How to disable slow agpgart in kernel config?
Hello,
the agpgart backend is now always compiled in and selected with 2.6.11-rc3 x86_64. I can delete or disable it in the config, it is always back written.
Is this the default future behaviour? The eg Nforce3 AGP is on a normal desktop so slow on 2D and also in 3D mode a lot slower and all nvidia kernel driver users can not more use the really faster nv_agp.
Greetings,
Marcus
Quoted 2 lines · Marcus Hartig
the agpgart backend is now always compiled in and selected with 2.6.11-rc3
x86_64. I can delete or disable it in the config, it is always back written.
probably you have selected IOMMU, which is dependant on it.
Quoted 1 line
Is this the default future behaviour?
This is how it's always been.
Quoted 3 lines
The eg Nforce3 AGP is on a normal desktop so slow on 2D and also in 3D mode a lot slower and all nvidia kernel driver users can not more use the really faster
nv_agp.
This surprises me, especially considering the in-kernel nvidia-agp driver was actually written by NVidia. Are there any agp error messages in your dmesg / X log ?
How big a speed difference do you notice with the two gart drivers?
Dave
Quoted 1 line · Dave Jones
probably you have selected IOMMU, which is dependant on it.
Yes, thanks. Sorry my fault. I had it not deactivated, arggg.
Quoted 3 lines
This surprises me, especially considering the in-kernel nvidia-agp driver was actually written by NVidia. Are there any agp error messages in your dmesg / X log ?
No warnings/errors in both logs. All clean. But switching/maximizing between tasks like firefox, thunderbird or a gnome-terminal is so slow, that you can see it how firefox/GTK+ theme is writing the GUI and the fonts slowly back. Minimizing is no more fun, like a fast slide-show. And that on a fast amd64 3200 with 1 GB RAM and a FX 5900XT. :(
With the nVidia own nv_agp it appears directly in all apps, very fast under GNOME 2.8.1. Why, I do not know. Also game (opengl) performance is faster with the nv_agp, that I haven't used the kernel agp for months, now.
Greetings,
Marcus
Quoted 5 lines · Marcus Hartig
No warnings/errors in both logs. All clean. But switching/maximizing between tasks like firefox, thunderbird or a gnome-terminal is so slow, that you can see it how firefox/GTK+ theme is writing the GUI and the fonts slowly back. Minimizing is no more fun, like a fast slide-show. And that on a fast amd64 3200 with 1 GB RAM and a FX 5900XT. :(
None of this involves 3D operation, or AGPGART.
Quoted 3 lines
With the nVidia own
nv_agpit appears directly in all apps, very fast under GNOME 2.8.1. Why, I do not know. Also game (opengl) performance is faster with thenv_agp, that I haven't used the kernel agp for months, now.
*shrug*, if the nvidia module is properly configured, it should make no difference at all. AGPGART operation isn't a performance critical thing, as the hardware does 99% of the work.
Dave
Quoted 3 lines · Dave Jones
*shrug*, if the nvidia module is properly configured, it should make no difference at all. AGPGART operation isn't a performance critical thing, as the hardware does 99% of the work.
Yes, that was also my opinion, but after using AGPGART, hmm.
And it was on my last 32 bit FC2 systems with other hardware the same slow operations on the desktop. And I'm not alone, there are some nvnews.net linux forum users which report the same slow performance with AGPGART.
Maybe the linux kernel AGPGART do not run well with the nVidia 2D acceleration renderer or the kernel driver and is a nvidia problem.
http://www.marcush.de/Xorg.0.log
Greetings,
Marcus