Problem with remap_page_range
We have a DSP shared memory which we should access (from PowerPC).
The problem is when I do ioremap I can see the memory correctly from the driver (see below) but when I do remap_page_range to the user space application then data appears to be wrong, I can recognize some values there, but they are in the wrong places and other values around from everywhere else (see below).
I tried mem_map_reserve - but still without luck.
Could somebody please give me a clue on this.
Thank you very much in advance for any help.
Below: the dsp_area prints correct values from DSP RAM but remap_page_range does not work properly.
dsp_ptr=ioremap_nocache( DSP_ADDR, WINDOW_SIZE); dsp_area=(ushort *)(((unsigned long)dsp_ptr + PAGE_SIZE -1) &PAGE_MASK);
/* for (virt_addr=(unsigned long)dsp_area; virt_addr<(unsigned
long)dsp_area+WINDOW_SIZE; */
/* virt_addr+=PAGE_SIZE) { */
/* /\* reserve all pages to make them remapable *\/ */
/* mem_map_reserve(virt_to_page(virt_addr)); */
/* } */
printk("dsp_area[0]=%04x\n", dsp_area[0]); //prints correct values
...
vma->vm_flags |= (VM_SHM | VM_LOCKED | VM_IO | VM_RESERVED);
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
DSP_ADDR,
size,
vma->vm_page_prot
))
{
printk("remap page range failed\n");
return -ENXIO;}
Here is the ouput:
//correct from the driver
dsp_area[0]=0000
dsp_area[1]=bc00
dsp_area[2]=eb17
dsp_area[3]=2643
dsp_area[4]=54cd
dsp_area[5]=5405
dsp_area[6]=91ba
dsp_area[7]=49c2
dsp_area[8]=1f61hpi_mmap: vma->vm_start=3006f000, vma->vm_end=30097000 vma->vm_flags=864fb
//wrong from the user space application
kadr=0x3006f000
kadr[0]=1c59
kadr[1]=49c2
kadr[2]=5405
kadr[3]=bc00
kadr[4]=49c2
kadr[5]=54cd
kadr[6]=bc00
kadr[7]=54cd
Quoted 1 line · Dmytro Bablinyuk
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
Try io_remap_page_range() instead?
-- Jamie
Quoted 5 lines
Try
io_remap_page_range()instead?
I just tried - the problem remains, but what is interesting:
Correct values (driver):
dsp_area[0]=91ba
dsp_area[1]=bc00
dsp_area[2]=eb17
dsp_area[3]=2643
dsp_area[4]=54cd
dsp_area[5]=5405
dsp_area[6]=91ba
dsp_area[7]=49c2
dsp_area[8]=1f61
Wrong values (application):
kadr[0]=1c59
kadr[1]=5405
kadr[2]=1f61
kadr[3]=49c2
kadr[4]=49c2
kadr[5]=eb17
kadr[6]=1f61
kadr[7]=2643
It's looks like application has some correct values but it's kind of mess. What else could be wrong?
Thank you very much
Quoted 4 lines · Jamie Lokier
Quoted 1 line · Dmytro Bablinyuk
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
Try
io_remap_page_range()instead?
These are identical on PPC.
-Matt
Quoted 7 lines · Dmytro Bablinyuk
We have a DSP shared memory which we should access (from PowerPC). The problem is when I do ioremap I can see the memory correctly from the driver (see below) but when I do
remap_page_rangeto the user space application then data appears to be wrong, I can recognize some values there, but they are in the wrong places and other values around from everywhere else (see below).
<snip>
Quoted 5 lines
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
DSP_ADDR, size, vma->vm_page_prot ))
Your remap call isn't adding _PAGE_NO_CACHE and _PAGE_GUARDED flags like ioremap_nocache()/ioremap() do on PPC. You'll get bad results because of the ordering and cache issues resulting from not using these PTE flags. In 2.6, these can be added using pgprot_noncached() that is defined per-arch.
BTW, ioremap_nocache() and ioremap() are identical on PPC.
-Matt
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
DSP_ADDR, size, vma->vm_page_prot ))
Quoted 8 lines
Your remap call isn't adding
_PAGE_NO_CACHEand_PAGE_GUARDEDflags like ioremap_nocache()/ioremap() do on PPC. You'll get bad results because of the ordering and cache issues resulting from not using these PTE flags. In 2.6, these can be added usingpgprot_noncached()that is defined per-arch.
Thank you Matt,
Coud you please give me en example on how to add these flags to remap in kernel 2.4.21 (powerpc). It seems I could not find these flags available in my kernel.
Thank you very much
Quoted 18 lines · Dmytro Bablinyuk
Quoted 10 lines
Quoted 9 lines
if (remap_page_range(vma->vm_start,
DSP_ADDR, size, vma->vm_page_prot ))Quoted 8 lines
Your remap call isn't adding
_PAGE_NO_CACHEand_PAGE_GUARDEDflags like ioremap_nocache()/ioremap() do on PPC. You'll get bad results because of the ordering and cache issues resulting from not using these PTE flags. In 2.6, these can be added usingpgprot_noncached()that is defined per-arch.
Quoted 5 lines
Thank you Matt,
Coud you please give me en example on how to add these flags to remap in kernel 2.4.21 (powerpc).
It seems I could not find these flags available in my kernel.
They're defined in include/asm-ppc/pgtable.h
-Matt