Why is the length of max mount option a page size??
Hi, now i'm interested in mount lenght of max mount option. I anaylsis ksys_mount() function in /fs/namespace.c. and find out the length of max mount option is a page size (4096 bytes).
I know that almost mount option short and page size is enough to contain almost mount options. but because of options for unionfs(overlay, aufs), lenght of mount option could be exceed it and cut.
I suffer this problem with aufs. aufs's branch option is cut and fail to aufs mount. I know that aufs is not offical fs in linux, but overlay fs now support multi layer mount option and could be suffer the same problem.
I think the best is dynamic allocate mount option's kernel memory. but I'm only have shallow knowlege of kernel, I can't guess it. And I think If the length of mount option cannot exceed a page size, kernel must leave warning messsage about lenght and return err. copy_mount_options() function seems to done this.
Jungsub Shin:
Quoted 7 lines
I know that almost mount option short and page size is enough to contain almost mount options. but because of options for
unionfs(overlay, aufs), lenght of mount option could be exceed it and cut.I suffer this problem with aufs. aufs's branch option is cut and fail to aufs mount. I know that aufs is not offical fs in linux,
For aufs, it should not happen because of the module parameter 'brs.'
(from the aufs manual)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
.SH Module Parameters
.TP
.B brs=1 | 0
Specifies to use the branch path data file under sysfs or not.
If the number of your branches is large or their path is long and you meet the limitation of mount(8) ro /etc/mtab, you need to enable CONFIG_SYSFS and set aufs module parameter brs=1.
When this parameter is set as 1, aufs does not show `br:' (or dirs=) mount option through /proc/mounts (and /etc/mtab). So you can keep yourself from the page limitation of
mount(8) or /etc/mtab.
Aufs shows branch paths through <sysfs>/fs/aufs/si_XXX/brNNN. Actually the file under sysfs has also a size limitation, but I don't think it is harmful.
There is one more side effect in setting 1 to this parameter.
If you rename your branch, the branch path written in /etc/mtab will be obsoleted and the future remount will meet some error due to the unmatched parameters (Remember that mount(8) may take the options from /etc/mtab and pass them to the systemcall).
If you set 1, /etc/mtab will not hold the branch path and you will not meet such trouble. On the other hand, the entries for the
branch path under sysfs are generated dynamically. So it must not be obsoleted. But I don't think users want to rename branches so often.
If CONFIG_SYSFS is disable, this parameter is always set to 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
If you post the details of your environment to aufs-users ML, then I may be able to describe more.
J. R. Okajima
Quoted 44 lines · J. R. Okajima
Jungsub Shin:
Quoted 7 lines
I know that almost mount option short and page size is enough to contain almost mount options. but because of options for
unionfs(overlay, aufs), lenght of mount option could be exceed it and cut.I suffer this problem with aufs. aufs's branch option is cut and fail to aufs mount. I know that aufs is not offical fs in linux,
For aufs, it should not happen because of the module parameter 'brs.'
(from the aufs manual)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
.SH Module Parameters
.TP
.B brs=1 | 0
Specifies to use the branch path data file under sysfs or not.If the number of your branches is large or their path is long and you meet the limitation of mount(8) ro
/etc/mtab, you need to enableCONFIG_SYSFSand set aufs module parameter brs=1.When this parameter is set as 1, aufs does not show `br:' (or dirs=) mount option through
/proc/mounts(and/etc/mtab). So you can keep yourself from the page limitation of
mount(8) or/etc/mtab.
Aufs shows branch paths through <sysfs>/fs/aufs/si_XXX/brNNN. Actually the file under sysfs has also a size limitation, but I don't think it is harmful.There is one more side effect in setting 1 to this parameter.
If you rename your branch, the branch path written in/etc/mtabwill be obsoleted and the future remount will meet some error due to the unmatched parameters (Remember that mount(8) may take the options from/etc/mtaband pass them to the systemcall).
If you set 1,/etc/mtabwill not hold the branch path and you will not meet such trouble. On the other hand, the entries for the
branch path under sysfs are generated dynamically. So it must not be obsoleted. But I don't think users want to rename branches so often.If
CONFIG_SYSFSis disable, this parameter is always set to 0.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Quoted 5 lines
If you post the details of your environment to aufs-users ML, then I may be able to describe more.
J. R. Okajima
I think brs module option is irrelevant to this issue. brs module option looks like that didn't affect passing option parameter with in mount() system call.
I suffered this problem below environments.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
OS : Ubuntu 18.04 LTS / 4.15.0-20-generic / 64bit
AUFS module parameter : brs = 1 / allow_userns = N
Mount command : mount -t aufs -o br=~/tca_agent/container_rw_dir/51509032=rw:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5a259d94211e449fd466d997b5b0b149cb2997a732fd3a838c14295e0eb93f92=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/faca908333f884648b75738571879df977339ee7615c65410c98001a463bcd00=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67b50813aedeb67fd06b434163fa64d07fbd16f714196daea1cd139a0171b080=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/28b6f7699be037b7f80dd03b22830712aa75b88ddfbba0910dd059b522fbff20=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c47c7125efa9172d262c5b3645594010704f67cf44005da9f6d7ea5a5d2a05db=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b91ed1b448ac52d251c785f5cfc299ca3ba4cfd68d739832b766228afa84a651=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0169cd8bc0bdbecedb30c7d995e69e832d7ccd5c435e72c40af6940db87851b7=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e7ef7d443e31f8b3b8a0a002a6895746d3737289eb2eea18d669924c089279f2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/31bfb0cd724fda09280305b8dc1c4b0587ca01f5dd503d28afa82cff4fa92475=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74428f0d76521fa9b9b1189cb72d303e367003c113cc8a11db125e3f7df1daa1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b20a927da14045cac0cd6a745f67fdeb88ead6d85752c670ea2773b27387f6ae=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/7dee3bce119631e3c922d78860d6b0ae160e237b63bf19f43713a05d1086c72f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/636bce8f18e8734cb98f170bdcf1fb9ae52f1b091bfadcb2bef378b0d829ceb6=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9c6fde234e701cf7b61534ef3a23cc4e0cdb6d3ffc497feaa8fcddc52e8d1fda=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/83c2f1968a932e3e284ef20b10a4ef8a9cfc01589dacf2100fb9a78e88c3888e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ec096a351601040fcd37c31edccd2f68106438097e8adf7253539366b2232de5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6de889accecb819028355196bde150749598e982b5dfe556540e102c737bfc34=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1042cb8f2263d1030fdb57e0ca671b34a2180bb35d9448737e4a03e4987cf942=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/4fab8c997a447af2375e325467661ca1d74bf62dc6d802426f20d0134c9c43bc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ca57efb1c28464fab46af1826243c02af0a0b6cfb90bf92b30110e79028c5e68=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ad86d54176611b5117fc155e8dfbd0b59bc0abce4e2051baef12c2f1e152c92f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f323ae7b264dcc517876e7c722ac3369baaef1a7c18cc5aae5f43f440fd646c0=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a7d1c89c8422563102bd353de46154191038f92c9ebde8b22a8b2749140029ec=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/104adb8634902678f87db6bdbdb12d43d5bd6db9909ae9b12e078286046a1298=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/00450b5308ac99846ae7e5fa47652952c4fbbe82882ac241d5153d630644f790=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/129675caf5fdc1616c619d5b5718417806a64f282d324a3a580d6df1269b4f3f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/8ce8b37ab4829a1fd34fcd38842b912d46eb3f7511365ccec0399a06670ab2fc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57080e2e0baad381605079107f08435133d7829364a9c450fc08877f01e57601=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9ca225075a8c2bfd27ef5084e41335d781d24e7be0cbf4575ec3d42de662c6ac=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74ec3835691908f9e6e271797f373257de3f9cc4bb408fd66dd229537ea5fcc1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/59aa8f04c38abaae9c0e430d7b1a91f6560641e429386ee2c4eec57f0af35c04=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bc318ac48b4f7a9536b72e2b0f223726a5225e13ecc70eba4b7b00e2bf80081b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bbfb0e8818be82ca0f17f280f7ad89497fef6c92e2bb50c40b2bd17c79347425=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f36b94436263ce21d885d2f3f94c7b307e966a989fcefd3027c039e987d7dc2b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9103dae307f5748103f89093273329a523300b4f103a1d397c44abd766fe0015=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9bd48cc89c1fc083b0db7ed45e5d7e4fec277450b8b47f96884588930ce8c56f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/47ba0411cc8344ab1895a6b8eb0878a9ffd34410170a140ad1f210f20eedcdce=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/42b317de582399eb395b2818b4d658fb0a5987e8df1163e49ac2d8bec95a078e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57bb07a87ab6c29b048638c65566febe800fe79672730f7bb9e70b8f2e677e5a=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b89b49aa036df19c6a2e77cc4aaef707ab3fd916d2d936b9e5e160d448d96ab3=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d7bf931f8235cc7cc68c223b2945f77e858eb8cff4c9cb8bd64bacfd29312672=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/49a8b40dbec97066dbad4fb14d1bf388102190442679527e112b030270426ccc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/05f05d402ea8ee67da1af2c9e35d10b9619b0f0c14a56788a1a0b5eeb290d685=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b05d3f32ac4ff52a542dfcf50dbf155d060d79bd23d0ebed1439a3c6b1120731=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0d061258f32c904c95aa020a9f679790c5722c3017eef98e298d6e29b4f02089=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1f9c07049bcd59c59413c1706d0402b04c96598174eb16ef3de25b4e47413ad2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a86578a8bff61017b80eb653705c3f41136efb9b88facd6a2c67e8b3426e47f9=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c3fdf4a694f0cc03939ee2cfdd09fb623966c5bb193778eaaea317655773656e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1b8fcd446a37050b55f57687aaae1150d74cc7f4468bbd00942535bad5ab22fe=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6624cfa732b528cf7c1996719e30d1525aa27af7584f61a149d4d386aa8cf301=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5b57e87f9b5859d902c4338c7a7ce5996a51fb8226a8f11ab29e10af4af5f14f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0c65112ac5c572a950e2671f903ef11e918e6e3cdbf026edda90db6c7a9c6ef8=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ce16b72d243b82ded684a547da1400b8f2d07ed7b36b114ae0cbe2f20c17b0bf=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3937b112d7dbedfe075162862e404b7b85803d880589eaf3ebad9855629bdd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b486d646cd9f5b8151856133ea3e81d53c3664bb727a0a87d0197cbbae9211de=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/de1b712fcfedbc3f61248c1a5fb9cba5a5ab6c7415f2c71c7ea162fd7c738c6f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/2958a858559d3091b8162c066cfe5e17012f2307772180e702ffbc89bcae8fc2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/14eae848ef41eb275ad37cc9d12dc276d3f08beeb06e041407371b9489335ee1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d72e07c403501a4abefaa80f3b81121392c42f314fc14bbf1bb434dc84457dd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ee0efde24e35b4e2f801ca25640169ca2f319f9b5d37dbb0917cfd43e818d1f4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67dfb4d7c7ce39829d36740e1ef5279e00320a0d2bfe06bb67b6571f1ff47627=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b3a1a69310f719755232ed5f8509f11f549d620d723ea293f001e3d30795108b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3ed95caeb02ffe68cdd9fd84406680ae93d633cb16422d00e8a7c22955b46d4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e5ad7970bc69d2ba62d2bbb4b80627273350e1982ff43bc1ca04a3215bc6da5b=ro+wh none ~/tca_agent/container_root_dir/51509032 dmesg : [343090.744067] aufs opt_add:810:mount[30864]: lookup failed /root/tca_agent/image_layer_di (-2)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
br option is cut and aufs search cut directory. Length of mount option is about 6400. So I tested again with reduced option to about 4000 characters (PAGE_SIZE 4096 in kernel) by reducing branches, AUFS works well.
So I looked copy_mount_options() function in the kernel. This function copys mount option form user memory to kernel memory within PAGE_SIZE(4096).
Al Viro
maintainerQuoted 6 lines · Jungsub Shin
Mount command : mount -t aufs -o br=~/tca_agent/container_rw_dir/51509032=rw:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5a259d94211e449fd466d997b5b0b149cb2997a732fd3a838c14295e0eb93f92=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/faca908333f884648b75738571879df977339ee7615c65410c98001a463bcd00=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67b50813aedeb67fd06b434163fa64d07fbd16f714196daea1cd139a0171b080=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/28b6f7699be037b7f80dd03b22830712aa75b88ddfbba0910dd059b522fbff20=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c47c7125efa9172d262c5b3645594010704f67cf44005da9f6d7ea5a5d2a05db=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b91ed1b448ac52d251c785f5cfc299ca3ba4cfd68d739832b766228afa84a651=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0169cd8bc0bdbecedb30c7d995e69e832d7ccd5c435e72c40af6940db87851b7=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e7ef7d443e31f8b3b8a0a002a6895746d3737289eb2eea18d669924c089279f2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/31bfb0cd724fda09280305b8dc1c4b0587ca01f5dd503d28afa82cff4fa92475=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74428f0d76521fa9b9b1189cb72d303e367003c113cc8a11db125e3f7df1daa1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b20a927da14045cac0cd6a745f67fdeb88ead6d85752c670ea2773b27387f6ae=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/7dee3bce119631e3c922d78860d6b0ae160e237b63bf19f43713a05d1086c72f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/636bce8f18e8734cb98f170bdcf1fb9ae52f1b091bfadcb2bef378b0d829ceb6=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9c6fde234e701cf7b61534ef3a23cc4e0cdb6d3ffc497feaa8fcddc52e8d1fda=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/83c2f1968a932e3e284ef20b10a4ef8a9cfc01589dacf2100fb9a78e88c3888e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ec096a351601040fcd37c31edccd2f68106438097e8adf7253539366b2232de5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6de889accecb819028355196bde150749598e982b5dfe556540e102c737bfc34=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1042cb8f2263d1030fdb57e0ca671b34a2180bb35d9448737e4a03e4987cf942=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/4fab8c997a447af2375e325467661ca1d74bf62dc6d802426f20d0134c9c43bc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ca57efb1c28464fab46af1826243c02af0a0b6cfb90bf92b30110e79028c5e68=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ad86d54176611b5117fc155e8dfbd0b59bc0abce4e2051baef12c2f1e152c92f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f323ae7b264dcc517876e7c722ac3369baaef1a7c18cc5aae5f43f440fd646c0=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a7d1c89c8422563102bd353de46154191038f92c9ebde8b22a8b2749140029ec=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/104adb8634902678f87db6bdbdb12d43d5bd6db9909ae9b12e078286046a1298=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/00450b5308ac99846ae7e5fa47652952c4fbbe82882ac241d5153d630644f790=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/129675caf5fdc1616c619d5b5718417806a64f282d324a3a580d6df1269b4f3f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/8ce8b37ab4829a1fd34fcd38842b912d46eb3f7511365ccec0399a06670ab2fc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57080e2e0baad381605079107f08435133d7829364a9c450fc08877f01e57601=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9ca225075a8c2bfd27ef5084e41335d781d24e7be0cbf4575ec3d42de662c6ac=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74ec3835691908f9e6e271797f373257de3f9cc4bb408fd66dd229537ea5fcc1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/59aa8f04c38abaae9c0e430d7b1a91f6560641e429386ee2c4eec57f0af35c04=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bc318ac48b4f7a9536b72e2b0f223726a5225e13ecc70eba4b7b00e2bf80081b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bbfb0e8818be82ca0f17f280f7ad89497fef6c92e2bb50c40b2bd17c79347425=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f36b94436263ce21d885d2f3f94c7b307e966a989fcefd3027c039e987d7dc2b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9103dae307f5748103f89093273329a523300b4f103a1d397c44abd766fe0015=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9bd48cc89c1fc083b0db7ed45e5d7e4fec277450b8b47f96884588930ce8c56f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/47ba0411cc8344ab1895a6b8eb0878a9ffd34410170a140ad1f210f20eedcdce=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/42b317de582399eb395b2818b4d658fb0a5987e8df1163e49ac2d8bec95a078e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57bb07a87ab6c29b048638c65566febe800fe79672730f7bb9e70b8f2e677e5a=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b89b49aa036df19c6a2e77cc4aaef707ab3fd916d2d936b9e5e160d448d96ab3=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d7bf931f8235cc7cc68c223b2945f77e858eb8cff4c9cb8bd64bacfd29312672=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/49a8b40dbec97066dbad4fb14d1bf388102190442679527e112b030270426ccc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/05f05d402ea8ee67da1af2c9e35d10b9619b0f0c14a56788a1a0b5eeb290d685=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b05d3f32ac4ff52a542dfcf50dbf155d060d79bd23d0ebed1439a3c6b1120731=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0d061258f32c904c95aa020a9f679790c5722c3017eef98e298d6e29b4f02089=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1f9c07049bcd59c59413c1706d0402b04c96598174eb16ef3de25b4e47413ad2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a86578a8bff61017b80eb653705c3f41136efb9b88facd6a2c67e8b3426e47f9=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c3fdf4a694f0cc03939ee2cfdd09fb623966c5bb193778eaaea317655773656e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1b8fcd446a37050b55f57687aaae1150d74cc7f4468bbd00942535bad5ab22fe=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6624cfa732b528cf7c1996719e30d1525aa27af7584f61a149d4d386aa8cf301=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5b57e87f9b5859d902c4338c7a7ce5996a51fb8226a8f11ab29e10af4af5f14f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0c65112ac5c572a950e2671f903ef11e918e6e3cdbf026edda90db6c7a9c6ef8=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ce16b72d243b82ded684a547da1400b8f2d07ed7b36b114ae0cbe2f20c17b0bf=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3937b112d7dbedfe075162862e404b7b85803d880589eaf3ebad9855629bdd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b486d646cd9f5b8151856133ea3e81d53c3664bb727a0a87d0197cbbae9211de=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/de1b712fcfedbc3f61248c1a5fb9cba5a5ab6c7415f2c71c7ea162fd7c738c6f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/2958a858559d3091b8162c066cfe5e17012f2307772180e702ffbc89bcae8fc2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/14eae848ef41eb275ad37cc9d12dc276d3f08beeb06e041407371b9489335ee1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d72e07c403501a4abefaa80f3b81121392c42f314fc14bbf1bb434dc84457dd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ee0efde24e35b4e2f801ca25640169ca2f319f9b5d37dbb0917cfd43e818d1f4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67dfb4d7c7ce39829d36740e1ef5279e00320a0d2bfe06bb67b6571f1ff47627=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b3a1a69310f719755232ed5f8509f11f549d620d723ea293f001e3d30795108b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3ed95caeb02ffe68cdd9fd84406680ae93d633cb16422d00e8a7c22955b46d4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e5ad7970bc69d2ba62d2bbb4b80627273350e1982ff43bc1ca04a3215bc6da5b=ro+wh none ~/tca_agent/container_root_dir/51509032 dmesg : [343090.744067] aufs opt_add:810:mount[30864]: lookup failed
/root/tca_agent/image_layer_di(-2)
------------------------------------------------------------------------br option is cut and aufs search cut directory. Length of mount option is about 6400.
The lack of planning on your part...
IOW, don't do it. Use of symlinks (or bindings) might alleviate the problem if aufs interface is that nasty. And before you go "just read up to \0", consider e.g. NFS flavours with binary data structure passed instead of a string.
Quoted 3 lines · Al Viro
Quoted 2 lines · Jungsub Shin
Mount command : mount -t aufs -o br=~/tca_agent/container_rw_dir/51509032=rw:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5a259d94211e449fd466d997b5b0b149cb2997a732fd3a838c14295e0eb93f92=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/faca908333f884648b75738571879df977339ee7615c65410c98001a463bcd00=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67b50813aedeb67fd06b434163fa64d07fbd16f714196daea1cd139a0171b080=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/28b6f7699be037b7f80dd03b22830712aa75b88ddfbba0910dd059b522fbff20=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c47c7125efa9172d262c5b3645594010704f67cf44005da9f6d7ea5a5d2a05db=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b91ed1b448ac52d251c785f5cfc299ca3ba4cfd68d739832b766228afa84a651=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0169cd8bc0bdbecedb30c7d995e69e832d7ccd5c435e72c40af6940db87851b7=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e7ef7d443e31f8b3b8a0a002a6895746d3737289eb2eea18d669924c089279f2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/31bfb0cd724fda09280305b8dc1c4b0587ca01f5dd503d28afa82cff4fa92475=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74428f0d76521fa9b9b1189cb72d303e367003c113cc8a11db125e3f7df1daa1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b20a927da14045cac0cd6a745f67fdeb88ead6d85752c670ea2773b27387f6ae=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/7dee3bce119631e3c922d78860d6b0ae160e237b63bf19f43713a05d1086c72f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/636bce8f18e8734cb98f170bdcf1fb9ae52f1b091bfadcb2bef378b0d829ceb6=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9c6fde234e701cf7b61534ef3a23cc4e0cdb6d3ffc497feaa8fcddc52e8d1fda=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/83c2f1968a932e3e284ef20b10a4ef8a9cfc01589dacf2100fb9a78e88c3888e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ec096a351601040fcd37c31edccd2f68106438097e8adf7253539366b2232de5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6de889accecb819028355196bde150749598e982b5dfe556540e102c737bfc34=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1042cb8f2263d1030fdb57e0ca671b34a2180bb35d9448737e4a03e4987cf942=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/4fab8c997a447af2375e325467661ca1d74bf62dc6d802426f20d0134c9c43bc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ca57efb1c28464fab46af1826243c02af0a0b6cfb90bf92b30110e79028c5e68=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ad86d54176611b5117fc155e8dfbd0b59bc0abce4e2051baef12c2f1e152c92f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f323ae7b264dcc517876e7c722ac3369baaef1a7c18cc5aae5f43f440fd646c0=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a7d1c89c8422563102bd353de46154191038f92c9ebde8b22a8b2749140029ec=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/104adb8634902678f87db6bdbdb12d43d5bd6db9909ae9b12e078286046a1298=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/00450b5308ac99846ae7e5fa47652952c4fbbe82882ac241d5153d630644f790=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/129675caf5fdc1616c619d5b5718417806a64f282d324a3a580d6df1269b4f3f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/8ce8b37ab4829a1fd34fcd38842b912d46eb3f7511365ccec0399a06670ab2fc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57080e2e0baad381605079107f08435133d7829364a9c450fc08877f01e57601=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9ca225075a8c2bfd27ef5084e41335d781d24e7be0cbf4575ec3d42de662c6ac=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/74ec3835691908f9e6e271797f373257de3f9cc4bb408fd66dd229537ea5fcc1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/59aa8f04c38abaae9c0e430d7b1a91f6560641e429386ee2c4eec57f0af35c04=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bc318ac48b4f7a9536b72e2b0f223726a5225e13ecc70eba4b7b00e2bf80081b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/bbfb0e8818be82ca0f17f280f7ad89497fef6c92e2bb50c40b2bd17c79347425=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/f36b94436263ce21d885d2f3f94c7b307e966a989fcefd3027c039e987d7dc2b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9103dae307f5748103f89093273329a523300b4f103a1d397c44abd766fe0015=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/9bd48cc89c1fc083b0db7ed45e5d7e4fec277450b8b47f96884588930ce8c56f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/47ba0411cc8344ab1895a6b8eb0878a9ffd34410170a140ad1f210f20eedcdce=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/42b317de582399eb395b2818b4d658fb0a5987e8df1163e49ac2d8bec95a078e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/57bb07a87ab6c29b048638c65566febe800fe79672730f7bb9e70b8f2e677e5a=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b89b49aa036df19c6a2e77cc4aaef707ab3fd916d2d936b9e5e160d448d96ab3=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d7bf931f8235cc7cc68c223b2945f77e858eb8cff4c9cb8bd64bacfd29312672=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/49a8b40dbec97066dbad4fb14d1bf388102190442679527e112b030270426ccc=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/05f05d402ea8ee67da1af2c9e35d10b9619b0f0c14a56788a1a0b5eeb290d685=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b05d3f32ac4ff52a542dfcf50dbf155d060d79bd23d0ebed1439a3c6b1120731=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0d061258f32c904c95aa020a9f679790c5722c3017eef98e298d6e29b4f02089=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1f9c07049bcd59c59413c1706d0402b04c96598174eb16ef3de25b4e47413ad2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a86578a8bff61017b80eb653705c3f41136efb9b88facd6a2c67e8b3426e47f9=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/c3fdf4a694f0cc03939ee2cfdd09fb623966c5bb193778eaaea317655773656e=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/1b8fcd446a37050b55f57687aaae1150d74cc7f4468bbd00942535bad5ab22fe=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/6624cfa732b528cf7c1996719e30d1525aa27af7584f61a149d4d386aa8cf301=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/5b57e87f9b5859d902c4338c7a7ce5996a51fb8226a8f11ab29e10af4af5f14f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/0c65112ac5c572a950e2671f903ef11e918e6e3cdbf026edda90db6c7a9c6ef8=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ce16b72d243b82ded684a547da1400b8f2d07ed7b36b114ae0cbe2f20c17b0bf=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3937b112d7dbedfe075162862e404b7b85803d880589eaf3ebad9855629bdd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b486d646cd9f5b8151856133ea3e81d53c3664bb727a0a87d0197cbbae9211de=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/de1b712fcfedbc3f61248c1a5fb9cba5a5ab6c7415f2c71c7ea162fd7c738c6f=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/2958a858559d3091b8162c066cfe5e17012f2307772180e702ffbc89bcae8fc2=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/14eae848ef41eb275ad37cc9d12dc276d3f08beeb06e041407371b9489335ee1=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/d72e07c403501a4abefaa80f3b81121392c42f314fc14bbf1bb434dc84457dd5=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/ee0efde24e35b4e2f801ca25640169ca2f319f9b5d37dbb0917cfd43e818d1f4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/67dfb4d7c7ce39829d36740e1ef5279e00320a0d2bfe06bb67b6571f1ff47627=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/b3a1a69310f719755232ed5f8509f11f549d620d723ea293f001e3d30795108b=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/a3ed95caeb02ffe68cdd9fd84406680ae93d633cb16422d00e8a7c22955b46d4=ro+wh:~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir/e5ad7970bc69d2ba62d2bbb4b80627273350e1982ff43bc1ca04a3215bc6da5b=ro+wh none ~/tca_agent/container_root_dir/51509032 dmesg : [343090.744067] aufs opt_add:810:mount[30864]: lookup failed
/root/tca_agent/image_layer_di(-2)
I think kernel at least must print warning message when mount option overflow the PAGE_SIZE if length of mount option should be fixed. When i encouter this problem, i found the reason hard because of lack of kernel log and wrong infomation.
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 4 lines
------------------------------------------------------------------------
br option is cut and aufs search cut directory. Length of mount option is about 6400.
The lack of planning on your part...
IOW, don't do it. Use of symlinks (or bindings) might alleviate the problem if aufs interface is that nasty. And before you go "just read up to \0", consider e.g. NFS flavours with binary data structure passed instead of a string.
Do you mean using symlinks or bind mount to reduce length of mount options?? I can remove "~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir" string. But the other character means unique ID of layer and i can't compress it or replace it to another string. This is not fundamental solution. Docker use the same unique ID to manage layers.
As i said before overlayfs could suffer same problem because overlayfs support multiple lowerdir options and there is no route to pass lower dirs without mount option. So i think to support unionfs stably in kernel, dynamic memory allocation for mount option is needed.
Thanks.
Jungsub Shin:
Quoted 4 lines
Do you mean using symlinks or bind mount to reduce length of mount options?? I can remove "~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir" string. But the other character means unique ID of layer and i can't compress it or replace it to another string. This is not fundamental solution. Docker=20
Can't it be a solution?
# mount -o bind /long/path0 /br0 # mount -o bind /long/path1 /br1 ::: # mount -t aufs -o br=/br0:/br1:... none /mntpnt
or
# ln -s /long/path0 /br0 # ln -s /long/path1 /br1 ::: # mount -t aufs -o br=/br0:/br1:... none /mntpnt
J. R. Okajima
Quoted 15 lines · J. R. Okajima
Jungsub Shin:
Quoted 4 lines
Do you mean using symlinks or bind mount to reduce length of mount options?? I can remove "~/tca_agent/image_layer_dir" string. But the other character means unique ID of layer and i can't compress it or replace it to another string. This is not fundamental solution. Docker=20
Can't it be a solution?
# mount -o bind /long/path0 /br0 # mount -o bind /long/path1 /br1 ::: # mount -t aufs -o br=/br0:/br1:... none /mntpntor
Quoted 7 lines
# ln -s /long/path0 /br0 # ln -s /long/path1 /br1 ::: # mount -t aufs -o br=/br0:/br1:... none /mntpntJ. R. Okajima
I don't test them, but they will work well.
That's temporary solution. So i'm use remount,append option.
Thanks
Jungsub Shin:
Quoted 5 lines
I suffered this problem below environments.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
OS : Ubuntu 18.04 LTS / 4.15.0-20-generic / 64bit
AUFS module parameter : brs =3D 1 /allow_userns=3D N
Mount command : mount -t aufs -o br=3D~/tca_agent/container_rw_dir/51509032=
:::
(very long command line)
For such long branches, try "remount,append" option.
# mount -t aufs -o br=br0:br1:br2...:brN none /mntpnt # mount -o remount,append=brN+1 /mntpnt # mount -o remount,append=brN+2 /mntpnt :::
J. R. Okajima