2.6.33.2 does not boot on Atom?
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.
The 2.6.33.2 kernel works fine on a "Pentium(R) Dual-Core CPU E5200 @ 2.50GHz" but on the Atom (Fedora 12) it does not even get to the "uncompressing Linux kernel" message (I have early printk and such). No Grub error, just blank screen with cursor, alt-ctrl-del does not work and power does a hard power-off immediately. Booting other kernels still works, boot partition is 48% full, all image sizes etc seem fine.
So I am really puzzled.. did anything get changed into the very early boot sequence?
Richard
Quoted 6 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.
Oops, that's the problem, you need to do 'make oldconfig' to ensure you didn't miss anything, and to adjust any new defaults.
Have you tried that?
greg k-h
Quoted 10 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 6 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.Oops, that's the problem, you need to do 'make oldconfig' to ensure you didn't miss anything, and to adjust any new defaults.
did not tried that yet. Although it is possible to miss something with menuconfig I did diff the .config files without noticing anything obvious.
Meanwhile I have tried a few recent Fedora-12 kernels and none of them worked on this particular Atom Netbook with which I have never had problems before. With the Fedora kernels the issue appears to be Intel graphics and it seems the boot continued when I blindly typed the dm password.. so I will investigate further. Last Fedora kernel that worked was 2.6.31 based, the 2.6.32.* I tried so far will display a black screen.
Richard
Quoted 10 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 6 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.Oops, that's the problem, you need to do 'make oldconfig' to ensure you didn't miss anything, and to adjust any new defaults.
I can confirm that "make oldconfig" does not fix the problem.
Grub appears to load the kernel (at least it does not come back with an error as it otherwise would), cursor in the topleft corner and absolutely no activity.
no reaction to ctrl-alt-del or magic keys. For all other kernels I would see at least the "uncompressing kerne.." message, not here.
Richard
Quoted 12 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Quoted 10 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 6 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.Oops, that's the problem, you need to do 'make oldconfig' to ensure you didn't miss anything, and to adjust any new defaults.
Quoted 6 lines
I can confirm that "make oldconfig" does not fix the problem.
Grub appears to load the kernel (at least it does not come back with an error as it otherwise would), cursor in the topleft corner and absolutely no activity.
no reaction to ctrl-alt-del or magic keys. For all other kernels I would see at least the "uncompressing kerne.." message, not here.
Try asking on a Fedora kernel list as this might just be a config issue with the way modesetting is set up.
good luck,
greg k-h
Quoted 15 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 14 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Quoted 10 lines · Greg KH
Quoted 6 lines · Richard Zidlicky
Hi,
I have been compiling my own kernels since ages and switched from 2.6.32.8 to 2.6.33.2 now.
Same procedure like allways - copied .config to new buildtree, make menuconfig (almost nothing changed in config), installed the new kernel on 2 machines.Oops, that's the problem, you need to do 'make oldconfig' to ensure you didn't miss anything, and to adjust any new defaults.
I can confirm that "make oldconfig" does not fix the problem.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Grub appears to load the kernel (at least it does not come back with an error as it otherwise would), cursor in the topleft corner and absolutely no activity.
no reaction to ctrl-alt-del or magic keys. For all other kernels I would see at least the "uncompressing kerne.." message, not here.Try asking on a Fedora kernel list as this might just be a config issue with the way modesetting is set up.
it is a clean kernel.org kernel, with early printk and I tried playing with various (no)rhgb noquiet options just to be sure. So this does really appear to be something that happens in the earliest bootstages before uncompressing and can not think how it could be Fedora's fault - it does not get anywhere close to touching the initramd image.
The only way I can proceed is try some kind of bisecting.. real bisect won't work as the wlan connection is painfully slow with the only working kernel taht I have installed on that computer.
Btw I have filled a Fedora bug against a 2.6.32.11-fedora kernel with broken kms but afaics this appears to be totally unrelated.
Richard