EDD failures since edd=off patch
Hi Matt,
it seems the edd=off patch has caused some problems with some machines I have access to. They simply don't boot anymore unless I specify edd=foo. foo can be {off,skip,bar} so it seems the hang on boot is related to the parser not finding the parameter it is looking for.
I looked through the code some days ago and it seemed to me that the register used to iterate through the command line buffer only got its lower 16 bit reset before calling into the BIOS. I don't have the code handy right now, but I can look later if the hints I gave are insufficient.
Regards,
Carl-Daniel
Signature · 1 line
http://www.hailfinger.org/
Quoted 12 lines · Carl-Daniel Hailfinger
Hi Matt,
it seems the edd=off patch has caused some problems with some machines I have access to. They simply don't boot anymore unless I specify edd=foo. foo can be {off,skip,bar} so it seems the hang on boot is related to the parser not finding the parameter it is looking for.
I looked through the code some days ago and it seemed to me that the register used to iterate through the command line buffer only got its lower 16 bit reset before calling into the BIOS. I don't have the code handy right now, but I can look later if the hints I gave are insufficient.
Yes, please. I'm reading the code, and %ecx gets set to (COMMAND_LINE_SIZE-7) which is 256-7=249. So the upper 24 bits of %ecx are going to always be zero, and if "edd=" isn't seen, then %ecx will be zero when dropping into edd_mbr_sig_start. The only other register touched is %esi, but it's pushed at the beginning, and pop'd on all exit cases, so that should be unchanged.
ZF is the only other bit I can picture. On the "no edd= option" path, ZF=0 on exit. With "edd=of" or "edd=sk", ZF=1. But with "edd=bar", ZF=0, which you say works too. So that's not it...
CF is taken care of around the int13 calls already, so that's not it...
Thanks,
Matt
Signature · 4 lines
Matt Domsch Software Architect Dell Linux Solutions linux.dell.com & www.dell.com/linux Linux on Dell mailing lists @ http://lists.us.dell.com
Quoted 23 lines · Matt Domsch
Quoted 12 lines · Carl-Daniel Hailfinger
Hi Matt,
it seems the edd=off patch has caused some problems with some machines I have access to. They simply don't boot anymore unless I specify edd=foo. foo can be {off,skip,bar} so it seems the hang on boot is related to the parser not finding the parameter it is looking for.
I looked through the code some days ago and it seemed to me that the register used to iterate through the command line buffer only got its lower 16 bit reset before calling into the BIOS. I don't have the code handy right now, but I can look later if the hints I gave are insufficient.Yes, please. I'm reading the code, and %ecx gets set to (COMMAND_LINE_SIZE-7) which is 256-7=249. So the upper 24 bits of %ecx are going to always be zero, and if "edd=" isn't seen, then %ecx will be zero when dropping into
edd_mbr_sig_start. The only other register touched is %esi, but it's pushed at the beginning, and pop'd on all exit cases, so that should be unchanged.
Quoted 6 lines
ZF is the only other bit I can picture. On the "no edd= option" path, ZF=0 on exit. With "edd=of" or "edd=sk", ZF=1. But with "edd=bar", ZF=0, which you say works too. So that's not it...
CF is taken care of around the int13 calls already, so that's not it...
It all boils down to the question: When do the flags set by INCL differ from those set by CMPW? We have already ruled out CF and ZF, so only OF, SF, AF, PF can be the culprit.
Looking again, I think it will hang with edd=zz, but I have to verify that.
Regards,
Carl-Daniel
Signature · 1 line
http://www.hailfinger.org/