Suggestion for CD filesystem for Backups
You can use CDs or DVDs for Backup purposes. They do error correction, everything is fine, until the errors get too much, than everything is lost. This is a nuisance for a backup, especially because normal people don't have the hardware to measure errors, jitter and the like.
Suggestion:
Why not write a file system on top of ISO9660 which uses the rest of the CD to write error correction. If a sector becomes unreadable, the error correction saves the data. Besides, a tool for testing the error rate and the safety of the data can be easily written for a normal CD-ROM drive.
The data for error correction might be written into a file so that the CD can be read using any System, but Linux provides error correction.
Mirko Kloppstech
Quoted 7 lines · Judith und Mirko Kloppstech
Why not write a file system on top of ISO9660 which uses the rest of the CD to write error correction. If a sector becomes unreadable, the error correction saves the data. Besides, a tool for testing the error rate and the safety of the data can be easily written for a normal CD-ROM drive.
The data for error correction might be written into a file so that the CD can be read using any System, but Linux provides error correction.
Send patches, or possibly if you are dumping tars and the like just write yourself an app to generate a second file of ECC data.
Quoted 2 lines · Judith und Mirko Kloppstech
The data for error correction might be written into a file so that the CD can be read using any System, but Linux provides error correction.
You may want to look at parchive, if you havn't already. It does this, is cross- platform and is in wide use. http://parchive.sourceforge.net/
Quoted 6 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 5 lines · Judith und Mirko Kloppstech
Why not write a file system on top of ISO9660 which uses the rest of the CD to write error correction. If a sector becomes unreadable, the error correction saves the data. Besides, a tool for testing the error rate and the safety of the data can be easily written for a normal CD-ROM drive.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The data for error correction might be written into a file so that the CD can be read using any System, but Linux provides error correction.
Send patches, or possibly if you are dumping tars and the like just write yourself an app to generate a second file of ECC data.
Wouldn't it be safer to do ECC on meta-data also?
That probably means replacing ISO9660 though.
-ali
Signature · 1 line
Ali Bayazit <[email protected]>
Quoted 8 lines · Ali Bayazit
Quoted 6 lines · Alan Cox
Quoted 5 lines · Judith und Mirko Kloppstech
Why not write a file system on top of ISO9660 which uses the rest of the CD to write error correction. If a sector becomes unreadable, the error correction saves the data. Besides, a tool for testing the error rate and the safety of the data can be easily written for a normal CD-ROM drive.
Quoted 8 lines
Quoted 5 lines
Quoted 2 lines
The data for error correction might be written into a file so that the CD can be read using any System, but Linux provides error correction.
Send patches, or possibly if you are dumping tars and the like just write yourself an app to generate a second file of ECC data.
Wouldn't it be safer to do ECC on meta-data also?
That probably means replacing ISO9660 though.
There seems to be a good user space alternative for this purpose:
Regards,
Toon.
Signature · 3 lines
"Debugging is twice as hard as writing the code in the first place. Therefore, if you write the code as cleverly as possible, you are, by definition, not smart enough to debug it." - Brian W. Kernighan