unexpected truncated files
While testing with the current 5.7 development kernel, I've encountered some strange behaviour. I'm using Gentoo linux, and during updating the system I got some unexpected errors. It looked like some files were missing. Some investigations showed me, that files from shortly installed packages were truncated to zero. So for example the config files for apache webserver were affected. I've reinstalled apache, verified that the config was ok and continued the system update with the next package. After this, the apache config files were truncated again. I've found several files from different packages that were affed too, but only text files (configs, cmake-files, headers). Files which were writen, are truncated by some other write operation to the filesystem.
I'm not sure, if this is really caused by btrfs, but it's the most obvious candidate. After switching back to 5.6-kernel, the truncation stopped und I was able to (re-)install the packages without any trouble.
Has anyone ideas what could cause this behaviour?
Signature · 2 lines
Regards, Johannes Hirte
Quoted 13 lines · Johannes Hirte
While testing with the current 5.7 development kernel, I've encountered some strange behaviour. I'm using Gentoo linux, and during updating the system I got some unexpected errors. It looked like some files were missing. Some investigations showed me, that files from shortly installed packages were truncated to zero. So for example the config files for apache webserver were affected. I've reinstalled apache, verified that the config was ok and continued the system update with the next package. After this, the apache config files were truncated again. I've found several files from different packages that were affed too, but only text files (configs, cmake-files, headers). Files which were writen, are truncated by some other write operation to the filesystem.
Quoted 5 lines
I'm not sure, if this is really caused by btrfs, but it's the most obvious candidate. After switching back to 5.6-kernel, the truncation stopped und I was able to (re-)install the packages without any trouble.
Has anyone ideas what could cause this behaviour?
It's likely due to file cloning.
I found this out yesterday but hadn't sent a patch yet, was waiting for monday morning.
I've just sent the patch to the list:
https://patchwork.kernel.org/patch/11474453/
Since you are only getting this with small files, it's likely the cloning of inline extents causing it, due to some changes in 5.7 that changed the file size update logic.
Can you try it?
Thanks.
Quoted 5 lines
--
Regards,
Johannes Hirte
Signature · 3 lines
Filipe David Manana, “Whether you think you can, or you think you can't — you're right.”
Quoted 28 lines · Filipe Manana
Quoted 13 lines · Johannes Hirte
While testing with the current 5.7 development kernel, I've encountered some strange behaviour. I'm using Gentoo linux, and during updating the system I got some unexpected errors. It looked like some files were missing. Some investigations showed me, that files from shortly installed packages were truncated to zero. So for example the config files for apache webserver were affected. I've reinstalled apache, verified that the config was ok and continued the system update with the next package. After this, the apache config files were truncated again. I've found several files from different packages that were affed too, but only text files (configs, cmake-files, headers). Files which were writen, are truncated by some other write operation to the filesystem.
Quoted 5 lines
I'm not sure, if this is really caused by btrfs, but it's the most obvious candidate. After switching back to 5.6-kernel, the truncation stopped und I was able to (re-)install the packages without any trouble.
Has anyone ideas what could cause this behaviour?
It's likely due to file cloning.
I found this out yesterday but hadn't sent a patch yet, was waiting for monday morning.
I've just sent the patch to the list:
https://patchwork.kernel.org/patch/11474453/
Quoted 7 lines
Since you are only getting this with small files, it's likely the cloning of inline extents causing it, due to some changes in 5.7 that changed the file size update logic.
Can you try it?
Thanks.
Yes, this was it. Installing the second package for triggering the truncation was a coincidence. Installing the first package (appache here) and rebooting triggered the error reliable. With portage (the package manager from Gentoo) everything is compiled and installed to a a location on /tmp. After this, the content is copied to the target location and seems to be done with cloning. With your patch the problem doesn't occur anymore.
Signature · 2 lines
Regards, Johannes Hirte
Quoted 38 lines · Johannes Hirte
Quoted 28 lines · Filipe Manana
Quoted 13 lines · Johannes Hirte
While testing with the current 5.7 development kernel, I've encountered some strange behaviour. I'm using Gentoo linux, and during updating the system I got some unexpected errors. It looked like some files were missing. Some investigations showed me, that files from shortly installed packages were truncated to zero. So for example the config files for apache webserver were affected. I've reinstalled apache, verified that the config was ok and continued the system update with the next package. After this, the apache config files were truncated again. I've found several files from different packages that were affed too, but only text files (configs, cmake-files, headers). Files which were writen, are truncated by some other write operation to the filesystem.
Quoted 5 lines
I'm not sure, if this is really caused by btrfs, but it's the most obvious candidate. After switching back to 5.6-kernel, the truncation stopped und I was able to (re-)install the packages without any trouble.
Has anyone ideas what could cause this behaviour?
It's likely due to file cloning.
I found this out yesterday but hadn't sent a patch yet, was waiting for monday morning.
I've just sent the patch to the list:
https://patchwork.kernel.org/patch/11474453/Quoted 7 lines
Since you are only getting this with small files, it's likely the cloning of inline extents causing it, due to some changes in 5.7 that changed the file size update logic.
Can you try it?
Thanks.
Quoted 7 lines
Yes, this was it. Installing the second package for triggering the truncation was a coincidence. Installing the first package (appache here) and rebooting triggered the error reliable. With portage (the package manager from Gentoo) everything is compiled and installed to a a location on /tmp. After this, the content is copied to the target location and seems to be done with cloning. With your patch the problem doesn't occur anymore.
Thanks for testing it.
I'll add reported-by and test-by tags to the patch.
Quoted 5 lines
--
Regards,
Johannes Hirte
Signature · 3 lines
Filipe David Manana, “Whether you think you can, or you think you can't — you're right.”