Skip to contentSkip to conversation

acerhdf: stilll fighting between kernel and BIOS?

DISCUSSION Adrian von Bidder 3 participants 6 messages Nov 20, 2009 – Dec 1, 2009

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Heyho!

With 2.6.31 (as packaged by Debian), kernel and BIOS are still fighting over who controls the fan on my Acer AOA-150.

If the system is idle, I see repeated

Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.224141] acerhdf: temp 51      
Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.272136] acerhdf: fan OFF      
Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.328145] acerhdf: temp 51      
Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.376072] acerhdf: fan OFF      

(and the fan is turned on and off accordingly, using a rather noisy speed for ca. .5s every time.)

As soon as the system gets a bit warmer, fan is running on low speed and the system is much quieter.

ISTR reading that this should have been fixed in 2.6.31, or was that wrong? Did anything change in current kernels or the separate releases of the acerhdf driver? I might be able to run newer driver releases, or at least I can provide more info if desired (and if you're patient to deal with quite slow round trip times from my side. It's not an urgent problem either.)

cheers
-- vbi

Signature · 1 line
featured product: ClamAV Antivirus - http://www.clamav.net/
#1 lore raw

Hey Adrian,

issues with AOA 150 netbooks should be solved with current 2.6.32-git tree. You can also try to use latest acerhdf of http://piie.net

kind regards,
--peter

Quoted 20 lines · Adrian von Bidder

Heyho!

With 2.6.31 (as packaged by Debian), kernel and BIOS are still fighting over who controls the fan on my Acer AOA-150.

If the system is idle, I see repeated

Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.224141] acerhdf: temp 51      Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.272136] acerhdf: fan OFF      Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.328145] acerhdf: temp 51      Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.376072] acerhdf: fan OFF      

(and the fan is turned on and off accordingly, using a rather noisy speed for ca. .5s every time.)

As soon as the system gets a bit warmer, fan is running on low speed and the system is much quieter.

ISTR reading that this should have been fixed in 2.6.31, or was that wrong? Did anything change in current kernels or the separate releases of the acerhdf driver? I might be able to run newer driver releases, or at least I can provide more info if desired (and if you're patient to deal with quite slow round trip times from my side. It's not an urgent problem either.)

cheers
-- vbi

Signature · 1 line
featured product: ClamAV Antivirus - http://www.clamav.net/
#2 lore raw

Heyho!

Quoted 2 lines · On Sunday 22 November 2009 22.27:50 Peter Feuerer wrote:

issues with AOA 150 netbooks should be solved with current 2.6.32-git
tree. You can also try to use latest acerhdf of http://piie.net

Seems to work fine. That was the fix I thought was already included in 2.6.31.

thanks a lot.

-- vbi

Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.224141] acerhdf: temp 51
Nov 20 08:07:12 laeggerli kernel: [100246.272136] acerhdf: fan OFF
Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.328145] acerhdf: temp 51
Nov 20 08:07:22 laeggerli kernel: [100256.376072] acerhdf: fan OFF
Signature · 2 lines
As flies to wanton boys are we to the gods; they kill us for their sport.
		-- Shakespeare, "King Lear"
#3 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Adrian von Bidder

Heyho!

Quoted 2 lines · On Sunday 22 November 2009 22.27:50 Peter Feuerer wrote:

issues with AOA 150 netbooks should be solved with current 2.6.32-git tree. You can also try to use latest acerhdf of http://piie.net

Seems to work fine.  That was the fix I thought was already included in 2.6.31.

Is that commit ded0cdfc6a7673916b0878c32fa8ba566b4f8cdb ("acerhdf: fix fan control for AOA150 model")? Should it go to -stable?

#4 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines · On Monday 23 November 2009 10.58:54 Pekka Enberg wrote:

On Mon, Nov 23, 2009 at 11:17 AM, Adrian von Bidder

Quoted 3 lines · <[email protected]> wrote:

Heyho!

On Sunday 22 November 2009 22.27:50 Peter Feuerer wrote:

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines

issues with AOA 150 netbooks should be solved with current 2.6.32-git
tree. You can also try to use latest acerhdf of http://piie.net

Seems to work fine. That was the fix I thought was already included in 2.6.31.

Is that commit ded0cdfc6a7673916b0878c32fa8ba566b4f8cdb ("acerhdf: fix fan control for AOA150 model")? Should it go to -stable?

Sorry for not answering sooner.

I don't really have time to recompile / test more at this time; in any case, I think it's just a minor annoyance and not what I'd feed into a "fixes only" tree. (I'm not involved in kernel development in any way, but I thought that the stable tree should be quite limited in what goes in?)

cheers
-- vbi

Signature · 3 lines
<towo> Alle schlauen Amerikaner arbeiten bei der NSA,
       und die dürfen nicht mit Ausländern sprechen.
        -- #Debian.DE
#5 lore raw

Adrian von Bidder kirjoitti:

Quoted 9 lines · On Monday 23 November 2009 10.58:54 Pekka Enberg wrote:
Quoted 8 lines

On Mon, Nov 23, 2009 at 11:17 AM, Adrian von Bidder

Quoted 5 lines · <[email protected]> wrote:

Heyho!

Quoted 2 lines · On Sunday 22 November 2009 22.27:50 Peter Feuerer wrote:

issues with AOA 150 netbooks should be solved with current 2.6.32-git
tree. You can also try to use latest acerhdf of http://piie.net

Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 2 lines

Seems to work fine. That was the fix I thought was already included in 2.6.31.

Is that commit ded0cdfc6a7673916b0878c32fa8ba566b4f8cdb ("acerhdf: fix fan control for AOA150 model")? Should it go to -stable?

Sorry for not answering sooner.

I don't really have time to recompile / test more at this time; in any case, I think it's just a minor annoyance and not what I'd feed into a "fixes only" tree. (I'm not involved in kernel development in any way, but I thought that the stable tree should be quite limited in what goes in?)

Your call. The rules of stable are pretty simple: (1) the patch needs to fix a _real_ problem and (2) it needs to be rather small. AFAICT, both apply here.

Pekka