Removing LLVM objtool warning filter
Hi Philip and other LKP folks,
At some point, I believe there was a filter set up so that reports of objtool warnings that appear in clang builds were sent only to our mailing list ([email protected]) for triage. At this point, we believe it is best to treat those reports like other objtool reports and send them to the author of the change that introduced the warning with our list on CC in case people think it is a compiler bug or need further help understanding what is going on. Is that possible?
Cheers,
Nathan
Quoted 9 lines · Nathan Chancellor
Hi Philip and other LKP folks,
At some point, I believe there was a filter set up so that reports of objtool warnings that appear in clang builds were sent only to our mailing list ([email protected]) for triage. At this point, we believe it is best to treat those reports like other objtool reports and send them to the author of the change that introduced the warning with our list on CC in case people think it is a compiler bug or need further help understanding what is going on. Is that possible?
Got it Nathan, I will update the bot to send out this warning to author and cc llvm list, same as other warnings from clang.
Just to confirm, is it applied to all clang version or only latest one like clang 19/20?
Thanks
Quoted 3 lines
Cheers,
Nathan
Hi Philip,
Quoted 11 lines · Philip Li
Quoted 9 lines · Nathan Chancellor
Hi Philip and other LKP folks,
At some point, I believe there was a filter set up so that reports of objtool warnings that appear in clang builds were sent only to our mailing list ([email protected]) for triage. At this point, we believe it is best to treat those reports like other objtool reports and send them to the author of the change that introduced the warning with our list on CC in case people think it is a compiler bug or need further help understanding what is going on. Is that possible?
Quoted 2 lines
Got it Nathan, I will update the bot to send out this warning to author and cc llvm list, same as other warnings from clang.
Thanks a lot!
Quoted 2 lines
Just to confirm, is it applied to all clang version or only latest one like clang 19/20?
Let's do all clang versions and see how noisy it is. If we need to scale it back to just the latest, we can definitely do so.
Cheers,
Nathan
Quoted 17 lines · Nathan Chancellor
Hi Philip,
Quoted 11 lines · Philip Li
Quoted 9 lines · Nathan Chancellor
Hi Philip and other LKP folks,
At some point, I believe there was a filter set up so that reports of objtool warnings that appear in clang builds were sent only to our mailing list ([email protected]) for triage. At this point, we believe it is best to treat those reports like other objtool reports and send them to the author of the change that introduced the warning with our list on CC in case people think it is a compiler bug or need further help understanding what is going on. Is that possible?
Quoted 2 lines
Got it Nathan, I will update the bot to send out this warning to author and cc llvm list, same as other warnings from clang.
Quoted 7 lines
Thanks a lot!
Quoted 2 lines
Just to confirm, is it applied to all clang version or only latest one like clang 19/20?
Let's do all clang versions and see how noisy it is. If we need to scale it back to just the latest, we can definitely do so.
Got it, thanks for confirmation.
Quoted 3 lines
Cheers,
Nathan