i_generation consistency
Hi Neil,
I am writing a file system and having problem implementing the i_generation of the inode. Should the i_generation be persistent in the disk? Or it has to be changed every time the dcache shrinks or reload after read_inode()? Should I check the i_generation in the fh_dentry() ops and include it in file handle or leave it to the NFS clients and nfsd and I should forget about implementing i_generation in file handles. Can you please clarify? Thanks.
regards,
David Chow
Quoted 9 lines · On Tuesday November 26, [email protected] wrote:
Hi Neil,
I am writing a file system and having problem implementing the
i_generationof the inode. Should thei_generationbe persistent in the disk? Or it has to be changed every time the dcache shrinks or reload afterread_inode()? Should I check thei_generationin thefh_dentry()ops and include it in file handle or leave it to the NFS clients and nfsd and I should forget about implementingi_generationin file handles. Can you please clarify? Thanks.
The core requirement is that dentry_to_fh must provide a filehandle that fh_to_dentry can
1/ recoginise and find, even if it isn't in cache 2/ check that the inode that was found is still valid. i.e.
that it hasn't been re-used after the original was deleted.
This is sometimes done using a combination of
inode number, that can be used to locate a file, but that can be reused after a file is removed, and a generation number, that is stored in the inode and has a different value each time the inode is reused (though this is not the only way to do it).
In this case, the generation number must be stored on stable storage, and should be checked in fh_to_dentry.
Hope this helps.
NeilBrown
Quoted 15 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I am writing a file system and having problem implementing the
i_generationof the inode. Should thei_generationbe persistent in the disk? Or it has to be changed every time the dcache shrinks or reload afterread_inode()? Should I check thei_generationin thefh_dentry()ops and include it in file handle or leave it to the NFS clients and nfsd and I should forget about implementingi_generationin file handles. Can you please clarify? Thanks.The core requirement is that
dentry_to_fhmust provide a filehandle thatfh_to_dentrycan
1/ recoginise and find, even if it isn't in cache 2/ check that the inode that was found is still valid. i.e.
that it hasn't been re-used after the original was deleted.This is sometimes done using a combination of inode number, that can be used to locate a file, but that can be reused after a file is removed, and a generation number, that is stored in the inode and has a different value each time the inode is reused (though this is not the only way to do it).
Quoted 7 lines
In this case, the generation number must be stored on stable storage, and should be checked in
fh_to_dentry.Hope this helps.
NeilBrown
Thanks, it seems some file system change the i_generation each time the inode is read ... I don't think this is a good idea because the server can shrink the dcache and got the inode flushed, while the client keep that i_generation in its dcache. The next time the client requests that inode using the old i_generation and find it is stale. That means the lifetime of an i_generation is the same as the dcache which is not persistent. But from what you say is that the i_generation should be kept persistent until it is reused after a remove or delete, is my understanding right?
regards,
David
Quoted 9 lines · On Thursday November 28, [email protected] wrote:
Thanks, it seems some file system change the
i_generationeach time the inode is read ... I don't think this is a good idea because the server can shrink the dcache and got the inode flushed, while the client keep thati_generationin its dcache. The next time the client requests that inode using the oldi_generationand find it is stale. That means the lifetime of ani_generationis the same as the dcache which is not persistent. But from what you say is that thei_generationshould be kept persistent until it is reused after a remove or delete, is my understanding right?
Yes, your understanding is correct. If filesystems set i_generation to something that is not stable, they would work well when exported via knfsd.
NeilBrown