RFC: Is SM_SIMU_CRASH (in rpc.statd) needed?
Subsystems (2)
Quoted 3 lines
Does anybody know who uses
SM_SIMU_CRASHand is it still needed? I'm getting some push back from our security folks to plug this DoS hole up...
How is it a DoS? statd ignores any SM_SIMU_CRASH from a non-loopback address that does not use a privileged port. To invoke it, you basically have to be a privileged local user.
Right now, no one uses it, but I think we should reserve the right to use it in the future. This could be part of a more robust interface between lockd and statd.
Signature · 1 line
Chuck Lever
Quoted 7 lines · Chuck Lever
Quoted 3 lines
Does anybody know who uses
SM_SIMU_CRASHand is it still needed? I'm getting some push back from our security folks to plug this DoS hole up...How is it a DoS? statd ignores any
SM_SIMU_CRASHfrom a non-loopback address that does not use a privileged port. To invoke it, you basically have to be a privileged local user.
It happens during an ISS scan....
Quoted 4 lines
Right now, no one uses it, but I think we should reserve the right to use it in the future. This could be part of a more robust interface between lockd and statd.
hmm... how can having a way of bringing down a daemon, make it more robust?
steved.
Quoted 11 lines · Steve Dickson
Quoted 7 lines · Chuck Lever
Quoted 3 lines
Does anybody know who uses
SM_SIMU_CRASHand is it still needed? I'm getting some push back from our security folks to plug this DoS hole up...How is it a DoS? statd ignores any
SM_SIMU_CRASHfrom a non-loopback address that does not use a privileged port. To invoke it, you basically have to be a privileged local user.It happens during an ISS scan....
What were the exact results?
Quoted 4 lines
Quoted 3 lines
Right now, no one uses it, but I think we should reserve the right to use it in the future. This could be part of a more robust interface between lockd and statd.
hmm... how can having a way of bringing down a daemon, make it more robust?
SM_SIMU_CRASH is not supposed to bring down statd, it's supposed to trigger sm-notify. If something else is happening, that's a bug.