Skip to contentSkip to conversation

sanitized kernel headers

DISCUSSION Alexander E. Patrakov 2 participants 2 messages Jan 7, 2006 – Jan 8, 2006

lore
Share & tools
lore
#0 lore raw

Hello,

almost two years ago, a decision has been made that raw kernel headers are for the kernel only, and that userspace should be built against some "sanitized" kernels. Linux-Libc-Headers (http://ep09.pld-linux.org/~mmazur/linux-libc-headers/) were one of the implementations of such sanitized headers, and they worked well and were used e.g. in Linux From Scratch.

But now, the Linux-Libc-Headers project looks dead: no commits in the SVN for the last two months, and the only changes in SVN as compared to LLH 2.6.12.0 are addition of inotify.h, removal of some kernel-only headers and some minor fix for non-glibc systems.

What is the recommended (non-dead) alternative implementation of such "sanitized" headers? Where is the roadmap for this area?

Signature · 3 lines
Alexander E. Patrakov
Don't mail to [email protected]: the server is off until 2006-01-11
Use my GMail or linuxfromscratch address instead
#1 lore raw
Quoted 3 lines · Alexander E. Patrakov

What is the recommended (non-dead) alternative implementation of such "sanitized" headers? Where is the roadmap for this area?

I still don't buy the arguments of the kernel maintainers who shun responsibility for this. My undoubtedly naive position is that

1) The kernel does a load of really clever low level stuff, and presents a stable API that the rest of the world (userspace) can use

2) Every part of that API that userspace needs should be presented to userspace in a consistent and reliably useable way

3) Any part of the kernel to which userspace absolutely needs access _must_ be part of that consistently and reliably presented API.

This 'sanitized kernel headers' mess (the single biggest _PITA_ for all small independent linux distro creators/maintainers) should either

1) be unnecessary
2) be included as part of the kernel sources and acknowledged as specifically for use by userspace

Currently affected userspace packages include stuff like glibc, directfb, netfilter, iproute2, alsa, iputils, pcmcia-cs, udev and wireless-tools.

Andrew Walrond
[thumbs nose, dons hardhat, dives into hastily prepared bunker]