Linux on Intel "Big Sur"
Hello!
I happen to posses an old "Big Sur" machine manufactured by Intel, based around two Itanium (Merced) CPU's and a 460GX chipset. The machine is labeled as an "enginnering sample" (label:
http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00873.jpg), and looks identical to the HP i2000 workstation (picture: http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00880.jpg).
I have faced a problem of getting an operating system for it. Namely, Linux. I have tried installing both Debian 3.0r6 Woody and Debian 4.0r1 Etch, however, the CD kernel doesn't succeed to boot. Somewhere after probing for USB and SCSI devices, the video signal is lost (monitor switches into a stand-by mode), and nothing else happens. Since I'm using some old Matrox graphics card, I thought it could be a problem with framebuffer, but disabling the framebuffer didn't help.
On the Debian website, it's stated that there could be problems due to old BIOS/firmware versions. Here's what I've got:
BIOS: W460GXBS2.86E.0117C.P09.200108091154
SMBIOS: 2.3.1
PAL (A/B): 6623/6625
SAL (A/B): 101/101
Boot Block: 30
There are BIOS and firmware updates for i2000 available on the HP website, but I'm not sure if they are compatible with my machine, and am afraid of damaging either BIOS or firmware at updating attempt.
Do you reckon it is safe to update? What else would you suggest me to do about my machine to succeed with Linux installation? And is it possible to run HP-UX 11i (probably v1.5/1.6/2.0) on it?
Thanks in advance,
Alexei Gerasimov.
Quoted 5 lines
I happen to posses an old "Big Sur" machine manufactured by Intel, based around two Itanium (Merced) CPU's and a 460GX chipset. The machine is labeled as an "enginnering sample" (label:
http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00873.jpg), and looks identical to the HP i2000 workstation (picture: http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00880.jpg).
I haven't booted kernels on BigSur/Merced based systems for a very long time (3 years? perhaps more) ... and untested code very quickly turns into non-working code :-(
Quoted 2 lines
Do you reckon it is safe to update? What else would you suggest me to do about my machine to succeed with Linux installation?
You'd probably be a lot happier if you re-cycled this machine and found a newer one (at least McKinley based). If you really want to continue you might try to track down some install disks for a version of Linux that is the same age as the machine (e.g. RedHat AS 2.1). At least these are known to work on this h/w.
-Tony
Quoted 24 lines · Alexei Gerasimov
I happen to posses an old "Big Sur" machine manufactured by Intel, based around two Itanium (Merced) CPU's and a 460GX chipset. The machine is labeled as an "enginnering sample" (label:
http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00873.jpg), and looks identical to the HP i2000 workstation (picture: http://ishells.net/spy/itanium/DSC00880.jpg).I have faced a problem of getting an operating system for it. Namely, Linux. I have tried installing both Debian 3.0r6 Woody and Debian 4.0r1 Etch, however, the CD kernel doesn't succeed to boot. Somewhere after probing for USB and SCSI devices, the video signal is lost (monitor switches into a stand-by mode), and nothing else happens. Since I'm using some old Matrox graphics card, I thought it could be a problem with framebuffer, but disabling the framebuffer didn't help.
On the Debian website, it's stated that there could be problems due to old BIOS/firmware versions. Here's what I've got:
BIOS: W460GXBS2.86E.0117C.P09.200108091154
SMBIOS: 2.3.1PAL (A/B): 6623/6625
SAL (A/B): 101/101
Boot Block: 30
Quoted 7 lines
There are BIOS and firmware updates for i2000 available on the HP website, but I'm not sure if they are compatible with my machine, and am afraid of damaging either BIOS or firmware at updating attempt.
Do you reckon it is safe to update? What else would you suggest me to do about my machine to succeed with Linux installation? And is it possible to run HP-UX 11i (probably v1.5/1.6/2.0) on it?
I've only used the HP i2000 version, and even that's been a long time, but my guess is that the firmware upgrade would be safe, and that the appropriate HP-UX version would probably run on it.
If you want to debug the Linux problem, you might try using a serial console (try something like "console=uart,io,0x3f8,9600n8" or "console=uart,io,0x2f8,9600n8"), adding some debug options ("debug initcall_debug") and booting to single-user mode ("single" or "init=/bin/bash").
Bjorn
Quoted 4 lines · Bjorn Helgaas
I've only used the HP i2000 version, and even that's been a long time, but my guess is that the firmware upgrade would be safe, and that the appropriate HP-UX version would probably run on it.
I've discovered a small detail about updates: the firmware update seems to be safe, but the BIOS update (to the version 1.30) available from the HP website is marked as for CPU's with C2 stepping. According to my CPUID, my Itanium's are C0 stepping, therefore an update to the version dedicated for CPU's with different stepping might be fatal. Personally, I don't know what stepping is, thus cannot be sure to make any conclusions. What do you think about this?
Alex.
Quoted 5 lines · Alexei Gerasimov
Quoted 4 lines · Bjorn Helgaas
I've only used the HP i2000 version, and even that's been a long time, but my guess is that the firmware upgrade would be safe, and that the appropriate HP-UX version would probably run on it.
Quoted 7 lines
I've discovered a small detail about updates: the firmware update seems to be safe, but the BIOS update (to the version 1.30) available from the HP website is marked as for CPU's with C2 stepping. According to my CPUID, my Itanium's are C0 stepping, therefore an update to the version dedicated for CPU's with different stepping might be fatal. Personally, I don't know what stepping is, thus cannot be sure to make any conclusions. What do you think about this?
CPU steppings are minor changes to the processor, usually to fix problems. The CPU comes with a piece of firmware called PAL that is specific to the CPU model. The PAL is packaged up as part of the firmware update from HP, but the PAL itself comes from Intel, and we really don't have much visibility into it.
Normally, a new PAL would work on all previous steppings of a given processor model, but sometimes there are exceptions, especially for early prototype CPUs.
If this were my machine, and I really, really wanted to get it working (it's ancient and slow by today's standards), I would leave the firmware alone and try to debug it as a Linux problem. If it turns out to be a firmware issue, you could try the upgrade. But I'd hate to brick the box if it failed.
Bjorn
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Alexei" = Alexei Gerasimov <[email protected]> writes:
Alexei> I have faced a problem of getting an operating system for Alexei> it. Namely, Linux. I have tried installing both Debian 3.0r6 Alexei> Woody and Debian 4.0r1 Etch, however, the CD kernel doesn't Alexei> succeed to boot. Somewhere after probing for USB and SCSI Alexei> devices, the video signal is lost (monitor switches into a Alexei> stand-by mode), and nothing else happens. Since I'm using some Alexei> old Matrox graphics card, I thought it could be a problem with Alexei> framebuffer, but disabling the framebuffer didn't help.
Hmmm. I boot i2000s at least once a month to make sure Linux still works with the latest kernels. But I use the BigSur defconfig, not the generic one the distros use (note to self: try with a generic kernel).
I strongly suggest trying to boot using a serial console. The video stuff has been pretty flakey at various times.
--
Dr Peter Chubb http://www.gelato.unsw.edu.au peterc AT gelato.unsw.edu.au
http://www.ertos.nicta.com.au ERTOS within National ICT Australia
Quoted 13 lines · Peter Chubb
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
Quoted 1 line
"Alexei" = Alexei Gerasimov <[email protected]> writes:
Alexei> I have faced a problem of getting an operating system for Alexei> it. Namely, Linux. I have tried installing both Debian 3.0r6 Alexei> Woody and Debian 4.0r1 Etch, however, the CD kernel doesn't Alexei> succeed to boot. Somewhere after probing for USB and SCSI Alexei> devices, the video signal is lost (monitor switches into a Alexei> stand-by mode), and nothing else happens. Since I'm using some Alexei> old Matrox graphics card, I thought it could be a problem with Alexei> framebuffer, but disabling the framebuffer didn't help.
Quoted 4 lines
Hmmm. I boot i2000s at least once a month to make sure Linux still works with the latest kernels. But I use the BigSur defconfig, not the generic one the distros use (note to self: try with a generic kernel).
Yeah, I booted a bigsur with the 2.6.22 kernel bigsur config a couple months ago. I ran into userland issues as the OS was ancient.
Good Luck,
Robin