Skip to contentSkip to conversation

CPU vulnerabilities and web JavaScript

DISCUSSION Kernel User 1 participant 2 messages Dec 8, 2019 – Dec 9, 2019

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello kernel developers!

I have been looking for information but I couldn't find the answers I need, so thought it might be best to ask the experts first hand.

As soon as Spectre and Meltdown were announced in early 2018 I got paranoid. I am not a programmer per se but my understanding is that the main security mechanism in computers (isolation) is not reliable any more and there is no fix for it - only mitigations which are not available for all vulnerabilities and for all CPUs.

So I instantly blocked all web JavaScript in browsers. I don't want anything creepy reading the contents of my RAM, my passwords, keys or anything else in a way which it is not supposed to. However without JS web (and life) is difficult and for some sites (e.g. online payments) I must use JS.

So what I do:

To minimize the chance of any JS reading anything important from the contents of my RAM I "simulate single tasking":

1. Close all open programs

2. Clean clipboard contents

3. Lock any open keyrings

4. Enable JS for the particular website only (one window, one tab, incognito mode, all history/cache cleared beforehand)

5. Do what I need on the site as quickly as possible.

6. Close the browser

Of course there are the processes running in background. I am also aware that closing a program doesn't necessarily mean it wipes the memory it has used but simply makes it available for other apps (i.e. memory contents may still be vulnerable). I also have no idea whether the login credentials (of the current system user I am logged in as) are somewhere in a vulnerable RAM zone. IOW I realize my approach is incomplete.

So my questions to the experts here are:

(1) Is what I do reasonable, meaningful and does it actually provide any additional security? (assume a CPU with, or without mitigations)

(2) As experts knowing the intricacies of all that, what is your approach and recommendations regarding usage of web JavaScript?

*NOTE: I am aware that web-JS, even without vulnerabilities, has additional privacy implications but I am asking only in relation to CPU vulnerabilities.

Sorry for the long message.
I really hope you could shed some light on the subject!