Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Allowing empty enevelope senders

mlmmj Thomas Jarosch 3 participants 7 messages Jul 8, 2014 – Jul 11, 2014

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hi,

we have one mlmmj list that gets back email bounces from a newsletter. Such bounce emails are usually sent using an empty envelope sender address "<>".

Currently mlmmj discards all emails with an empty envelope sender address and this is not configurable (see mlmmj-process.c, line ~704)

I've found a good description why an empty envelope is a valid thing according to RFC 821, page 15:
http://marc.merlins.org/netrants/nullenvelope.txt

Should we make this configurable or disable the code altogether? If we make it configurable: Should we invert the default value?

Best regards,
Thomas

#1 lore raw

Thomas Jarosch:

Quoted 3 lines

we have one mlmmj list that gets back email bounces from a newsletter. Such bounce emails are usually sent using an empty envelope sender address "<>".

that may happen

Quoted 2 lines

Currently mlmmj discards all emails with an empty envelope sender address and this is not configurable (see mlmmj-process.c, line ~704)

show logs of your evidence please

Quoted 3 lines

I've found a good description why an empty envelope is a valid thing according to RFC 821, page 15:
http://marc.merlins.org/netrants/nullenvelope.txt

RFC821 is 32 years old and updated many times. In terms of <> it's still not wrong
but be careful with your references.

Quoted 2 lines

Should we make this configurable or disable the code altogether? If we make it configurable: Should we invert the default value?

first make sure you solve the right problem

Andreas

#2 lore raw
In reply to Thomas Jarosch
Quoted 3 lines · Thomas Jarosch

I've found a good description why an empty envelope is a valid thing according to RFC 821, page 15:
http://marc.merlins.org/netrants/nullenvelope.txt

That link correctly identifies empty envelope senders as used for bounce messages.

Furthermore, as you've identified, the mails are being discarded by Mlmmj, not the mail server. The mail server accepts them, meeting the requirements of the RFC and the document above. Mlmmj discards them, because they should not be delivered to the mailing list.

If they are getting to that point in Mlmmj, it probably means VERP is not working/misconfigured, because bounce messages should come back to listname+bounces and get handled by mlmmj-bounce so bouncing users are automatically unsubscribed (which helps prevent your mail server getting blacklisted, among other things).

Ben.

#3 lore raw
In reply to Thomas Jarosch

Hi Ben,

Quoted 13 lines · On Thursday, 10. July 2014 17:54:01 Ben Schmidt wrote:
Quoted 3 lines · Thomas Jarosch

I've found a good description why an empty envelope is a valid thing according to RFC 821, page 15:
http://marc.merlins.org/netrants/nullenvelope.txt

That link correctly identifies empty envelope senders as used for bounce messages.

Furthermore, as you've identified, the mails are being discarded by Mlmmj, not the mail server. The mail server accepts them, meeting the requirements of the RFC and the document above. Mlmmj discards them, because they should not be delivered to the mailing list.

Quoted 5 lines

If they are getting to that point in Mlmmj, it probably means VERP is not working/misconfigured, because bounce messages should come back to listname+bounces and get handled by mlmmj-bounce so bouncing users are automatically unsubscribed (which helps prevent your mail server getting blacklisted, among other things).

the problem here is a bit more complex: The mlmmj managed mailinglist gets the replies from a separate newsletter that is not managed by mlmmj. So the return path of that newsletter is set to an address that is managed by mlmmj :)

Would you be ok with if I develop a patch to make the "discard of empty envelope address" configurable? Default is to keep the current behavior.

Thomas

#4 lore raw
In reply to Thomas Jarosch
Quoted 8 lines

the problem here is a bit more complex: The mlmmj managed mailinglist gets the replies from a separate newsletter that is not managed by mlmmj. So the return path of that newsletter is set to an address that is managed by mlmmj :)

Would you be ok with if I develop a patch to make the "discard of empty envelope address" configurable? Default is to keep the current behavior.

I'm not convinced yet. Why would you want these bounce messages delivered to the mailing list? It seems to me that such a feature is just asking for trouble on the whole.

Ben.

#5 lore raw
In reply to Thomas Jarosch
Quoted 6 lines · On Friday, 11. July 2014 06:55:39 Ben Schmidt wrote:
Quoted 6 lines

the problem here is a bit more complex: The mlmmj managed mailinglist gets the replies from a separate newsletter that is not managed by mlmmj.
So the return path of that newsletter is set to an address that is managed by mlmmj :)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Would you be ok with if I develop a patch to make the "discard of empty envelope address" configurable? Default is to keep the current behavior.

I'm not convinced yet. Why would you want these bounce messages delivered to the mailing list? It seems to me that such a feature is just asking for trouble on the whole.

the list is read by a bunch of poor human souls that have to unsubscribe the bounced recipients manually from the newsletter system.

But as this is asking probably for more trouble, we've now moved the recipients of the mlmmj list to a pure postfix based "list". That seems to do the job.

Thanks for your time.

Cheers,
Thomas

#6 lore raw
In reply to Thomas Jarosch
Quoted 15 lines · Thomas Jarosch
Quoted 6 lines · On Friday, 11. July 2014 06:55:39 Ben Schmidt wrote:
Quoted 6 lines

the problem here is a bit more complex: The mlmmj managed mailinglist gets the replies from a separate newsletter that is not managed by mlmmj.
So the return path of that newsletter is set to an address that is managed by mlmmj :)

Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 3 lines

Would you be ok with if I develop a patch to make the "discard of empty envelope address" configurable? Default is to keep the current behavior.

I'm not convinced yet. Why would you want these bounce messages delivered to the mailing list? It seems to me that such a feature is just asking for trouble on the whole.

Quoted 6 lines

the list is read by a bunch of poor human souls that have to unsubscribe the bounced recipients manually from the newsletter system.

But as this is asking probably for more trouble, we've now moved the recipients of the mlmmj list to a pure postfix based "list". That seems to do the job.

That seems like the right solution to me. It seems unlikely to me you need a full-featured MLM in this scenario, as you shouldn't need automatic bounce handling, subscription management, archives, etc. for your 'bunch of poor human souls'.

Cheers,

Ben.