Skip to contentSkip to conversation

dbench throughput(sync, reflink=0|1) on xfs over hardware throughput

DISCUSSION Wang Yugui 1 participant 3 messages Oct 13, 2020 – Oct 14, 2020

lore
Share & tools
lore

Wang Yugui

author
#0 lore raw

Hi,

#any reply, please Cc: [email protected]

dbench throughput(sync, reflink=0|1) on xfs over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Is this a bug of xfs sync? or some feature of performance optimization?

we test mkfs.xfs -m reflink=0|1, crc=0|1, still over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Disk: TOSHIBA PX05SMQ040
This is a 12Gb/s SAS SSD disk, but connect to 6Gb/s SAS HBA, so it works with 6Gb/s.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 32
#Throughput 884.406 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 1
#Throughput 149.172 MB/sec (sync open)

we test the same disk with ext4 filesystem,
the throughput is very close to, but less than the hardware limit.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 32
#Throughput 740.95 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 1
#Throughput 124.67 MB/sec (sync open)

linux kernel: 5.4.70, 5.9.0

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/13

author
#1 lore raw

Hi,

For xfs sync performance optimization, there is an option 'osyncisdsync' which is removed in 4.0(man xfs)

the xfs sync performance optimization in linux 5.4.70/5.9.0 is beyond 'osyncisdsync'? When multiple write(sync) at the same time, just some of them are guaranteed?

Or deduplication(based on reflink=1) help the sync write? and 'mkfs.xfs -m reflink=0' failed to disable it?

iotop show that 'Actual DISK WRITE:' is NOT over hardware throughput.

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/14

Quoted 38 lines

Hi,

#any reply, please Cc: [email protected]

dbench throughput(sync, reflink=0|1) on xfs over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Is this a bug of xfs sync? or some feature of performance optimization?

we test mkfs.xfs -m reflink=0|1, crc=0|1, still over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Disk: TOSHIBA PX05SMQ040
This is a 12Gb/s SAS SSD disk, but connect to 6Gb/s SAS HBA, so it works with 6Gb/s.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 32
#Throughput 884.406 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 1
#Throughput 149.172 MB/sec (sync open)

we test the same disk with ext4 filesystem,
the throughput is very close to, but less than the hardware limit.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 32
#Throughput 740.95 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 1
#Throughput 124.67 MB/sec (sync open)

linux kernel: 5.4.70, 5.9.0

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/13

author
#2 lore raw

Hi,

Thanks a lot fo Dave Chinner,

The 'Throughput' of dbench include not only 'write', but also include 'read' in dbench too.

And 'max_latency' include not only 'write', but also include others too.

1)dbench result example1
WriteX 365460 4.474 2279.808
...
Throughput 385.697 MB/sec (sync open) 32 clients 32 procs max_latency=2279.818 ms

2)dbench result example2
WriteX 741543 3.521 16.380
...
Throughput 779.972 MB/sec (sync open) 48 clients 48 procs max_latency=11.246 ms

for ext4, with more clients(32->80), the Throughput of ext4 is over 6Gb/s too.

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/15

Quoted 57 lines

Hi,

For xfs sync performance optimization, there is an option 'osyncisdsync' which is removed in 4.0(man xfs)

the xfs sync performance optimization in linux 5.4.70/5.9.0 is beyond 'osyncisdsync'? When multiple write(sync) at the same time, just some of them are guaranteed?

Or deduplication(based on reflink=1) help the sync write? and 'mkfs.xfs -m reflink=0' failed to disable it?

iotop show that 'Actual DISK WRITE:' is NOT over hardware throughput.

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/14

Quoted 38 lines

Hi,

#any reply, please Cc: [email protected]

dbench throughput(sync, reflink=0|1) on xfs over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Is this a bug of xfs sync? or some feature of performance optimization?

we test mkfs.xfs -m reflink=0|1, crc=0|1, still over hardware throughput(6Gb/s=750MB/s).

Disk: TOSHIBA PX05SMQ040
This is a 12Gb/s SAS SSD disk, but connect to 6Gb/s SAS HBA, so it works with 6Gb/s.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 32
#Throughput 884.406 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /xfs 1
#Throughput 149.172 MB/sec (sync open)

we test the same disk with ext4 filesystem,
the throughput is very close to, but less than the hardware limit.

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 32
#Throughput 740.95 MB/sec (sync open)

dbench -s -t 60 -D /ext4 1
#Throughput 124.67 MB/sec (sync open)

linux kernel: 5.4.70, 5.9.0

Best Regards
Wang Yugui ([email protected])
2020/10/13