Skip to contentSkip to conversation

ALSA: hda - Update CA0132 codec to load DSP firmware binary

DISCUSSION Dan Carpenter 1 participant 1 message Feb 28, 2014 Kernel janitors

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

[ Not likely a bug. Just confusing code ].

Hello Ian Minett,

The patch 01ef7dbffb41: "ALSA: hda - Update CA0132 codec to load DSP firmware binary" from Sep 20, 2012, leads to the following static checker warning:

	sound/pci/hda/patch_ca0132.c:2281 dspxfr_one_seg()
	warn: we tested 'hci_write' before and it was 'false'

sound/pci/hda/patch_ca0132.c

  2255          const struct dsp_image_seg *hci_write = NULL;
  2256          unsigned long timeout;
  2257          bool dma_active;

2258
2259 if (fls = NULL)
2260 return -EINVAL;
2261 if (is_hci_prog_list_seg(fls)) {
2262 hci_write = fls;
2263 fls = get_next_seg_ptr(fls);
2264 }
2265
2266 if (hci_write && (!fls || is_last(fls))) {

If fls->count = 0 and hci_write is non-zero then we return here.

  2267                  snd_printdd("hci_write\n");
  2268                  return dspxfr_hci_write(codec, hci_write);
  2269          }
  2270  
  2271          if (fls = NULL || dma_engine = NULL || port_map_mask = 0) {
  2272                  snd_printdd("Invalid Params\n");
  2273                  return -EINVAL;
  2274          }
  2275  
  2276          data = fls->data;
  2277          chip_addx = fls->chip_addr,
  2278          words_to_write = fls->count;

words_to_write is fls->count.

  2279  
  2280          if (!words_to_write)
  2281                  return hci_write ? dspxfr_hci_write(codec, hci_write) : 0;

If fls->count is zero then hci_write is zero so the test here is redundant/confusing. Were we intentending to test something else? This code is confusing.

  2282          if (reloc)
  2283                  chip_addx = (chip_addx & (0xFFFF0000 << 2)) + (reloc << 2);

regards,
dan carpenter