Fixup relocation patch.]
A message that is not in the archive (sent off-list or not yet received): [email protected]
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Quoted 3 lines · Grant Likely
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.
It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the -fPIC flag. It could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for the ppc4xx.
Quoted 2 lines
However, -mrelocatable is a powerpc-only flag. I don't know what the magic flag is to do the same on arm/mips/etc.
It should be the -fPIC flag. But I think that the main problem is the existence or not of a piece of code that copy the fixup section elements from flash to ram and adjust it as the powerpc code does it. I think we need the help of other architectures experts to resolve this doubt.
Quoted 2 lines
It would be great if this can get sorted out for all u-boot targets. It's an invasive change though. I think your right that having it wrapped in a conditional is the right way to start, but I would start with a patchset that fixes up all powerpc targets first and get it out for comments/testing before it gets merged to mainline. Once powerpc is proven, then turn to look at the other architectures.
I agree.
Quoted 3 lines
I'll happily help you with this task.
I'm sorry but I've got not time to do this task by now. I'm not sure if this work must be done by only one persone or by the people who have the equipment to test it. Anway, if you are a volunteer for me is OK.
BR,
Txema
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: tlopez.vcf
Type: text/x-vcard
Size: 324 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/attachments/20070213/4a2f2edd/attachment.vcf
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Quoted 8 lines · Txema Lopez
Quoted 3 lines · Grant Likely
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the -fPIC flag. It could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for the ppc4xx.
I added -mrelocatable to gcc during compile, but not to the linking stage and that worked too.
How do you guys link? This is how I do:
UNDEF_SYM=`powerpc-softfloat-linux-gnu-objdump -x lib_generic/libgeneric.a board/tmcu/libtmcu.a cpu/mpc83xx/libmpc83xx.a lib_ppc/libppc.a fs/cramfs/libcramfs.a fs/fat/libfat.a fs/fdos/libfdos.a fs/jffs2/libjffs2.a fs/reiserfs/libreiserfs.a fs/ext2/libext2fs.a net/libnet.a disk/libdisk.a rtc/librtc.a dtt/libdtt.a drivers/libdrivers.a drivers/nand/libnand.a drivers/nand_legacy/libnand_legacy.a drivers/sk98lin/libsk98lin.a post/libpost.a post/cpu/libcpu.a common/libcommon.a cpu/mpc83xx/qe/ucc/libucc.a cpu/mpc83xx/qe/libqe.a |sed -n -e 's/.*\(__u_boot_cmd_.*\)/-u\1/p'|sort|uniq`;\ cd /usr/local/src/tm-uboot/u-boot && powerpc-softfloat-linux-gnu-ld -Bstatic -T /usr/local/src/tm-uboot/u-boot/board/tmcu/u-boot.lds -Ttext 0xF8020000 -n $UNDEF_SYM cpu/mpc83xx/start.o cpu/mpc83xx/resetvec.o \ --start-group lib_generic/libgeneric.a board/tmcu/libtmcu.a cpu/mpc83xx/libmpc83xx.a lib_ppc/libppc.a fs/cramfs/libcramfs.a fs/fat/libfat.a fs/fdos/libfdos.a fs/jffs2/libjffs2.a fs/reiserfs/libreiserfs.a fs/ext2/libext2fs.a net/libnet.a disk/libdisk.a rtc/librtc.a dtt/libdtt.a drivers/libdrivers.a drivers/nand/libnand.a drivers/nand_legacy/libnand_legacy.a drivers/sk98lin/libsk98lin.a post/libpost.a post/cpu/libcpu.a common/libcommon.a cpu/mpc83xx/qe/ucc/libucc.a cpu/mpc83xx/qe/libqe.a --end-group -L /usr/lib/gcc/powerpc-softfloat-linux-gnu/3.4.6 -lgcc \ -Map u-boot.map -o u-boot
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Quoted 6 lines · Joakim Tjernlund
Quoted 5 lines · Txema Lopez
Quoted 3 lines · Grant Likely
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.
Quoted 6 lines
Quoted 3 lines
It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the -fPIC flag. It could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for the ppc4xx.
I added -mrelocatable to gcc during compile, but not to the linking stage and that worked too.
Sorry, my mistake. I needed the -mrelocatable flag for *compiling*, not linking. :)
g.
Signature · 4 lines
Grant Likely, B.Sc. P.Eng. Secret Lab Technologies Ltd. grant.likely at secretlab.ca (403) 399-0195
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
In reply to Txema LopezQuoted 7 lines · Txema Lopez
Quoted 3 lines · Grant Likely
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the -fPIC flag. It could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for the ppc4xx.
I actually tried it on the 5200 also, and I didn't get the fixup section without -mrelocatable. Might be a gcc version difference. I'm using ELDK 4.0 which uses gcc 4.0. What version of gcc are you using?
Quoted 3 lines
I'm sorry but I've got not time to do this task by now. I'm not sure if this work must be done by only one persone or by the people who have the equipment to test it. Anway, if you are a volunteer for me is OK.
Okay, I'll take this on then.
g.
Signature · 4 lines
Grant Likely, B.Sc. P.Eng. Secret Lab Technologies Ltd. grant.likely at secretlab.ca (403) 399-0195
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Grant Likely wrote:
Hi Grant,
Are you are still going ahead with the patch to add a device level cp
and cmp function to u-boot? Let me know if you are not proceeding, and I will try to fit it in to my schedule.
On what I hope is a different note, this relocation patch will be a
big problem across different architectures, so I hope you are not relying on it. First, -fPIC is
not used in several u-boot ports. The Blackfin u-boot_1..1.3 for example builds a u-boot that is not PIC. Several other processors do almost the same thing, where the code is not relocated but the variables are re-located from rom to ram. In those cases, u-boot runs from ROM with variables in ram. Mr. Denk doesn't like this approach, but people do it and will continue to do it particularly on cores embedded into FPGAs, where u-boot is not the first bootstrap to run. The power-pc -fPIC approach simply won't work in those cases. Also, -fPIC code is generally buggy on new CPUs for quite a while after the compiler is first ported to them. It was quite some time after the Blackfin port was working before PIC code was working. We appear to see differences between gcc versions even today on power-pcs, let alone more obscure CPUs. Therefore, requiring PIC code to make the boot loader work at all is probably not going to be popular. The existing approach is probably the way it is because people had so much trouble making "unified" relocation work on all configurations. Worst-case, during initial port to a new chip, you can build u-boot to run in rom at a fixed location without PIC and know the ram references that need relocating will be relocated. That won't be true with the new approach.
The total number of relocations done in the u-boot code explicitly is
small enough that it is better, IMNSHO, to preserve the existing approach. Function tables can be built/relocated at run time without much cost, as is done with the stdio functions. If you can come up with a way to make the single-point relocation work for all the different ways different systems use u-boot, More Power To You, but I would lay long odds that this is possible.
Best Regards,
Bill Campbell
Quoted 36 lines · Txema Lopez
Quoted 6 lines
Grant Likely wrote:
Quoted 9 lines
Quoted 5 lines
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the -fPIC flag. It could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for the ppc4xx.
I actually tried it on the 5200 also, and I didn't get the fixup section without -mrelocatable. Might be a gcc version difference. I'm using ELDK 4.0 which uses gcc 4.0. What version of gcc are you using?
Quoted 5 lines
I'm sorry but I've got not time to do this task by now. I'm not sure if this work must be done by only one persone or by the people who have the equipment to test it. Anway, if you are a volunteer for me is OK.
Okay, I'll take this on then.
g.
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Quoted 5 lines · J. William Campbell
Grant Likely wrote:
Hi Grant,
Are you are still going ahead with the patch to add a device level cp
and cmp function to u-boot? Let me know if you are not proceeding, and I will try to fit it in to my schedule.
Yep; I'm working towards it. I've got some patches in my local tree which will provide a command set that MMC and dataflash can use so they can be moved out of the cmd_mem functions. In fact, that's how I learned about the relocation issue. It was in writing this code that I came across the static initializer problem.
Instead of adding yet another set of manual fixups; I'd like to focus on getting the C environment right first.
Quoted 8 lines
On what I hope is a different note, this relocation patch will be a
big problem across different architectures, so I hope you are not relying on it. First, -fPIC is
not used in several u-boot ports. The Blackfin u-boot_1..1.3 for example builds a u-boot that is not PIC. Several other processors do almost the same thing, where the code is not relocated but the variables are re-located from rom to ram. In those cases, u-boot runs from ROM with variables in ram.
Okay, fair enough; but I'm not so much concerned with getting all platforms to relocate in the same way. What I am concerned about is the fact that u-boot has a broken C environment that requires manual fixups to work right. I don't think anyone thinks this is desirable, and it should be fixable on all supported platforms (but it might be hard).
For the targets which use relocation, this means fixing the linker script and making sure -fPIC/-mrelocatable/whatever works in the right way.
On other targets, different magic is needed. Heck, for all I know, some boards might already be working. gd->reloc_off is used for all the manual fixups. If there are any platforms where gd->reloc_off == 0 then those platforms are already working, and therefore doesn't need any work.
For boards that relocate only the data section; maybe the linker script should be modified to specify both a vma and lma for the data sections; so the program looks for them at the vma, but elf and bin images place them at the lma. Then the data is already in the correct place after relocation; no fixup required.
Quoted 7 lines
Mr. Denk doesn't like this approach, but people
do it and will continue to do it particularly on cores embedded into FPGAs, where u-boot is not the first bootstrap to run. The power-pc -fPIC approach simply won't work in those cases. Also, -fPIC code is generally buggy on new CPUs for quite a while after the compiler is first ported to them. It was quite some time after the Blackfin port was working before PIC code was working. We appear to see differences
Quoted 8 lines
between gcc versions even today on power-pcs, let alone more obscure CPUs. Therefore, requiring PIC code to make the boot loader work at all is probably not going to be popular. The existing approach is probably the way it is because people had so much trouble making "unified" relocation work on all configurations. Worst-case, during initial port to a new chip, you can build u-boot to run in rom at a fixed location without PIC and know the ram references that need relocating will be relocated. That won't be true with the new approach.
Okay, I did not describe the problem well; I agree that trying to move *all* platforms to -fPIC is not a good idea.
Heck, most of the u-boot code could care less about relocation and only needs a working C environment. In fact, I've got a number of powerpc targets where I'd *prefer* to compile it without -fPIC (because SDRAM is initialized and u-boot is loaded via a different mechanism). There is no reason why many architectures couldn't support both -fPIC and non-fPIC builds. (with the inherent design tradeoffs).
Quoted 3 lines
The total number of relocations done in the u-boot code explicitly is
small enough that it is better, IMNSHO, to preserve the existing approach.
Preserve the way each platform does or does not relocate: I agree 100% Preserve the broken C environment: Hell No! We can do better! :-D
Quoted 5 lines
Function tables can be built/relocated at run time without much cost, as is done with the stdio functions. If you can come up with a way to make the single-point relocation work for all the different ways different systems use u-boot, More Power To You, but I would lay long odds that this is possible.
understood, and I agree.
Cheers,
g.
Signature · 4 lines
Grant Likely, B.Sc. P.Eng. Secret Lab Technologies Ltd. grant.likely at secretlab.ca (403) 399-0195
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
In reply to Grant LikelyQuoted 28 lines
-----Original Message-----
From: u-boot-users-bounces at lists.sourceforge.net [mailto:u-boot-users-bounces at lists.sourceforge.net] On Behalf Of Grant Likely
Sent: den 13 februari 2007 17:51
To: Txema Lopez
Cc: u-boot-users at lists.sourceforge.net
Subject: Re: [U-Boot-Users] [PATCH] Fixup relocation patch.]Quoted 3 lines · Txema Lopez
Quoted 1 line · Grant Likely
I needed to add the -mrelocatable flag to the linker flags
in
cpu/ppc4xx/config.mk(I did not remove the -fPIC flag when I did this). Without -mrelocatable, the .fixup section would remain empty.Quoted 3 lines
Quoted 2 lines
It's not the case of the MPC5200. It's enough with the
-fPIC flag. It
Quoted 1 line
could be a problem with the gcc cross compiler/linker for
the ppc4xx.
I actually tried it on the 5200 also, and I didn't get the fixup section without -mrelocatable. Might be a gcc version difference. I'm using ELDK 4.0 which uses gcc 4.0. What version of gcc are you using?
Quoted 7 lines
Quoted 1 line
I'm sorry but I've got not time to do this task by now. I'm
not sure if
Quoted 1 line
this work must be done by only one persone or by the people
who have the
Quoted 1 line
equipment to test it. Anway, if you are a volunteer for me is OK.
Okay, I'll take this on then.
I wonder, how far off is a fully relocatable u-boot? That is, burn it anywhere in flash and start it from there?
Jocke
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
Quoted 7 lines · Joakim Tjernlund
I wonder, how far off is a fully relocatable u-boot? That is, burn it anywhere in flash and start it from there?
Jocke
Hi Jocke,
The patch was done precisely for it. You can copy a U-Boot image from an address in flash to another and calculate the new pointers in the GOT an FIXUP sections before do the copy.
But you need another change in U-Boot to turn it fully relocatable. U-Boot is hardly joined with the link address TEXT_BASE. You must replace it for a label in U-Boot and change the lines in the U-Boot code where there is a direct or indirect reference (as CFG_MONITOR_BASE) to TEXT_BASE.
Best regards,
Txema
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: tlopez.vcf
Type: text/x-vcard
Size: 324 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/attachments/20070214/5dee477f/attachment.vcf
PATCH 1/1 Fixup relocation patch.]
In reply to Grant LikelyQuoted 5 lines · Grant Likely
I actually tried it on the 5200 also, and I didn't get the fixup section without -mrelocatable. Might be a gcc version difference. I'm using ELDK 4.0 which uses gcc 4.0. What version of gcc are you using?
I'm using a gcc 3.3.6 version patched for uclibc (buidroot patches). This is the command line of the compiler call.
/home/txema/ppc5200/build_powerpc/toolchain/bin/powerpc-linux-uclibc-gcc
-g -O1 -fno-common -fno-schedule-insns -fno-schedule-insns2 -fPIC
-ffixed-r14 -meabi -D__KERNEL__ -DTEXT_BASE=0xFE040100 -I/home/txema/ppc5200/build_powerpc/system/u-boot/include -fno-builtin -ffreestanding -nostdinc -isystem /home/txema/ppc5200/build_powerpc/toolchain/lib/gcc-lib/powerpc-linux-uclibc/3.3.6/include -pipe -DCONFIG_PPC -D__powerpc__ -DCONFIG_MPC5xxx -ffixed-r2
-ffixed-r29 -mstring -mcpu=603e -mmultiple -DTEXT_BASE=0xFE040100 -I/home/txema/ppc5200/build_powerpc/system/u-boot/board -Wall -Wstrict-prototypes -c -o usb_storage.o usb_storage.c
BR
Txema,
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: tlopez.vcf
Type: text/x-vcard
Size: 324 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : http://lists.denx.de/pipermail/u-boot/attachments/20070214/38b9e4c5/attachment.vcf