mpc8xx-2.2.13 kernel hangs during boot.
I am trying to get mpc8xx-2.2.13 booting. As far as I can tell, it is hanging just after the kernel is decompressed into RAM and tries to execute. I get the following console output
loaded at: FF801000 FF80C1F0
Relocate to: 00100000 0010B1F0
Board Data at: 001001C4 001001E0
relocated to: 00200100 0020011C
Boot args at: 00200000 00200200
zimage at: FF807000 FF8676C8
avail ram: 00201000 01000000
Linux/PPC load:
Uncompressing Linux... done.
Now booting the kernelI'm a little concerned about the overlap of BootArgs and the relocated BoardData. Does this seem right or wrong to anyone ?
I had previously had similar problem when using embedded-2.2.5. It was hanging during the boot. It was suggested to me that I disable the caches. I did that in arch/ppc/mbxboot/head.S and arch/ppc/kernel/head.S and I never had a problem booting embedded-2.2.5 since. It was suggested to me that the UPM was probably incorrect and that's why it fails with the caches enabled.
I have disabled the caches in mpc8xx-2.2.13 but I still get the same results. I have tried with 4 different UPM settings for a 25MHz bus with 60ns EDO DRAM. I got the values from the ADS manual, SDS Single Step debugger and a commercial operating system. I even tried with the burst inhibit flag set/cleared in the chip select option registers.
I'm not sure if it is my bootloader or kernel. In the bootloader I basically setup the clocks, ports, chip selects for flash and dram and that's about it. Is there anything else the kernel expects to be setup ?
I've run out of ideas now and need some advice.
What could be causing the kernel not to boot ?
How can I tell where it is failing ? I don't think I can use printk as the console is not setup yet. Is this correct ?
Getting a little desperate now.
Brendan Simon.
** Sent via the linuxppc-embedded mail list. See http://lists.linuxppc.org/
Quoted 6 lines · Brendan John Simon
Board Data at: 001001C4 001001E0 relocated to: 00200100 0020011C Boot args at: 00200000 00200200I'm a little concerned about the overlap of BootArgs and the relocated BoardData. Does this seem right or wrong to anyone ?
No, that is the way it is supposed to work. I doubled the size of the boot arguments (it is only 256 bytes), and placed the board information structure there. I just didn't update the messages to further describe what is going on. This information is really only useful when debugging the boot code, and it seems to be working now.
The command line and board information structure must reside within the first 8Mbytes, and it seemed somewhat logical to me to just use the same buffer space.
Quoted 2 lines
.... It was suggested to me that the UPM was probably incorrect and that's why it fails with the caches enabled.
I was the one that probably suggested that. If all of the memory mapping is correct (IMMR > 0xd0000000, and such) this is usually where I start looking, since the code is known to operate on other platforms.
Quoted 2 lines
.... I have tried with 4 different UPM settings for a 25MHz bus with 60ns EDO DRAM.
Although others may be more talented, I have never been able to program the UPM without the actual DRAM specifications, schematics and a logic analyzer connected to the processor bus. Guessing at UPM values is kind of like playing the lottery.
Quoted 2 lines
.... Is there anything else the kernel expects to be setup ?
Not much. Obviously the DRAM must be configured because the kernel is loaded there. Beyond that it just reads the IMMR and maps it.
Quoted 2 lines
How can I tell where it is failing ? I don't think I can use printk as the console is not setup yet. Is this correct ?
Here is a hint. Look at the symbol table from System.map and convert the address of log_buf to a physical address (mask the upper couple of bits). Dump this area of memory, as all of the printk() messages end up in this buffer before they are sent to the console.
Quoted 1 line
Getting a little desperate now.
Are those ready-for-production boards looking any better yet :-)? The world is passing you by........
-- Dan
** Sent via the linuxppc-embedded mail list. See http://lists.linuxppc.org/
Quoted 7 lines · Dan Malek
Quoted 2 lines
.... It was suggested to me that the UPM was probably incorrect and that's why it fails with the caches enabled.
I was the one that probably suggested that. If all of the memory mapping is correct (IMMR >
0xd0000000, and such) this is usually where I start looking, since the code is known to operate on other platforms.
I based my port on the BSEIP board as it is the simplest.
The IMMR is at 0xff000000 and all peripherals are mapped above 0x80000000 except for DRAM which is mapped at 0x00000000.
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
.... I have tried with 4 different UPM settings for a 25MHz bus with 60ns EDO DRAM.
Although others may be more talented, I have never been able to program the UPM without the actual DRAM specifications, schematics and a logic analyzer connected to the processor bus. Guessing at UPM values is kind of like playing the lottery.
I think I have to agree with you :(
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
.... Is there anything else the kernel expects to be setup ?
Not much. Obviously the DRAM must be configured because the kernel is loaded there. Beyond that it just reads the IMMR and maps it.
I didn't think so. The embedded-2.2.5 kernel works fine with the same bootloader. I forgot to mention the the embedded-2.2.5 kernel is compiled with binutils-2.9.1.0.19a/egcs-1.1.2 and the mpc8xx-2.2.12 kernel is compiled with binutils-2.9.5.0.24/gcc-2.95.2. I'm not sure if it makes any difference. I'm recompiling the embedded-2.2.5 kernel with my new tools to see if that makes any difference ? The embedded-2.2.5 does not having an floating point emulation where as the mpc8xx-2.2.13 does. I will also try without the floating point emulation patches to see if that makes any difference.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
How can I tell where it is failing ? I don't think I can use printk as the console is not setup yet. Is this correct ?
Here is a hint. Look at the symbol table from System.map and convert the address of
log_bufto a physical address (mask the upper couple of bits). Dump this area of memory, as all of theprintk()messages end up in this buffer before they are sent to the console.
How can I look at this memory area ? With a BDM debugger ? I thought BDM can't be used.
Can a serial debugger be used ?
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Getting a little desperate now.
Are those ready-for-production boards looking any better yet :-)? The world is passing you by........
No pain, no gain :)
Yes I know the off the shelf boards will get me going on the application sides of things, but I still need to get it running on our custom board/s too.
Brendan Simon.
** Sent via the linuxppc-embedded mail list. See http://lists.linuxppc.org/
Hi, Brendan:
Have you solved your 2.2.13 kernel problem hanging yet? Now I have the similar problem as you.
First I cross-compile the kernel under the following environment:
[binutils-2.9.1.0.19a] [egcs-1.1.2] [glibc-2.1(including crypt and
linuxthreads)]
Then the kernel can run correctly and don't hang.
Then I destroy all above environment and rebuild my new environment:
[binutils-2.9.5.0.22] [gcc-2.95.2] [gcc-core-2.95.2] [glibc-2.1.2(including crypt and linuxthreads)]
and recompile my kernel. This time it hangs when showing "Now booting
the kernel..."
Anyone knows why?
Thank you very much.
dony
Quoted 59 lines · Brendan John Simon
Quoted 7 lines · Dan Malek
Quoted 2 lines
.... It was suggested to me that the UPM was probably incorrect and that's why it fails with the caches enabled.
I was the one that probably suggested that. If all of the memory mapping is correct (IMMR >
0xd0000000, and such) this is usually where I start looking, since the code is known to operate on other platforms.I based my port on the BSEIP board as it is the simplest.
The IMMR is at0xff000000and all peripherals are mapped above0x80000000except for DRAM which is mapped at0x00000000.Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 2 lines
.... I have tried with 4 different UPM settings for a 25MHz bus with 60ns EDO DRAM.
Although others may be more talented, I have never been able to program the UPM without the actual DRAM specifications, schematics and a logic analyzer connected to the processor bus. Guessing at UPM values is kind of like playing the lottery.
I think I have to agree with you :(
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
.... Is there anything else the kernel expects to be setup ?
Not much. Obviously the DRAM must be configured because the kernel is loaded there. Beyond that it just reads the IMMR and maps it.
I didn't think so. The embedded-2.2.5 kernel works fine with the same bootloader. I forgot to mention the the embedded-2.2.5 kernel is compiled with binutils-2.9.1.0.19a/egcs-1.1.2 and the mpc8xx-2.2.12 kernel is compiled with binutils-2.9.5.0.24/gcc-2.95.2. I'm not sure if it makes any difference. I'm recompiling the embedded-2.2.5 kernel with my new tools to see if that makes any difference ? The embedded-2.2.5 does not having an floating point emulation where as the mpc8xx-2.2.13 does. I will also try without the floating point emulation patches to see if that makes any difference.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 2 lines
How can I tell where it is failing ? I don't think I can use printk as the console is not setup yet. Is this correct ?
Here is a hint. Look at the symbol table from System.map and convert the address of
log_bufto a physical address (mask the upper couple of bits). Dump this area of memory, as all of theprintk()messages end up in this buffer before they are sent to the console.How can I look at this memory area ? With a BDM debugger ? I thought BDM can't be used.
Can a serial debugger be used ?Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 1 line
Getting a little desperate now.
Are those ready-for-production boards looking any better yet :-)? The world is passing you by........
Quoted 6 lines
No pain, no gain :)
Yes I know the off the shelf boards will get me going on the application sides of things, but I still need to get it running on our custom board/s too.Brendan Simon.
** Sent via the linuxppc-embedded mail list. See http://lists.linuxppc.org/