a proposal for binary drivers.
Quoted 6 lines
if there was binary allowed (with any license) maybe dlink themself would build a driver, make documentation and provide it on CD, just see how much effort would be saved and in end he would get more time to treat his patients.
Apart from all the other good arguments already posted:
Are you really sure they will? Maybe dlink will, but I can tell from personal expierience (whine, whine) that the majority of vendors still won't release drivers. For the simple reason because they regard Linux a market too small to support. That is the main reason for most of them, not the license stuff.
Before Linux, I was an OS/2 user and although every vendor in the world was allowed to provide OS/2 drivers, there were more or less the same amount of vendor contributed drivers as there are now in Linux.
I'm 100% sure that Linux supports more hardware than OS/2 did back then and the user base (Desktop wise) was at least as big as Linux.
OS/2 died exactly because software companies didn't write closed-source software, hardware companies didn't write closed-source drivers, and IBM couldn't write it all themselves.
So why repeat this desaster?
Tim
Quoted 7 lines · Tim Tassonis
Quoted 6 lines
if there was binary allowed (with any license) maybe dlink themself would build a driver, make documentation and provide it on CD, just see how much effort would be saved and in end he would get more time to treat his patients.
Quoted 7 lines
Apart from all the other good arguments already posted:
Are you really sure they will? Maybe dlink will, but I can tell from personal expierience (whine, whine) that the majority of vendors still won't release drivers. For the simple reason because they regard Linux a market too small to support. That is the main reason for most of them, not the license stuff.
Right, what we really need IMO is specs and the right to produce GPL drivers from the specs. Very little real work is required from the vendors aside from IP/legal.
Quoted 13 lines
Before Linux, I was an OS/2 user and although every vendor in the world was allowed to provide OS/2 drivers, there were more or less the same amount of vendor contributed drivers as there are now in Linux.
I'm 100% sure that Linux supports more hardware than OS/2 did back then and the user base (Desktop wise) was at least as big as Linux.
OS/2 died exactly because software companies didn't write closed-source software, hardware companies didn't write closed-source drivers, and IBM couldn't write it all themselves.
So why repeat this desaster?
Tim
Signature · 1 line
~Randy
Quoted 3 lines · Tim Tassonis
OS/2 died exactly because software companies didn't write closed-source software, hardware companies didn't write closed-source drivers, and IBM couldn't write it all themselves.
I read somewhere that the development kit was obscenely expensive and effectively locked out all hobbyists and small companies.
Quoted 11 lines · Jan Knutar
Quoted 3 lines · Tim Tassonis
OS/2 died exactly because software companies didn't write closed-source software, hardware companies didn't write closed-source drivers, and IBM couldn't write it all themselves.
I read somewhere that the development kit was obscenely expensive and effectively locked out all hobbyists and small companies.
IBM stuff may have been expensive.
There was gcc for os/2 though, which was nice for hobbyists. The way I remember it, drivers wasn't the big problem. The lack of drivers could have become a problem if the lack of software was solved. But it wasn't - no need to drive a device for which you don't have an app . . .
Having gcc meant one could port some gpl software, which usually originated on linux or other unixes. But using such software on linux was always easier, and so I switched os.
Helge Hafting
I knew this was sore issue, i knew some people would say to me, i am just another troll barking at tree not knowing anything , and i knew loads of people will share same views or atleast do have lots of questions regarding EULA, LAW, COPYRIGHT, "does it suit fundamental's of linux", and similar things to say but boy, i never never never expected this many views going back and forth, some real live developer issue someone mentioned here (glucometer) did give some sense of how_it_gets difficult for a developer to_do kernel related things. due to my work i wasnt able to reply to this post, just reading all replies here was overwhelming (ofcourse gmail did made it lots easier).
(think of this i shud had put my hosting company name at start, that wud had been cheap but plenty of adverting :) but i wanted and still want the_issue to be core of this thread)
Linus might either be thinking "boy is this the longest and oldest ever rant or what" or "this needs some serious attending, gotta talk about this with morton" or, "this pisses me off to maximum, mustttt resists pulling my eyes out sticking fingers in and swirling my brain around" .
I agree asking for modular/binary driver option in linux kernel is trollling, as asking for open source windows to billyg . but why did i ask? no i didnt wake up one day and felt i shud bark at some tree, this is same kind of trolling like , if someone with old pc saying how sad it is for him with no updates available for win98 and slowing apps and no modern applications suck for him and i in reply to give a suggestion like "have you tried linux? its pretty neat now, give it a try".
i already mentioned at starting of thread what drove me to writing
this topic and i think linus should seriously give a thought or review to this.
I even read a long time some japanese company (maybe mobile company docomo, i really dont know the name) were asking to make binary driver legal and more integrated with linux kernel to which linus vehemently opposed it, i googled "binary drivers" and found loads of article like in 1999 and similar where linus has shown his displeasure. but who knows, times change, needs change, people too change.
To end this email, I from heart want to thank and congratulate to all developers users coders and others who shared , challenged, confronted, discussed their views, it really educated me as it must have done to lot others too.
Thank you.
Quoted 4 lines · Anshuman Gholap
i already mentioned at starting of thread what drove me to writing
this topic and i think linus should seriously give a thought or review to this.
It is not his decision, he is just one (albeit an important, influential one) of something like 900 copyright holders in the kernel.