Skip to contentSkip to conversation

Why is Device3Dfx driver (voodoo1/2) not in the kernel?

DISCUSSION Steven Griffiths 4 participants 9 messages Sep 19, 2001 – Sep 27, 2001

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Does anyone know why the Device3Dfx kernel driver is not in the standard kernel?

Would anyone be willing to accept a patch?

#1 lore raw
Quoted 2 lines

Does anyone know why the Device3Dfx kernel driver is not in the standard kernel?

Because it lets anyone crash the machine by feeding a Voodoo1 garbage. To get something like that into the kernel I suspect would involve

- Making sure glide is using the fifo
- Writing a parser for packet1-packet5 commands to verify they
are valid

then voodoo would be safe for user direct access.

Alan

#2 lore raw
Quoted 8 lines · Alan Cox

Because it lets anyone crash the machine by feeding a Voodoo1 garbage. To get something like that into the kernel I suspect would involve

(quoted diff) +0 -2
-	Making sure glide is using the fifo
-	Writing a parser for packet1-packet5 commands to verify they 

are valid

then voodoo would be safe for user direct access.

Better stop that this minute Alan! You're starting
to sound like those old KGI people, with their 'safe kernel drivers for video' spiel... ;^)

Signature · 4 lines
Jason McMullan, Senior Linux Consultant
Linuxcare, Inc. 412.432.6457 tel, 412.656.3519 cell
[email protected], http://www.linuxcare.com/
Linuxcare. Putting open source to work.
#3 lore raw
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 1 line

then voodoo would be safe for user direct access.

Better stop that this minute Alan! You're starting
to sound like those old KGI people, with their 'safe kernel drivers for video' spiel... ;^)

There are actually distinct similarities between some DRI drivers and what Linus suggested the KGI people needed to be doing. Certain hardware isnt totally user safe (not on the extremes of the voodoo1 here) and the drivers do small amounts of work to stop abuse. All mode changes, rendering primitives and the like are however in userspace.

I firmly believe you can do X11 with 3D in windows, including partial occlusion of 3d windows on a 3dfx voodoo1 or voodoo2 card.

Alan

#5 lore raw
In reply to Jason McMullan
Quoted 5 lines · Alan Cox

There are actually distinct similarities between some DRI drivers and what Linus suggested the KGI people needed to be doing. Certain hardware isnt totally user safe (not on the extremes of the voodoo1 here) and the drivers do small amounts of work to stop abuse. All mode changes, rendering primitives and the like are however in userspace.

Rendering - definitely agree. Userspace.

Mode changing - Now there I can get into an argument. I
still (after all these years) feel that the Kernel is the best place to put video mode control. That way 'killall -9 X' isn't nearly as nasty... The kernel could at least get you back to a text console.

And now that XFree86 4 has a vm86 system to 'run the
Video BIOS' for certain cards, it shouldn't be to hard to emulate the old OS/2 system - in a vm86 session, use the BIOS to switch to all the supported modes, and record (via vm86 io traps) everything the BIOS does. Then, in the driver, just 'play back' the scripts... Worked beatifully for OS/2 back in the day for 2D framebuffers...

Anyway, I'll just let sleeping dogs lie and leave it
at that.

Quoted 2 lines

I firmly believe you can do X11 with 3D in windows, including partial occlusion of 3d windows on a 3dfx voodoo1 or voodoo2 card.

As do I, but I lack three things: The time, The Specs, and
The Hardware. :(

Signature · 4 lines
Jason McMullan, Senior Linux Consultant
Linuxcare, Inc. 412.432.6457 tel, 412.656.3519 cell
[email protected], http://www.linuxcare.com/
Linuxcare. Putting open source to work.
#4 lore raw
In reply to Alan Cox
Quoted 4 lines

Certain hardware isnt
totally user safe (not on the extremes of the voodoo1 here) and the drivers do small amounts of work to stop abuse.

The voodoo1 is really dangerous. I have locked my system many times.

Quoted 2 lines

I firmly believe you can do X11 with 3D in windows, including partial occlusion of 3d windows on a 3dfx voodoo1 or voodoo2 card.

SGI has been doing it for a long long time.

#6 lore raw
In reply to Jason McMullan
Quoted 6 lines

Mode changing - Now there I can get into an argument. I
still (after all these years) feel that the Kernel is the best place to put video mode control. That way 'killall -9 X' isn't nearly as nasty... The kernel could at least get you back to a text console.

Can we say framebuffer devices. As graphics cards are placed into more and more different types of systems we need to have a way to make these cards workable on different platforms. This requires us to write drivers that can initialize a mode without firmware. I have reworked the console layer to deal with this and with allowing different modes on different VCs. The current system allows it too but it is more of a later add on hack. I have a much cleaner implementation which does what you ask of the above.

Quoted 7 lines

And now that XFree86 4 has a vm86 system to 'run the
Video BIOS' for certain cards, it shouldn't be to hard to emulate the old OS/2 system - in a vm86 session, use the BIOS to switch to all the supported modes, and record (via vm86 io traps) everything the BIOS does. Then, in the driver, just 'play back' the scripts... Worked beatifully for OS/2 back in the day for 2D framebuffers...

Really. I have my own personal compain to make all the graphics drivers firmware independent. I even like to see the VGA console driver also firmware independent.

#7 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines

different VCs. The current system allows it too but it is more of a later add on hack. I have a much cleaner implementation which does what you ask of the above.

The requirements of ACPI may yet see you get your wish ...

#8 lore raw
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 4 lines

different VCs. The current system allows it too but it is more of a later add on hack. I have a much cleaner implementation which does what you ask of the above.

The requirements of ACPI may yet see you get your wish ...

Let me guess. Insane like the rest of it.