Skip to contentSkip to conversation

meta-measured updates

tpm2 Trevor Woerner 3 participants 6 messages May 30, 2018 – Jun 2, 2018

lore
Share & tools
lore

Trevor Woerner

author
#0 lore raw

Hi Philip,

My hope is that one day the OE community will have one security layer to choose, rather than the three that we have currently.

I've looked at the three different layers and feel that meta-secure-core might be a better one to target. With respect to its TPM2 recipes, however, meta-secure-core (and the other, meta-security) lag behind meta-measured. As such I've been working on some updates for meta-secure-core.

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If not I could prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've noticed a number of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys
- libtss2-mu
- libtss2-sys
- libtss2-tcti-device
- libtss2-tcti-mssim

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old libtcti-device. But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older libtcti-socket and libsapi?

It looks like things are going to get messy. It looks like, going forward, we're going to need to keep tpm2-tss_1.x.bb around as well as create tpm2-tss_2.x.bb recipes with differently named PACKAGES so existing recipes that use tss (and expect the old 1.x behaviour/API) can continue to work while allowing new code (or updates to the old) to use the new API (?).

Best regards,
Trevor

author
#1 lore raw
Quoted 20 lines · Trevor Woerner

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If not I could
prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've noticed a number
of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys
- libtss2-mu
- libtss2-sys
- libtss2-tcti-device
- libtss2-tcti-mssim

Quoted 6 lines

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old libtcti-device.
But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older libtcti-socket and
libsapi?

In any case, here's a WIP of my changes:
https://github.com/twoerner/meta-secure-core/tree/contrib/twoerner/tpm2-recipe-updates/meta-tpm2/recipes-tpm

Specifically, please take a look at the _git recipes, which currently build off the master branch of all tpm2-software's components.
What do you think of tpm2-tss/tpm2-tss_git.bb's PACKAGES?

#2 lore raw
Quoted 20 lines

-----Original Message-----
From: tpm2 [mailto:tpm2-bounces(a)lists.01.org] On Behalf Of Trevor Woerner
Sent: Wednesday, May 30, 2018 4:49 PM
To: tpm2(a)lists.01.org
Subject: Re: [tpm2] meta-measured updates

On Wed, May 30, 2018 at 5:13 PM, Trevor Woerner <twoerner(a)gmail.com <mailto:twoerner(a)gmail.com> > wrote:

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If not I
could
prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've noticed a
number
of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

Quoted 7 lines

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys

This is the new enhanced (I think its enhanced) system api

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-mu

This is the new marshaling library

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-sys

This is the old libsapi

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-tcti-device

This is the old device tcti

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-tcti-mssim

This is the old socket tcti

Quoted 5 lines

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old libtcti-device. But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older libtcti-socket
and
libsapi?

See above inline comments.

Quoted 11 lines

In any case, here's a WIP of my changes:
https://github.com/twoerner/meta-secure-core/tree/contrib/twoerner/tpm2-
recipe-updates/meta-tpm2/recipes-tpm

Specifically, please take a look at the _git recipes, which currently build off the master branch of all tpm2-software's components.
What do you think of tpm2-tss/tpm2-tss_git.bb <http://tpm2-tss_git.bb> 's PACKAGES?

author
#3 lore raw
Quoted 50 lines · William C
Quoted 4 lines

-----Original Message-----
From: tpm2 [mailto:tpm2-bounces(a)lists.01.org] On Behalf Of Trevor

Woerner

Quoted 9 lines

Sent: Wednesday, May 30, 2018 4:49 PM
To: tpm2(a)lists.01.org
Subject: Re: [tpm2] meta-measured updates

On Wed, May 30, 2018 at 5:13 PM, Trevor Woerner <twoerner(a)gmail.com <mailto:twoerner(a)gmail.com> > wrote:

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If

not I

Quoted 4 lines

could
prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've

noticed a

Quoted 10 lines

number
of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys

This is the new enhanced (I think its enhanced) system api

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-mu

This is the new marshaling library

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-sys

This is the old libsapi

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-tcti-device

This is the old device tcti

Quoted 1 line

- libtss2-tcti-mssim

This is the old socket tcti

Quoted 1 line
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 1 line

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old

libtcti-device.

Quoted 1 line

But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older

libtcti-socket

Quoted 2 lines

and
libsapi?

See above inline comments.

Excellent, thank you! :-)

#4 lore raw
In reply to Trevor Woerner
Quoted 4 lines · Trevor Woerner

Hi Philip,

My hope is that one day the OE community will have one security layer to choose, rather than the three that we have currently.

In my experience things that live in a separate "security" area rarely get tested well. Ideally they would live as close to the upstream "core" as possible.

Quoted 7 lines

I've looked at the three different layers and feel that meta-secure-core might be a better one to target. With respect to its TPM2 recipes, however, meta-secure-core (and the other, meta-security) lag behind meta-measured. As such I've been working on some updates for meta-secure-core.

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If not I could prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Given the above my first priority is figuring out how far upstream the various pieces can go. I've been chatting with a few folks and have been working up patches to yocto-kernel-cache and openembedded-core to cleanup the kernel config fragments and integrate the resulting kernel-module packages into packagegroup-base. With the swtpm stuff being integrated into qemu it's now possible to test at least the tpm-tis driver by:
1) creating a qemu machine with 'tpm-tis' added to the MACHINE_FEATURES
2) setup the swtpm daemon
3) runqemu booting core-image-base to verity the /dev/tpm* is created

After this gets reviewed and if usptream is willing I'm then hoping to propose moving the recipes for user space bits as close to openembedded-core as possible. I think the ideal end state would be enabling something via COMBINED_FEATURES so that we can have MACHINE_FEATURES and DISTRO_FEATURES working together to seamlessly pull in the right kernel driver and TSS(2)? recipes.

Something you're willing to help test and maybe contribute a 'tested-by' tag on patches when they get sent upstream?

Quoted 19 lines

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've noticed a number of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys
- libtss2-mu
- libtss2-sys
- libtss2-tcti-device
- libtss2-tcti-mssim

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old libtcti-device. But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older libtcti-socket and libsapi?

Quoted 5 lines

It looks like things are going to get messy. It looks like, going forward, we're going to need to keep tpm2-tss_1.x.bb around as well as create tpm2-tss_2.x.bb recipes with differently named PACKAGES so existing recipes that use tss (and expect the old 1.x behaviour/API) can continue to work while allowing new code (or updates to the old) to use the new API (?).

I think Bill got all of this covered in his reply.

Philip

Quoted 7 lines

Best regards,
Trevor
_______________________________________________
tpm2 mailing list
tpm2(a)lists.01.org
https://lists.01.org/mailman/listinfo/tpm2

author
#5 lore raw
Quoted 11 lines · Philip Tricca
Quoted 4 lines · Trevor Woerner

Hi Philip,

My hope is that one day the OE community will have one security layer to choose, rather than the three that we have currently.

In my experience things that live in a separate "security" area rarely get tested well. Ideally they would live as close to the upstream "core" as possible.

If enough people can be convinced that this needs to be in core that it ends up there one day, that would be awesome! But my gut feeling is that there isn't quite enough interest just yet for all this security stuff to not be in its own layer.

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 1 line

I've looked at the three different layers and feel that meta-secure-core

might

Quoted 2 lines

be a better one to target. With respect to its TPM2 recipes, however, meta-secure-core (and the other, meta-security) lag behind

meta-measured. As

Quoted 3 lines

such I've been working on some updates for meta-secure-core.

Are you still keen to fold meta-measured into something else? If not I

could

Quoted 1 line

prepare a set of patches for meta-measured as well.

Quoted 12 lines

Given the above my first priority is figuring out how far upstream the various pieces can go. I've been chatting with a few folks and have been working up patches to yocto-kernel-cache and openembedded-core to cleanup the kernel config fragments and integrate the resulting kernel-module packages into packagegroup-base. With the swtpm stuff being integrated into qemu it's now possible to test at least the tpm-tis driver by:
1) creating a qemu machine with 'tpm-tis' added to the MACHINE_FEATURES
2) setup the swtpm daemon
3) runqemu booting core-image-base to verity the /dev/tpm* is created

I wasn't aware that the latest qemu had support for TPM; this is great news! I've heard that the latest qemu also has raspberrypi emulation support, that's something else I should investigate as well :-)

Quoted 11 lines

After this gets reviewed and if usptream is willing I'm then hoping to propose moving the recipes for user space bits as close to openembedded-core as possible. I think the ideal end state would be enabling something via COMBINED_FEATURES so that we can have MACHINE_FEATURES and DISTRO_FEATURES working together to seamlessly pull in the right kernel driver and TSS(2)? recipes.

Something you're willing to help test and maybe contribute a 'tested-by' tag on patches when they get sent upstream?

Absolutely! (although I might need an individual, side-channel ping to alert me to their addition since I can't follow the various OE patch lists in detail every day)

Currently meta-measured has one kernel option that isn't RPi-friendly. I never said anything about it since it was easy enough to remove through local configurations. Therefore I'm looking forward to these new fragments to see how they'll do on non-Intel hardware.

In any case, I could imaging the kernel fragments *might* make it into oe-core, but I doubt something like the TPM2 recipes would. Those will probably need to find a home outside oe-core.

Quoted 24 lines
Quoted 1 line

Looking at the master commit of tpm2-tss, specifically, I've noticed a

number

Quoted 7 lines

of changes and was hoping for your feedback.

With the tss 1.x stuff we had:
- libtcti-device
- libtcti-socket
- libsapi

Quoted 8 lines

The new tss 2.x stuff has:
- libtss2-esys
- libtss2-mu
- libtss2-sys
- libtss2-tcti-device
- libtss2-tcti-mssim

I'm guessing libtss2-tcti-device is the new name for the old

libtcti-device.

Quoted 1 line

But are there any mappings from the new stuff to the older

libtcti-socket and

Quoted 3 lines

libsapi?

It looks like things are going to get messy. It looks like, going

forward,

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 2 lines

we're going to need to keep tpm2-tss_1.x.bb around as well as create tpm2-tss_2.x.bb recipes with differently named PACKAGES so existing

recipes

Quoted 1 line

that use tss (and expect the old 1.x behaviour/API) can continue to work

while

Quoted 1 line

allowing new code (or updates to the old) to use the new API (?).

I think Bill got all of this covered in his reply.

Yes, and he did an excellent job; thank you!

PS: how was the security summit?