Skip to contentSkip to conversation

rtnetlink: Support fine-grained netdevice bulk deletion

PATCH Superseded Lahav Schlesinger 6 participants 11 messages Dec 2, 2021 – Dec 7, 2021

Subsystems (2)

v4 of 6 Superseded Latest is v6 →

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

PATCH v4 1/1 rtnetlink: Support fine-grained netdevice bulk deletion

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

---
v3 -> v4
- Change single IFLA_INDEX_LIST into multiple IFLA_IFINDEX
- Fail if passing both IFLA_GROUP and at least one IFLA_IFNEX

v2 -> v3
- Rename 'ifindex_list' to 'ifindices', and pass it as int*
- Clamp 'ops' variable in second loop.

v1 -> v2
- Unset 'len' of IFLA_IFINDEX_LIST in policy.
- Use __dev_get_by_index() instead of n^2 loop.
- Return -ENODEV if any ifindex is not present.
- Saved devices in an array.
- Fix formatting.

 include/uapi/linux/if_link.h |  1 +
 net/core/rtnetlink.c         | 68 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 69 insertions(+)
include/uapi/linux/if_link.h +1 -0
index eebd3894fe89..68fcde9c0c5e 100644
@@ -348,6 +348,7 @@ enum {
 	IFLA_PARENT_DEV_NAME,
 	IFLA_PARENT_DEV_BUS_NAME,
 
+	IFLA_IFINDEX,
 	__IFLA_MAX
 };
 
net/core/rtnetlink.c +68 -0

92 lines not on this page · raw message

Signature · 1 line
2.25.1
maintainer
#1 lore raw
Quoted 7 lines · On Thu, 2 Dec 2021 19:45:02 +0200 Lahav Schlesinger wrote:

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

LGTM, David, Nicolas, ack?

https://lore.kernel.org/all/[email protected]/

#2 lore raw
In reply to Lahav Schlesinger
Quoted 67 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

---
v3 -> v4
- Change single IFLA_INDEX_LIST into multiple IFLA_IFINDEX
- Fail if passing both IFLA_GROUP and at least one IFLA_IFNEX

v2 -> v3
- Rename 'ifindex_list' to 'ifindices', and pass it as int*
- Clamp 'ops' variable in second loop.

v1 -> v2
- Unset 'len' of IFLA_IFINDEX_LIST in policy.
- Use __dev_get_by_index() instead of n^2 loop.
- Return -ENODEV if any ifindex is not present.
- Saved devices in an array.
- Fix formatting.

Quoted 4 lines
 include/uapi/linux/if_link.h |  1 +
 net/core/rtnetlink.c         | 68 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 69 insertions(+)

I like the idea, but what happens if the same device is present twice or more times? I mean are you sure it is safe to call dellink method of all device types multiple times with the same device?

Cheers,
Nik

#3 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines · Nikolay Aleksandrov

I like the idea, but what happens if the same device is present twice or more times? I mean are you sure it is safe to call dellink method of all device types multiple times with the same device?

Very good point. Can't rely on dellink callbacks being able to handle multiple calls.

#4 lore raw
In reply to Nikolay Aleksandrov
Quoted 76 lines · Nikolay Aleksandrov

CAUTION: External E-Mail - Use caution with links and attachments

Quoted 67 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

---
v3 -> v4
- Change single IFLA_INDEX_LIST into multiple IFLA_IFINDEX
- Fail if passing both IFLA_GROUP and at least one IFLA_IFNEX

v2 -> v3
- Rename 'ifindex_list' to 'ifindices', and pass it as int*
- Clamp 'ops' variable in second loop.

v1 -> v2
- Unset 'len' of IFLA_IFINDEX_LIST in policy.
- Use __dev_get_by_index() instead of n^2 loop.
- Return -ENODEV if any ifindex is not present.
- Saved devices in an array.
- Fix formatting.

Quoted 4 lines
 include/uapi/linux/if_link.h |  1 +
 net/core/rtnetlink.c         | 68 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 69 insertions(+)
Quoted 7 lines

I like the idea, but what happens if the same device is present twice or more times? I mean are you sure it is safe to call dellink method of all device types multiple times with the same device?

Cheers,
Nik

Thanks for catching this. I initially went over a few dellink() functions and they all seemed to be re-entrant, but evidently I missed some..

#5 lore raw
In reply to Lahav Schlesinger
Quoted 33 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Quoted 8 lines

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

These are the number I get in a VM running on my laptop.

Moving 16k dummy netdevs to a group:

# time -p ip -b group.batch 
real 1.91
user 0.04
sys 0.27

Deleting the group:

# time -p ip link del group 10
real 6.15
user 0.00
sys 3.02

IMO, these numbers do not justify a new API. Also, your user space can be taught to create all the netdevs in the same group to begin with:

# ip link add name dummy1 group 10 type dummy
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 1500 qdisc noop state DOWN mode DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff

Moreover, unlike the list API that is specific to deletion, the group API also lets you batch set operations:

# ip link set group 10 mtu 2000
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 2000 qdisc noop state DOWN mode
DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff

If you are using namespaces, then during "factory reset" you can delete the namespace which should trigger batch deletion of the netdevs inside it.

Quoted 10 lines

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

#6 lore raw
Quoted 55 lines · Ido Schimmel

CAUTION: External E-Mail - Use caution with links and attachments

Quoted 33 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Quoted 8 lines

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

These are the number I get in a VM running on my laptop.

Moving 16k dummy netdevs to a group:

# time -p ip -b group.batch
real 1.91
user 0.04
sys 0.27
Quoted 7 lines

Deleting the group:

# time -p ip link del group 10
real 6.15
user 0.00
sys 3.02

Hi Ido, in your tests in which state the dummy devices are before deleting/changing group?
When they are DOWN I get similar numbers to yours (16k devices):

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real	0m0.640s
user	0m0.152s
sys	0m0.478s
# time ip link delete group 100
real	0m5.324s
user	0m0.017s
sys	0m4.991s

But when the devices are in state UP, I get:

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real	0m48.605s
user	0m0.218s
sys	0m48.244s
# time ip link delete group 100
real	1m13.219s
user	0m0.010s
sys	1m9.117s

And for completeness, setting the devices to DOWN prior to deleting them is as fast as deleting them in the first place while they're UP.

Also, while this is probably a minuscule issue, changing the group of 10ks+ of interfaces will result in a storm of netlink events that will make any userspace program listening on link events to spend time handling these events. This will result in twice as many events compared to directly deleting the devices.

Quoted 8 lines

IMO, these numbers do not justify a new API. Also, your user space can be taught to create all the netdevs in the same group to begin with:

# ip link add name dummy1 group 10 type dummy
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 1500 qdisc noop state DOWN mode DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff
Quoted 8 lines

Moreover, unlike the list API that is specific to deletion, the group API also lets you batch set operations:

# ip link set group 10 mtu 2000
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 2000 qdisc noop state DOWN mode
DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff

The list API can be extended to support other operations as well (similar to group set operations, we can call do_setlink() for each device specified in an IFLA_IFINDEX).
I didn't implement it in this patch because we don't have a use for it currently.

Quoted 5 lines

If you are using namespaces, then during "factory reset" you can delete the namespace which should trigger batch deletion of the netdevs inside it.

In some scenarios we are required to delete only a subset of devices (e.g. when a physical link becomes DOWN, we need to delete all the VLANs and any tunnels configured on that device). Furthermore, a user is allowed to load a new configuration in which he deletes only some of the devices (e.g. delete all of the loopbacks in the system), while not touching the other devices.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 10 lines

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

#7 lore raw
Quoted 90 lines · Lahav Schlesinger
Quoted 55 lines · Ido Schimmel

CAUTION: External E-Mail - Use caution with links and attachments

Quoted 33 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Quoted 8 lines

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

These are the number I get in a VM running on my laptop.

Moving 16k dummy netdevs to a group:

# time -p ip -b group.batch
real 1.91
user 0.04
sys 0.27
Quoted 7 lines

Deleting the group:

# time -p ip link del group 10
real 6.15
user 0.00
sys 3.02

Hi Ido, in your tests in which state the dummy devices are before deleting/changing group?
When they are DOWN I get similar numbers to yours (16k devices):

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real	0m0.640s
user	0m0.152s
sys	0m0.478s
# time ip link delete group 100
real	0m5.324s
user	0m0.017s
sys	0m4.991s

But when the devices are in state UP, I get:

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real	0m48.605s
user	0m0.218s
sys	0m48.244s
# time ip link delete group 100
real	1m13.219s
user	0m0.010s
sys	1m9.117s
Quoted 8 lines

And for completeness, setting the devices to DOWN prior to deleting them is as fast as deleting them in the first place while they're UP.

Also, while this is probably a minuscule issue, changing the group of 10ks+ of interfaces will result in a storm of netlink events that will make any userspace program listening on link events to spend time handling these events. This will result in twice as many events compared to directly deleting the devices.

Yes, in my setup the netdevs were down. Looking at the code, I think the reason for the 75x increase in latency is the fact that netlink notifications are not generated when the netdev is down. See netdev_state_change().

In your specific case, it is quite useless for the kernel to generate 16k notifications when moving the netdevs to a group since the entire reason they are moved to a group is so that they could be deleted in a batch.

I assume that there are other use cases where having the kernel suppress notifications can be useful. Did you consider adding such a flag to the request? I think such a mechanism is more generic/useful than an ad-hoc API to delete a list of netdevs and should allow you to utilize the existing group deletion mechanism.

Quoted 47 lines
Quoted 9 lines

IMO, these numbers do not justify a new API. Also, your user space can be taught to create all the netdevs in the same group to begin with:

# ip link add name dummy1 group 10 type dummy
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 1500 qdisc noop state DOWN mode DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff
Quoted 8 lines

Moreover, unlike the list API that is specific to deletion, the group API also lets you batch set operations:

# ip link set group 10 mtu 2000
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 2000 qdisc noop state DOWN mode
DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff

The list API can be extended to support other operations as well (similar to group set operations, we can call do_setlink() for each device specified in an IFLA_IFINDEX).
I didn't implement it in this patch because we don't have a use for it currently.

Quoted 5 lines

If you are using namespaces, then during "factory reset" you can delete the namespace which should trigger batch deletion of the netdevs inside it.

In some scenarios we are required to delete only a subset of devices (e.g. when a physical link becomes DOWN, we need to delete all the VLANs and any tunnels configured on that device). Furthermore, a user is allowed to load a new configuration in which he deletes only some of the devices (e.g. delete all of the loopbacks in the system), while not touching the other devices.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 10 lines

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

#8 lore raw
Quoted 113 lines · Ido Schimmel

CAUTION: External E-Mail - Use caution with links and attachments

Quoted 90 lines · Lahav Schlesinger
Quoted 55 lines · Ido Schimmel

CAUTION: External E-Mail - Use caution with links and attachments

Quoted 33 lines · Lahav Schlesinger

Under large scale, some routers are required to support tens of thousands of devices at once, both physical and virtual (e.g. loopbacks, tunnels, vrfs, etc).
At times such routers are required to delete massive amounts of devices at once, such as when a factory reset is performed on the router (causing a deletion of all devices), or when a configuration is restored after an upgrade, or as a request from an operator.

Currently there are 2 means of deleting devices using Netlink:
1. Deleting a single device (either by ifindex using ifinfomsg::ifi_index, or by name using IFLA_IFNAME)
2. Delete all device that belong to a group (using IFLA_GROUP)

Deletion of devices one-by-one has poor performance on large scale of devices compared to "group deletion":
After all device are handled, netdev_run_todo() is called which calls rcu_barrier() to finish any outstanding RCU callbacks that were registered during the deletion of the device, then wait until the refcount of all the devices is 0, then perform final cleanups.

However, calling rcu_barrier() is a very costly operation, each call taking in the order of 10s of milliseconds.

When deleting a large number of device one-by-one, rcu_barrier() will be called for each device being deleted.
As an example, following benchmark deletes 10K loopback devices, all of which are UP and with only IPv6 LLA being configured:

1. Deleting one-by-one using 1 thread : 243 seconds
2. Deleting one-by-one using 10 thread: 70 seconds
3. Deleting one-by-one using 50 thread: 54 seconds
4. Deleting all using "group deletion": 30 seconds

Quoted 8 lines

Note that even though the deletion logic takes place under the rtnl lock, since the call to rcu_barrier() is outside the lock we gain some improvements.

But, while "group deletion" is the fastest, it is not suited for deleting large number of arbitrary devices which are unknown a head of time. Furthermore, moving large number of devices to a group is also a costly operation.

These are the number I get in a VM running on my laptop.

Moving 16k dummy netdevs to a group:

# time -p ip -b group.batch
real 1.91
user 0.04
sys 0.27
Quoted 7 lines

Deleting the group:

# time -p ip link del group 10
real 6.15
user 0.00
sys 3.02

Hi Ido, in your tests in which state the dummy devices are before deleting/changing group?
When they are DOWN I get similar numbers to yours (16k devices):

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real  0m0.640s
user  0m0.152s
sys   0m0.478s
# time ip link delete group 100
real  0m5.324s
user  0m0.017s
sys   0m4.991s

But when the devices are in state UP, I get:

# time ip -b group_16000_batch
real  0m48.605s
user  0m0.218s
sys   0m48.244s
# time ip link delete group 100
real  1m13.219s
user  0m0.010s
sys   1m9.117s
Quoted 8 lines

And for completeness, setting the devices to DOWN prior to deleting them is as fast as deleting them in the first place while they're UP.

Also, while this is probably a minuscule issue, changing the group of 10ks+ of interfaces will result in a storm of netlink events that will make any userspace program listening on link events to spend time handling these events. This will result in twice as many events compared to directly deleting the devices.

Yes, in my setup the netdevs were down. Looking at the code, I think the reason for the 75x increase in latency is the fact that netlink notifications are not generated when the netdev is down. See netdev_state_change().

In your specific case, it is quite useless for the kernel to generate 16k notifications when moving the netdevs to a group since the entire reason they are moved to a group is so that they could be deleted in a batch.

Quoted 5 lines

I assume that there are other use cases where having the kernel suppress notifications can be useful. Did you consider adding such a flag to the request? I think such a mechanism is more generic/useful than an ad-hoc API to delete a list of netdevs and should allow you to utilize the existing group deletion mechanism.

I think having an API to suppress kernel notifications will be abused by userspace and introduce hard-to-debug bugs, e.g. some program will incorrectly set this flag when it shouldn't (on the premise that this flag will "make things faster") and inadvertently break other programs that depend on the notifications to function.

Furthermore, such ability can be used by malicious programs to hide their activity, effectively masking themselves from Intrusion Detection Systems that monitor these notifications.
Allowing this flag _only_ for group change can still be used maliciously, e.g. a malicious program can covertly change the group of a device to a "management group" (something that will usually be detected by an IDS), and depend on a trusty program that performs bulk group operation on said group to change some configuration of that device.

The last point might be a bit of a stretch, but I imagine there are more creative scenarios where such flag can be maliciously used.

Quoted 48 lines
Quoted 48 lines
Quoted 10 lines

IMO, these numbers do not justify a new API. Also, your user space can be taught to create all the netdevs in the same group to begin with:

# ip link add name dummy1 group 10 type dummy
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 1500 qdisc noop state DOWN mode DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff
Quoted 8 lines

Moreover, unlike the list API that is specific to deletion, the group API also lets you batch set operations:

# ip link set group 10 mtu 2000
# ip link show dev dummy1
10: dummy1: <BROADCAST,NOARP> mtu 2000 qdisc noop state DOWN mode
DEFAULT group 10 qlen 1000
    link/ether 12:b6:7d:ff:48:99 brd ff:ff:ff:ff:ff:ff

The list API can be extended to support other operations as well (similar to group set operations, we can call do_setlink() for each device specified in an IFLA_IFINDEX).
I didn't implement it in this patch because we don't have a use for it currently.

Quoted 5 lines

If you are using namespaces, then during "factory reset" you can delete the namespace which should trigger batch deletion of the netdevs inside it.

In some scenarios we are required to delete only a subset of devices (e.g. when a physical link becomes DOWN, we need to delete all the VLANs and any tunnels configured on that device). Furthermore, a user is allowed to load a new configuration in which he deletes only some of the devices (e.g. delete all of the loopbacks in the system), while not touching the other devices.

Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 10 lines

This patch adds support for passing an arbitrary list of ifindex of devices to delete with a new IFLA_IFINDEX attribute. A single message may contain multiple instances of this attribute).
This gives a more fine-grained control over which devices to delete, while still resulting in rcu_barrier() being called only once. Indeed, the timings of using this new API to delete 10K devices is the same as using the existing "group" deletion.

#9 lore raw

Le 05/12/2021 à 16:05, Lahav Schlesinger a écrit :
[snip]

Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 10 lines

In your specific case, it is quite useless for the kernel to generate 16k notifications when moving the netdevs to a group since the entire reason they are moved to a group is so that they could be deleted in a batch.

I assume that there are other use cases where having the kernel suppress notifications can be useful. Did you consider adding such a flag to the request? I think such a mechanism is more generic/useful than an ad-hoc API to delete a list of netdevs and should allow you to utilize the existing group deletion mechanism.

Quoted 5 lines

I think having an API to suppress kernel notifications will be abused by userspace and introduce hard-to-debug bugs, e.g. some program will incorrectly set this flag when it shouldn't (on the premise that this flag will "make things faster") and inadvertently break other programs that depend on the notifications to function.

+1

#10 lore raw
In reply to Ido Schimmel
Quoted 10 lines · Ido Schimmel

In your specific case, it is quite useless for the kernel to generate 16k notifications when moving the netdevs to a group since the entire reason they are moved to a group is so that they could be deleted in a batch.

I assume that there are other use cases where having the kernel suppress notifications can be useful. Did you consider adding such a flag to the request? I think such a mechanism is more generic/useful than an ad-hoc API to delete a list of netdevs and should allow you to utilize the existing group deletion mechanism.

I do agree that we do not want to allow netdev changes without userspace notifications.

It would be nice to re-use the group delete API, but really there is no guaranteed, reserved group value that can be used for a temp assignment and to then use the group delete call.