toybox in OpenEmbedded
Hi all,
I've been wanting to try out toybox within OpenEmbedded for quite a while and have finally found time to put a recipe together. Toybox is a BSD-licensed alternative to Busybox which may be of interest to a few people. It's still a work in progress but it already covers a large number of the basic commands a system needs. It should tie in well with the recent work Khem has done to enable the use of musl in OpenEmbedded as toybox and musl are often used together (e.g. Aboriginal Linux distro).
My patches are currently against openembedded-core for convenience but this probably belongs in meta-oe for now. I've done some basic testing on qemuarm but nothing significant. toybox builds and installs correctly though and I've set ALTERNATIVE_PRIORITY = 60 so that it takes precedence over busybox tools.
Removing toybox after it has been installed currently bricks the system though as the postrm script runs after '/bin/toybox' has been removed (so things like '/bin/ln' become broken links and the update-alternatives script can't run).
I can send patches but as I say, this is a work in progress and you shouldn't install toybox using this recipe on a production system yet. Would anyone else be interested in testing this out? And should I send these patches against openembedded-core or meta-oe or should I create a separate layer for this until it stabilises?
Thanks,
Signature · 4 lines
Paul Barker Email: [email protected] http://www.paulbarker.me.uk
Quoted 20 lines · Paul Barker
I've been wanting to try out toybox within OpenEmbedded for quite a while and
have finally found time to put a recipe together. Toybox is a BSD-licensed alternative to Busybox which may be of interest to a few people. It's still a
work in progress but it already covers a large number of the basic commands a
system needs. It should tie in well with the recent work Khem has done to enable
the use of musl in OpenEmbedded as toybox and musl are often used together (e.g.
Aboriginal Linux distro).My patches are currently against openembedded-core for convenience but this probably belongs in meta-oe for now. I've done some basic testing on qemuarm but
nothing significant. toybox builds and installs correctly though and I've setALTERNATIVE_PRIORITY= 60 so that it takes precedence over busybox tools.
Quoted 7 lines
Removing toybox after it has been installed currently bricks the system though
as the postrm script runs after '/bin/toybox' has been removed (so things like
'/bin/ln' become broken links and the update-alternatives script can't run).
One option for that might be to try the C implementation of alternatives that's provided in chkconfig, rather than cworth's shell version. I haven't tested it in that context, but I doubt it runs so many external tools.
Signature · 5 lines
Christopher Larson clarson at kergoth dot com Founder - BitBake, OpenEmbedded, OpenZaurus Maintainer - Tslib Senior Software Engineer, Mentor Graphics
Quoted 30 lines · Christopher Larson
Quoted 20 lines · Paul Barker
I've been wanting to try out toybox within OpenEmbedded for quite a while and
have finally found time to put a recipe together. Toybox is a BSD-licensed alternative to Busybox which may be of interest to a few people. It's still a
work in progress but it already covers a large number of the basic commands a
system needs. It should tie in well with the recent work Khem has done to enable
the use of musl in OpenEmbedded as toybox and musl are often used together (e.g.
Aboriginal Linux distro).My patches are currently against openembedded-core for convenience but this probably belongs in meta-oe for now. I've done some basic testing on qemuarm but
nothing significant. toybox builds and installs correctly though and I've setALTERNATIVE_PRIORITY= 60 so that it takes precedence over busybox tools.Quoted 7 lines
Removing toybox after it has been installed currently bricks the system though
as the postrm script runs after '/bin/toybox' has been removed (so things like
'/bin/ln' become broken links and the update-alternatives script can't run).
Quoted 3 lines
One option for that might be to try the C implementation of alternatives that's provided in chkconfig, rather than cworth's shell version. I haven't tested it in that context, but I doubt it runs so many external tools.
I did try that at one point in the last year or so but couldn't get it to work. I think it was something to do with it lacking offline root support. The only implementation I've been able to get working is the shell script one which is now in opkg-utils.
I'm actually looking at making a new update-alternatives implementation in C as I wanted to explore a few alternative ways of doing things. I was going to post about that once I have some basic working code.
I think the solution for the removal problem is to call update-alternatives in a pre-rm script rather than a post-rm script. There's already an entry in the opkg issue tracker for adding support for pre-rm scripts, that's another thing I'm planning on fixing soon.
Thanks,
Signature · 4 lines
Paul Barker Email: [email protected] http://www.paulbarker.me.uk