Skip to contentSkip to conversation

CONFIG_BOOTP_VENDOREX ???, I'm a newbie

U-Boot g_remlin 1 participant 1 message Oct 6, 2010

lore
Share & tools
lore

g_remlin

author
#0 lore raw

I want 'options' processing in the dhcp client to permit
setting\sending 'user-class' and the like via the environment. I found CONFIG_BOOTP_VENDOREX (with it's functions 'dhcp_vendorex_prep' & 'dhcp_vendorex_proc' ) used in a handful of boards, which looks like it was intended for a similar purpose.

As dhcp supports the processing of non-standard options through it's expression evaluation support:

Why are vendor specific options implemented this way at all ? Why specifically for only a handful of boards, and not globally for anything bootp capable ?
Why does it support current standard (term used vaguely) dhcp options rather than something 'vendor specific' as the name implies ?

And now to the point - Should I replace it or fudge around it ?

Yes, I am a total newbie to free open source collaborative programming. Yes, I need my hand held (everybody had to start for the first time sometime).

If an individual or 'the list' is willing to mentor me, I am prepared to put in the effort to attempt to implement the basic skeleton in a form that can be submitted. A typical type of question any mentor could expect is most likely to be 'political' i.e. :

Currently the convention for environment variable naming appears to me to be a little sketchy. Visually scanning a complex environment is becoming more tedious as the number of options increase, when would be a good time to do something about this ?

I propose (that I implement dhcp options processing with) the use of upper case prefixes to denote a particular variable class.

For example:

setenv DHCP_user-class 'cluster01'
setenv DHCP_vendor-class-identifier 'Marvell'

and later this class prefixing could optionally be extended to encompass the variables already defined as required.

Gray Remlin - comments invited.