Skip to contentSkip to conversation

mxb: fix audio handling

bug report Dan Carpenter 2 participants 3 messages Apr 10, 2019 Media (V4L/DVB)

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

[ Hi Hans,

This might not really be your bug, but I just respect you a lot and so I always come to you with questions and for advice. -dan ]

Hello Hans Verkuil,

The patch 6680427791c9: "[media] mxb: fix audio handling" from Apr 30, 2012, leads to the following static checker warning:

	drivers/media/pci/saa7146/mxb.c:196 tea6420_route()
	warn: uncapped user index 'TEA6420_cd[idx]'

drivers/media/pci/saa7146/mxb.c
194 static inline void tea6420_route(struct mxb *mxb, int idx) 195 {
--> 196 v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_1, audio, s_routing,

    197 		TEA6420_cd[idx][0].input, TEA6420_cd[idx][0].output, 0);
                                   ^^^

Index overflow. The TEA6420_cd[] array has MXB_AUDIOS + 1 (which is 7 altogether) elements.

    198 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_2, audio, s_routing,
    199 		TEA6420_cd[idx][1].input, TEA6420_cd[idx][1].output, 0);
    200 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_1, audio, s_routing,
    201 		TEA6420_line[idx][0].input, TEA6420_line[idx][0].output, 0);
    202 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_2, audio, s_routing,
    203 		TEA6420_line[idx][1].input, TEA6420_line[idx][1].output, 0);
    204 }

[ snip ]

    650  static int vidioc_s_audio(struct file *file, void *fh, const struct v4l2_audio *a)
    651  {
    652          struct saa7146_dev *dev = ((struct saa7146_fh *)fh)->dev;
    653          struct mxb *mxb = (struct mxb *)dev->ext_priv;
    654  
    655          DEB_D("VIDIOC_S_AUDIO %d\n", a->index);
    656          if (mxb_inputs[mxb->cur_input].audioset & (1 << a->index)) {

This a->index comes from the ioctl and it's a u32 so the shift can wrap. The .audioset variable is always 0x3f. In other words BIT(6) is the highest valid bit so we could add a check:

		if (a->index > MXB_AUDIOS)
			return;

    657                  if (mxb->cur_audinput != a->index) {
    658                          mxb->cur_audinput = a->index;
                                 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Now here's the complication. We also use a->index as an index into the mxb_inputs[] array which only has MXB_INPUTS (4) elements, so just adding the limit would still lead to a different array out of bounds later...

    659                          tea6420_route(mxb, a->index);
    660                          if (mxb->cur_audinput == 0)
    661                                  mxb_update_audmode(mxb);
    662                  }
    663                  return 0;
    664          }
    665          return -EINVAL;
    666  }

regards,
dan carpenter

#1 lore raw
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Carpenter

[ Hi Hans,

This might not really be your bug, but I just respect you a lot and so I always come to you with questions and for advice. -dan ]

Hmm, in other words, I'm too nice!

Quoted 36 lines

Hello Hans Verkuil,

The patch 6680427791c9: "[media] mxb: fix audio handling" from Apr 30, 2012, leads to the following static checker warning:

	drivers/media/pci/saa7146/mxb.c:196 tea6420_route()
	warn: uncapped user index 'TEA6420_cd[idx]'

drivers/media/pci/saa7146/mxb.c
194 static inline void tea6420_route(struct mxb *mxb, int idx) 195 {
--> 196 v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_1, audio, s_routing,

    197 		TEA6420_cd[idx][0].input, TEA6420_cd[idx][0].output, 0);
                                   ^^^

Index overflow. The TEA6420_cd[] array has MXB_AUDIOS + 1 (which is 7 altogether) elements.

    198 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_2, audio, s_routing,
    199 		TEA6420_cd[idx][1].input, TEA6420_cd[idx][1].output, 0);
    200 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_1, audio, s_routing,
    201 		TEA6420_line[idx][0].input, TEA6420_line[idx][0].output, 0);
    202 	v4l2_subdev_call(mxb->tea6420_2, audio, s_routing,
    203 		TEA6420_line[idx][1].input, TEA6420_line[idx][1].output, 0);
    204 }

[ snip ]

    650  static int vidioc_s_audio(struct file *file, void *fh, const struct v4l2_audio *a)
    651  {
    652          struct saa7146_dev *dev = ((struct saa7146_fh *)fh)->dev;
    653          struct mxb *mxb = (struct mxb *)dev->ext_priv;
    654  
    655          DEB_D("VIDIOC_S_AUDIO %d\n", a->index);
    656          if (mxb_inputs[mxb->cur_input].audioset & (1 << a->index)) {
Quoted 6 lines

This a->index comes from the ioctl and it's a u32 so the shift can wrap. The .audioset variable is always 0x3f. In other words BIT(6) is the highest valid bit so we could add a check:

		if (a->index > MXB_AUDIOS)
			return;

That's correct.

Quoted 6 lines
    657                  if (mxb->cur_audinput != a->index) {
    658                          mxb->cur_audinput = a->index;
                                 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Now here's the complication. We also use a->index as an index into the mxb_inputs[] array which only has MXB_INPUTS (4) elements, so just

We do? Where does that happen? I don't see that in the code. That would be a bug since mxb_inputs are the video inputs, whereas s_audio deals with audio inputs.

Regards,

Hans

Quoted 15 lines

adding the limit would still lead to a different array out of bounds later...

    659                          tea6420_route(mxb, a->index);
    660                          if (mxb->cur_audinput == 0)
    661                                  mxb_update_audmode(mxb);
    662                  }
    663                  return 0;
    664          }
    665          return -EINVAL;
    666  }

regards,
dan carpenter

#2 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Hans Verkuil
Quoted 4 lines · Dan Carpenter

[ Hi Hans,

This might not really be your bug, but I just respect you a lot and so I always come to you with questions and for advice. -dan ]

Hmm, in other words, I'm too nice!

Indeed.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 5 lines
    657                  if (mxb->cur_audinput != a->index) {
    658                          mxb->cur_audinput = a->index;
                                 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Now here's the complication. We also use a->index as an index into the mxb_inputs[] array which only has MXB_INPUTS (4) elements, so just

We do? Where does that happen? I don't see that in the code. That would be a bug since mxb_inputs are the video inputs, whereas s_audio deals with audio inputs.

Oh, you're right. But then there is a smaller problem because we use it as in index into the mxb_audios[] array and that array only has 6 elements so we're still out of bounds. The bigger array has a mute element at the end.

regards,
dan carpenter