Skip to contentSkip to conversation

proposal: sending list-archive as mbox?

mlmmj Moritz Wilhelmy 4 participants 6 messages Mar 15, 2011 – Mar 16, 2011

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

something I'd like to have as an extension to the [email protected] mechanism, which is rather cumbersome to use, would be a way to make mlmmj send the whole archive as mbox, to have a flawless mail-only way to get archived mails (I believe a MLM should be standalone and shouldn't depend on webstuff for that matter).

Best regards,

Moritz

#1 lore raw

----- Original message -----

Quoted 7 lines

Hi,

something I'd like to have as an extension to the [email protected] mechanism, which is rather cumbersome to use, would be a way to make mlmmj send the whole archive as mbox, to have a flawless mail-only way to get archived mails (I believe a MLM should be standalone and shouldn't depend on webstuff for that matter).

While getting all the archive at once is a good
idea, the mbox format isn't. IMHO, having each
post as a MIME attachement would be much better.

Thomas

#2 lore raw
In reply to Moritz Wilhelmy
Quoted 5 lines · Moritz Wilhelmy

something I'd like to have as an extension to the [email protected] mechanism, which is rather cumbersome to use, would be a way to make mlmmj send the whole archive as mbox, to have a flawless mail-only way to get archived mails (I believe a MLM should be standalone and shouldn't depend on webstuff for that matter).

Even in these days of massive mailbox sizes, isn't this going to quickly exceed maximum message sizes that many servers will deliver or accept?

Ben.

#3 lore raw
In reply to Moritz Wilhelmy

----- Original message -----

Quoted 4 lines

Even in these days of massive mailbox sizes, isn't this going to quickly exceed maximum message sizes that many servers will deliver or accept?

Ben.

The problem might be individual message size, not the overall mailbox size. My servers are set to a limit of max 2MB per msg. So a nice configurable message limit would solve it (send as multiple msg if it exeed the limit).

Thomas

#4 lore raw
In reply to Moritz Wilhelmy

Hi,

Well, I guess you're right, which inspired me to hack a little shellscript that does this kind of archive creation.

I didn't implement the tar archiver (yet) because I don't need it.

http://paste.xinu.at/gcIq5/
consider it public domain.

It's actually quite hacky, but it works. The formail part is for From-escaping. I'm going to run it via cronjob.

Best regards,

Moritz

#5 lore raw
In reply to Moritz Wilhelmy
Quoted 4 lines · Moritz Wilhelmy

use, would be a way to make mlmmj send the whole archive as mbox, to have a flawless mail-only way to get archived mails (I believe a MLM should be standalone and shouldn't depend on webstuff for that matter).

-1
Would rather like to see development time go into make a better MLM not a better mail (un)archiver tool.

M.