a lot of remote controls. Will we have a second incompatible format to map the keys in-kernel? Where are the tools that create the key maps for new remotes?

Same as the keymaps for the other input devices I'd expect.

Quoted 3 lines

Maybe someone can shed some light on this.

Christoph

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#111 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 11 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi Gerd,

on 26 Nov 09 at 00:22, Gerd Hoffmann wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

To sum it up: I don't think this information will be useful at all for lircd or anyone else.

[...]

Quoted 4 lines

I know that lircd does matching instead of decoding, which allows to handle unknown encodings. Thats why I think there will always be cases which only lircd will be able to handle (using raw samples).

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

That doesn't make attempts to actually decode the IR samples a useless exercise though ;)

Well, in my opinion it is kind of useless. I don't see any use case or any demand for passing this kind of information to userspace, at least in the LIRC context.
If there's no demand, why bother?

There have been complains about this getting lost somewhere in this thread, so it looks like there are people which do care.

cheers,
Gerd

#178 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 2 lines · Jarod Wilson

Well, when mythtv was started, I don't know that there were many input layer remotes around... lirc was definitely around though.

lirc predates the input layer IR drivers by years, maybe even the input layer itself.

The main reason for the input layer IR drivers appearing was lirc not being mainline. A in-kernel driver (bttv in that case) which depends on a out-of-tree subsystem for IR support was simply a pain in the ass for both maintainer (/me back then) and users.

At least for IR hardware which allows access to the raw samples it certainly makes sense to support lirc, additional to the current (or improved) input layer support.

Quoted 5 lines

The lirc support in mythtv actually relies on mapping remote button names as defined in lircd.conf to keyboard key strokes. As mentioned elsewhere in this beast of a thread, mythtv doesn't currently support things like KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, KEY_CHANNELUP, etc. just yet, but I intend on fixing that...

lircd can handle the input layer as input as well, so you actually can remap things via lircd even for pure input layer drivers. mythtv handling KEY_VOLUMEUP directly would be more elegant though.

cheers,
Gerd

#15 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 14 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 3 lines

(This is no recommendation for lirc. I have no idea whether a pulse/space -> scancode -> keycode translation would be practical there.)

It would, but not exactly in the present shape.

Quoted 5 lines

For example, there are several bttv and saa7134 devices that polls (or receive IRQ interrupts) to detect pulses (and the absense of them) in order to create a pulse/space code. The conversion from pulse/space to scancode is done inside the driver, with the help of some generic routines and based on the protocol specifications.

Quoted 7 lines

Right. There are currently several problems (I'm quite familiar with saa713x RC5 code): the one that it barely works and is not implemented for most such "GPIO/IRQ-driven" cards (as of 2.6.29 or so). This could be fixed, I even have a working though quick&dirty patch. Another: the RC5 allows for groups and codes within groups. The mapping can only use one group, and there can only be one mapping. These design limitations mean it's unusable in many cases.

This is a current limitation, since the saa713x code converts the RC5 code into a 7bits scancode, by applying a mask. One of the reasons for that conversion is that the two ioctls that allows reading/changing the keycode table (EVIOCSKEYCODE and EVIOCGKEYCODE) were implemented via a table with a fixed size of 128 entries.

We already have an implementation at the dvb-usb driver that uses a table without such limits, where the IR scancode is completely stored there. So, you can create any arbitrary scancode <--> keycode table there.

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

Maybe one alternative would be to add a modprobe parameter at the converted drivers to allow them to work with the old behavior, after their migration.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Those devices where the decoding is done by software can support any IR protocols.

Yes, and there can be multiple remote controllers, and multiple code groups within a remote.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

This can be solved by adding a few ioctls to enumerate the supported protocols and to select the one(s) that will be handled by the kernel driver.

The driver may have to handle many protocols simultaneously. This is not a problem from a technical POV.

There are 3 different situations:
1) hardware where you can support multiple protocols at the same time;
2) hardware that supports one programmable protocol;
3) hardware that support just one (or a limited set) of protocols.

In general, (1) applies only to those devices that outputs a raw pulse/space code, where they just connect the IR sensor to a generic I/O pin and let the software to decode the code. This is the case of most of cheapest devices. Yet, you can find some cheap devices with low-cost micro-controllers with a dedicated firmware on its ROM, doing (2).

The most commonly found hardware, in general have a chip to decode IR pulse/space sequences, converting it on a scancode and implementing (3).

That's said, a raw input interface, only fits on case (1). On the other hand, the existing input API works for all types of IR. However, we need to add the ioctls to allow protocol selection, to better handle (1) and (3).

Cheers,
Mauro.

#180 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 50 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 33 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 23 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Czesc Krzysztof,

on 23 Nov 09 at 15:14, Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
[...]

Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I agree with Christoph.

Is it that the input subsystem is better developed and seen as a leverage point for development and thus an "easier" place to get results earlier? If so, then one should definitely deal with transmitters early in the design, as that is where the most unknowns lie.

With the end of analog TV, people will have STBs feeding analog only video cards. Being able to change the channel on the STB with an IR transmitter controlled by applications like MythTV is essential.

Quoted 8 lines

And on some different notes:

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Quoted 4 lines

Is it that LIRC supports MythTV and mplayer or MythTV and mplayer are forced to support lirc because the remores are not available through other means? I believe it is the latter and applications writers would be happy to reduce number of ways they get button data.

Well, when mythtv was started, I don't know that there were many input layer remotes around... lirc was definitely around though. serial receivers and transmitters, both supported by lirc_serial, were the most frequently used devices outside of plain old keyboards. The lirc support in mythtv actually relies on mapping remote button names as defined in lircd.conf to keyboard key strokes. As mentioned elsewhere in this beast of a thread, mythtv doesn't currently support things like KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, KEY_CHANNELUP, etc. just yet, but I intend on fixing that...

Quoted 7 lines

I don't think there is LIRC aversion per se. We are just trying to decide whether multiple interfaces for the same data is needed. And I don't think that we will completely reject userspace components. Just as input subsystem allows for userspace drivers I do not think why we can't have the same for the LIRC. But I do think that the primary interface for regular userspace consumers (read mplayer and MythTV and the likes) should be input event interface (EV_KEY/KEY_*).

Quoted 1 line

Works for me.

Even though two interfaces is a bit of "extra" work, I'm not averse to Gerd's suggestions of a dual implementation: input layer for the simple, common use case, and lirc type interface for more sophisticated usage.

One thing I would like to be provided by the input layer is automatic key-up after a specified time. Remote protocols send an initial button press and then after a certain amount of time (~115 ms for RC-5) send a repeated code or repeat sequence, if the button is still pressed. Currently, most of the V4L-DVB drivers have some code to perform a timeout just to send the key-up event. That's a good bit of redundant code for key-up timeouts that I suspect makes sense for the input layer to handle.

Regards,
Andy

#29 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

If you see patch 3/3, of the lirc submission series, you'll notice a driver that has hardware decoding, but, due to lirc interface, the driver generates pseudo pulse/space code for it to work via lirc interface.

IOW the driver generates artificial pulse code for lircd? I think - pure bloat. lircd can get events from input layer without problems. Perhaps I misunderstood?

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

It is very bad to have two interfaces for the same thing, because people may do things like that.

I think having a "raw" scan code interface + the key code "cooked" mode is beneficial. For remotes lacking the raw interface only the latter could be used.

It sounds an interesting idea.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Are you meaning that we should do more than one RC per input event interface?

I think so. Why not?

For example, one of my remotes generates codes from at least two RC5 groups (in only one "mode"). Currently a remote is limited to only one RC5 group.

Yet, both are RC5. This can already be handled by the input layer. See dvb-usb implementation.

The issue I see is to support at the same time NEC and RC5 protocols. While this may work with some devices, for others, the hardware won't allow.

Quoted 3 lines

I think the mapping should be: key = proto + group + raw code, while key2 could be different_proto + different group (if any) + another code.

This may work for protocols up to RC5, that uses either 8 or 16 bits. However, RC6 mode 6 codes can be 32 bits, and we have "only" 32 bits for a scancode. So, we don't have spare bits to represent a protocol, if we consider RC6 mode 6 codes as well.

Quoted 12 lines
Quoted 2 lines

If so, why do you think we need to handle more than one IR protocol at the same time?

Why not?
There are X-in-1 remotes on the market for years. They can "speak" many protocols at once. One may want to have a protocol to handle DVD apps while another for DVB etc.
And someone may want to use several different remotes, why not? Personally I use two different remotes (both set to speak RC5 but what if I couldn't set the protocol?). Sure, it requires a bit of hackery (not with pulse code and lircd).

Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line

I think this will just make the driver more complex without need.

Not much more, and there is a need.

See above. Also, several protocols have a way to check if a keystroke were properly received. When handling just one protocol, we can use this to double check the key. However, on a multiprotocol mode, we'll need to disable this feature.

PS.: For those following those discussions that want to know more about IR protocols, a good reference is at:
http://www.sbprojects.com/knowledge/ir/ir.htm

Unfortunately, it doesn't describe RC6 mode 6.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#181 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 5 lines · Andy Walls

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception).

Regards,
Andy "LIRC Fan-Boy" Walls

This is not a lirc love or hate thread. We're simply discussing the better API's for IR, from the technical standpoint, considering that some users may want to use lirc and some users may want to have their IR working out-of-the-box.

By not using lirc, users will loose the advantages of having lircd, like clicking on a button and calling automatically the DVD player application, but this means that their device with the shipped IR will work without needing to do any setup.

Whatever we do, both kind of usages should be possible, since there are demand for both.

Also, the decision should consider that the existing drivers will need to support the new way without causing regressions.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#30 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 1 line · Krzysztof Halasa

Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> writes:

PS.: For those following those discussions that want to know more about IR protocols, a good reference is at:
http://www.sbprojects.com/knowledge/ir/ir.htm

Unfortunately, it doesn't describe RC6 mode 6.

RC-6 Mode 0 and Mode 6A is briefly describe here:

http://www.picbasic.nl/frameload_uk.htm?http://www.picbasic.nl/rc5-rc6_transceiver_uk.htm

That page is slightly wrong, as there is some data coded in the header such as the RC-6 Mode.

This page is an older version of the sbprojects.com RC-6 page, before the information on RC-6 Mode 6A was removed:

http://slycontrol.ru/scr/kb/rc6.htm

My personal opinion is that, for non-technical reasons, RC-6 Mode 6A decoding should not be included in the kernel. That's why I didn't do it for the HVR-1850/CX23888.

Regards,
Andy

#90 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 19 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 10 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:
Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I don't say don't use a transmitter.
I say the transmitter is not an input device, they are completely independent functions. I can't see any reason to try and fit both in the same interface - can you?

The underlying hardware need not be completely independent.

For example, the CX2584[0123], CX2388[578], CX23418, and CX2310[012] chips have IR hardware that shares a common timing source, interrupt line, interrupt status register, etc, between IR Rx and Tx. They can also do things like loopback of Tx to Rx.

Quoted 5 lines

That said, an underlying hardware implementation can be split up to user space with separate interfaces Tx and Rx. The underlying driver module would have to manage the dependencies. I would guess that would be easier for driver modules, if the userspace interfaces were designed with such combined IR Tx/Rx hardware in mind.

True, but, in the case of Rx, there are already API's for it. Tx case is simpler, as we don't have any API for it yet.

I'm not sure if all the existing hardware for TX currently supports only raw pulse/code sequencies, but I still think that, even on the Tx case, it is better to send scancodes to the driver, and let it do the conversion to raw pulse/code, if the hardware requires pulse/code instead of scancodes.

However, as we have green field,
I would add the protocol explicitly for each scancode to be transmitted, like:

struct ir_tx {
	enum ir_protocol proto;
	u32 scancode;
};

Eventually, we might have a protocol "raw" and some extra field to allow passing a raw pulse/code sequence instead of a scancode.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#91 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 26 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 19 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 10 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:
Quoted 1 line

I think we shouldn't at this time worry about IR transmitters.

Sorry, but I have to disagree strongly.
Any interface without transmitter support would be absolutely unacceptable for many LIRC users, including myself.

I don't say don't use a transmitter.
I say the transmitter is not an input device, they are completely independent functions. I can't see any reason to try and fit both in the same interface - can you?

The underlying hardware need not be completely independent.

For example, the CX2584[0123], CX2388[578], CX23418, and CX2310[012] chips have IR hardware that shares a common timing source, interrupt line, interrupt status register, etc, between IR Rx and Tx. They can also do things like loopback of Tx to Rx.

Quoted 5 lines

That said, an underlying hardware implementation can be split up to user space with separate interfaces Tx and Rx. The underlying driver module would have to manage the dependencies. I would guess that would be easier for driver modules, if the userspace interfaces were designed with such combined IR Tx/Rx hardware in mind.

Quoted 7 lines

True, but, in the case of Rx, there are already API's for it. Tx case is simpler, as we don't have any API for it yet.

I'm not sure if all the existing hardware for TX currently supports only raw pulse/code sequencies, but I still think that, even on the Tx case, it is better to send scancodes to the driver, and let it do the conversion to raw pulse/code, if the hardware requires pulse/code instead of scancodes.

That seems like a decision which will create a lots of duplicative code in the kernel. Add it's just busy-work to write such code when a userspace application in common use already handles the protocols and sends raw pulses to hardware that expects raw pulses.

Quoted 10 lines

However, as we have green field,
I would add the protocol explicitly for each scancode to be transmitted, like:

struct ir_tx {
	enum ir_protocol proto;
	u32 scancode;
};

Eventually, we might have a protocol "raw" and some extra field to allow passing a raw pulse/code sequence instead of a scancode.

I think you would have to. 32 bits is really not enough for all protocols, and it is already partial encoding of information anyway.

If the Tx driver has to break them down into pulses anyway, why not have fields with more meaningful names

mode
toggle
customer code (or system code or address), information (or command)

According to

	http://slycontrol.ru/scr/kb/rc6.htm

the "information" field could be up to 128 bits.

(Not that I'm going to put any RC-6 Mode 6A decoding/encoding in the kernel.)

Regards,
Andy

Quoted 2 lines

Cheers,
Mauro.

#135 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 11 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-11-23 at 22:11 +0100, Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

...

Quoted 6 lines

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Quoted 5 lines

There's one gripe I agree with, and that is that its still not plug-n-play. Something where udev auto-loads a sane default remote config for say, mceusb transceivers, and the stock mce remote Just Works would be nice, but auto-config is mostly out the window the second you involve transmitters and universal remotes anyway.

For several devices, an udev rule that auto-loads a sane default keymap does work. Of course, this won't cover 100% of the usages, and I lirc is a very good way of covering the holes.

Quoted 3 lines

But outside of that, I think objections are largely philosophical -- in a nutshell, the kernel has an input layer, remotes are input devices, and lirc doesn't conform to input layer standards.

Yes. I think this is mainly the issue.

The other issue is how to migrate the existing drivers to a new API without causing regressions. If we decide that IR's that receive raw pulse/code should use the raw input interface, this means that a large task force will be needed to convert the existing drivers to use it.

Quoted 3 lines

I do understand that argument, I just don't currently agree that all IR must go through the input layer before the drivers are acceptable for upstream -- especially since lircd can reinject decoded key presses into the input layer via uinput.

IMHO, there are some scenarios for an upcoming kernel IR raw input interface:

1) as a temporary solution for merging lirc drivers, knowing in advance that it will be later converted to the standard input API;

2) as a raw interface for some weird usages, with its usage limited to just a few device drivers;

3) as the solution for all IR's that produces pulse/code raw sequences;

For (1), while it may make sense, we'll be creating an userspace API that is meant to be stable, knowing in advance that it will be removed in a close future.

IMHO, we should avoid (2), since it will be hard to define what is the "limited usage", and I bet that it will evolute to (3) in a long term.

For (3), we need to consider the migration of the existing drivers.

By discarding scenario (2), this means that, in the long term, we'll need to either migrate all existing out-of-tree lirc drivers to the standard input API interface (scenario 1) or to migrate the existing drivers to the raw input interface (scenario 3).

For me, scenario (1) is fine if we add the lirc drivers at drivers/staging.

Quoted 16 lines
Quoted 5 lines

I believe Jarod's intent is to have the LIRC components, that need to be in kernel modules, moved into kernel mainline to avoid the headaches of out of kernel driver maintenance. I'm not sure it is time well spent for developers, or end users, to develop yet another IR receive implementation in addition to the ones we suffer with now.

Yeah, a fairly relevant factor in all this is that, despite not being in the linux kernel source tree proper-like, the lirc drivers and lirc have been in use for many years by lots of users. The likes of Fedora, Debian, Ubuntu, SUSE, Mandriva, etc. have all been shipping lirc drivers for years now. While lirc certainly isn't perfect (its not always the easiest thing for users to set up), it has actually proven itself pretty robust and useful in the field, once set up. The bulk of breakage in lirc I've personally had to deal with has mostly come in the form of kernel interface changes, which would definitely be mitigated by not having to maintain the drivers out-of-tree any longer.

Quoted 11 lines

Now, I'm all for "improving" things and integrating better with the input subsystem, but what I don't really want to do is break compatibility with the existing setups on thousands (and thousands?) of MythTV boxes around the globe. The lirc userspace can be pretty nimble. If we can come up with a shiny new way that raw IR can be passed out through an input device, I'm pretty sure lirc userspace can be adapted to handle that. If a new input-layer-based transmit interface is developed, we can take advantage of that too. But there's already a very mature lirc interface for doing all of this. So why not start with adding things more or less as they exist right now and evolve the drivers into an idealized form? Getting *something* into the kernel in the first place is a huge step in that direction.

I agree. We should really move forward and add it to kernel as soon as possible, and start to work on improving the IR support at the upstream kernel.

Jarold,

What do you think of adding lirc at staging while we discuss/improve the API's and lircd support for the input event interface? Do you think this would work?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#141 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices. If it is just a new keytable, this issue could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#123 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 8 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 6 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · [email protected] (Christoph Bartelmus) writes:

I'm not sure what two ways you are talking about. With the patches posted by Jarod, nothing has to be changed in userspace.
Everything works, no code needs to be written and tested, everybody is happy.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The existing drivers use input layer. Do you want part of the tree to use existing lirc interface while the other part uses their own in-kernel (badly broken for example) code to do precisely the same thing?

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

They are not limited to the currently bundled IR's, since almost all drivers allow replacing the existing scancode/keycode table to a new onw.

Quoted 1 line

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

It should be done. Having two ways for doing the same thing is not an option. We'll need to unify them sooner or later. The sooner, the better.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 4 lines

We can have a good code for both, or we can end up with "badly broken" media drivers and incompatible, suboptimal existing lirc interface (though most probably much better in terms of quality, especially after Jarod's work).

Well, is there any reason most of those drivers with currently-in-kernel-but-badly-broken decoding can't be converted to use the lirc interface if its merged into the kernel?

Quoted 5 lines

And/or, everything
could converge on a new in-kernel decoding infra that wasn't badly broken. Sure, there may be two separate ways of doing essentially the same thing for a while, but meh. The lirc way works NOW for an incredibly wide variety of receivers, transmitters, IR protocols, etc.

Yes: the same drivers support both pulse/space and in-hardware scancode conversion. In order to use the raw pulse/space API, they'll need to generate pseudo pulse/space's. This would be a dirty solution, IMHO.

Also, changing the drivers would not be that easy, since it will require lots of tests with IR's and devices that the developers won't have. This is a weaker argument, since no matter what decided, we'll need to change the drivers code (on lirc drivers or on the in-kernel drivers) even without having all hardware available.

Quoted 6 lines

I do concur that Just Works decoding for bundled remotes w/o having to configure anything would be nice, and one way to go about doing that certainly is via in-kernel IR decoding. But at the same time, the second you want to use something other than a bundled remote, things fall down, and having to do a bunch of setkeycode ops seems less optimal than simply dropping an appropriate lircd.conf in place.

I don't see this as an issue. We have by far too much work to be done in kernelspace than the changes that are needed on userspace.

Replace the entire scancode table with setkeycode ops is very fast, and needs to be done only once, at lirc startup. Once you load the new IR code at the driver, the kernel will send the new keycodes to lirc.

It doesn't seem hard to modify lirc to do read the lircd.conf table and replace the IR scancodes at the in-kernel driver. It took me half an hour to write my own keycode loader code, and you can use it as the basis for such feature:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/tip/v4l2-apps/util/keytable.c

Cheers,
Mauro.

#114 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 40 lines · Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 9 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 7 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

I think at the end of the day we'll want to have all IR drivers use the same interface. The way the current in-kernel input layer drivers work obviously isn't perfect too, so we *must* consider both worlds to get a good solution for long-term ...

Quoted 3 lines

This is one of the key use cases I would be very concerned with. For many users who have bought tuner products, the bundled remotes work "out-of-the-box", regardless of whether lircd is installed.

I bet this simply isn't going to change.

Quoted 4 lines

I have no objection so much as to saying "well, you have to install the lircd service now", but there needs to be a way for the driver to
automatically tell lirc what the default remote control should be,
to avoid a regression in functionality.

*Requiring* lircd for the current in-kernel drivers doesn't make sense at all. Allowing lircd being used so it can do some more advanced stuff makes sense though.

Quoted 4 lines

This is why I think we really should put together a list of use cases, so that we can see how any given proposal addresses those use cases. I offered to do such, but nobody seemed really interested in this.

Lets have a look at the problems the current input layer bits have compared to lirc:

Quoted 8 lines

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

input_event->type = EV_IR
input_event->code = IR_RC5
input_event->value = <rc5 value>

Agreed. We're doing this already with some drivers (dvb-usb ones). I've started working on a patchset to extend this to the remaining drivers. I'm not sure whare were already merged from this tree, but my intention is to extend this to all drivers.

Quoted 2 lines

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

Well, RC6 mode 6 uses 32 bits. I don't know if is there any case for more than 32 bits. However, on some I2C IR chips, we see some cases where the IR scancode key is encapsulated into some protocol with more bytes. It seems that those extra bytes are used to handle key repetition sort of events. I'm not sure if it would make sense to pass the raw data to userspace. Probably not.

Quoted 8 lines

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified

    rc5/rc6/... codes.

* All the ir-code -> keycode mapping magic can be handled by the core input layer then. All the driver needs to do is to pass on the information which keymap should be loaded by default (for the bundled remote if any). The configuration can happen in userspace (sysfs attribute + udev + small utility in tools/ir/).

I like the idea of such small utility to load the keymap table.

Quoted 5 lines

* lirc drivers which get ir codes from the hardware can be converted to pure input layer drivers without regressions. lircd is not required any more.

Quoted 7 lines

(2) input layer doesn't give access to the raw samples.

Not sure how to deal with that best. Passing them through the input layer would certainly be possible to hack up. But what would be the point? The input layer wouldn't do any processing on them. It wouldn't buy us much. So we might want to simply stick with todays lirc interface for the raw samples.

If we need such interface, the better is to keep using the lirc interface. Yet, I'm not sure if we should really keep outputing raw samples, since several devices won't support it.

Quoted 10 lines

Drivers which support both ir codes (be it by hardware or by in-kernel decoding) and raw samples would register two devices then, one input device and one lirc device. It would probably a good idea to stop sending events to the input layer as soon as someone (most likely lircd) opens the lirc device to avoid keystrokes showing up twice.

By default the in-kernel bits will be at work, but optionally you can have lircd grab the raw samples and do fancy advanced decoding.

Quoted 6 lines

(3) input layer doesn't allow transmitting IR codes.

If we keep the lirc interface for raw samples anyway, then we can keep it for sending too, problem solved ;) How does sending hardware work btw? Do they all accept just raw samples? Or does some hardware also accept ir-codes?

I would do it in a way that it will accept scancodes and raw samples, since, even if we currently have only devices that accept raw samples, it would be more future-proof to allow sending scancodes also.

Cheers,
Mauro

#115 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 9 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 7 lines · Devin Heitmueller
Quoted 5 lines · Jarod Wilson

Took me a minute to figure out exactly what you were talking about. You're referring to the current in-kernel decoding done on an ad-hoc basis for assorted remotes bundled with capture devices, correct?

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Admittedly, unifying those and the lirc driven devices hasn't really been on my radar.

I think at the end of the day we'll want to have all IR drivers use the same interface.  The way the current in-kernel input layer drivers work obviously isn't perfect too, so we *must* consider both worlds to get a good solution for long-term ...

I made an attempt at implementing all of this a year ago.
http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/5/233

All of this kernel code is tiny, about 20K including a driver.

Basic flow works like this:

Add a new IR data type to the input framework
http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/5/234

Example mceusb IR input driver
http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/5/238

In-kernel decoding of core IR protocols - RC5, RC6, etc
http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/5/234

Decoded core protocols pass through a translation map based on configfs When core protocol matches an entry in configfs it is turned into a keycode event.
http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/5/235

You make a directory in /configfs/remotes for each remote you have. Making the directory creates a new evdev device. Under the directory make an entry for each command generated by the device. These entries cause the decoded IR data to be mapped into keycodes on the new evdev device. udev would load these configfs mappings at boot time...

mkdir /config/remotes/sony
-- this creates a new evdev device
mkdir remotes/sony/one
echo 7 >remotes/sony/one/protocol
echo 264 >remotes/sony/one/command
echo 2 >remotes/sony/one/keycode

This transforms a button push of 1 on my remote into a key stroke for KEY_1

 *   configfs root
 *   --remotes
 *   ----specific remote
 *   ------keymap
 *   --------protocol
 *   --------device
 *   --------command
 *   --------keycode
 *   ------repeat keymaps
 *   --------....
 *   ----another remote
 *   ------more keymaps

You can map the 1 button from multiple remotes to KEY_1 if you want. Or you can use a single remote to create multiple virtual keyboards.

-------------------------

Raw IR pulse data is available in a FIFO via sysfs. You can use this to figure out new remote protocols.

Two input events are generated
1) an event for the decoded raw IR protocol
2) a keycode event if thedecoded raw IR protocol matches an entry in the configfs

You can also send pulses.

------

If you want to script this, you would have a user space task that watches for either the decoded IR codes or the mapped keycodes.

This system also works with user space device drivers. They can inject input events into the early event flow and they will get processed as if the event originated in the kernel.

---------------------

Sure you could push the protocol decoding code (RC5, etc) into user space. Seems like a lot of hassle to move about 3KB of code out of the kernel.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#116 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

BTW, we used to have device specific user space interfaces for mouse and keyboard. These caused all sort of problems. A lot of work went into unifying them under evdev. It will be years until the old, messed up interfaces can be totally removed.

I'm not in favor of repeating the problems with a device specific user space interface for IR. I believe all new input devices should implement the evdev framework.

Signature · 2 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
#72 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 21 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 5 lines

I guess the question is what is the interface we want the regular userspace (i.e. not lircd) to use. Right now programs has to use 2 intercfaces - one lirc for dealing with remotes that are not using the standard event interface and evdev for remotes using it as well as the rest of the input devices.

From the mythtv perspective, using the input layer could yield a better out-of-the-box experience -- users don't have to set up an lircrc mapping that converts key names as specified in lircd.conf into commands
(key strokes, actually) that mythtv understands. For example, a button labeled "Play" in lircd.conf has to be mapped to 'p' in ~/.lircrc for mythtv to do the right thing with it. If everything came through the input layer, be that natively or via lircd's uinput reinjection, there would be no need to do that extra mapping step, mythtv would simply handle a KEY_PLAY event. So at worst, one manual mapping to do -- IR signal to standard button name in lircd.conf -- instead of two. But the lircrc approach does also allow more flexibility, in that you can only have a certain app respond to a certain key, if so desired, and remap a key to a different function (KEY_RED, KEY_GREEN, KEY_BLUE, KEY_YELLOW
-- what should their default functionality be? I know some users map a pair
of those to mythtv's "skip to next commflag point" and "skip to prior commflag point").

Quoted 3 lines

Unfortunately, mythtv currently doesn't handle KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, etc., etc. at all right now, it operates purely on keys commonly found on a standard keyboard. Remedying that is on my TODO list for the next release, if I can carve out the time.

This discussion is a little OT from the API discussions, since it affects both out-of-the box IR reception via input layer and lirc.

All media applications should be capable of handling the corresponding KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP ... keys without needing to do anything else than just handling the corresponding keycode. You shouldn't need to start a daemon or doing anything else for this to work out-of-the-box.

They currently don't do it due to historic reasons (it is easier to let something else remap KEY_PLAY into 'p' than to add the proper code there).

When using non-hot-pluggable devices where you're building a dedicated MCE hardware (this is the common case of MythTV setups), things are not that bad, since, once you set your hardware, it is done.

However, by looking on the number of different new devices, it seems that the most common type of devices are the TV USB sticks. As they are hot pluggable, eventually users may have more than one hardware and they expect that the IR layer will work equally on all your devices.

The proper way for supporting it is to have a common application-agnostic keycode to indicate the received events. For example, all IR's should produce KEY_CHANNELUP/KEY_CHANNELDOWN events for changing the channels. Also, on a perfect world, lirc should send this event to the multimedia application that handles TV when such key is pressed, instead of converting into some other keycode. This prevents future problems if, for some reason, the application needs to do something else with that key, or if the key has a different meaning on some different contexts.

For example, on some applications, KEY_UP/KEY_DOWN can mean to change a channel, but those keys are also used for menu navigation. However, KEY_CHANNELUP has a clear unique meaning: to change a channel. The expected behavior, from users perspective, is to mimic a TV box, where if you press channel UP any open menu will be closed and the channel will be changed, but pressing UP key will navigate at the menu. Well, if you map KEY_CHANNELUP as KEY_UP, you'll produce a different behavior.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#129 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 10 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi,

on 25 Nov 09 at 12:44, Jarod Wilson wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines

Ah, but the approach I'd take to converting to in-kernel decoding[*] would be this:

[...]

Quoted 2 lines

[*] assuming, of course, that it was actually agreed upon that in-kernel decoding was the right way, the only way, all others will be shot on sight.

Quoted 6 lines

I'm happy to see that the discussion is getting along.
But I'm still a bit hesitant about the in-kernel decoding. Maybe it's just because I'm not familiar at all with input layer toolset.

1. For sure in-kernel decoding will require some assistance from userspace to load the mapping from IR codes to keys.

Current drivers have the IR keycode tables in-kernel also, directly associated with the board ID.

Quoted 4 lines

So, if there needs to be a tool
in userspace that does some kind of autodetection, why not have a tool that does some autodetection and autoconfigures lircd for the current device.

There are userspace tools to change the IR keycode maps. It shouldn't be hard to change it to autodetect the hardware and to autoconfigure lircd.

Quoted 1 line

Lots of code duplication in kernel saved.

Huh? The code is already there.

Quoted 1 line

What's the actual benefit of in-kernel decoding?

There are two benefits:

1) the developer that adds the hardware also adds the IR code. He has the hardware and the IR for testing, so it means a faster development cycle than waiting for someone else with the same hardware and IR to recode it on some other place. You should remember that not all developers use lirc;

2) the IR works out of the box.

Quoted 4 lines

2. What would be the format of the key map? lircd.conf files already exist for a lot of remote controls. Will we have a second incompatible format to map the keys in-kernel? Where are the tools that create the key maps for new remotes?

No matter what tool you use, the format should be very close: scancode -> key_code.

If you wan to take a look on a real example, I'm enclosing the keycode table used by dib0700 driver, as generated/readed by a simple keycode application I made to test the dynamic keycode loading:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/file/tip/v4l2-apps/util/keytable.c

Most of the keycodes there are RC5 keys. There are also some NEC keys, as those devices can work with either RC5 or NEC keycodes, by using a different parameter during module load.

In the case of this driver, the pulse/space is done in hardware by the DibCom chip. The scancode is sent to PC via the USB interface.

I hope it helps for you to better understand how this works.

Cheers,
Mauro.

0x0700 KEY_MUTE
0x0701 KEY_MENU
0x0739 KEY_POWER
0x0703 KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x0709 KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x0706 KEY_CHANNELUP
0x070c KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x070f KEY_1
0x0715 KEY_2
0x0710 KEY_3
0x0718 KEY_4
0x071b KEY_5
0x071e KEY_6
0x0711 KEY_7
0x0721 KEY_8
0x0712 KEY_9
0x0727 KEY_0
0x0724 KEY_SCREEN
0x072a KEY_TEXT
0x072d KEY_REWIND
0x0730 KEY_PLAY
0x0733 KEY_FASTFORWARD
0x0736 KEY_RECORD
0x073c KEY_STOP
0x073f KEY_CANCEL
0xeb01 KEY_POWER
0xeb02 KEY_1
0xeb03 KEY_2
0xeb04 KEY_3
0xeb05 KEY_4
0xeb06 KEY_5
0xeb07 KEY_6
0xeb08 KEY_7
0xeb09 KEY_8
0xeb0a KEY_9
0xeb0b KEY_VIDEO
0xeb0c KEY_0
0xeb0d KEY_REFRESH
0xeb0f KEY_EPG
0xeb10 KEY_UP
0xeb11 KEY_LEFT
0xeb12 KEY_OK
0xeb13 KEY_RIGHT
0xeb14 KEY_DOWN
0xeb16 KEY_INFO
0xeb17 KEY_RED
0xeb18 KEY_GREEN
0xeb19 KEY_YELLOW
0xeb1a KEY_BLUE
0xeb1b KEY_CHANNELUP
0xeb1c KEY_VOLUMEUP
0xeb1d KEY_MUTE
0xeb1e KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0xeb1f KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0xeb40 KEY_PAUSE
0xeb41 KEY_HOME
0xeb42 KEY_MENU
0xeb43 KEY_SUBTITLE
0xeb44 KEY_TEXT
0xeb45 KEY_DELETE
0xeb46 KEY_TV
0xeb47 KEY_DVD
0xeb48 KEY_STOP
0xeb49 KEY_VIDEO
0xeb4a KEY_AUDIO
0xeb4b KEY_SCREEN
0xeb4c KEY_PLAY
0xeb4d KEY_BACK
0xeb4e KEY_REWIND
0xeb4f KEY_FASTFORWARD
0xeb54 KEY_PREVIOUS
0xeb58 KEY_RECORD
0xeb5c KEY_NEXT
0x1e00 KEY_0
0x1e01 KEY_1
0x1e02 KEY_2
0x1e03 KEY_3
0x1e04 KEY_4
0x1e05 KEY_5
0x1e06 KEY_6
0x1e07 KEY_7
0x1e08 KEY_8
0x1e09 KEY_9
0x1e0a KEY_KPASTERISK
0x1e0b KEY_RED
0x1e0c KEY_RADIO
0x1e0d KEY_MENU
0x1e0e KEY_GRAVE
0x1e0f KEY_MUTE
0x1e10 KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x1e11 KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x1e12 KEY_CHANNEL
0x1e14 KEY_UP
0x1e15 KEY_DOWN
0x1e16 KEY_LEFT
0x1e17 KEY_RIGHT
0x1e18 KEY_VIDEO
0x1e19 KEY_AUDIO
0x1e1a KEY_MEDIA
0x1e1b KEY_EPG
0x1e1c KEY_TV
0x1e1e KEY_NEXT
0x1e1f KEY_BACK
0x1e20 KEY_CHANNELUP
0x1e21 KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x1e24 KEY_LAST
0x1e25 KEY_OK
0x1e29 KEY_BLUE
0x1e2e KEY_GREEN
0x1e30 KEY_PAUSE
0x1e32 KEY_REWIND
0x1e34 KEY_FASTFORWARD
0x1e35 KEY_PLAY
0x1e36 KEY_STOP
0x1e37 KEY_RECORD
0x1e38 KEY_YELLOW
0x1e3b KEY_GOTO
0x1e3d KEY_POWER
0x0042 KEY_POWER
0x077c KEY_TUNER
0x0f4e KEY_PRINT
0x0840 KEY_SCREEN
0x0f71 KEY_DOT
0x0743 KEY_0
0x0c41 KEY_1
0x0443 KEY_2
0x0b7f KEY_3
0x0e41 KEY_4
0x0643 KEY_5
0x097f KEY_6
0x0d7e KEY_7
0x057c KEY_8
0x0a40 KEY_9
0x0e4e KEY_CLEAR
0x047c KEY_CHANNEL
0x0f41 KEY_LAST
0x0342 KEY_MUTE
0x064c KEY_RESERVED
0x0172 KEY_SHUFFLE
0x0c4e KEY_PLAYPAUSE
0x0b70 KEY_RECORD
0x037d KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x017d KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x0242 KEY_CHANNELUP
0x007d KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x1d00 KEY_0
0x1d01 KEY_1
0x1d02 KEY_2
0x1d03 KEY_3
0x1d04 KEY_4
0x1d05 KEY_5
0x1d06 KEY_6
0x1d07 KEY_7
0x1d08 KEY_8
0x1d09 KEY_9
0x1d0a KEY_TEXT
0x1d0d KEY_MENU
0x1d0f KEY_MUTE
0x1d10 KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x1d11 KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x1d12 KEY_CHANNEL
0x1d14 KEY_UP
0x1d15 KEY_DOWN
0x1d16 KEY_LEFT
0x1d17 KEY_RIGHT
0x1d1c KEY_TV
0x1d1e KEY_NEXT
0x1d1f KEY_BACK
0x1d20 KEY_CHANNELUP
0x1d21 KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x1d24 KEY_LAST
0x1d25 KEY_OK
0x1d30 KEY_PAUSE
0x1d32 KEY_REWIND
0x1d34 KEY_FASTFORWARD
0x1d35 KEY_PLAY
0x1d36 KEY_STOP
0x1d37 KEY_RECORD
0x1d3b KEY_GOTO
0x1d3d KEY_POWER
0x8613 KEY_MUTE
0x8612 KEY_POWER
0x8601 KEY_1
0x8602 KEY_2
0x8603 KEY_3
0x8604 KEY_4
0x8605 KEY_5
0x8606 KEY_6
0x8607 KEY_7
0x8608 KEY_8
0x8609 KEY_9
0x8600 KEY_0
0x860d KEY_CHANNELUP
0x8619 KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x8610 KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x860c KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x860a KEY_CAMERA
0x860b KEY_ZOOM
0x861b KEY_BACKSPACE
0x8615 KEY_ENTER
0x861d KEY_UP
0x861e KEY_DOWN
0x860e KEY_LEFT
0x860f KEY_RIGHT
0x8618 KEY_RECORD
0x861a KEY_STOP
0x7a00 KEY_MENU
0x7a01 KEY_RECORD
0x7a02 KEY_PLAY
0x7a03 KEY_STOP
0x7a10 KEY_CHANNELUP
0x7a11 KEY_CHANNELDOWN
0x7a12 KEY_VOLUMEUP
0x7a13 KEY_VOLUMEDOWN
0x7a40 KEY_POWER
0x7a41 KEY_MUTE

#92 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 11 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 4 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

I'm not sure if all the existing hardware for TX currently supports only raw pulse/code sequencies, but I still think that, even on the Tx case, it is better to send scancodes to the driver, and let it do the conversion to raw pulse/code, if the hardware requires pulse/code instead of scancodes.

That seems like a decision which will create a lots of duplicative code in the kernel. Add it's just busy-work to write such code when a userspace application in common use already handles the protocols and sends raw pulses to hardware that expects raw pulses.

I don't see how this would create lots of duplicative code.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 8 lines

However, as we have green field,
I would add the protocol explicitly for each scancode to be transmitted, like:

struct ir_tx {
	enum ir_protocol proto;
	u32 scancode;
};
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Eventually, we might have a protocol "raw" and some extra field to allow passing a raw pulse/code sequence instead of a scancode.

I think you would have to. 32 bits is really not enough for all protocols, and it is already partial encoding of information anyway.

If the Tx driver has to break them down into pulses anyway,

Do all Tx drivers need handle pulse by pulse, or there are some that works only with scancodes?

Quoted 7 lines

why not have fields with more meaningful names

mode
toggle
customer code (or system code or address), information (or command)

Quoted 5 lines

According to

	http://slycontrol.ru/scr/kb/rc6.htm

the "information" field could be up to 128 bits.

Seems fine to me.

Quoted 10 lines

(Not that I'm going to put any RC-6 Mode 6A decoding/encoding in the kernel.)

Regards,
Andy

Quoted 2 lines

Cheers,
Mauro.

#112 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 4 lines · Gerd Hoffmann

Why not? With RC5 remotes applications can get the device address bits for example, which right now are simply get lost in the ir code ->
keycode conversion step.

Right, this in fact makes the input layer interface unusable for many remotes at this time.
I think the address (aka group) should be just a part of the key ("command") code, IIRC this is what lirc RC5 does (I'm presently using a custom "media" version of RC5).

Quoted 6 lines

I know that lircd does matching instead of decoding, which allows to handle unknown encodings. Thats why I think there will always be cases which only lircd will be able to handle (using raw samples).

That doesn't make attempts to actually decode the IR samples a useless exercise though ;)

Sure. Especially RC5-like protos are simple to decode, and it's very reliable, even with a very unstable remote clock source (such as RC-based = resistor + capacitor).

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#179 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 6 lines · Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 2 lines · Jarod Wilson

Well, when mythtv was started, I don't know that there were many input layer remotes around... lirc was definitely around though.

lirc predates the input layer IR drivers by years, maybe even the input layer itself.

That was my guess, but I didn't have a timeline in front of me. :)

Quoted 8 lines

The main reason for the input layer IR drivers appearing was lirc not being mainline. A in-kernel driver (bttv in that case) which depends on a out-of-tree subsystem for IR support was simply a pain in the ass for both maintainer (/me back then) and users.

At least for IR hardware which allows access to the raw samples it certainly makes sense to support lirc, additional to the current (or improved) input layer support.

I'm liking the idea of a hybrid approach, where IR devices can support both lirc and input device interfaces. I think its the most regression-proof for end-users, if done correctly, which is one of my biggest concerns.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines

The lirc support in mythtv actually relies on mapping remote button names as defined in lircd.conf to keyboard key strokes. As mentioned elsewhere in this beast of a thread, mythtv doesn't currently support things like KEY_PLAY, KEY_VOLUMEUP, KEY_CHANNELUP, etc. just yet, but I intend on fixing that...

lircd can handle the input layer as input as well, so you actually can remap things via lircd even for pure input layer drivers. mythtv handling KEY_VOLUMEUP directly would be more elegant though.

Yeah, no, I know lircd can attach to an input device. But even if you do that, you have to have a mapping that converts KEY_VOLUMEUP as captured by lircd into (iirc) right-bracket (]) for mythtv to actually consume it. Directly handling definitely needs to be added to mythtv.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#136 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 26 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 11 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-11-23 at 22:11 +0100, Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

...

Quoted 6 lines

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread (maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Quoted 5 lines

There's one gripe I agree with, and that is that its still not plug-n-play. Something where udev auto-loads a sane default remote config for say, mceusb transceivers, and the stock mce remote Just Works would be nice, but auto-config is mostly out the window the second you involve transmitters and universal remotes anyway.

For several devices, an udev rule that auto-loads a sane default keymap does work. Of course, this won't cover 100% of the usages, and I lirc is a very good way of covering the holes.

Quoted 3 lines

But outside of that, I think objections are largely philosophical -- in a nutshell, the kernel has an input layer, remotes are input devices, and lirc doesn't conform to input layer standards.

Quoted 6 lines

Yes. I think this is mainly the issue.

The other issue is how to migrate the existing drivers to a new API without causing regressions. If we decide that IR's that receive raw pulse/code should use the raw input interface, this means that a large task force will be needed to convert the existing drivers to use it.

Aversion to regression is definitely a major concern. And why I'm liking the idea of a hybrid approach, at least initially.

Quoted 2 lines

What do you think of adding lirc at staging while we discuss/improve the API's and lircd support for the input event interface? Do you think this would work?

Sure, I don't see why not. And I've got another dozen or so drivers to follow those first three... :)

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#52 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 2 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

In what way the key interface is unsufficient for delivering button events?

At present: 128 different keys only (RC5: one group). One remote per device only.

The protocol itself doesn't have the above limitations, but has others, with are acceptable for key input.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#137 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 42 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 32 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 13 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-11-23 at 22:11 +0100, Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

...

Quoted 8 lines

I generally don't understand the LIRC aversion I perceive in this thread
(maybe I just have a skewed perception). Aside for a video card's default remote setup, the suggestions so far don't strike me as any simpler for the end user than LIRC -- maybe I'm just used to LIRC. LIRC
already works for both transmit and receive and has existing support in applications such as MythTV and mplayer.

Quoted 7 lines

There's one gripe I agree with, and that is that its still not plug-n-play.
Something where udev auto-loads a sane default remote config for say, mceusb transceivers, and the stock mce remote Just Works would be nice, but auto-config is mostly out the window the second you involve transmitters
and universal remotes anyway.

For several devices, an udev rule that auto-loads a sane default keymap does work.
Of course, this won't cover 100% of the usages, and I lirc is a very good way
of covering the holes.

Quoted 3 lines

But outside of that, I think objections are largely philosophical -- in a nutshell, the kernel has an input layer, remotes are input devices, and lirc doesn't conform to input layer standards.

Quoted 8 lines

Yes. I think this is mainly the issue.

The other issue is how to migrate the existing drivers to a new API without
causing regressions. If we decide that IR's that receive raw pulse/code should use the raw input interface, this means that a large task force will be
needed to convert the existing drivers to use it.

Quoted 2 lines

Aversion to regression is definitely a major concern. And why I'm liking the idea of a hybrid approach, at least initially.

Yes. This indeed seems to be a very good idea.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

What do you think of adding lirc at staging while we discuss/improve the API's and lircd
support for the input event interface? Do you think this would work?

Sure, I don't see why not. And I've got another dozen or so drivers to follow those first three... :)

Ok. As you said you'll do some work at the patches, could you please send us v3 in order to add it into drivers/staging?

In the case of the API header file, I would tag at the header file that the API is experimental, so can be changed without prior announcements, etc (in order to avoid people to use and rely on it it outside lirc). IMO, the better is to keep such announcement there while we're still working at the hybrid approach, as we may need to change something during the development phase.

Dmitry,

While lirc is basically a series of input drivers, considering that they have lots in common with the input drivers at V4L/DVB and that we'll need to work on some glue to merge both, do you mind if I add the lirc drivers at drivers/staging from my trees?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#53 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 10 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

In what way the key interface is unsufficient for delivering button events?

At present: 128 different keys only (RC5: one group). One remote per device only.

The protocol itself doesn't have the above limitations, but has others, with are acceptable for key input.

This is not a limit at the input subsystem. It were a design decision for some drivers at the V4L subsystem that we need to change.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#130 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

1) the developer that adds the hardware also adds the IR code. He has the hardware and the IR for testing, so it means a faster development cycle than waiting for someone else with the same hardware and IR to recode it on some other place. You should remember that not all developers use lirc;

It's fine, but please - no keymaps in the kernel (except for fixed receivers, i.e. the ones which can only work with their own dedicated remote, and which don't pass RC5/etc. code).

The existing keymaps (those which can be used with lirc) have to be moved to userspace as well.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#16 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

We don't want to "port it" to other drivers. We need to have a common module which does all RCx decoding. The individual drivers should be as simple as possible, something that I outlined in a previous mail.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#31 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

The issue I see is to support at the same time NEC and RC5 protocols. While this may work with some devices, for others, the hardware won't allow.

Sure. We can handle it for the "simple" devices at least.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

I think the mapping should be: key = proto + group + raw code, while key2 could be different_proto + different group (if any) + another code.

This may work for protocols up to RC5, that uses either 8 or 16 bits. However, RC6 mode 6 codes can be 32 bits, and we have "only" 32 bits for a scancode. So, we don't have spare bits to represent a protocol, if we consider RC6 mode 6 codes as well.

I don't see this limitation. The number of bits should depend on the protocol.

Quoted 4 lines

See above. Also, several protocols have a way to check if a keystroke were properly received. When handling just one protocol, we can use this to double check the key. However, on a multiprotocol mode, we'll need to disable this feature.

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#65 lore raw

Re: IR raw input is not sutable for input system

In reply to Maxim Levitsky
Quoted 2 lines · Maxim Levitsky

But devices that send raw pulse/space data should be handled in lirc that will feed the data back to the kernel via uinput.

I still do want the in-kernel RCx decoding. And lirc pulse/space.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#103 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 1 line · Dmitry Torokhov

Why would sysfs write be slower than ioctl?

Sysfs is generally one-value, one-file. open, read/write, close. ioctl() OTOH does everything (e.g. a whole key table) in one syscall.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#131 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

1) the developer that adds the hardware also adds the IR code. He has the hardware and the IR for testing, so it means a faster development cycle than waiting for someone else with the same hardware and IR to recode it on some other place. You should remember that not all developers use lirc;

Quoted 6 lines

It's fine, but please - no keymaps in the kernel (except for fixed receivers, i.e. the ones which can only work with their own dedicated remote, and which don't pass RC5/etc. code).

The existing keymaps (those which can be used with lirc) have to be moved to userspace as well.

The removal of the existing keymaps from kernel depends on having an application to be called from udev to load the proper keymaps when a device is probed.

After having it for a while, we should deprecate the in-kernel keymaps and move them to userspace.

I also think that it is important to remove the 7 bits limitation from all drivers and re-generate the keymaps, since they'll change after it.

cheers,
Mauro.

#17 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 11 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

We don't want to "port it" to other drivers. We need to have a common module which does all RCx decoding. The individual drivers should be as simple as possible, something that I outlined in a previous mail.

With the current 7bits mask applied to almost all devices, it is probably not very useful for those who want to use generic IRs. We really need to port the solution we've done on dvb-usb to the other drivers, allowing them to have the entire scancode at the tables while keep supporting table replacement.

The issue is that we currently have only 7bits of the scan codes produced by the IR's. So, we need to re-generate the keycode tables for each IR after the changes got applied.

With respect to a common module, unfortunately most of the work should be done on each driver, since the code that communicates with the hardware is specific to each device. There is a common code (at ir-common.ko) with helper decoding routines.

Please feel free to send us contributions to improve the current code.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#32 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

The issue I see is to support at the same time NEC and RC5 protocols. While this may work with some devices, for others, the hardware won't allow.

Sure. We can handle it for the "simple" devices at least.

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

I think the mapping should be: key = proto + group + raw code, while key2 could be different_proto + different group (if any) + another code.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

This may work for protocols up to RC5, that uses either 8 or 16 bits. However, RC6 mode 6 codes can be 32 bits, and we have "only" 32 bits for a scancode. So, we don't have spare bits to represent a protocol, if we consider RC6 mode 6 codes as well.

I don't see this limitation. The number of bits should depend on the protocol.

see include/linux/input.h:

struct input_event {
        struct timeval time;
        __u16 type;
        __u16 code;
        __s32 value;
};

extending the value to more than 32 bits require some changes at the input layer, probably breaking kernel API.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines

See above. Also, several protocols have a way to check if a keystroke were properly received. When handling just one protocol, we can use this to double check the key. However, on a multiprotocol mode, we'll need to disable this feature.

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

What happens if it succeeds on two protocol handlers?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#142 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 22 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

I don't know for sure what Microsoft claims to be licensing. I think it is the protocol itself:

http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/Press/2002/Apr02/04-16FreestylePhilipsPR.mspx

"Under the terms of the agreement, Microsoft and Philips will license to OEMs an IR protocol based on Philips proprietary RC6 IR technology. The patented and globally adopted solution minimizes interference from other remote-control devices in the household. Use of this established protocol will help ensure uniform development of Windows infrared remote-control products, which include infrared remote-control units and remote-control receivers..."

http://download.microsoft.com/download/9/8/f/98f3fe47-dfc3-4e74-92a3-088782200fe7/TWEN05007_WinHEC05.ppt

See Slide 5, which has the bullet: "How to License RC6"

Since the content of the information field in RC-6 Mode 6A is left up to OEMs, I would not be surprised by bogus "innovations" in OEM patents about RC-6 Mode 6A contents. I would not be at all surprised by something like "a bit to indicate a toggled remote key press in the information field" since RC-6's T bits for mode 6 indicate Mode 6A or Mode 6B and not toggles.

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

Regards,
Andy

Quoted 2 lines

Cheers,
Mauro.

#132 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 6 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

The removal of the existing keymaps from kernel depends on having an application
to be called from udev to load the proper keymaps when a device is probed.

After having it for a while, we should deprecate the in-kernel keymaps and move them to userspace.

Sounds like a plan.

Quoted 3 lines

I also think that it is important to remove the 7 bits limitation from all drivers
and re-generate the keymaps, since they'll change after it.

I think the existing space/mark media drivers need to be reworked completely.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#33 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 11 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

see include/linux/input.h:

struct input_event {
        struct timeval time;
        __u16 type;
        __u16 code;
        __s32 value;
};

extending the value to more than 32 bits require some changes at the input layer, probably breaking kernel API.

Yeah, but that's a "key" space, not "raw code" space. Keys via input and raw codes via lirc and there is no problem.

The mapping tables for input layer need to have variable code widths, depending on the protocol, sure.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

What happens if it succeeds on two protocol handlers?

We signal both and hope it isn't self-destruct button. We can't fix it no matter how hard we try.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#44 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Hi Mauro,

on 26 Nov 09 at 10:36, Mauro Carvalho Chehab wrote:
[...]

Quoted 4 lines

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Nonsense! There's no generation of artificial pulse codes in the drivers. The LIRC interface includes ways to pass decoded IR codes of arbitrary length to userspace.

Christoph

#45 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 4 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi Mauro,

on 26 Nov 09 at 10:36, Mauro Carvalho Chehab wrote:
[...]

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Nonsense! There's no generation of artificial pulse codes in the drivers. The LIRC interface includes ways to pass decoded IR codes of arbitrary length to userspace.

I might have got wrong then a comment in the middle of the imon_incoming_packet() of the SoundGraph iMON IR patch:

+ /*
+ * Translate received data to pulse and space lengths.
+ * Received data is active low, i.e. pulses are 0 and
+ * spaces are 1.
+ *
+ * My original algorithm was essentially similar to
+ * Changwoo Ryu's with the exception that he switched
+ * the incoming bits to active high and also fed an
+ * initial space to LIRC at the start of a new sequence
+ * if the previous bit was a pulse.
+ *
+ * I've decided to adopt his algorithm.
+ */

Cheers,
Mauro.

#34 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 11 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

see include/linux/input.h:

struct input_event {
        struct timeval time;
        __u16 type;
        __u16 code;
        __s32 value;
};
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

extending the value to more than 32 bits require some changes at the input layer, probably breaking kernel API.

Yeah, but that's a "key" space, not "raw code" space. Keys via input and raw codes via lirc and there is no problem.

No. All the other API functions there work with 32 bits for scancodes.

For example, the two ioctls to replace a scancode x key code are defined as:

#define EVIOCGKEYCODE           _IOR('E', 0x04, int[2])                 /* get keycode */
#define EVIOCSKEYCODE           _IOW('E', 0x04, int[2])                 /* set keycode */

We need to better analyze the API to see how this can be extended to allow bigger widths.

(what's worse is that it is defined as "int" instead of "u32" - so the number of bits is different on 32 and on 64 systems)

Quoted 11 lines

The mapping tables for input layer need to have variable code widths, depending on the protocol, sure.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 4 lines

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

What happens if it succeeds on two protocol handlers?

We signal both and hope it isn't self-destruct button. We can't fix it no matter how hard we try.

We can fix. Just let the userspace select what protocol(s) is(are) enabled.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#35 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

No. All the other API functions there work with 32 bits for scancodes.

We don't need them, do we? We need a new ioctl for changing key mappings anyway (a single ioctl for setting the whole table I think), and we can have arbitrary length of scan codes there.

Quoted 2 lines

(what's worse is that it is defined as "int" instead of "u32" - so the number of bits is different on 32 and on 64 systems)

Most (all?) 64-bit systems use 32-bit ints (and 64-bit longs). u32 and similar are for sure better.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines

We signal both and hope it isn't self-destruct button. We can't fix it no matter how hard we try.

We can fix. Just let the userspace select what protocol(s) is(are) enabled.

Sure, I meant the situation when both protocols (and scan codes) where enabled and configured. If we don't use RCx in the mapping table, we don't pass anything to RCx routine. If we have RCx but don't have the scan code in question, we don't find the key in the table and thus we ignore it again.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#133 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 6 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

The removal of the existing keymaps from kernel depends on having an application
to be called from udev to load the proper keymaps when a device is probed.

After having it for a while, we should deprecate the in-kernel keymaps and move them to userspace.

Quoted 8 lines

Sounds like a plan.

Quoted 3 lines

I also think that it is important to remove the 7 bits limitation from all drivers
and re-generate the keymaps, since they'll change after it.

I think the existing space/mark media drivers need to be reworked completely.

Nah. the changes aren't big. The first part of the change were already done for 2.6.32: instead of having a vector of 128 elements, where the element order used to be the masked scancode, we now have a table of scancode x keycode, defined as:

struct ir_scancode {
        u16     scancode;
        u32     keycode;
};

Changing scancode to u32 is as easy as edit a file - it is currently 16 just because all currently supported IR's and protocols have 16 bits only - there's no in-kernel implementation for RC6 mode 6 yet. However, increasing it above to 64 bits will break on 32 bits kernels (and above 64 bits, on all architectures), due to the current API limits.

this change is currently limited to the ir keytables, but I have a patch already done extending this change for the drivers to work directly with the new table.

The next step is to replace the ir->mask_keycode at the drivers to a value that gets the entire scancode. We may still need a mask there, since not all drivers output a 32 bits scancode.

Also, there's no single "space/mark" media driver. All drivers that support pulse/space also support in-hardware IR decoding, in order to support the
different types of devices. They generally support several ways to get keys:
- serial pulse/space decoding on one GPIO pin (most pci hardware have);
- serial pulse/space decoding via a IRQ enabled GPIO pin (several saa7134 IR's use this way);
- i2c IR's (common on several popular devices);
- parallel scancode output via gpio pins several cx88 IR's use this way);
- direct IR hardware decoding done by the video chipset
(DibCom and newer em28xx hardware, for example).

So, the driver input complexity is needed to support all those different ways.

So, rewriting it would likely cause regressions.

I agree that there are some cleanups that should be done for the serial pulse/space raw decoding. By adding a lirc interface, we'll need to have a common code for handling those events anyway.

Cheers,
Mauro.

maintainer
#54 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 6 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

In what way the key interface is unsufficient for delivering button events?

At present: 128 different keys only (RC5: one group).

Where did this limitation come from? We have more than 256 keycodes already _defined_ in the input core and we can add more if needed.

Quoted 2 lines

One remote per
device only.

Why would you want more? One physical device usually corresponds to a logical device. If you have 2 remotes create 2 devices.

Quoted 4 lines

The protocol itself doesn't have the above limitations, but has others, with are acceptable for key input.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#46 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Hi Mauro,

Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

[...]

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Nonsense! There's no generation of artificial pulse codes in the drivers. The LIRC interface includes ways to pass decoded IR codes of arbitrary length to userspace.

I might have got wrong then a comment in the middle of the imon_incoming_packet() of the SoundGraph iMON IR patch:

Indeed, you got it wrong.
As I already explained before, this device samples the signal at a constant rate and delivers the current level in a bit-array. This data is then condensed to pulse/space data.

Christoph

#36 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

No. All the other API functions there work with 32 bits for scancodes.

We don't need them, do we? We need a new ioctl for changing key mappings anyway (a single ioctl for setting the whole table I think), and we can have arbitrary length of scan codes there.

Why do you want to replace everything into a single shot? Had you ever tried to replace a scancode table with the current API?

$ wc ./keycodes/dib0700_rc_keys
 216  432 3541 ./keycodes/dib0700_rc_keys

This is the biggest table we have: 216 scancodes. It has codes for several different IR's bound together into the same table.

Let's replace the entire table (tested on a dib8076 reference design device):

$ time ./keytable ./keycodes/dib0700_rc_keys
real    0m0.029s
user    0m0.000s
sys     0m0.027s

Don't you think that 29ms to replace 216 codes to be fast enough, especially since you only need to do it once after plugging a device?

Also, if you want to control your device with two different IR controllers, the better is to allow adding new keycodes there, instead of just allowing the replacement of the entire table.

Maybe we'll need some extensions there, for example to extend the size of the dynamic table, but I don't see any timing issue here.

Cheers,
Mauro

#47 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 13 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi Mauro,

Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

[...]

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Nonsense! There's no generation of artificial pulse codes in the drivers. The LIRC interface includes ways to pass decoded IR codes of arbitrary length to userspace.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

I might have got wrong then a comment in the middle of the imon_incoming_packet() of the SoundGraph iMON IR patch:

Indeed, you got it wrong.
As I already explained before, this device samples the signal at a constant rate and delivers the current level in a bit-array. This data is then condensed to pulse/space data.

Ah, ok. It is now clear to me.

IMHO, it would be better to explain this at the source code, since the imon_incoming_packet() is a little complex.

It would help the review process if those big routines could be broken into
a few functions. While this improves code readability, it shouldn't
affect performance, as gcc will handle the static functions used only once as inline.

Quoted 1 line

Christoph

Cheers,
Mauro.

#41 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 11 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 4 lines

See above. Also, several protocols have a way to check if a keystroke were properly received. When handling just one protocol, we can use this to double check the key. However, on a multiprotocol mode, we'll need to disable this feature.

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

What happens if it succeeds on two protocol handlers?

Then you use the protocol that fits best. For instance decoding with one protocol might produce a scancode that isn't assigned to any key, while another protocol produces an assigned scancode. Clearly then the latter is most likely to be correct. It also possible to have a space/mark length that is within the allowable tolerances for one remote, but is even closer another remote. You don't want to just find *a* match, you want to find the *best* match.

The in kernel code in v4l is very simple in that it is only designed to work with one procotol and one remote. Once you have multiple remotes of any type things become much more complicted. Keep in mind that remotes that aren't even intended to be used with the computer but are used in the same room will still be received by the receiver. It's not enough to decode the signals you expect to receive, you must also not get confused by random signals destined for somewhere else.

#48 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 12 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

lircd supports input layer interface. Yet, patch 3/3 exports both devices that support only pulse/space raw mode and devices that generate scan codes via the raw mode interface. It does it by generating artificial pulse codes.

Nonsense! There's no generation of artificial pulse codes in the drivers. The LIRC interface includes ways to pass decoded IR codes of arbitrary length to userspace.

I might have got wrong then a comment in the middle of the imon_incoming_packet() of the SoundGraph iMON IR patch:

Review

Quoted 4 lines
(quoted diff) +4 -0
+	/*
+	 * Translate received data to pulse and space lengths.
+	 * Received data is active low, i.e. pulses are 0 and
+	 * spaces are 1.

I'm not sure about this specific code, but what is likely going on here is the waveform is being RLE encoding.

For example, a cx88 receiver has two ways of being connected (without using an external decoder chip). One generates an IRQ on each edge of the signal. The time between IRQs gives mark/space lengths which is what lirc expects. This is how a simple serial port receiver works too.

Another connections effectivly samples the waveform one bit deep at IIRC 4kHz. I think that's what the code you are looking at gets. The code extracts the edges from the waveform and returns the time between them. In effect one is run length encoding a sequence of bits.

maintainer
#40 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 12 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

For example, the two ioctls to replace a scancode x key code are defined as:

#define EVIOCGKEYCODE           _IOR('E', 0x04, int[2])                 /* get keycode */
#define EVIOCSKEYCODE           _IOW('E', 0x04, int[2])                 /* set keycode */

We need to better analyze the API to see how this can be extended to allow bigger widths.

(what's worse is that it is defined as "int" instead of "u32" - so the number of bits is different on 32 and on 64 systems)

Not really, int is 32 bits on both, longs the ones that differ.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#39 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 7 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

No. All the other API functions there work with 32 bits for scancodes.

We don't need them, do we? We need a new ioctl for changing key mappings anyway (a single ioctl for setting the whole table I think), and we can have arbitrary length of scan codes there.

Unless we determine that we 100% need bigger size of scancode then the current ioctls are just fine. Why do we _need_ an ioctl to load the whole tabe? Are you concerned about speed with which the keymap is populated? I don't think it would be an issue.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#73 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 17 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 15 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 14 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 12 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

Right, but still the keys usually do have the well-defined meaning,

Except when they don't. I have two very similar remotes, one that was bundled with a system from CaptiveWorks, and one that was bundled with an Antec Veris IR/LCD (SoundGraph iMON rebrand). Outside of the Antec remote having a mouse pad instead of up/down/left/right/enter, they have an identical layout, and the keys in the same locations on the remotes send the same IR signal. But the button names vary a LOT between the two. So on the DVD key on the Antec and the MUTE key on the CW send the same signal. Same with Audio vs. Eject, TV vs. History, etc. Moral of the story is that not all IR protocols spell things out particularly well for what a given code should actually mean.

I guess we are talking about different things. While the 2 remotes may use different protocols to communicate and may use the same codes to mean different things they buttons have well-defined meaning and we could map that to input keycodes. Then what is left is to load the proper mapping for particular device into the kernel. This can be done either automatically (when we know the mapping) or with the help of the user (owner of the system).

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 5 lines

teh
issue is in mapping raw code to the appropriate keycode. This can be done either by lirc config file (when lirc is used) or by some other means.

The desire to map a button press to multiple keystrokes isn't uncommon either, though I presume that's doable within the input layer context too.

No, at present we expect 1:1 button->event mapping leaving macro expansion (i.e. KEY_PROG1 -> "do some multi-step sequence" to userspace).

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#104 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 6 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 1 line · Dmitry Torokhov

Why would sysfs write be slower than ioctl?

Sysfs is generally one-value, one-file. open, read/write, close. ioctl() OTOH does everything (e.g. a whole key table) in one syscall.

There are binary sysfs attributes. For ioctl you also need to open and close the device. Plus, how often do you expect to perform this operation? Don't you think you are trying to optimize something that does not have any real performavnce impact here?

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#117 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Gerd Hoffmann
Quoted 16 lines · Gerd Hoffmann

(1) ir code (say rc5) -> keycode conversion looses information.

I think this can easily be addressed by adding a IR event type to the input layer, which could look like this:

input_event->type = EV_IR
input_event->code = IR_RC5
input_event->value = <rc5 value>

In case the 32bit value is too small we might want send two events instead, with ->code being set to IR_<code>_1 and IR_<code>_2

Advantages:
* Applications (including lircd) can get access to the unmodified

    rc5/rc6/... codes.
Quoted 9 lines

* All the ir-code -> keycode mapping magic can be handled by the core input layer then. All the driver needs to do is to pass on the information which keymap should be loaded by default (for the bundled remote if any). The configuration can happen in userspace (sysfs attribute + udev + small utility in tools/ir/).
* lirc drivers which get ir codes from the hardware can be converted to pure input layer drivers without regressions. lircd is not required any more.

I think we need to separate 2 kinds of applications since they have different requirements as far as interface goes:

1. "Reguilar" user-space applications interested in receiving keystrokes from user and reacting to them. Movie players, CD players, MythTV-like applications and so on. Those, to my understanding, are not concerned with the fine details of RC5, RC6, NEC and so forth protocol decoding and just want to know when to start playing, when to stop and when to revind. That class of applications is best served by current input layer since it unifies data coming from IR, keyboards, button devices and so forth.

2. "System" applications that are interested in protocol decoding. Those need interface best suited for IR and nothing else. This protocol is appears is better kept separate from the evdev input protocol. In case where we rely solely on such userspace application(s) to perform protocol decoding we should route input events back to kernel through uinput for consumption by "class 1" applications.

We use this approach for PS/2 (serio allows binding either psmouse/atkbd or serio_raw to provide alternate interfaces depending on the users need), USB hid allows raw access as well, maybe we should follow the suit here.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#138 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Dmitry,

While lirc is basically a series of input drivers, considering that they have lots in common with the input drivers at V4L/DVB and that we'll need to work on some glue to merge both, do you mind if I add the lirc drivers at drivers/staging from my trees?

Mauro,

I would not mind if you will be pushing it to staging, however I am not sure we have an agreement on what exactly the interface that we will be using. I would hate to get something in that will need to be reworked again.

Thanks.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#55 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 5 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 2 lines

One remote per
device only.

Why would you want more? One physical device usually corresponds to a logical device. If you have 2 remotes create 2 devices.

I meant "per receiver device".

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#37 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Why do you want to replace everything into a single shot?

Why not? It seems simpler to me. We need to change this anyway.

If we change the whole table in a single ioctl, we can easily enumerate protocols requested and enable then selectively.
But I think it's a minor implementation decision and we don't need to look at it at this time.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
maintainer
#56 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 2 lines

One remote per
device only.

Why would you want more? One physical device usually corresponds to a logical device. If you have 2 remotes create 2 devices.

I meant "per receiver device".

There is nothing in input layer that precludes you from creating multiple input devices per *whatever*. Please, when you are talking about limitations, specify whether those limitations are applicable to the input layer, the current implementation of IR in DVB or something else.

Thanks.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#105 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ?

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 1 line · Dmitry Torokhov

There are binary sysfs attributes.

Aren't they to be used for things like ROMs and EEPROMs exclusively?

Quoted 2 lines

For ioctl you also need to open and
close the device.

Sure, but I do it once.

Quoted 3 lines

Plus, how often do you expect to perform this
operation? Don't you think you are trying to optimize something that does not have any real performavnce impact here?

Maybe, anyway it will have to work before it's included in the kernel, so I don't worry too much about it. Perhaps we should then merge the lirc patches so both driver sets can be improved?

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#38 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · On Friday 27 November 2009 00:19:44 Krzysztof Halasa wrote:
Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Why do you want to replace everything into a single shot?

Why not? It seems simpler to me. We need to change this anyway.

ioctls with a variable argument length are a pain for 32 bit emulation and stuff like strace. You either need to encode the variable length into the ioctl cmd, making it variable as well, or use a pointer in the data structure, which requires conversion.

Ideally, ioctl arguments have a constant layout, no pointers and are at most 64 bits long.

	Arnd <><
#57 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 2 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

There is nothing in input layer that precludes you from creating multiple input devices per *whatever*.

Of course. I though it was obvious I mean present situation with the media drivers but I can see now it was far from being obvious.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#42 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Trent Piepho
Quoted 4 lines · Trent Piepho

Then you use the protocol that fits best. For instance decoding with one protocol might produce a scancode that isn't assigned to any key, while another protocol produces an assigned scancode. Clearly then the latter is most likely to be correct.

Right.

Quoted 4 lines

It also possible to have a space/mark length
that is within the allowable tolerances for one remote, but is even closer another remote. You don't want to just find *a* match, you want to find the *best* match.

That won't work, the decoders don't calculate quality. And even if they did, if you have two remotes generating the same e.g. RC5 code, you won't be able to differentiate between them. Your TV etc. won't do that either.

Quoted 3 lines

The in kernel code in v4l is very simple in that it is only designed to work with one procotol and one remote. Once you have multiple remotes of any type things become much more complicted.

If you're using them at once, sure :-)

Quoted 5 lines

Keep in mind that remotes
that aren't even intended to be used with the computer but are used in the same room will still be received by the receiver. It's not enough to decode the signals you expect to receive, you must also not get confused by random signals destined for somewhere else.

This is usually not a problem. My experience is the decoding is very reliable.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#139 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 7 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Dmitry,

While lirc is basically a series of input drivers, considering that they have lots in common with the input drivers at V4L/DVB and that we'll need to work on some glue to merge both, do you mind if I add the lirc drivers at drivers/staging from my trees?

Quoted 6 lines

Mauro,

I would not mind if you will be pushing it to staging, however I am not sure we have an agreement on what exactly the interface that we will be using. I would hate to get something in that will need to be reworked again.

I understand your concerns.

IMHO, we should be really careful with API's when migrating from staging to the right place, but I'm not that much concerned with staging. We already have several drivers there with bad behaviors and even with some API's there that will go to /dev/null.

For example there's a V4L2 driver there (staging/go7007) that has their own private API to handle compressed streams. I won't ack moving it from staging while it has their own private extensions for something that are part of V4L2 API.

Also, staging drivers without progress for a few kernel cycles will be moved to /dev/null, so I don't see much sense of denying a driver to go there.

Anyway, I'll add it there only when you feel comfortable about that and send us your ack.

-

Quoted 1 line

From what I heard on the comments, I think we have already a consensus of some points:

1) all IR's should implement the standard evdev interface;
2) IR's with raw interfaces will implement a raw pulse/space IR interface.
The proposal is to use lirc API interface for raw pulse/code TX and RX.

Do you think we'll need to better detail the IR raw interface API before accepting the patches for staging? If so, what level of details do you want?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#74 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 22 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 21 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 19 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 17 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 6 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 5 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line

Right, but still the keys usually do have the well-defined meaning,

Except when they don't. I have two very similar remotes, one that was bundled with a system from CaptiveWorks, and one that was bundled with an Antec Veris IR/LCD (SoundGraph iMON rebrand). Outside of the Antec remote having a mouse pad instead of up/down/left/right/enter, they have an identical layout, and the keys in the same locations on the remotes send the same IR signal. But the button names vary a LOT between the two. So on the DVD key on the Antec and the MUTE key on the CW send the same signal. Same with Audio vs. Eject, TV vs. History, etc. Moral of the story is that not all IR protocols spell things out particularly well for what a given code should actually mean.

I guess we are talking about different things. While the 2 remotes may use different protocols to communicate

The remotes use the exact same protocol. Their respective bundled receivers however, do translate key presses differently. Perhaps this is a bad example though, because both of these remotes came with receivers that do onboard decoding. But there's nothing stopping me from wanting to use either of these remotes with an mceusb IR transceiver.

Quoted 4 lines

and may use the same codes to
mean different things they buttons have well-defined meaning and we could map that to input keycodes. Then what is left is to load the proper mapping for particular device into the kernel.

In this case, its not the device, but the remote, that we need a different mapping for.

Quoted 3 lines

This can be done
either automatically (when we know the mapping) or with the help of the user (owner of the system).

Yep, that'd work. Just trying to illustrate that the same code doesn't always mean anywhere near the same thing from one remote to another.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

teh
issue is in mapping raw code to the appropriate keycode. This can be done either by lirc config file (when lirc is used) or by some other means.

The desire to map a button press to multiple keystrokes isn't uncommon either, though I presume that's doable within the input layer context too.

No, at present we expect 1:1 button->event mapping leaving macro expansion (i.e. KEY_PROG1 -> "do some multi-step sequence" to userspace).

Hm. So ctrl-x, alt-tab, etc. would have to be faked in userspace somehow. Bummer.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#43 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Trent Piepho

Am Donnerstag, den 26.11.2009, 14:59 -0800 schrieb Trent Piepho:

Quoted 21 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 4 lines

See above. Also, several protocols have a way to check if a keystroke were properly received. When handling just one protocol, we can use this to double check the key. However, on a multiprotocol mode, we'll need to disable this feature.

I don't think so. We can pass the space/mark data to all (configured, i.e. with active mapping) protocol handlers at once. Should a check fail, we ignore the data. Perhaps another protocol will make some sense out of it.

What happens if it succeeds on two protocol handlers?

Then you use the protocol that fits best. For instance decoding with one protocol might produce a scancode that isn't assigned to any key, while another protocol produces an assigned scancode. Clearly then the latter is most likely to be correct. It also possible to have a space/mark length that is within the allowable tolerances for one remote, but is even closer another remote. You don't want to just find *a* match, you want to find the *best* match.

Quoted 7 lines

The in kernel code in v4l is very simple in that it is only designed to work with one procotol and one remote. Once you have multiple remotes of any type things become much more complicted. Keep in mind that remotes that aren't even intended to be used with the computer but are used in the same room will still be received by the receiver. It's not enough to decode the signals you expect to receive, you must also not get confused by random signals destined for somewhere else.

Giving some random living room these days, likely open to the kids rooms, you have to take that into account.

Another point, if decoding from IRQs generated by the remote, there is flawed hardware around, needing to poll IRQs in some timely manner to get it to something at all.

This will break such remotes. Never seen?

For me the first priority is, that existing remotes are not broken.

Don't tell you have done a nice job just now, but are unfortunately in need of testers ...

Cheers,
Hermann

#75 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 6 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 3 lines

No, at present we expect 1:1 button->event mapping leaving macro expansion (i.e. KEY_PROG1 ->  "do some multi-step sequence" to userspace).

Hm. So ctrl-x, alt-tab, etc. would have to be faked in userspace somehow. Bummer.

That is scripting. Scripting always needs to be done in user space.

In the code I posted there is one evdev device for each configured remote. Mapped single keycodes are presented on these devices for each IR burst. There is no device for the IR receiver. A LIRC type process could watch these devices and then execute scripts based on the keycodes reported.

The configfs model is very flexible. You could make a "remote" that translates the UP/DOWN buttons of several different remotes into KEY_UP/DOWN. That lets several different remotes control the same app.

Sure it is clunky to play with IR hex codes and keycodes in the configfs mapping dir. If you don't like it write a GUI app for manipulating the codes. GUI would then generate a script for udev to run which builds the configfs entries.

Maybe I should rename those directory entries to "app" instead of "remote". They contain the mappings from IR hex codes to keycodes that an app is interested in. Usually there is a 1:1 correspondence between remote and app but there doesn't have to be.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
maintainer
#81 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 36 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 22 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 21 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 19 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 17 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 6 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 5 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Event input has the advantage that the keystrokes will provide an unique representation that is independent of the device.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

This can hardly work as the only means, the remotes have different keys, the user almost always has to provide customized key<>function mapping.

Is it true? I would expect the remotes to have most of the keys to have well-defined meanings (unless it is one of the programmable remotes)...

Its the cases like programmable universal remotes that really throw things for a loop. That, and people wanting to use random remote X that came with the amp or tv or set top box, with IR receiver Y.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 1 line

Right, but still the keys usually do have the well-defined meaning,

Except when they don't. I have two very similar remotes, one that was bundled with a system from CaptiveWorks, and one that was bundled with an Antec Veris IR/LCD (SoundGraph iMON rebrand). Outside of the Antec remote having a mouse pad instead of up/down/left/right/enter, they have an identical layout, and the keys in the same locations on the remotes send the same IR signal. But the button names vary a LOT between the two. So on the DVD key on the Antec and the MUTE key on the CW send the same signal. Same with Audio vs. Eject, TV vs. History, etc. Moral of the story is that not all IR protocols spell things out particularly well for what a given code should actually mean.

I guess we are talking about different things. While the 2 remotes may use different protocols to communicate

The remotes use the exact same protocol. Their respective bundled receivers however, do translate key presses differently. Perhaps this is a bad example though, because both of these remotes came with receivers that do onboard decoding. But there's nothing stopping me from wanting to use either of these remotes with an mceusb IR transceiver.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

and may use the same codes to
mean different things they buttons have well-defined meaning and we could map that to input keycodes. Then what is left is to load the proper mapping for particular device into the kernel.

In this case, its not the device, but the remote, that we need a different mapping for.

I would say that the remote is the device, not the receiver...

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

This can be done
either automatically (when we know the mapping) or with the help of the user (owner of the system).

Yep, that'd work. Just trying to illustrate that the same code doesn't always mean anywhere near the same thing from one remote to another.

We have the same scenatio with atkbd and various laptops - the "extended" keys may use the same scancodes for different keys and we use DMI data to load the proper keymap. Obviously in case if IRC we won't be using DMI but something else.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 5 lines

teh
issue is in mapping raw code to the appropriate keycode. This can be done either by lirc config file (when lirc is used) or by some other means.

Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

The desire to map a button press to multiple keystrokes isn't uncommon either, though I presume that's doable within the input layer context too.

No, at present we expect 1:1 button->event mapping leaving macro expansion (i.e. KEY_PROG1 -> "do some multi-step sequence" to userspace).

Hm. So ctrl-x, alt-tab, etc. would have to be faked in userspace somehow. Bummer.

What is Ctrl-x? Alt-tab? This are application-specific binding and of course kernel does not emit these. If there is a distinct action that needs to be signalled then there [normally] is a keycode for it.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#76 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 26 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 6 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 3 lines

No, at present we expect 1:1 button->event mapping leaving macro expansion (i.e. KEY_PROG1 ->  "do some multi-step sequence" to userspace).

Hm. So ctrl-x, alt-tab, etc. would have to be faked in userspace somehow. Bummer.

That is scripting. Scripting always needs to be done in user space.

In the code I posted there is one evdev device for each configured remote. Mapped single keycodes are presented on these devices for each IR burst. There is no device for the IR receiver. A LIRC type process could watch these devices and then execute scripts based on the keycodes reported.

The configfs model is very flexible. You could make a "remote" that translates the UP/DOWN buttons of several different remotes into KEY_UP/DOWN. That lets several different remotes control the same app.

Sure it is clunky to play with IR hex codes and keycodes in the configfs mapping dir. If you don't like it write a GUI app for manipulating the codes. GUI would then generate a script for udev to run which builds the configfs entries.

Quoted 5 lines

Maybe I should rename those directory entries to "app" instead of "remote". They contain the mappings from IR hex codes to keycodes that an app is interested in. Usually there is a 1:1 correspondence between remote and app but there doesn't have to be.

Maybe we should revisit Jon's patchset as well. Regretfully I did not have time to do that when it was submitted the last time.

Signature · 5 lines
Dmitry
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#77 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 6 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 6 lines

In the code I posted there is one evdev device for each configured remote. Mapped single keycodes are presented on these devices for each IR burst. There is no device for the IR receiver.  A LIRC type process could watch these devices and then execute scripts based on the keycodes reported.

...

Quoted 3 lines

Maybe we should revisit Jon's patchset as well. Regretfully I did not have time to do that when it was submitted the last time.

Consider my patch set a technology demo starting point. It shows a modern architecture for integrating IR into evdev. Use the input from everyone else to turn these concepts into a real design. I wrote the code for the fun of it, I have no commercial interest in IR. I was annoyed with how LIRC handled Sony remotes on my home system.

The design is a clean slate implementation of IR for the kernel. No attempt was made at legacy compatibility. I was familiar with evdev vs /dev/mouse problems from my work on the X server. Because of working on X I've also always hated keymaps (that's what drove the configfs design).

I wish one of the set top box or TV manufacturers would step up and own this. They are the ones that would benefit the most. Jarod would probably be open to some consulting, right?

Signature · 2 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
#78 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Hi Jon,

on 27 Nov 09 at 00:06, Jon Smirl wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines

code for the fun of it, I have no commercial interest in IR. I was annoyed with how LIRC handled Sony remotes on my home system.

Can you elaborate on this?
I'm not aware of any issue with Sony remotes.

Christoph

#134 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Hi Mauro,

Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Christoph Bartelmus wrote:

[...]

Quoted 2 lines
Quoted 2 lines

But I'm still a bit hesitant about the in-kernel decoding. Maybe it's just because I'm not familiar at all with input layer toolset.

[...]

Quoted 1 line

I hope it helps for you to better understand how this works.

So the plan is to have two ways of using IR in the future which are incompatible to each other, the feature-set of one being a subset of the other?

When designing the key mapping in the kernel you should be aware that there are remotes out there that send a sequence of scan codes for some buttons, e.g.
http://lirc.sourceforge.net/remotes/pioneer/CU-VSX159

Christoph

#79 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Christoph Bartelmus
Quoted 9 lines · Christoph Bartelmus

Hi Jon,

on 27 Nov 09 at 00:06, Jon Smirl wrote:
[...]

Quoted 2 lines

code for the fun of it, I have no commercial interest in IR. I was annoyed with how LIRC handled Sony remotes on my home system.

Can you elaborate on this?
I'm not aware of any issue with Sony remotes.

irrecord can't figure out that Sony remotes transmit multiple protocols so it reverts to raw mode. When trying to figure that out I started working on the concept of running simultaneous state machines to decode the pulse timings. I also had an embedded system with an IR receiver hooked to a timer input pin. I started off with a implementation that ran multiple Sony protocol decoders and used the input from the timer pin. I know now that I could use irrecord individually for each group of keys on the Sony remote and then glue the flies together. But that's the path that caused me to write the code.

Also throw into pot that I had previously had some very bad experiences trying to deal with the old mouse and kbd device inside of the X server. I was aware that evdev was designed to fix all of those problems. That made me want a fully evdev based design.

Quoted 7 lines

Christoph
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-media" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#18 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Em Thu, 26 Nov 2009 17:06:03 -0200
Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> escreveu:

Quoted 13 lines
Quoted 11 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

We don't want to "port it" to other drivers. We need to have a common module which does all RCx decoding. The individual drivers should be as simple as possible, something that I outlined in a previous mail.

Quoted 7 lines

With the current 7bits mask applied to almost all devices, it is probably not very useful for those who want to use generic IRs. We really need to port the solution we've done on dvb-usb to the other drivers, allowing them to have the entire scancode at the tables while keep supporting table replacement.

The issue is that we currently have only 7bits of the scan codes produced by the IR's. So, we need to re-generate the keycode tables for each IR after the changes got applied.

Ok, I got some time to add support for tables with the full scan codes at the V4L drivers. In order to not break all tables, I've confined the changes to just one device (HVR-950, at the em28xx driver). The patches were already committed at the -hg development tree.

In order to support tables with the full scan codes, all that is needed is to add the RC5 address + RC5 data when calling ir_input_keydown. So, the change is as simple as:

- ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
- poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+ ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
+ poll_result.rc_address << 8 |
+ poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+ else

An example of such patch can be seen at:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/9c38704cfd56

There are still some work to do, since, currently, the drivers will use a table with a fixed size. So, you can replace the current values, but it is not possible to add new keys.

The fix for it is simple, but we need to think what would be the better way for it. There are two alternatives:
- A table with a fixed size (like 128 or 256 entries - maybe a modprobe parameter
could be used to change its size);
- some way to increase/reduce the table size. In this case, we'll likely need some
ioctl for it.

Signature · 2 lines
Cheers,
Mauro
maintainer
#19 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 44 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Em Thu, 26 Nov 2009 17:06:03 -0200
Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> escreveu:

Quoted 13 lines
Quoted 11 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

We don't want to "port it" to other drivers. We need to have a common module which does all RCx decoding. The individual drivers should be as simple as possible, something that I outlined in a previous mail.

Quoted 7 lines

With the current 7bits mask applied to almost all devices, it is probably not very useful for those who want to use generic IRs. We really need to port the solution we've done on dvb-usb to the other drivers, allowing them to have the entire scancode at the tables while keep supporting table replacement.

The issue is that we currently have only 7bits of the scan codes produced by the IR's. So, we need to re-generate the keycode tables for each IR after the changes got applied.

Ok, I got some time to add support for tables with the full scan codes at the V4L drivers. In order to not break all tables, I've confined the changes to just one device (HVR-950, at the em28xx driver). The patches were already committed at the -hg development tree.

In order to support tables with the full scan codes, all that is needed is to add the RC5 address + RC5 data when calling ir_input_keydown. So, the change is as simple as:

(quoted diff) +4 -2
-			ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
-					 poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+			ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
+					 poll_result.rc_address << 8 |
+					 poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+		else

An example of such patch can be seen at:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/9c38704cfd56

There are still some work to do, since, currently, the drivers will use a table with a fixed size. So, you can replace the current values, but it is not possible to add new keys.

Quoted 7 lines

The fix for it is simple, but we need to think what would be the better way for it. There are two alternatives:
- A table with a fixed size (like 128 or 256 entries - maybe a modprobe parameter
could be used to change its size);
- some way to increase/reduce the table size. In this case, we'll likely need some
ioctl for it.

Hmm, why can't you just resize it when you get EVIOCSKEYCODE for scancode that would be out of bounds for the current table (if using table approach)?

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#20 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 42 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 41 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Em Thu, 26 Nov 2009 17:06:03 -0200
Mauro Carvalho Chehab <[email protected]> escreveu:

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 5 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Technically, it is not hard to port this solution to the other drivers, but the issue is that we don't have all those IR's to know what is the complete scancode that each key produces. So, the hardest part is to find a way for doing it without causing regressions, and to find a group of people that will help testing the new way.

We don't want to "port it" to other drivers. We need to have a common module which does all RCx decoding. The individual drivers should be as simple as possible, something that I outlined in a previous mail.

Quoted 7 lines

With the current 7bits mask applied to almost all devices, it is probably not very useful for those who want to use generic IRs. We really need to port the solution we've done on dvb-usb to the other drivers, allowing them to have the entire scancode at the tables while keep supporting table replacement.

The issue is that we currently have only 7bits of the scan codes produced by the IR's. So, we need to re-generate the keycode tables for each IR after the changes got applied.

Ok, I got some time to add support for tables with the full scan codes at the V4L drivers. In order to not break all tables, I've confined the changes to just one device (HVR-950, at the em28xx driver). The patches were already committed at the -hg development tree.

In order to support tables with the full scan codes, all that is needed is to add the RC5 address + RC5 data when calling ir_input_keydown. So, the change is as simple as:

(quoted diff) +4 -2
-			ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
-					 poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+			ir_input_keydown(ir->input, &ir->ir,
+					 poll_result.rc_address << 8 |
+					 poll_result.rc_data[0]);
+		else

An example of such patch can be seen at:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/9c38704cfd56

There are still some work to do, since, currently, the drivers will use a table with a fixed size. So, you can replace the current values, but it is not possible to add new keys.

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 7 lines

The fix for it is simple, but we need to think what would be the better way for it. There are two alternatives:
- A table with a fixed size (like 128 or 256 entries - maybe a modprobe parameter
could be used to change its size);
- some way to increase/reduce the table size. In this case, we'll likely need some
ioctl for it.

Hmm, why can't you just resize it when you get EVIOCSKEYCODE for scancode that would be out of bounds for the current table (if using table approach)?

For your reference, the code where EVIOGKEYCODE/EVIOSKEYCODE handling is done is at this changeset:

	http://linuxtv.org/hg/v4l-dvb/rev/21e71d58cd2a

Dynamic resizing can be done, but there are a few different use cases for someone to touch on the keymaps:

1. People want to change the key assignment for a key at the shipped IR. In this case, the table won't need to change its size;

2. People want to use the shipped IR, plus a different one. In this case, table size needs to be extended to store the newer codes;

3. People want to discard the shipped IR and use something else.

Case 3 is the worse scenario. Let's suppose, for example that instead of using a 49 keys IR, they want to use some programable IR with 55 keys, with different scancodes. This means that they'll need to delete all 49 scancodes from the old IR and add 55 new scancodes. As there's no explicit call to delete a scan code, the solution I found with the current API is to read the current scancode table and replace them with KEY_UNKNOWN, allowing its re-use (this is what the driver currently does) or deleting that scancode from the table. After deleting 49 keys, you'll need to add the 55 new keys. If we do dynamic table resize for each operation, we'll do 104 sequences of kmalloc/kfree for replacing one table.

IMO, it would be better to have an ioctl to do the keycode table resize. An optional flag at the ioctl (or a separate one) can be used to ask the driver to clean the current keymap table and allocate a new one with the specified size.
This will avoid playing with memory allocation for every new key and will provide a simple way to say to the driver to discard the current keybable, since a new one will be used.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#21 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 1 line · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

Dmitry Torokhov wrote:

[scancode-to-keycode map size]

Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Hmm, why can't you just resize it when you get EVIOCSKEYCODE for scancode that would be out of bounds for the current table (if using table approach)?

[...]

Quoted 9 lines

Let's suppose, for example that instead of using a 49 keys
IR, they want to use some programable IR with 55 keys, with different scancodes. This means that they'll need to delete all 49 scancodes from the old IR and add 55 new scancodes. As there's no explicit call to delete a scan code, the solution I found with the current API is to read the current scancode table and replace them with KEY_UNKNOWN, allowing its re-use (this is what the driver currently does) or deleting that scancode from the table. After deleting 49 keys, you'll need to add the 55 new keys. If we do dynamic table resize for each operation, we'll do 104 sequences of kmalloc/kfree for replacing one table.

It is not a performance sensitive task, is it? If you can trade ABI simplicity for performance (which shouldn't actually matter), that'd be a better deal.

Besides, some of the necessary kernel-internal house-keeping can also be deferred until close().

Quoted 5 lines

IMO, it would be better to have an ioctl to do the keycode table resize. An optional flag at the ioctl (or a separate one) can be used to ask the driver to clean the current keymap table and allocate a new one with the specified size.
This will avoid playing with memory allocation for every new key and will provide a simple way to say to the driver to discard the current keybable, since a new one will be used.

OTOH, an additional "forget all current mappings" ioctl sounds like an ABI simplification.

Signature · 3 lines
Stefan Richter
-=====-==--= =-== ===--
http://arcgraph.de/sr/
#22 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

After deleting 49 keys, you'll need to add the 55 new keys. If we do dynamic table resize for each operation, we'll do 104 sequences of kmalloc/kfree for replacing one table.

Given that kmalloc only does power-of-two allocations, you can limit the resize operations to when you go beyond the current allocation limit. You can also choose a reasonable minimum table size (e.g. 32 or 64 entries) and avoid resizes for many of the common cases entirely.

	Arnd <><
#183 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 1 line

Hi,

this remind me
http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.drivers.video-input-infrastructure/584/focus=585
thread.

Quoted 4 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab <mchehab <at> redhat.com> writes:

So, the basic question that should be decided is: should we create a new userspace API for raw IR pulse/space or it would be better to standardize it to always use the existing input layer?

To me the old ttpci approach was great :
- the kernel does the IR pulse translation to input layer. In the current kernel there code duplication, it is done in many driver (with different way) [1]. A new subdriver should take as input the decoded remote address, data and toggle and output a key in input layer
- userspace need to configure IR pulse type (RC5, ...), remote address, keymap. But the kernel can have some default config for the hardware. Keymap are stored in userspace.

Matthieu

[1] for example there not way to specify remote remote address to use. "ir->addr" hardcoded in bttv, saa7134. em28xx doesn't use the decoded rc_address, ...

#80 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 25 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 6 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 6 lines

In the code I posted there is one evdev device for each configured remote. Mapped single keycodes are presented on these devices for each IR burst. There is no device for the IR receiver. A LIRC type process could watch these devices and then execute scripts based on the keycodes reported.

...

Quoted 3 lines

Maybe we should revisit Jon's patchset as well. Regretfully I did not have time to do that when it was submitted the last time.

Consider my patch set a technology demo starting point. It shows a modern architecture for integrating IR into evdev. Use the input from everyone else to turn these concepts into a real design. I wrote the code for the fun of it, I have no commercial interest in IR. I was annoyed with how LIRC handled Sony remotes on my home system.

The design is a clean slate implementation of IR for the kernel. No attempt was made at legacy compatibility. I was familiar with evdev vs /dev/mouse problems from my work on the X server. Because of working on X I've also always hated keymaps (that's what drove the configfs design).

Quoted 3 lines

I wish one of the set top box or TV manufacturers would step up and own this. They are the ones that would benefit the most. Jarod would probably be open to some consulting, right?

Mauro may actually have better connections on that front than I do... Thus far, I've only talked to a few vendors of IR devices, with mixed results getting any sort of support out of them. But its on my todo list to put out some feelers on the work front to see if we have any connections that we might be able to utilize.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#143 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 40 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 22 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 16 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Quoted 7 lines

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

Signature · 2 lines
Jarod Wilson
[email protected]
#144 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 4 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 1 line · Andy Walls

On Thu, 2009-11-26 at 12:05 -0200, Mauro Carvalho Chehab wrote:

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

That's good!

Cheers,
Mauro.

#145 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jarod Wilson
Quoted 63 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 40 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 22 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 20 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

OK. Thanks for having some professionals take a look. (I'm assuming that's the only patent.)

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Regards,
Andy

maintainer
#146 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 79 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 63 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 40 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 22 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 9 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 20 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

OK. Thanks for having some professionals take a look. (I'm assuming that's the only patent.)

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Quoted 8 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)? Like I said, I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device. Applications expect to query device capabilities and expect them to stay somewhat stable (we do support keymap change but I don't think anyone expectes flip-flopping).

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#172 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 69 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 60 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 37 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 20 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 20 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

Quoted 5 lines

OK. Thanks for having some professionals take a look. (I'm assuming that's the only patent.)

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Good! Please, try to design the decoder as an independent module that gets data from a kfifo and generate scancodes for the input API.

Quoted 7 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

IMO, the better is, by default, to open just one input device per IR receiver.

Quoted 1 line

From what I understand from our discussions, if the user wants to filter IR

commands into several input interfaces, some userspace interface will be provided to allow the creation of other input interfaces for that purpose.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#147 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 84 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 74 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 60 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 37 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 20 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 20 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

OK. Thanks for having some professionals take a look. (I'm assuming that's the only patent.)

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Quoted 8 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Quoted 7 lines

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)? Like I said, I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device. Applications expect to query device capabilities and expect them to stay somewhat stable (we do support keymap change but I don't think anyone expectes flip-flopping).

With RC-5, you have no fields describing the remote. So, all the driver could do is an educated guess.

Quoted 1 line

From a quick look I did at the RC-6 Mode 6A docs I found, I suspect that

you can distinguish two different remotes when someone press a key there.

However, I don't think it is a good idea to automatically create a new interface every time a different vendor is detected. Maybe the user simply have a RC-6 IR to control his TV and doesn't have any intention on using that device on his computer.

IMO, the better is to have an API to allow creation of multiple interfaces per IR receiver, based on some scancode matching table and/or on some matching mask.

It should be possible to use the filter API to match different IR's by vendor/product on protocols that supports it, or to match address/command tuples on protocols where you just have those fields.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#151 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 10 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 3 lines

Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK. With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes. However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Any one vendor usually picks one address for their bundled remote. Hauppaugue uses address 0x1e for it's RC-5 remotes AFAICT.

Quoted 4 lines

Applications
expect to query device capabilities and expect them to stay somewhat stable (we do support keymap change but I don't think anyone expectes flip-flopping).

OK.

#173 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 4 lines · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-12-07 at 13:19 -0500, Jarod Wilson wrote:

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Good! Please, try to design the decoder as an independent module that gets data from a kfifo and generate scancodes for the input API.

Hmmm. Let me see how the protoype turns out keeping that design objective in mind. I've already got the current RC-5 and NEC decoding state machines in cx23885-input a bit layered, but they are taking advantage of specific events signaled by my v4l2_subdev implementation.

Strictly speaking the state machines don't have to. All of the remote protocols I have played with make framing pretty easy.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 5 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

IMO, the better is, by default, to open just one input device per IR receiver.

Quoted 1 line

From what I understand from our discussions, if the user wants to filter IR

commands into several input interfaces, some userspace interface will be provided to allow the creation of other input interfaces for that purpose.

Hmm. That's not what I just thought I read from Dmitry....

Oh well. If I don'y get it done by 24 Dec, it'll be in the new year.

Regards,
Andy

#152 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 23 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 10 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Incoming scancodes are matched against all of the loaded maps and a keycode event is generated if a match occurs.

This illustrates why there should an EV_IR event which communicates scancodes, without this event you can't see the scancodes that don't match a map entry. A scancode would be first matched against the map, then if there as no match an EV_IR event would be reported.

Quoted 18 lines

Any one vendor usually picks one address for their bundled remote. Hauppaugue uses address 0x1e for it's RC-5 remotes AFAICT.

Quoted 4 lines

 Applications
expect to query device capabilities and expect them to stay somewhat stable (we do support keymap change but I don't think anyone expectes flip-flopping).

OK.

--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#162 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 14 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 13 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 11 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK. With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes. However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Any one vendor usually picks one address for their bundled remote. Hauppaugue uses address 0x1e for it's RC-5 remotes AFAICT.

The address field on RC-5 protocol is not meant to distinguish different vendors, but different "applications". It identifies that a code should be sent to a TV or a VCR, or a DVD or a SAT.

In the case of bundled IR's, some vendors like Hauppauge opted to use a reserved address to avoid conflicts with other equipments. It happens that vendor's "reserved address" can be different between two different vendors, but is just an educated guess to say that an address equal to 0x1e is Hauppauge.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#153 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 29 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK. With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes. However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Quoted 2 lines

Incoming scancodes are matched against all of the loaded maps and a keycode event is generated if a match occurs.

s/all of the loaded maps/all of the loaded maps per device/

You may have more than one IR receiver on a given machine.

IMO, we may have a mask filter matching also, associated with each keycode table, to minimize the keycode seek time. Something like:

if (scancode & scancode_mask)
check_scancode()

Quoted 4 lines

This illustrates why there should an EV_IR event which communicates scancodes, without this event you can't see the scancodes that don't match a map entry. A scancode would be first matched against the map, then if there as no match an EV_IR event would be reported.

There's nothing wrong on receiving a scancode that won't map. This can simply be an event that you don't want to handle (for example, an IR code sent to user's TV set).

IMO, the better is to provide this scancode at KERN_DEBUG (if debug is enabled), and via an "observer" program.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#163 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 22 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 14 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 13 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 11 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 1 line

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 4 lines

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field. My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

However, I prefer a different scheme for splitting the signals apart. Load separate maps containing scancodes for each address. When the IR signals come in they are matched against the maps and a keycode is generated when a match is found. Now there is no need to distinguish between the remotes. It doesn't matter which remote generated the signal.

scancode RC5/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.
scancode RC5/7/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 2.

Using the maps to split the commands out also fixes the problem with Sony remotes which use multiple protocols to control a single device. scancode Sony12/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to power_on on interface 1.
scancode Sony15/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.

Quoted 29 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 4 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

Quoted 7 lines

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Any one vendor usually picks one address for their bundled remote. Hauppaugue uses address 0x1e for it's RC-5 remotes AFAICT.

The address field on RC-5 protocol is not meant to distinguish different vendors, but different "applications". It identifies that a code should be sent to a TV or a VCR, or a DVD or a SAT.

In the case of bundled IR's, some vendors like Hauppauge opted to use a reserved address to avoid conflicts with other equipments. It happens that vendor's "reserved address" can be different between two different vendors, but is just an educated guess to say that an address equal to 0x1e is Hauppauge.

Cheers,
Mauro.
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#164 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 21 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 19 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 18 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field. My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

Quoted 12 lines

However, I prefer a different scheme for splitting the signals apart. Load separate maps containing scancodes for each address. When the IR signals come in they are matched against the maps and a keycode is generated when a match is found. Now there is no need to distinguish between the remotes. It doesn't matter which remote generated the signal.

scancode RC5/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.
scancode RC5/7/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 2.

Quoted 7 lines

Using the maps to split the commands out also fixes the problem with Sony remotes which use multiple protocols to control a single device. scancode Sony12/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to power_on on interface 1.
scancode Sony15/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.

I agree.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#154 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 36 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 29 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Quoted 5 lines

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Each IR receiver device driver would have a built-in keymap for the remote bundled with it. When you load the driver it will poke the input system and install the map. Any additional keymaps would get loaded from user space. You would load one keymap per input device.

You might have 89 maps in the kernel with each map being built into the device driver for those 89 IR receivers. But you'll only own one or two of those devices so only one or two of the 89 maps will load. Building the map for the bundled receiver into the device driver is an important part of achieving "just works".

I suspect we'll have a 1,000 maps defined after ten years, most of these maps will be loaded from user space. But you'll only have two or three loaded at any one time into your kernel. You need one map per input device created. These maps are tiny, less than 1KB.

Having all of these maps is the price of allowing everyone to use any more that they please. If you force the use of universal remotes most of the maps can be eliminated.

Quoted 29 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Incoming scancodes are matched against all of the loaded maps and a keycode event is generated if a match occurs.

s/all of the loaded maps/all of the loaded maps per device/

You may have more than one IR receiver on a given machine.

IMO, we may have a mask filter matching also, associated with each keycode table, to minimize the keycode seek time. Something like:

       if (scancode & scancode_mask)
               check_scancode()

Quoted 4 lines

This illustrates why there should an EV_IR event which communicates scancodes, without this event you can't see the scancodes that don't match a map entry. A scancode would be first matched against the map, then if there as no match an EV_IR event would be reported.

There's nothing wrong on receiving a scancode that won't map. This can simply be an event that you don't want to handle (for example, an IR code sent to user's TV set).

IMO, the better is to provide this scancode at KERN_DEBUG (if debug is enabled), and via an "observer" program.

Cheers,
Mauro.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#148 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 2 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

With RC-5, you have no fields describing the remote. So, all the driver could do is an educated guess.

It can't even do that, e.g. single remotes (even the dumb ones) can send different code groups (addresses) for different keys.

Quoted 3 lines

IMO, the better is to have an API to allow creation of multiple interfaces per IR receiver, based on some scancode matching table and/or on some matching mask.

I think setting the keytables for each logical device would do.

I.e. just have a way to create additional logical devices. Each can have its own keytable. The decoders would send their output to all logical remotes, trying to match the tables etc.

Quoted 2 lines

It should be possible to use the filter API to match different IR's by vendor/product on protocols that supports it,

That would mean unnecessary limiting.

Quoted 2 lines

or to match address/command
tuples on protocols where you just have those fields.

Precisely.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#155 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 53 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 34 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK. With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes. However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Quoted 5 lines

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Each IR receiver device driver would have a built-in keymap for the remote bundled with it. When you load the driver it will poke the input system and install the map. Any additional keymaps would get loaded from user space. You would load one keymap per input device.

You might have 89 maps in the kernel with each map being built into the device driver for those 89 IR receivers. But you'll only own one or two of those devices so only one or two of the 89 maps will load. Building the map for the bundled receiver into the device driver is an important part of achieving "just works".

Quoted 8 lines

I suspect we'll have a 1,000 maps defined after ten years, most of these maps will be loaded from user space. But you'll only have two or three loaded at any one time into your kernel. You need one map per input device created. These maps are tiny, less than 1KB.

Having all of these maps is the price of allowing everyone to use any more that they please. If you force the use of universal remotes most of the maps can be eliminated.

Makes sense. Yet, I would add an option at Kbuild to create a module or not with the bundled IR keymaps.

So, it should be possible to have all of them completely on userspace or having them at kernelspace.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#165 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 27 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 26 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 23 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 10 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field.  My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

You have a multi-function remote. Multi-function remotes combine multiple single function remotes into a single device. All universal remotes I have seen are multi-function. They usually combine three to five single function remotes.

Yours is a two function remote <TV> and <SAT>. When you push <TV> and <SAT> you are changing which single function remote is being emulated. That's why those keys don't send codes. When writing code you should think of this remote as being two indpendent virtual remotes, not a single one.

Note that it is common for multfunction remotes to completely change IR protocol families when you switch which single function remote you are emulating. I have my universal set for a Sony TV , JVC DVD player and a Comcast STB. All three of those use different IR protocols.

By using maps containing the two different addresses for <TV> and <SAT> you can split these commands onto two different evdev devices.

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

Quoted 26 lines
Quoted 13 lines

However, I prefer a different scheme for splitting the signals apart. Load separate maps containing scancodes for each address. When the IR signals come in they are matched against the maps and a keycode is generated when a match is found. Now there is no need to distinguish between the remotes. It doesn't matter which remote generated the signal.

scancode RC5/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.
scancode RC5/7/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 2.

Quoted 7 lines

Using the maps to split the commands out also fixes the problem with Sony remotes which use multiple protocols to control a single device. scancode Sony12/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to power_on on interface 1.
scancode Sony15/12/1 - protocol, address, command tuplet. Map this to KP_1 on interface 1.

I agree.

Cheers,
Mauro.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#149 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 6 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab

IMO, the better is to have an API to allow creation of multiple interfaces per IR receiver, based on some scancode matching table and/or on some matching mask.

I think setting the keytables for each logical device would do.

Yes.

Quoted 9 lines

I.e. just have a way to create additional logical devices. Each can have its own keytable. The decoders would send their output to all logical remotes, trying to match the tables etc.

Quoted 2 lines

It should be possible to use the filter API to match different IR's by vendor/product on protocols that supports it,

That would mean unnecessary limiting.

If the mask is (unsigned)-1, it will not add any limit. This should be the default.

The advantage of the mask is that you can speedup the keycode decoding by not calling a seek routine in the cases where it doesn't make sense.

Also, the cost of scancode & scancode_mask is cheap enough, comparing with the potential optimization gain of not seeking a data in a table that wouldn't match anyway.

Also, the IR core may automatically generate such mask, by doing an "and" operation of all the scancodes at the table during table initialization/changes. If the mask is zero, it defaults to use a (unsigned) -1 mask.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#156 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 63 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 53 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 34 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Quoted 5 lines

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Each IR receiver device driver would have a built-in keymap for the remote bundled with it. When you load the driver it will poke the input system and install the map. Any additional keymaps would get loaded from user space. You would load one keymap per input device.

You might have 89 maps in the kernel with each map being built into the device driver for those 89 IR receivers. But you'll only own one or two of those devices so only one or two of the 89 maps will load. Building the map for the bundled receiver into the device driver is an important part of achieving "just works".

Quoted 8 lines

I suspect we'll have a 1,000 maps defined after ten years, most of these maps will be loaded from user space. But you'll only have two or three loaded at any one time into your kernel. You need one map per input device created. These maps are tiny, less than 1KB.

Having all of these maps is the price of allowing everyone to use any more that they please. If you force the use of universal remotes most of the maps can be eliminated.

Quoted 5 lines

Makes sense. Yet, I would add an option at Kbuild to create a module or not with the bundled IR keymaps.

So, it should be possible to have all of them completely on userspace or having them at kernelspace.

Removing the maps for the bundled remotes from the receiver device drivers will break "just works". The map will be in an __init section of the IR device driver. When it is fed into the input system a RAM based structure will be created. If you really want the 1KB memory back, use sysfs to remove the default map. An embedded system will have a bundled remote so it is going to want the map. If you want to change the default map loading a new map will release the memory from the previous map.

Quoted 4 lines

Cheers,
Mauro.

Signature · 2 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
#166 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 31 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 29 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 15 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 14 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 13 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 11 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field. My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

You have a multi-function remote.

Yes.

Quoted 3 lines

That's why those keys don't send codes. When writing code you should think of this remote as being two indpendent virtual remotes, not a single one.

Not really. I may think on it as a single device and use the two groups of functions to control two aspects at the same application.

For example, I may map the <TV> group on kaffeine for DVB reception and the <SAT> group for DVD (well, probably, in this case, I'll use an IR with <TV> and <DVD> keys, instead ;) ).

Quoted 2 lines

By using maps containing the two different addresses for <TV> and <SAT> you can split these commands onto two different evdev devices.

True. I can do it, but I can opt to have both mapped as one evdev device as well. This will basically depend on how I want to mount my environment.

Quoted 5 lines

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

It is very common to have such remotes bundled with multimedia devices.

An unsolved question on my mind is how should we map such IR's? Should we provide a way for them to emulate a multifunction IR (for example, after pressing TV key, subsequent keystrokes would be directed to the TV evdev device?), or should we let this up to some userspace app to handle this case?

Cheers,
Mauro.

#157 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 63 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 61 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 60 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 34 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK. With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes. However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Quoted 5 lines

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Each IR receiver device driver would have a built-in keymap for the remote bundled with it. When you load the driver it will poke the input system and install the map. Any additional keymaps would get loaded from user space. You would load one keymap per input device.

You might have 89 maps in the kernel with each map being built into the device driver for those 89 IR receivers. But you'll only own one or two of those devices so only one or two of the 89 maps will load. Building the map for the bundled receiver into the device driver is an important part of achieving "just works".

I suspect we'll have a 1,000 maps defined after ten years, most of these maps will be loaded from user space. But you'll only have two or three loaded at any one time into your kernel. You need one map per input device created. These maps are tiny, less than 1KB.

Having all of these maps is the price of allowing everyone to use any more that they please. If you force the use of universal remotes most of the maps can be eliminated.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines

Makes sense. Yet, I would add an option at Kbuild to create a module or not with the bundled IR keymaps.

So, it should be possible to have all of them completely on userspace or having them at kernelspace.

Removing the maps for the bundled remotes from the receiver device drivers will break "just works".

No. This can be provided by an udev application that will load the keytable when the device is connected.

Of course before adding it into a module, we'll need to write such app.

This will only affects the need of IR during boot time.

Quoted 3 lines

The map will be in an __init section
of the IR device driver. When it is fed into the input system a RAM based structure will be created.

We can't use __init, since another device needing the keymap may be hot-plugged.

Quoted 3 lines

If you really want the 1KB memory
back, use sysfs to remove the default map. An embedded system will have a bundled remote so it is going to want the map.

Yes, but it needs just one map, not all of them. The maps shouldn't be linked into the drivers, as the same map is used by several different devices on different drivers. So, the option is to allow customizing the available keymaps, if CONFIG_EMBEDDED.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#167 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 64 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 31 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 29 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 15 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 14 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 13 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 11 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field.  My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

You have a multi-function remote.

Yes.

Quoted 3 lines

That's why those keys don't send codes. When writing code you should think of this remote as being two indpendent virtual remotes, not a single one.

Not really. I may think on it as a single device and use the two groups of functions to control two aspects at the same application.

For example, I may map the <TV> group on kaffeine for DVB reception and the <SAT> group for DVD (well, probably, in this case, I'll use an IR with <TV> and <DVD> keys, instead ;) ).

Quoted 2 lines

By using maps containing the two different addresses for <TV> and <SAT> you can split these commands onto two different evdev devices.

True. I can do it, but I can opt to have both mapped as one evdev device as well. This will basically depend on how I want to mount my environment.

Quoted 5 lines

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

Quoted 6 lines

It is very common to have such remotes bundled with multimedia devices.

An unsolved question on my mind is how should we map such IR's? Should we provide a way for them to emulate a multifunction IR (for example, after pressing TV key, subsequent keystrokes would be directed to the TV evdev device?), or should we let this up to some userspace app to handle this case?

Splitting them into multiple devices requires remembering state and scripting so it needs to be done in user space. If the user wants to control a radio app and a home automation app they need to choose. Keep the bundled remote and do some non-trivial scripting or buy a universal remote.

Universal remotes make it much easier to achieve "just works".

The IR core can contain default universal profiles for various classes of devices. Say Morotola_DVR and SciAtlanta_DVR. The core would check if the receiver is cable of receiving these profiles before loading them. There would be ten of these default universal profiles at most and you can unload them from RAM if they aren't needed.

Now Myth can have a menu with three remote choices:
Universal Morotola_DVR
Universal SciAtlanta_DVR
Bundled

The Bundled choice came from the map built into the IR receiver's device driver. The other two choices were loaded by the IR core after ensuring that the hardware could receive from a universal remote.

The core would also load a couple of default radio profiles
Univeral SonyDR112_RADIO
Univeral OnkyoTX8255_RADIO
Same for automation and mouse/keyboard emulation.

Myth looks in sysfs and builds a menu containing DVR devices and all bundled entries. First app to open the "Bundled" device gets to keep it.

These apps could take "just works" even farther. When they start up they could listen on all three evdev devices: Morotola_DVR,
SciAtlanta_DVR, Bundled. And then if you find Myth responding to
unwanted commands you could disable the unwanted profiles by deselecting them in the Myth UI.

All of this may seem complicated to build, but the purpose is to create an environment where a non-technical user can get an IR remote working without needing detailed knowledge about how IR protocols work.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#158 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 67 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 66 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 64 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 52 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 34 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 20 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 5 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Quoted 5 lines

No, please. We currently have already 89 different keymaps in-kernel. Creating 89 different interfaces per IR receiver is not useful at all.

IMO, the interfaces should be created as the keymaps are associated to an specific IR receiver.

Each IR receiver device driver would have a built-in keymap for the remote bundled with it. When you load the driver it will poke the input system and install the map. Any additional keymaps would get loaded from user space. You would load one keymap per input device.

You might have 89 maps in the kernel with each map being built into the device driver for those 89 IR receivers. But you'll only own one or two of those devices so only one or two of the 89 maps will load. Building the map for the bundled receiver into the device driver is an important part of achieving "just works".

Quoted 8 lines

I suspect we'll have a 1,000 maps defined after ten years, most of these maps will be loaded from user space. But you'll only have two or three loaded at any one time into your kernel. You need one map per input device created. These maps are tiny, less than 1KB.

Having all of these maps is the price of allowing everyone to use any more that they please. If you force the use of universal remotes most of the maps can be eliminated.

Makes sense. Yet, I would add an option at Kbuild to create a module or not with the bundled IR keymaps.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

So, it should be possible to have all of them completely on userspace or having them at kernelspace.

Removing the maps for the bundled remotes from the receiver device drivers will break "just works".

No. This can be provided by an udev application that will load the keytable when the device is connected.

Why do you want to pull the 1KB default mapping table out of the device driver __init section and more it to a udev script? Now we will have to maintain a parallel udev script for ever receiver's device driver.

The purpose of putting this table into __init is to get rid of all these udev scripts in the default case.

Quoted 10 lines

Of course before adding it into a module, we'll need to write such app.

This will only affects the need of IR during boot time.

Quoted 3 lines

The map will be in an __init section
of the IR device driver. When it is fed into the input system a RAM based structure will be created.

We can't use __init, since another device needing the keymap may be hot-plugged.

You can handle that with __devinit

Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines

If you really want the 1KB memory
back, use sysfs to remove the default map.  An embedded system will have a bundled remote so it is going to want the map.

Yes, but it needs just one map, not all of them. The maps shouldn't be linked into the drivers, as the same map is used by several different devices on

Link them or #include them, it doesn't make any difference.

Quoted 6 lines

different drivers. So, the option is to allow customizing the available keymaps, if CONFIG_EMBEDDED.

Cheers,
Mauro.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#171 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 5 lines · Jon Smirl

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

Quoted 5 lines

An unsolved question on my mind is how should we map such IR's? Should we provide a way for them to emulate a multifunction IR (for example, after pressing TV key, subsequent keystrokes would be directed to the TV evdev device?), or should we let this up to some userspace app to handle this case?

This case feels similar to that of Caps Lock, Num Lock and Scrool Lock, but I don't know if that scheme could be applied here.

Signature · 2 lines
Regards,
Feri.
#168 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 63 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 61 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 26 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 25 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 23 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 10 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes. RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field. My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

You have a multi-function remote.

Yes.

Quoted 3 lines

That's why those keys don't send codes. When writing code you should think of this remote as being two indpendent virtual remotes, not a single one.

Not really. I may think on it as a single device and use the two groups of functions to control two aspects at the same application.

For example, I may map the <TV> group on kaffeine for DVB reception and the <SAT> group for DVD (well, probably, in this case, I'll use an IR with <TV> and <DVD> keys, instead ;) ).

Quoted 2 lines

By using maps containing the two different addresses for <TV> and <SAT> you can split these commands onto two different evdev devices.

True. I can do it, but I can opt to have both mapped as one evdev device as well. This will basically depend on how I want to mount my environment.

Quoted 5 lines

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

It is very common to have such remotes bundled with multimedia devices.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

An unsolved question on my mind is how should we map such IR's? Should we provide a way for them to emulate a multifunction IR (for example, after pressing TV key, subsequent keystrokes would be directed to the TV evdev device?), or should we let this up to some userspace app to handle this case?

Splitting them into multiple devices requires remembering state and scripting so it needs to be done in user space.

It shouldn't be hard to do it in kernelspace, since you'll need to have one evdev interface associated with the IR anyway, but this will add some extra complexity at the scancode->keycode conversion, but I'm wandering if we should do it or not.

Maybe the better is to not do it in kernelspace, to avoid adding there an extra complexity that can easily be done in userspace.

Quoted 4 lines

If the user wants to
control a radio app and a home automation app they need to choose. Keep the bundled remote and do some non-trivial scripting or buy a universal remote.

Ok, but using the shipped IR even without a separate address group for different applications, and having it controlling radio app and tv app (not simultaneously) should not be hard, but I LIRC already covers such usecase, so maybe we don't need to worry about it.

Quoted 1 line

Universal remotes make it much easier to achieve "just works".

True.

Quoted 11 lines

The IR core can contain default universal profiles for various classes of devices. Say Morotola_DVR and SciAtlanta_DVR. The core would check if the receiver is cable of receiving these profiles before loading them. There would be ten of these default universal profiles at most and you can unload them from RAM if they aren't needed.

Now Myth can have a menu with three remote choices:
Universal Morotola_DVR
Universal SciAtlanta_DVR
Bundled

Quoted 8 lines

The Bundled choice came from the map built into the IR receiver's device driver. The other two choices were loaded by the IR core after ensuring that the hardware could receive from a universal remote.

The core would also load a couple of default radio profiles
Univeral SonyDR112_RADIO
Univeral OnkyoTX8255_RADIO
Same for automation and mouse/keyboard emulation.

Agreed.

Quoted 3 lines

Myth looks in sysfs and builds a menu containing DVR devices and all bundled entries. First app to open the "Bundled" device gets to keep it.

Myth (or other userspace apps) don't need to to that, since we've standardized the keycode actions (see the IR chapter of the media DocBook). It just needs to support the keycodes already defined, for the common case.

Quoted 5 lines

These apps could take "just works" even farther. When they start up they could listen on all three evdev devices: Morotola_DVR,
SciAtlanta_DVR, Bundled. And then if you find Myth responding to
unwanted commands you could disable the unwanted profiles by deselecting them in the Myth UI.

I don't like the idea of automatically loading 3 different keycodes at the same time. You may have overlaps between different keycode tables. The better is to have some userspace GUI that will allow the user to select what keycode table(s) he want to be available, if he decides to not use the bundled IR.

The same applies to applications: if you have 3 keymaps loaded, is because you want do do different things with the 3 keymaps (like using keymap 1 for kaffeine, keymap 2 for mplayer, keymap 3 for mythtv).

So, IR-aware applications should have a setup interface to specify what IR keycodes are relevant to that particular application, and how to associate an evdev interface to an specific group of functions (for applications that supports several different types of media, like MythTV and Kaffeine, where you'll end by having a "TV" keymap/evdev, a "Radio" keymap/evdev, a "CD/DVD" Keymap/evdev, etc).

Btw, if we're doing that, IMO, we should have an string sysfs alias attribute, to allow associating the userspace application to an specific keymap alias (like "radio", "tv", etc.).

Quoted 4 lines

All of this may seem complicated to build, but the purpose is to create an environment where a non-technical user can get an IR remote working without needing detailed knowledge about how IR protocols work.

IMO, this is an important requisite to fulfill.

Cheers,
Mauro.

maintainer
#150 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 103 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 84 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 74 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 60 lines · Jarod Wilson
Quoted 37 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 20 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 8 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 3 lines · Andy Walls

I would also note that RC-6 Mode 6A, used by most MCE remotes, was developed by Philips, but Microsoft has some sort of licensing interest in it and it is almost surely encumbered somwhow:

I don't know about legal problems in some countries but from the technical POV handling the protocol in the kernel is more efficient or (/and) simpler.

A software licensing from Microsoft won't apply to Linux kernel, so I'm assuming that you're referring to some patent that they could be filled about RC6 mode 6A.

I don't know if is there any US patent pending about it (AFAIK, only US accepts software patents), but there are some prior-art for IR key decoding. So, I don't see what "innovation" RC6 would be adding. If it is some new way to transmit waves, the patent issues aren't related to software, and the device manufacturer had already handled it when they made their devices.

Quoted 7 lines

If it is just a new keytable, this issue
could be easily solved by loading the keytable via userspace.

Also, assuming that you can use the driver only with a hardware that comes with a licensed software, the user has already the license for using it.

Do you have any details on what patents they are claiming?

The US Philips RC-6 patent is US Patent 5,877,702

http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT5877702

Click on download PDF to get a copy of the whole patent.

I am not a lawyer. Philips claims' all appear to tie to a transmitter or receiver as part of a system, but most of the claims are about information and bit positions and lengths.

...

Quoted 20 lines

IMO, given

a. the dearth of public information about RC-6, indicating someone thinks it's their trade secret or intellectual property

b. Microsoft claiming to license something related to the MCE remote protocols (which are obviously RC-6 Mode 6A),

c. my inability to draw a "clear, bright line" that RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding, as needed by MCE remotes, implemented in software doesn't violate anyone's government granted rights to exclusivity.

I think it's much better to implement software RC-6 Mode 6A encoding and decoding in user space, doing only the minimum needed to get the hardware setup and going in the kernel.

Encoding/decoding of RC-6 by microcontrollers with firmware doesn't worry me.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Maybe I'm being too conservative here, but I have a personal interest in keeping Linux free and unencumbered even in the US which, I cannot deny, has a patent system that is screwed up.

So I had one of the people who does all the license and patent audits for Fedora packages look at the Philips patent on RC-6. He's 100% positive that the patent *only* covers hardware, there should be no problem whatsoever writing a software decoder for RC-6.

OK. Thanks for having some professionals take a look. (I'm assuming that's the only patent.)

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Quoted 8 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Quoted 7 lines

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)? Like I said, I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device. Applications expect to query device capabilities and expect them to stay somewhat stable (we do support keymap change but I don't think anyone expectes flip-flopping).

With RC-5, you have no fields describing the remote. So, all the driver could do is an educated guess.

From a quick look I did at the RC-6 Mode 6A docs I found, I suspect that you can distinguish two different remotes when someone press a key there.

However, I don't think it is a good idea to automatically create a new interface every time a different vendor is detected. Maybe the user simply have a RC-6 IR to control his TV and doesn't have any intention on using that device on his computer.

Quoted 8 lines

IMO, the better is to have an API to allow creation of multiple interfaces per IR receiver, based on some scancode matching table and/or on some matching mask.

It should be possible to use the filter API to match different IR's by vendor/product on protocols that supports it, or to match address/command tuples on protocols where you just have those fields.

OK, fair enough.

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
maintainer
#161 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 33 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 23 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 10 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 3 lines

 Like I said,
I think the preferred way is to represent every remote that can be distinguished from each other as a separate input device.

OK.  With RC-5, NEC, and RC-6 at least there is also an address or system byte or word to distingish different remotes.  However creating multiple input devices on the fly for detected remotes would be madness
- especially with a decoding error in the address bits.

Quoted 9 lines

I agree that creating devices on the fly has problems. Another solution is to create one device for each map that is loaded. There would be a couple built-in maps for bundled remotes - each would create a device. Then the user could load more maps with each map creating a device.

Incoming scancodes are matched against all of the loaded maps and a keycode event is generated if a match occurs.

How many sancodes do we need to reliably recognize the device though? I am not sure users would want to press 5 random buttons in order to start using the remote, unless it happens exactly once and then we manage to store the data somewhere.

Quoted 4 lines

This illustrates why there should an EV_IR event which communicates scancodes, without this event you can't see the scancodes that don't match a map entry. A scancode would be first matched against the map, then if there as no match an EV_IR event would be reported.

Just report MSC_SCAN always. As I said elsewhere we can extend it to be multi-dword if needed (just need to agree on endianness).

Signature · 5 lines
Dmitry
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
maintainer
#174 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Andy Walls
Quoted 28 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 8 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 4 lines · Andy Walls

On Mon, 2009-12-07 at 13:19 -0500, Jarod Wilson wrote:

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

Good! Please, try to design the decoder as an independent module that gets data from a kfifo and generate scancodes for the input API.

Hmmm. Let me see how the protoype turns out keeping that design objective in mind. I've already got the current RC-5 and NEC decoding state machines in cx23885-input a bit layered, but they are taking advantage of specific events signaled by my v4l2_subdev implementation.

Strictly speaking the state machines don't have to. All of the remote protocols I have played with make framing pretty easy.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 7 lines

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once. The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

IMO, the better is, by default, to open just one input device per IR receiver.

Quoted 1 line

From what I understand from our discussions, if the user wants to filter IR

commands into several input interfaces, some userspace interface will be provided to allow the creation of other input interfaces for that purpose.

Hmm. That's not what I just thought I read from Dmitry....

I am a resonable guy ;) In cases when we can certainly say that there are 2 separate remotes (and we know characteristics somehow) we need to create 2 input devices. Otherwise we can't ;)

Signature · 1 line
Dmitry
#169 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 130 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 63 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 61 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 28 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 26 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 25 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 23 lines · Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Quoted 10 lines · Andy Walls
Quoted 9 lines · Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 8 lines · Andy Walls

So I'll whip up an RC-6 Mode 6A decoder for cx23885-input.c before the end of the month.

I can setup the CX2388[58] hardware to look for both RC-5 and RC-6 with a common set of parameters, so I may be able to set up the decoders to handle decoding from two different remote types at once.  The HVR boards can ship with either type of remote AFAIK.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines

I wonder if I can flip the keytables on the fly or if I have to create two different input devices?

Can you distinguish between the 2 remotes (not receivers)?

Yes.  RC-6 and RC-5 are different enough to distinguish between the two. (Honestly I could pile on more protocols that have similar pulse time periods, but that's complexity for no good reason and I don't know of a vendor that bundles 3 types of remotes per TV card.)

You'll be distinguishing the protocol, not the remote. If I understood Dmitry's question, he is asking if you can distinguish between two different remotes that may, for example, be using both RC-5 or both RC-6 or one RC-5 and another RC-6.

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

RC-5 and RC-6 both contain an address field.  My opinion is that different addresses represent different devices and in general they should appear on an input devices per address.

The same IR can produce two different addresses. The IR bundled with my satellite STB produces two different codes, depending if you previously pressed <TV> or <SAT> key (in fact, I think it can even produce different protocols for TV, as it can be configured to work with different TV sets).

You have a multi-function remote.

Yes.

Quoted 3 lines

That's why those keys don't send codes. When writing code you should think of this remote as being two indpendent virtual remotes, not a single one.

Not really. I may think on it as a single device and use the two groups of functions to control two aspects at the same application.

For example, I may map the <TV> group on kaffeine for DVB reception and the <SAT> group for DVD (well, probably, in this case, I'll use an IR with <TV> and <DVD> keys, instead ;) ).

Quoted 2 lines

By using maps containing the two different addresses for <TV> and <SAT> you can split these commands onto two different evdev devices.

True. I can do it, but I can opt to have both mapped as one evdev device as well. This will basically depend on how I want to mount my environment.

Quoted 5 lines

This model is complicated by the fact that some remotes that look like multi-function remotes aren't really multifunction. The remote bundled with the MS MCE receiver is one. That remote is a single function device even though it has function buttons for TV, Music, Pictures, etc.

It is very common to have such remotes bundled with multimedia devices.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines

An unsolved question on my mind is how should we map such IR's? Should we provide a way for them to emulate a multifunction IR (for example, after pressing TV key, subsequent keystrokes would be directed to the TV evdev device?), or should we let this up to some userspace app to handle this case?

Splitting them into multiple devices requires remembering state and scripting so it needs to be done in user space.

It shouldn't be hard to do it in kernelspace, since you'll need to have one evdev interface associated with the IR anyway, but this will add some extra complexity at the scancode->keycode conversion, but I'm wandering if we should do it or not.

Maybe the better is to not do it in kernelspace, to avoid adding there an extra complexity that can easily be done in userspace.

Quoted 4 lines

If the user wants to
control a radio app and a home automation app they need to choose. Keep the bundled remote and do some non-trivial scripting or buy a universal remote.

Ok, but using the shipped IR even without a separate address group for different applications, and having it controlling radio app and tv app (not simultaneously) should not be hard, but I LIRC already covers such usecase, so maybe we don't need to worry about it.

Quoted 1 line

Universal remotes make it much easier to achieve "just works".

True.

Quoted 11 lines

The IR core can contain default universal profiles for various classes of devices. Say Morotola_DVR and SciAtlanta_DVR. The core would check if the receiver is cable of receiving these profiles before loading them. There would be ten of these default universal profiles at most and you can unload them from RAM if they aren't needed.

Now Myth can have a menu with three remote choices:
 Universal Morotola_DVR
 Universal SciAtlanta_DVR
 Bundled

Quoted 8 lines

The Bundled choice came from the map built into the IR receiver's device driver. The other two choices were loaded by the IR core after ensuring that the hardware could receive from a universal remote.

The core would also load a couple of default radio profiles Univeral SonyDR112_RADIO
 Univeral OnkyoTX8255_RADIO
Same for automation and mouse/keyboard emulation.

Agreed.

Quoted 3 lines

Myth looks in sysfs and builds a menu containing DVR devices and all bundled entries. First app to open the "Bundled" device gets to keep it.

Myth (or other userspace apps) don't need to to that, since we've standardized the keycode actions (see the IR chapter of the media DocBook). It just needs to support the keycodes already defined, for the common case.

Quoted 5 lines

These apps could take "just works" even farther. When they start up they could listen on all three evdev devices:  Morotola_DVR, SciAtlanta_DVR,   Bundled. And then if you find Myth responding to unwanted commands you could disable the unwanted profiles by deselecting them in the Myth UI.

Quoted 5 lines

I don't like the idea of automatically loading 3 different keycodes at the same time. You may have overlaps between different keycode tables. The better is to have some userspace GUI that will allow the user to select what keycode table(s) he want to be available, if he decides to not use the bundled IR.

Of course there is going to be overlap of the keycodes, but not the scancodes. There should be almost 100% overlap.

The three maps are there to support a non-technical user, a sophisticated user will disable two of them. This works because the non-technical user is only going to use one of the three IR device profiles. The other two may be loaded, but the user isn't sending any IR signals that match their maps.

Where this breaks down is if they are using SciAtlanta_DVR to control MythTV and they also happen to have a physical Motorola DVR in the same room. The Linux box is going to pick up the commands meant for the Motorola DVR and both boxes will respond.. In that cause they will need to figure figure out how to disable the Motorola DVR profile. But is a non-technical person likely to have two DVRs in the same room?

Quoted 25 lines

The same applies to applications: if you have 3 keymaps loaded, is because you want do do different things with the 3 keymaps (like using keymap 1 for kaffeine, keymap 2 for mplayer, keymap 3 for mythtv).

So, IR-aware applications should have a setup interface to specify what IR keycodes are relevant to that particular application, and how to associate an evdev interface to an specific group of functions (for applications that supports several different types of media, like MythTV and Kaffeine, where you'll end by having a "TV" keymap/evdev, a "Radio" keymap/evdev, a "CD/DVD" Keymap/evdev, etc).

Btw, if we're doing that, IMO, we should have an string sysfs alias attribute, to allow associating the userspace application to an specific keymap alias (like "radio", "tv", etc.).

Quoted 4 lines

All of this may seem complicated to build, but the purpose is to create an environment where a non-technical user can get an IR remote working without needing detailed knowledge about how IR protocols work.

IMO, this is an important requisite to fulfill.

Cheers,
Mauro.

Signature · 6 lines
Jon Smirl
[email protected]
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-input" in
the body of a message to [email protected]
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
#159 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 4 lines · Jon Smirl

Why do you want to pull the 1KB default mapping table out of the device driver __init section and more it to a udev script? Now we will have to maintain a parallel udev script for ever receiver's device driver.

Of course no. We will need a single program (script etc.) for all devices. And we will need a database of the known remotes (scan and key codes).

Quoted 1 line

You can handle that with __devinit

__devinit is NOP with hot-plug.

Fortunately we don't need the keymaps in the kernel.
For certain uses we may (and may not) need to have one keymap built-in, perhaps something similar to the embedded initrd.

Signature · 1 line
Krzysztof Halasa
#160 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

Quoted 10 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 4 lines · Jon Smirl

Why do you want to pull the 1KB default mapping table out of the device driver __init section and more it to a udev script? Now we will have to maintain a parallel udev script for ever receiver's device driver.

Of course no. We will need a single program (script etc.) for all devices. And we will need a database of the known remotes (scan and key codes).

The keycode database can be easily extracted from kernel drivers by script. I have it already at V4L/DVB development tree.

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line

You can handle that with __devinit

__devinit is NOP with hot-plug.

Fortunately we don't need the keymaps in the kernel.
For certain uses we may (and may not) need to have one keymap built-in, perhaps something similar to the embedded initrd.

I still think the better is to have them in kernel, but compiled only if selected at Kbuild.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#175 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Dmitry Torokhov
Quoted 3 lines · Dmitry Torokhov

I am a resonable guy ;) In cases when we can certainly say that there are 2 separate remotes (and we know characteristics somehow) we need to create 2 input devices. Otherwise we can't ;)

Only on very few specific cases (a few protocols), you can be (almost) sure. Even on this case, universal remotes can fake another IR.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#170 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Jon Smirl
Quoted 8 lines · Jon Smirl
Quoted 5 lines

I don't like the idea of automatically loading 3 different keycodes at the same time. You may have overlaps between different keycode tables. The better is to have some userspace GUI that will allow the user to select what keycode table(s) he want to be available, if he decides to not use the bundled IR.

Of course there is going to be overlap of the keycodes, but not the scancodes. There should be almost 100% overlap.

What prevents users to create overlaps at scancodes? We might add some protection, but, providing that different keycode tables can be used by different applications, why do we need to prevent it?

Quoted 5 lines

The three maps are there to support a non-technical user, a sophisticated user will disable two of them. This works because the non-technical user is only going to use one of the three IR device profiles. The other two may be loaded, but the user isn't sending any IR signals that match their maps.

I doubt you can map all cases with just three profiles.

Quoted 7 lines

Where this breaks down is if they are using SciAtlanta_DVR to control MythTV and they also happen to have a physical Motorola DVR in the same room.
The Linux box is going to pick up the commands meant for the Motorola DVR and both boxes will respond.. In that cause they will need to figure figure out how to disable the Motorola DVR profile.

I used to have a Set Top Box that has some broken code to decode IR. So, sometimes, when I used to press a key on my TV IR, the STB were getting the code, producing a really bad result. That's really bad.

A normal user is able to click on some graphical application and select his IR model. The app may even have some photos or pictures representing the most used IR's. This is better than letting him to to to some forum, asking his friends, etc, trying to figure out why his PC is doing something wrong when he changes a channel on his TV.

Quoted 2 lines

But is a non-technical person likely to have two DVRs in the same room?

Well, I know someone that has an 8 year old children with a setup like this:
a PC monitor that has an IR, and a PC with a TV board also with IR. Of course, both the monitor and the PC are at the same room.

Cheers,
Mauro.

#88 lore raw

Re: [RFC] Should we create a raw input interface for IR's ? - Was: Re: [PATCH 1/3 v2] lirc core device driver infrastructure

In reply to Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 12 lines · Krzysztof Halasa
Quoted 9 lines · Devin Heitmueller

There is an argument to be made that since it may be desirable for both IR receivers and transmitters to share the same table of remote control definitions, it might make sense to at least *consider* how the IR transmitter interface is going to work, even if it is decided to not implement such a design in the first revision.

Personally, I would hate to see a situation where we find out that we took a bad approach because nobody considered what would be required for IR transmitters to reuse the same remote control definition data.

Quoted 5 lines

I briefly though about such possibility, but dismissed it with assumption that we won't transmit the same codes (including "key" codes) that we receive.

Perhaps I'm wrong.

I could definantly see this happening. the computer receives the 'play' button from a dvd remote, issues commands to control the audio system, dim lights, and then sends the 'play' button to the DVD player inside a cabinet where it can't see the remote directly.

but in any case, it shouldn't be hard to share a table of mappings.

David Lang