RFC: Libtool and wrong rpath
Hi,
I have noticed with strace that strange path is being probed by dynamic linker on the target. This makes applications to start slower, since each library is probed with wrong path first!
Problem is that ELF dynamic section (readelf -d) has RPATH set to absolute path of the satging dir on the host:
0x0000000f (RPATH) Library rpath:
[/home/paulius/buildroot/output/build/staging_dir/usr/i386-unknown-linux-uclibc/lib]
I have put some simple script to discover ELF files with this WRONG path:
#!/bin/sh
for file in find $@ -type f -executable; do
if [ -n "file $file | grep ELF" ]; then
if [ -n "readelf -d $file | grep staging" ]; then
echo $file
fi
fi
done
On my target directory it found 119 occurrences. Mostly X11 and GTK related. The source of this problem seems to be buggy libtool script...
I failed to fix/identify libtool lines responsible for this, but I think we can use chrpath utility to remove wrong RPATH from these executables.
If we use chrpath, then should we add package or require it from host? I guess we will have to run it after all packages are installed?
Very interesting...
Same thing here, I'm pretty sure it's because of the modifications we make on .la files
Quoted 25 lines · Paulius Zaleckas
Hi,
I have noticed with strace that strange path is being probed by dynamic linker
on the target. This makes applications to start slower, since each library is probed with wrong path first!Problem is that ELF dynamic section (readelf -d) has RPATH set to absolute path
of the satging dir on the host:
0x0000000f(RPATH) ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Library rpath:
[/home/paulius/buildroot/output/build/staging_dir/usr/i386-unknown-linux-uclibc/lib]I have put some simple script to discover ELF files with this WRONG path:
#!/bin/sh
for file infind $@ -type f -executable; do
? ? ? ?if [ -n "file $file | grep ELF" ]; then
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?if [ -n "readelf -d $file | grep staging" ]; then ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?echo $file
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?fi
? ? ? ?fi
done
Quoted 1 line
On my target directory it found 119 occurrences. Mostly X11 and GTK related.
On my target, it's all libraries, except the low level ones (libcurl, libdbus, libcrypto, ...).
In fact each library which has a dependency on another library providing a .la modified by buildroot will have this wrong rpath.
Quoted 1 line
The source of this problem seems to be buggy libtool script...
Or a buggy buildroot...
Quoted 6 lines
I failed to fix/identify libtool lines responsible for this, but I think we can
use chrpath utility to remove wrong RPATH from these executables.If we use chrpath, then should we add package or require it from host? I guess we will have to run it after all packages are installed?
That sucks ;)
Thx for reporting this.
--
Lionel Landwerlin