Binary Drivers
Quoted 10 lines · David
Honestly, I think it *is* wrong to sell someone a physical product and then not tell them how to make it work. If you're not actually selling them the physical product but selling them a way to get a particular thing done, then don't represent that you're selling them physical product because that would presumably include the right to use it any way they wanted provided it was lawful.
How would you feel if you bought a car and then discovered that the manufacturer had welded the hood shut? How many people still do their own oil changes anyway?
I think he is right. The linux kernel is free software and there should be no closed source in it. When Windows uses closed-source drivers, it doesn´t matter, but the in the linux kernel should be only open-source.
______________________________________________________________________________
"Ein Herz für Kinder" - Ihre Spende hilft! Aktion: www.deutschlandsegelt.de Unser Dankeschön: Ihr Name auf dem Segel der 1. deutschen America's Cup-Yacht!
Hi!
Maybe this does not belong to this thread, but I am wondering why manufactorers doesn't want to release specifications about drivers. They have decided to develop some hardware for, let say 3D accelaration. Now they are selling hardware and users are buying hardware. Users are not buying hardware because they want to run mighty drivers, they want to use hardware.
1. Why they do not reveal spec. if user allready bought hardware, though they give driver for free but not specs.
2. Who can contribute if they reveal specifications (how to use hardware) ?
Can anyone answer does questions?
PS: I am not talking about NVIDIA and ATI, but let's say intel and
2700G multimedia accelerator IC. They sell IC without specifications how to use it!?
Cheers,
Rok Markovic
Am Freitag, 22. Dezember 2006 20:22 schrieb Rok Markovic:
Quoted 8 lines
Hi!
Maybe this does not belong to this thread, but I am wondering why manufactorers doesn't want to release specifications about drivers. They have decided to develop some hardware for, let say 3D accelaration. Now they are selling hardware and users are buying hardware. Users are not buying hardware because they want to run mighty drivers, they want to use hardware.
You're not alone, I think everybody who knows, how things in a computer work shares this view.
Quoted 8 lines
1. Why they do not reveal spec. if user allready bought hardware, though they give driver for free but not specs.
2. Who can contribute if they reveal specifications (how to use hardware) ?
Can anyone answer does questions?
A few years ago I had some closer contact with a driver developer of a well known consumer HW manufacturer hunting down some nasty bugs I discovered and developed workarounds for. From him I know, that most developers and engineers would have no problem to disclose the hardware specifications. The real hinderers are legal affairs and - suprisingly - marketing departments; with little more knowledge about the internals of their products, for them _everything_ created within the company is considered as not to be leaked, valuable information by them.
Wolfgang Draxinger
Quoted 8 lines · Wolfgang Draxinger
Am Freitag, 22. Dezember 2006 20:22 schrieb Rok Markovic:
Quoted 4 lines
Hi!
Maybe this does not belong to this thread, but I am wondering why manufactorers doesn't want to release specifications about drivers....
You're not alone, I think everybody who knows, how things in a computer work shares this view.
---
Two of the specific arguments I've heard are (a) that the board (and its hardware interfaces that the documentation would describe) involve IP licensed from a third party, which the board manufacturer does not have a legal right to disclose, or (b) that there is, in fact, no suitable documentation, because the boards are developed somewhat fluidly and the driver is developed directly from low-level knowledge that simply isn't written down in a form suitable for passing on.
If you're building products with no expectation of supporting outside driver developers, both of those are quite possible.
scott
Quoted 5 lines
Two of the specific arguments I've heard are (a) that the board (and its hardware interfaces that the documentation would describe) involve IP licensed from a third party, which the board manufacturer does not have a legal right to disclose,
If they can't disclose it, they can't sell it. If they can't sell it, it's fraud to tell someone that they can buy it. If a contract with a third party limits your ability to sell something to someone, you have to *tell* *them* that they do not get all of the rights of ownership because you don't own some of them and hence can't transfer them.
If I can't tell you what you're buying, I can't sell it to you. It's really that simple. I might be able to make some kind of agreement with you that's something like a sale, but it is not a normal sale and you are not buying the expected type of ownership. To claim it's a sale is fraud.
Quoted 4 lines
or (b) that there is, in fact, no
suitable documentation, because the boards are developed somewhat fluidly and the driver is developed directly from low-level knowledge that simply isn't written down in a form suitable for passing on.
You can't sell something that doesn't exist. If you sell a car even though you can't explain how anyone could drive it, that's fraud. A person who buys something is entitled to be told how to operate it and make it work (and not just the one way you think they should use it, they have the right to use it any way they want if the transaction is a normal sale including all rights). If you can't tell them that, then they are not actually buying all of the thing.
Quoted 2 lines
If you're building products with no expectation of supporting outside driver developers, both of those are quite possible.
And they're both quite fraudulent. You cannot both sell something and keep its construction a secret. A person who owns something has a right to be told what they're buying. If you are only selling some of the rights that normally come with buying something, you cannot claim you are selling it free and clear.
As I said before, this same thing used to happen with cell phones. I bought a Primeco phone, fully believing that I fully owned it. However, Primeco refused to tell me the code to unlock the phone, demanding $200 to do so. That's simply fraud -- if I fully own the phone, free and clear, they have no right to sell access to it to me. You can't sell the car and then charge for the keys.
DS
Quoted 10 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 4 lines
Two of the specific arguments I've heard are (a) that the board (and its hardware interfaces that the documentation would describe) involve IP licensed from a third party, which the board manufacturer does not have a legal right to disclose,
If they can't disclose it, they can't sell it. If they can't sell it, it's fraud to tell someone that they can buy it. If a contract with a third party limits your ability to sell something to someone, you have to *tell* *them* that they do not get all of the rights of ownership because you don't own some of them and hence can't transfer them.
They aren't /selling/ you the rights to the driver, just charging you for its /use/.
[...]
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 4 lines
or (b) that there is, in fact, no
suitable documentation, because the boards are developed somewhat fluidly and the driver is developed directly from low-level knowledge that simply isn't written down in a form suitable for passing on.You can't sell something that doesn't exist. If you sell a car even though you can't explain how anyone could drive it, that's fraud.
Nonsense.
[...]
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
If you're building products with no expectation of supporting outside driver developers, both of those are quite possible.
And they're both quite fraudulent. You cannot both sell something and keep its construction a secret.
It is quite regularly done, so this argument won't fly.
Signature · 4 lines
Dr. Horst H. von Brand User #22616 counter.li.org Departamento de Informatica Fono: +56 32 2654431 Universidad Tecnica Federico Santa Maria +56 32 2654239 Casilla 110-V, Valparaiso, Chile Fax: +56 32 2797513
Quoted 2 lines · David Schwartz
You can't sell something that doesn't exist. If you sell a car even though you can't explain how anyone could drive it, that's fraud.
Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage?
Am Sonntag, 24. Dezember 2006 07:46 schrieb [email protected]:
Quoted 3 lines
Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage?
That would be a propritary fuel injection driver then.
What we want however is access to the documentation, the specifications, that allows us to develop a very own driver, independently from the propritary one. We don't want source code or anything. Of course if the hardware manufactor supplies us with source code, that's great.
Probably any customly written driver will be suboptimal in the first place, but OTOH there are so many skilled people around in the OSS scene, that such a driver would surely soon catch up, if not even surpass the propritary one.
Happy holydays
Wolfgang Draxinger
Signature · 1 line
"sooner or later we'll reverse engineer you."
Quoted 10 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 4 lines
You can't sell something that doesn't exist. If you sell a car even though
you can't explain how anyone could drive it, that's fraud.Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage?
I assume that's a rhetorical question. Of course they are.
Now, let's try it another way: Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage if it's impossible to *start* the car without knowing that algorithm?
Then, I think it's obvious the answer is, of course, no. If you buy the car, they have to tell you the algorithm.
If knowledge of the algorithm is required to use the car in a reasonable way, even if it's not the normal expected way, then they can't keep it secret. They can't sell something while keeping secret how to *use* it. And that doesn't just mean the normal expected use. Buying something free and clear allows you to use it even in unusual ways.
Perhaps that wasn't the best example. Let's try another one. You buy a car, and then discover that the car computer has a lockout and a code needs to be entered on the alarm panel to start the car between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays. You ask the manufacturer for that code, since you would like to start your car between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays even though many people don't.
How many of the following answers would you consider fair:
1) We never wrote the code down. We knew it, but we didn't put it in a form in which we can give it to you. Most people don't need it anyway. Sorry.
2) We're sorry. We know the code, but our contract with another company prohibits us from disclosing it.
And so on.
Buying the car includes the right to start it between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays if that's what you want to do. If the manufacturer couldn't sell you the right or ability to do that, it couldn't sell you the car.
Owning a video card includes the right to make it work with Linux if that's what you want to do. If the manufacturer couldn't sell you the right or ability to do that, it couldn't sell you the video card.
DS
Quoted 43 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 9 lines · David Schwartz
Quoted 4 lines
You can't sell something that doesn't exist. If you sell a car even though
you can't explain how anyone could drive it, that's fraud.Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage?
I assume that's a rhetorical question. Of course they are.
Now, let's try it another way: Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage if it's impossible to *start* the car without knowing that algorithm?
Then, I think it's obvious the answer is, of course, no. If you buy the car, they have to tell you the algorithm.
If knowledge of the algorithm is required to use the car in a reasonable way, even if it's not the normal expected way, then they can't keep it secret. They can't sell something while keeping secret how to *use* it. And that doesn't just mean the normal expected use. Buying something free and clear allows you to use it even in unusual ways.
Perhaps that wasn't the best example. Let's try another one. You buy a car, and then discover that the car computer has a lockout and a code needs to be entered on the alarm panel to start the car between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays. You ask the manufacturer for that code, since you would like to start your car between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays even though many people don't.
How many of the following answers would you consider fair:
1) We never wrote the code down. We knew it, but we didn't put it in a form in which we can give it to you. Most people don't need it anyway. Sorry.
2) We're sorry. We know the code, but our contract with another company prohibits us from disclosing it.
And so on.
Quoted 8 lines
Buying the car includes the right to start it between 4 AM and 4:15 AM on Tuesdays if that's what you want to do. If the manufacturer couldn't sell you the right or ability to do that, it couldn't sell you the car.
Owning a video card includes the right to make it work with Linux if that's what you want to do. If the manufacturer couldn't sell you the right or ability to do that, it couldn't sell you the video card.
Here's my personal favourite example:
You walk into a car dealership to buy a new car, because your old car
is too slow to drive on the freeway; you need something faster.
The salesman shows you a great vehicle. He tells you all about how this
car is the pinnacle of automotive technology. It's got muscle. It's got finesse. It's got tons of state of the art bells and whistles. Your friends will be soooo jealous. Chicks will dig you. You have to have it. You pay the man and have it delivered to you house.
When it arrives, you can't figure out how to open the door. The front
windows are opaque, so you can't see inside.
You: "Hey, delivery guy. How do I open the door on this thing?".
Guy: "I'm not the delivery guy. I'm your driver."
You: "Huh? Look, I don't need a driver, OK? I'll drive it myself. So how do I open the door?"
Driver: "I'm sorry sir, but I can't tell you that. It's secret car company stuff. If I told you, then our competition might find out how we do it, and we would lose our competitive advantage."
You: "Whatever. I need to get to work. Let's go."
You get in the back seat, but there is an opaque barrier between you
and the front of the car.
Driver: "Just talk into the speaker on your left, sir, and I'll go where you tell me to."
You get out on the freeway, but you're only going 30 kph.
You: "What the hell is wrong with this thing? I thought this car was the fastest thing on the road. Pick it up, why don't you?"
Driver: "I'm sorry sir. I don't really know how to make the car go faster than 30 kph. This is a new model, and the company hasn't yet taught us how to drive it fast. Check in with them next month. They're always training new drivers, and they might have a replacement for you by then."
You: "Well that's just great. Let's get off the freeway. Take a left on Broadway, at the bottom of the off-ramp."
You exit the freeway, but as you are turning left onto Broadway, your
car stalls in the intersection.
You: "Hey driver, WTF?"
Driver: "Sorry Sir, I seem t0 baeo ++_?+CFY^K$# ekbae."
The driver stumbles out of the car and starts spazzing out on the
ground. After a couple of minutes he's OK and you get back on the road. There's an uncomfortable silence in the car. You don't tell him to turn left any more.
Six months later, the company sends you a replacement driver.
Driver2: "Sorry it took so long sir. You see, there's not much call for drivers who know the streets in this neighbourhood, or that speak your language. Most of our clients speak Esperanto, and are over in the business district. They have priority when drivers are trained."
The new driver can reach 70kph and he turns left by turning right three
times, so things are looking up. Still, the salesman told you this baby can go 300kph, and you want to see it happen. You go to the company HQ to talk with someone.
When you get there, the office is cleaned out, and there are eviction
notices plastered on the doors. Oh well, at least you still have a driver. As long as the city doesn't alter the street layout in your neighbourhood, he'll do just fine.
David Schwartz <[email protected]> wrote:
[...]
Quoted 4 lines
Now, let's try it another way: Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage if it's impossible to *start* the car without knowing that algorithm?
It is done regularly. Current cars control the fuel injection etc via an onboard computer, without this control the engine just won't start. Did you get the specs for the exact fuel control algorithm with your car? Should you be able to fool around with that, thus violating emission control measures (this would damage not only you, but everybody)?
Almost everything around you is controlled by a uP nowadays (it is much cheaper/preciser to control e.g. the washing machine that way than via the customary rotating wheels with notches). Did you get the specs for that? Can you get them?
Signature · 4 lines
Dr. Horst H. von Brand User #22616 counter.li.org Departamento de Informatica Fono: +56 32 2654431 Universidad Tecnica Federico Santa Maria +56 32 2654239 Casilla 110-V, Valparaiso, Chile Fax: +56 32 2797513
It seems that debate around cars and drivers has gone too far (IMHO). I do not think
that there is a question if we have any right to demand details about hardware from
manufactorers -> we are NOT. But I think that we have right to know how to use it.
I will translate this to CAR language - We have to know how to drive the car but not all the details how is this done, so we can drive a car without the "driver". We do not need an exact knowledge about engine, ECU, suspension,...
Now the real question:
Why are manufatorers afraid to give us this information?
and
Who can benefit from this?
Let's that our manufactorer is not bound on licenced part of hardware.
If we would know the answers on those questions we could start thinking how can we convince Them to give us information we need to develop our own drivers.
Cheers
Rok Markovic
Quoted 1 line · Rok Markovic
It seems that debate around cars and drivers has gone too far (IMHO).
Ditto.
Quoted 3 lines
I
do not think that there is a question if we have any right to demand details about hardware from manufactorers -> we are NOT.
OK.
Quoted 2 lines
But I think that
we have right to know how to use it.
The card is designed for use with /Windows/, you get a /Windows/ driver. That your PC is able to also run, say, Plan 9, is not the manufacturer's business at all, it is /your/ choice, and /your/ problem if what the manufacturer provides doesn't help you there.
The manufacturer is keeping his part of the deal. You don't like the deal, tough luck.
Quoted 4 lines
I will translate this to CAR
language - We have to know how to drive the car but not all the details how is this done, so we can drive a car without the "driver". We do not need an exact knowledge about engine, ECU, suspension,...
Exactly.
Quoted 3 lines
Now the real question:
Why are manufatorers afraid to give us this information?
Not "afraid". It is more expensive to them:
- Because they would have to pick developer's brains and write it down, make sure it is complete, check it for publishing, etc. That costs money (and ties up key developers, and...) for /very/ little gain (open source systems is something like a 5 to 10% of all systems, mostly servers where highest performance isn't asked for, so the market for current high-end cards (where the brains are there at all for picking) is /extremely/ small).
- Because they would have to get permission to do so from third parties, that means paying real money for little gain
- Because sometimes it is just "we tried several combinations, this one(s) happen to work, dunno why". How do you write something like that down?
- Because wrong settings might break the hardware, people fiddling around would then want a replacement, a very real cost
- Because you can't write any software at all without violating some patent. In this area, it is probable that everybody is violating everybody else's patents, and making that easy to find out (via source code or specs) opens you up to lawsuits. Lawyers (and common sense) will tell yo not to go there unless it is very worthwhile. And it isn't (see above)
- See the bletcherous workarounds for many device bugs (or downright design braindamage) in the in-kernel drivers. They might be just embarrased by the junk they shove out the door (We all know it happens with software, right? Hardware is much the same...). And they can't just work a year or so longer to get them ironed out, by then they could be right out of business.
Signature · 4 lines
Dr. Horst H. von Brand User #22616 counter.li.org Departamento de Informatica Fono: +56 32 2654431 Universidad Tecnica Federico Santa Maria +56 32 2654239 Casilla 110-V, Valparaiso, Chile Fax: +56 32 2797513
Am Sonntag, 24. Dezember 2006 21:20 schrieb Horst H. von Brand:
Quoted 6 lines
It is done regularly. Current cars control the fuel injection etc via an onboard computer, without this control the engine just won't start. Did you get the specs for the exact fuel control algorithm with your car? Should you be able to fool around with that, thus violating emission control measures (this would damage not only you, but everybody)?
You won't get access to the software source code, but the car manufactors are required to document and publish the interfaces to their hardware, so that also independent car workshops are able to do maintenance and repair on it.
You have ever heared of chip tuning? Chip tuning is a replacement of the original firmware with a 3rd party one, that will give higher power and torque.
So your gave a perfect example from another industry, where the specs are actually published.
Again: We don't want the original drivers being open sourced. All we want is access to the hardware interface documentation, so that we can develop our very own drivers. And heck: With a custom driver for some RAID controller or a graphics card you will hardly violate any regulations.
There might be issues with radio hardware, but surprisingly the drivers for the good stuff (i.e. not those cheapo cards with lousy range and throughput) are open source (Prism/HostAP).
I'd even say, that selling hardware without giving documentation is illegal also from a competitions law point of view. By supplying a driver only for a small range of operating systems you, as the factual owner of a piece of hardware are hindered to use it in the way you like, e.g. use it with the homebrew operating system you wrote (or a finnish student wrote in 1991 ;-)). Thus the HW manufactor delivering drivers only for a small range of operating systems can be assumed to distort the market by biasing one specific operting system manufactor _and_ hardware manufactors. Remember, that many binary only drivers for Linux are only avaliable for the x86 variant. Only few are also avaliable for x86_64 (AMD64), even fewer for IA64 and for other architectures it's getting homeopathic. This is IMHO a extreme distortion of the free market.
Happy holydays
Wolfgang Draxinger
Quoted 11 lines
Quoted 7 lines
Now, let's try it another way: Are they allowed to sell a car that incorporates a computer that uses a trade-secret algorithm for controlling
the fuel injection to get 20 more horsepower and 5% better mileage if it's
impossible to *start* the car without knowing that algorithm?It is done regularly. Current cars control the fuel injection etc via an onboard computer, without this control the engine just won't start.
So? You don't need to know the algorithm to start the car.
Quoted 4 lines
Did you
get the specs for the exact fuel control algorithm with your car? Should you be able to fool around with that, thus violating emission control measures (this would damage not only you, but everybody)?
If I bought the car from the manufacturer, it also must include any rights the manufacturer might have to the car's use. That includes using the car to violate emission control measures. If I didn't buy the right to use the car that way (insofar as that right was owned by the car manufacturer), I didn't buy the whole care -- just *some* of the rights to use it.
If I buy a device that has a safety of some kind, the manufacturer cannot prohibit me from removing or disabling the safety unless some law gives them that authority. Otherwise, I didn't buy all of the rights to that device, just some of them. If the manufacturer kept the right to keep the safety there, then they didn't sell me the whole product. It's no conceptually different than if they kept the right to drive the car on Tuesdays.
If you bought the car, and it's a normal free and clear sale, then the manufacturer retains no rights to say how the car is used. Any they might have had, you bought from them. The exception is where operation of some specific law changes the rules. (For example, you know that when you buy a DVD of a movie, you do not get the right to charge admission to see the DVD. But that's because a specific law retains that right for the copyright holder.)
Quoted 4 lines
Almost everything around you is controlled by a uP nowadays (it is much cheaper/preciser to control e.g. the washing machine that way than via the customary rotating wheels with notches). Did you get the specs for that? Can you get them?
So long as you don't *need* them to use the device, there's no issue. The problem is when you need them to use the device (and not just the ordinary expected way, any reasonable way). Then you are entitled to them.
James C. Georgas made this point better than I did with his example of a car that includes a "driver".
DS
Quoted 7 lines · David Schwartz
If I bought the car from the manufacturer, it also must include any rights the manufacturer might have to the car's use. That includes using the car to violate emission control measures. If I didn't buy the right to use the car that way (insofar as that right was owned by the car manufacturer), I didn't buy the whole care -- just *some* of the rights to use it.
---
I have no idea why you assume that "having the right to do X" implies "must be told how to do X". The have the right (except as laws prohibit it) to modify the car's systems, but (except for some specific legal requirements) the manufacturer is not required to explain anything, even basic operation.
---
Quoted 3 lines
If I buy a device that has a safety of some kind, the manufacturer cannot prohibit me from removing or disabling the safety unless some law gives them that authority. ...
---
Yes, I agree. However, they are completely allowed to make it arbitrarily hard for you to remove (by, for instance, welding the safety in place).
---
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 4 lines
Almost everything around you is controlled by a uP nowadays (it is much cheaper/preciser to control e.g. the washing machine that way than via the customary rotating wheels with notches). Did you get the specs for that? Can you get them?
So long as you don't *need* them to use the device, there's no issue. The problem is when you need them to use the device (and not just the ordinary expected way, any reasonable way). Then you are entitled to them.
---
Again, (IANAL), I think this is simply a misconception. Buyng a physical object gives you the right to do anything with it that the law allows, but imposes no obligation on the seller to explain it (other than specific restrictions hte law may apply to specific classes of objects for safety or other reasons). It's up to you, in deciding whether to buy it, to decide whether it comes with sufficient documentation to satisfy your needs.
scott
Quoted 6 lines
I have no idea why you assume that "having the right to do X" implies "must be told how to do X". The have the right (except as laws prohibit it) to modify the car's systems, but (except for some specific legal requirements) the manufacturer is not required to explain anything, even basic operation.
It's really common sense. Imagine if you buy the right to use my car, but I don't give you the key. Can I say, "yes, you have the right to use my car, you bought that, but that doesn't mean I have to tell you how to use my car."
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines
If I buy a device that has a safety of some kind, the manufacturer cannot
prohibit me from removing or disabling the safety unless some law gives them
that authority. ...Yes, I agree. However, they are completely allowed to make it arbitrarily hard for you to remove (by, for instance, welding the safety in place).
I do not think they can. You cannot at the same time argue that they sold me the right to remove the safety and that they can take active steps to stop me from using the safety.
Again, the same example -- you buy the right to use my car, but I shoot at you every time you step on my property. Or I sell you my car, but right before I do, I put on a lock that only I can unlock and make it deliberately hard for you to remove it.
Quoted 3 lines
Again, (IANAL), I think this is simply a misconception. Buyng a physical object gives you the right to do anything with it that the law allows,
Exactly.
Quoted 5 lines
but imposes no obligation on the seller to explain it (other than specific restrictions hte law may apply to specific classes of objects for safety or other reasons). It's up to you, in deciding whether to buy it, to decide whether it comes with sufficient documentation to satisfy your needs.
I think that simply defies common sense. If I sold you a house and then refused to provide you the keys, and made you break down the doors to get in, you'd have every right to sue me. A house *has* *to* come with keys. If not, the seller should bear the cost of your inability to use the house in a reasonable way without damaging it.
You cannot sell something and then claim that you retained certain rights over the thing you sold unless you either negotiated for those rights or some law allows you to keep those rights. If you sell a computer, and it is password-protected, the password has to come with it. You cannot keep it a secret. You cannot negligently "happen to" lose it.
When you buy a video car, you are *not* buying the right to use that video card with Windows. You are buying all the rights to the video card, to use it any way you please. The manufacturer has no right (because it sold that right when it sold the video card) to interfere or obstruct your right to use it as you please.
If you retain some rights over something, then you are not selling it in the normal sense. You are selling a subset of the rights to it, and the buy must be told what rights he is getting and what rights he is not getting.
DS
Quoted 5 lines · David Schwartz
It's really common sense. Imagine if you buy the right to use my car, but I don't give you the key. Can I say, "yes, you have the right to use my car, you bought that, but that doesn't mean I have to tell you how to use my car."
---
I have to agree with Martin, that the car analogies really bear little relationship with the question of closed-source drivers...
My point was that you buy what you buy, under the terms that you agree to. For a house, or a car, the "normal" terms would include any associated accessories, including keys. Keys also have a certain common-law "specialness", because they historically corresponded to the right to access. If you were buying a house or car and the seller was retaining keys (perhaps because they have some historical or personal significance), that would have to be disclosed and it would have to be clear that no rights were associated with the retained keys.
---
Quoted 7 lines
... Skipping the rest of the house/car analogies...
When you buy a video car, you are *not* buying the right to use that video card with Windows. You are buying all the rights to the video card, to use it any way you please. The manufacturer has no right (because it sold that right when it sold the video card) to interfere or obstruct your right to use it as you please.
---
There is a notion of "fitness for purpose" that sometimes applies - if the seller describes the object as fit for a particular purpose, then the seller has an obligation to make sure the object is, in fact, fit for that purpose. However, that's a very limited requirement - it's not required to be fit for any other purpose and being fit for that purpose would not require documentation unless that purpose normally required it. Note that selling a card as suitable for use with Windows would not suggest, in any way, that it was offered as suitable for use with Linux. Again, you buy the right to do anything you like with the object, but the seller has no obligation beyond the agreed terms.
---
Quoted 3 lines
If you retain some rights over something, then you are not selling it in the normal sense. You are selling a subset of the rights to it, and the buy must be told what rights he is getting and what rights he is not getting.
---
Again, while some of the car/house analogies may describe situations where the seller has not conveyed all the rights, the video card situation is completely different. You have the right to do what you like with it and the seller retains no rights. Lack of documentation is not an imposition on your rights, unless you had a specific promise of documentation from the seller.
scott
Quoted 7 lines
Again, while some of the car/house analogies may describe situations where the seller has not conveyed all the rights, the video card situation is completely different. You have the right to do what you like with it and the seller retains no rights. Lack of documentation is not an imposition on your rights, unless you had a specific promise of documentation from the seller.
I'm curious if you really believe this. So let me set up one last hypothetical.
You buy a phone for $200. The manufacturer only represents that it works with CarrierCo. (You do not buy the phone form CarrierCo.)
Two months later, CarrierCo stops supporting your phone's configuration. You need to make a configuration change to the phone to get it to work on CarrierCo's "newly upgraded" network.
You go to change the phone's configuration and you discover it requires a code. You call the manufacturer of the phone and say "hey, it's my phone, give me my lock out code". The manufacturer says, "sure, for $450".
You have the right to do what you like with the phone, of course. It's a great doorstop and a reasonable paper weight. The manufacturer didn't promise the phone's configuration wouldn't become obsolete or that you would be able to change the configuration. Lack of documentation is not an imposition on your rights, and you had no specific promise of documentation from the seller.
I have to say, it honestly astonishes me that would people would make arguments like these. Are we so used to these kinds of one-sided arrangements that we've lost our common sense?
DS
Quoted 11 lines · David Schwartz
You buy a phone for $200. The manufacturer only represents that it works with CarrierCo. ...
You have the right to do what you like with the phone, of course. It's a great doorstop and a reasonable paper weight. The manufacturer didn't promise the phone's configuration wouldn't become obsolete or that you would be able to change the configuration. Lack of documentation is not an imposition on your rights, and you had no specific promise of documentation from the seller.
Quoted 3 lines
I have to say, it honestly astonishes me that would people would make arguments like these. Are we so used to these kinds of one-sided arrangements that we've lost our common sense?
---
If the manufacturer knew about the forthcoming configuration change, you might have a fraud claim. Otherwise it's just bad luck, which happens sometimes.
I'm not familiar with any situations where the manufacturer locks the phone. Locks are usually applied by the carrier in return for a subsidy. Once any contract restrictions are over, you would have the right to attempt to unlock the phone or to find someone who could do so. For most phones in the market today, I understand that to be a relatively easy thing to find. In the US, the Copyright office recently ruled that there should be an exception to the DMCA so that circumventing the lock would not be a DMCA violation.
I don't know why you think of this as a particularly unfair situation. There's at least a chance that the phone might be reconfigurable. The phone might as easily have been physically unable to work with the new configuration. If you bought, for instance, an Iridium phone (which worked only on the Iridium satellite network and had no other useful function), it became a paperweight when the network ceased operation. You could sell the device on ebay or attempt to salvage parts of it for other purposes, but otherwise you're just out of luck.
scott
Hi!
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 3 lines
You're not alone, I think everybody who knows, how things in a
computer work shares this view.---
Quoted 14 lines
Two of the specific arguments I've heard are (a) that the board (and
its hardware interfaces that the documentation would describe) involve
IP licensed from a third party, which the board manufacturer does not
have a legal right to disclose, or (b) that there is, in fact, no
suitable documentation, because the boards are developed somewhat
fluidly and the driver is developed directly from low-level knowledge
that simply isn't written down in a form suitable for passing on.
So just opensource the driver. It is usually easy to port it, and possible to clean it up.
I have once ported cd-rom driver from DOS to linux (do you still remember cdroms not talking ATA?) -- in 2days or so, and the comments in driver were in korean.
Pavel
Signature · 1 line
Thanks for all the (sleeping) penguins.